Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Open seeding

2 views
Skip to first unread message

bcs...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 8:57:10 AM10/13/08
to
Well, Doublewide, you guys screwed up seeding again. Way to go. This
leaves some serious confusion between 4 and 11 - the last five seem
relatively clear, as do the top three. In between: chaos. A first
stab:

1) Sockeye
2) Bravo
3) Ironside
4) Revolver (complicated seed, 4-6 could be switched easily. These
have the advantage of avoiding regional matchups in first round)
5) GOAT
6) Ring
7) Jam
8) Sub Zero (very mixed season, but hard to put them much lower)
9) Doublewide
10) Chain
11) Condors
12) Truck Stop
13) Machine
14) Bodhi
15) PoNY
16) El Diablo

This gives:
1) Sockeye 2) Bravo 3) Ironside 4) Revolver
8) Sub Zero 7) Jam 6) Ring 5) GOAT
9) Doublewide 10) Chain 11) Condors 12) Truck
16) El Diablo 15) PoNY 14) Bodhi 13) Machine

Should be exciting.

spa...@yahoo.com

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 9:25:23 AM10/13/08
to

This doesn't seem right, I don't think Revolver should be so high, nor
Chain so low. But I play coed so I'm probably off base.
That's some serious NW philatio there my man.
JB

trtr...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 10:03:54 AM10/13/08
to
On Oct 13, 6:57 am, bcst...@gmail.com wrote:

Pools are reversed snaked at nationals
Pool a:1, 8, 12, 13
Pool b: 2, 7, 11 14
Pool c: 3, 6, 10, 15
Pool d: 4, 5, 9, 16

trtr...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 10:11:24 AM10/13/08
to
> Pool d:  4, 5, 9, 16- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

I stand corrected, club nationals is the normal snake format.

Kazan

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 12:16:18 PM10/13/08
to
I think you have overseed Jam here. They are 0-1 against Chain, they
are 0-1 against Truck Stop, and they are 1-2 against Condors. To me,
I would put them underneath truck stop.

GOAT also seems a bit high. Losses to Sub Zero, Condors, Chain... but
they get the seeding nod above those teams? I think I disagree with
you there.

dar

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 12:36:06 PM10/13/08
to

1)      Sockeye
2)      Bravo
3)      Ironside

4)      Ring (head to head over revolver at Labor Day)
5)      Revolver
6)      GOAT
7)      Doublewide
8)      Chain (i know DW screws things up, but you can't really drop
Cahin below 8th in my opinion, and i can't argue seeding DW too much
higher)
9)      Jam (thought about switching with SZ here to avoid region
rematch)
10)     Sub Zero


11)     Condors
12)     Truck Stop
13)     Machine
14)     Bodhi
15)     PoNY
16)     El Diablo

This gives:
1) Sockeye                 2) Bravo       3) Ironside       4) Ring
8) Chain               7) DW          6) GOAT           5)
Revolver
9) Jam          10) Sub Zero 11) Condors     12) Truck


16) El Diablo             15) PoNY      14) Bodhi         13) Machine


dar

Handy

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 12:48:18 PM10/13/08
to

I realize that seeding shouldn't be done in relation to regional
matchups, and when it's only one rematch I don't see any problem fine,
but having Ironside, GOAT and Bodhi in the same pool doesn't seem to
make sense to me. That's only one game outside the region before
power pools...

-Handy

blw

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 1:00:12 PM10/13/08
to
Here is the link to all of the Open scores (I am fairly sure this
works)....should be available soon on the Score Reporter, I would
think.

http://tinyurl.com/49yqaj

rdelc...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 13, 2008, 5:18:19 PM10/13/08
to

Hmm this is a toughy.

Regardless I have some predictions,

Chain breaks seed regardless of where they are seeded to go 2-1 in
whatever pool theyre in unless pool d which I think they'd take 3-0.
Other than that teams like Bodhi and PoNY I think have good potential
for upsets. Semis will be Sockeye, Chain, Ironside, and Bravo. It is
unlikely Sockeye will lose, I'd venture to say a repeat of last years
finals.

muffin

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 12:02:50 AM10/14/08
to
1)      Sockeye - Nord > All
2)      Bravo - Beau > Nord
3)      Ironside - Gibson < Beau
4)      Revolver - Stanford < Gibson
5)     Jam - Bort < Stanford
6)      Sub Zero - Hodags > Stanford
7)      GOAT - Canada < Furious
8)      Ring - North Carolina < Mike Gerics
9)      Doublewide - Texas < Georgia
10)    Chain - Zip > Dylan
11)    Truck Stop - George > DLK
12)    Condors - Dugan < Banana Slugs
13)    Machine - Hensley > Georgia Tech
14)    Bodhi - Amherst > CUT
15)    PoNY - BVH < Financial Crisis
16)    El Diablo - NE > South

This should clear things up

Jay Schulkin

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 12:33:38 AM10/14/08
to
http://www1.upa.org/scores/scores.cgi?div=124&page=3&tourn=5217

Can anyone explain what the "Total" column represents? I can't figure
it out.
thanks

moremail...@yahoo.com

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 12:58:00 AM10/14/08
to
> > This gives:
> > 1) Sockeye                2) Bravo        3) Ironside       4) Revolver
> > 8) Sub Zero               7) Jam           6) Ring            5) GOAT
> > 9) Doublewide           10) Chain       11) Condors     12) Truck
> > 16) El Diablo             15) PoNY      14) Bodhi         13) Machine
>
> This doesn't seem right, I don't think Revolver should be so high, nor
> Chain so low. But I play coed so I'm probably off base.
> That's some serious NW philatio there my man.

