"John H. Gohde" <
john.h...@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1ad3b4c8-23e3-4385...@o5g2000yqi.googlegroups.com...
===============================================
As was pointed out, the RDA for potas is 4700 mg, and the RDA for sodium is
1500 mg, for a ratio of 3:1.
What many people -- perhaps even MOST people -- consume instead is 4700 mg
of sodium and 1500 mg of potassium.
So potassium supp -- assuming the RDA is in fact a realistic assessment --
makes sense for many, perhaps most people. The fact that "potassium is in
every food" doesn't mean that *enough* potassium is in every food, depending
of course on what foods you are eating.
You could say the same for calcium, or a dozen other nutrients, incl
protein. A typical Gohde mis-interpreteation of nutrition, science, basic
logic.
There is some logic to Gatorade, in some circumstances, altho the product
itself is basically a heavily marketed conjob.
But as someone pointed, cheap enough, compared to virtually any drink you
can buy at the corner store.
Electrolytes are only an issue for heavy endurance and/or heavy exposure to
heat.
*How* you reintroduce them is inneresting tho, from an osmotic pov --
Warning -- this is way over Gohde'shead...
The experimentation that Gatorade likely did -- of course at the finest
universities in the world of course -- was to find the optimal *osmotic
balance*.
If you drink pure water in a state of electrolyte stress/depletion,
re-hydration certainly occurs, but also the few electrolytes floating around
in the body are temporarily sucked in to the intestines -- at least in
theory -- making things temporarily worse.
If you drink heavily salted water in a state of dehydration, you can
temporarily worsen the dehydration thru the same osmotic process, except now
you are sucking WATER into the gut (out of the body) -- which is why you
can't drink seawater if you are lost on a raft.
All in all, a kind of non-issue, as someone pointed at that Gatorade and all
that other crap is just koolaid with a salt pill thrown in. You'd do just
as well drinking water and eating an orange, or a french fry. All in all,
much ado about not much.
Gatorade is like Starfuck$ -- half the reason assholes buy Starfuck$ is so
they can walk around with the coffee cup, *label out*.... esp. in Japan.
I'm surprised Nike dudn't have a sports drink.... the more the merrier.
Mountain Dew/Jolt woulda proly had an even more positive effect on
dehydrated football teams.... caffeine, donchaknow.... LOL
--
EA