RHF wrote:
What's nonsense? It's simply descriptive. I guess the 'new hobbyist' should try
to 'learn' something. I know, 'learning' is a novel concept for some folks, but
give it a try!
dxAce
Michigan
USA
dxAce
Michigan
USA <
Of course you're right on this - but you have to admit, there is a
plethora of theory (as opposed to fact) and misinformation out there
on every topic, SW included, and the multiple names (balun, unun, etc)
attached to something as simple as matching transformer do not make it
easy for a novice to figure out what the contraption is, especially
when some of the names *actually* apply to other devices for other
purposes.
It isn't the equipment or theory that is hard - it is the imprecision
with which authoritative people toss around terminology, and once
tossed, fail to explain what it means. Some are even haughty and
demeaning when asked a question - how helpful is that? A novice can't
learn accurately (or satisfactorily) when explanations are in short
supply and their questions aren't answered in straightforward (and
friendly) terms. It makes no difference whether the information is
given by mouth or by written text.
Bruce Jensen
Not a bad idea. There are, as dxAce would also point out, several
books out there that already attempt to put information out for the
beginner. I personally don't know of any modern books that try to
conveniently wrap all the most important basic points in one (including
some of the nifty tech stuff related to odd equipment and propagation
details), but there may be some.
Perhaps this newsgroup, if it could set aside its differences for a few
months, could concoct such a "book" and place it online. Certainly the
expertise is here, and as long as we could agree on careful definitions
and clear explanations, we might have something of lasting value
(instead of all the superfluous, if occasionally interesting, bickering
about hurricanes and Iraq and politics).
A nice small dream...
Bruce Jensen
I don't think this topic is that simple and I can see that many people
don't understand it. Some of these are technical terms for devices that
perform certain functions but for starters they are not all the same.
It is not a trivial task to get these devices to operate with a flat
response 500 KHz to 30 MHz, which is what most people want in a
receiving system.
--
Telamon
Ventura, California