Fer sure. When was the last time TWO northwest open teams made it to
semis, huh? Oh yeah, that's right. Like, always.

Are you suggesting that after beating both Furious and Jam, the second
NW team shouldn't be seeded in the top 4, just because they're not
Furious or Jam?

acle...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 1:14:28 AM10/14/08
to

Rodney sets up the program to do a 16 team round robin. The total
number is the number of pairwise matchups that the team won. The 14:1
next to sockey, ironside, and bravo indicate that they won 14
matchups, which resulted in a 3 way tie. Out of those 3 teams, they
each won one matchup. The 05 at the end of doublewide's line
indicated that they won matchups against 5 teams, the 03:0 next to
pony indicates they won matchups with 3 teams, and then 0 matchups in
the resulting 3 way tie.

After the full set of round robins is done, the teams are sorted by
the number of matchups they won.... I'm sure Rodney will drop by
later with more details :)

acle...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 1:15:14 AM10/14/08
to
On Oct 13, 11:33 pm, Jay Schulkin <Jay.Schul...@gmail.com> wrote:

Rodney sets up the program to do a 16 team round robin. The total

jacob

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 10:51:31 AM10/14/08
to
"Are you suggesting that after beating both Furious and Jam, the
second NW team shouldn't be seeded in the top 4, just because they're
not Furious or Jam?"

Normally, no, but this particular NW team lost Danny Karlinsky to the
Condors. A loss of epic proportions. The man is a thrower, a
receiver, a defender, a chef, a fashion model, a scholar, a
humanitarian, and occasional gigolo.

aghes...@gmail.com

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 12:24:01 PM10/14/08
to
Here's a different take with some justifications for discussion...
-Sockeye, Bravo, Ironside are the easy top 3.
-There are 3 contenders for the 4/5 spot - Goat, Ring, & Revolver with
Jam and Chain dropping due to Regionals losses and the rest of the
field having lost to these 3. Since the order of Goat, Ring, Revolver
is unclear I'd suggest the regional rematch between Boston/Goat and
Jam/Revolver is avoided and the seeding goes Revolver - Goat. The
order of Jam/Ring is vague since there is no head-to-head, but should
probably go to Jam since they have a better RRI and were semi-
finalists last year.
-The contenders for the next spot are Subzero, Doublewide, Chain,
Truckstop. Subzero has a win over Doublewide, who has to be seeded
above Chain who has two wins over Subzero. Complicated. Subzero,
Truckstop and Chain were all quarters teams last year but Truckstop
has two losses to the condors and worse RRI than Doublewide so
probably fall out here. I think the regional rematch concern is
trumped by the strength of Chain and the seeding ought to go
Doublewide-Chain-Subzero.
-The rest is easy with head-to-heads and regional results supporting
it - I'm swapping Pony and El Diablo for regional reasons since they
have no head-to-head.

1) Sockeye 2) Bravo 3) Ironside 4) Revolver

8) Doublewide 7) Ring 6) Jam 5) GOAT
9) Chain 10) Subzero 11) Condors 12) Truck
16) PoNY 15) El Diablo 14) Bodhi 13) Machine

On Oct 13, 9:58 pm, "moremailforsc...@yahoo.com"

MD

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 2:49:06 PM10/14/08
to
This is what happens when you're bored at work:

1. Truck Stop ..... who has a win over
2. Machine ..... who has a win over
3. Bodhi ..... who has a win over
4. PoNY ..... who has a win over
5. Doublewide ..... who has a win over
6. Chain ..... who has a win over
7. Condors ..... who has a win over
8. Jam ..... who has a win over
9. Revolver ..... who has a win over
10. Sub Zero ..... who has a win over
11. GOAT ..... who has a win over
12. Ring ..... who has a win over
13. Bravo ..... who has a win over
14. Ironside ..... who has a win over
15. Sockeye ..... who has a win over
1. Truck Stop

Jim Mallon

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 4:55:17 PM10/14/08
to

How zen.

No one's a champion ~ everyone's a champion.

jacob

unread,
Oct 14, 2008, 6:49:49 PM10/14/08
to
I do believe Red Tide from Maine won the World Championship back in
1998.

Joa'quine (Joaq)

unread,
Oct 16, 2008, 4:21:20 AM10/16/08
to
On Oct 13, 9:02 pm, muffin <bjmale...@wisc.edu> wrote:
> 11)    Truck Stop   - George > DLK
> 12)    Condors       - Dugan < Banana Slugs
>
> This should clear things up

I think you meant:
11) Truck Stop - Big Stout > Dugan
12) Condors - DLK < George (GVP)

wix

unread,
Oct 16, 2008, 9:47:44 AM10/16/08
to
>
> This doesn't seem right, I don't think Revolver should be so high, nor
> Chain so low. But I play coed so I'm probably off base.
> That's some serious NW philatio there my man.
> JB


for future reference, it's spelled fellatio. this could become
important if you continue to play coed.

0 new messages