It's not so much of a group mentality there, it's a group mentality
everywhere. If everyone you know raves about a certain kind of ride, then
you'll go into it with certain expectations. You're more likely to see the
good and ignore the bad. That certainly was true here on RRC in the heyday
of CCI, particularly with Shivering Timbers. With ACE, it's usually
classic woodies. With TPR, it happens to be Intamin coasters everyone
drools over!
As for I305, did you miss all that drama? When in June did you ride,
because that's when they changed the restraints? If it was early, then you
caught the crappy old ones, as I did. If it was later, then you caught the
replacements, which were much softer. I rarely complain about headbanging
restraints, but those were really bad. It dropped the coaster down on my
list well over a dozen notches from where it probably would have been,
because it hurt my enjoyment of the ride that much. I spent the whole ride
trying to brace myself from being hurt, rather than just enjoying the ride.
The original restraints were horrible for that coaster. They were the same
ones on Kingda Ka, I believe. Rectangular iron bars, with a touch of
padding on it. And I stress a touch. Look at how much lower Ka ranks than
Dragster on Mitch's poll (65 vs 33) and the Golden Ticket Awards's (33 vs
9) despite being taller and faster, to see how much those horrible
restraints hurt that coaster in the rankings. And that's on a coaster with
only two directional changes, unlike I305, which has lots of sudden
directional changes. Admittedly, there's a certain level of Cedar Point
fanboy bias there in both polls (particularly the GTA's), but that still
doesn't account for such a big discrepancy, which would almost have to be
because of the restraints.
I'm not usually one to complain about headbanging, but I found that they
REALLY hurt that ride. In fact, I said so when I ran into a park manager
later in the day, who pointedly asked me what I thought of the ride. I
told him how good it was, but that they really needed to change the lapbars
to get it to be a top 10 ride. He told me that the restraints they got
were NOT what they had been promised and strongly implied that a change was
in the works, which happened a week or two later.
But on TPR (and other sites as well), people were making fun of many of the
people who complained about the horrible restraints. But if they weren't a
problem, then the park obviously wouldn't have spent the money to change
them so soon after opening the ride.
It was also probably really hurting their onride photo sales, since there
was a major head-bang right before the onride photo, which meant that most
of the people were giving looks of pain in the pictures, which isn't
exactly what people would want to buy! It was actually entertaining to
look at the onride photos as you got off, to see who looked like they were
in the most pain. Not likely what they were hoping for! When you buy an
onride photo, you generally want to look like you were actually having fun!
That said, I can't comment on Skyrush's restraints, since I haven't ridden
it.