On Oct 4, 7:22 pm, poisoned rose <
pros...@poissonedrose.com> wrote:
>
> Out of all the eligible artists I collect myself, I thought Randy Newman
> was the #1 most deserving of induction.
Sampson's analysis has him as the least desering of the candidtaes:
http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_hall-of-fame-nom-2013.html
Randy Newman
A second nomination for the enigmatic singer/songwriter whose most
lasting contribution to music as a whole comes from his decidedly non-
rock film scores over the years many of which were brilliant and even
won him an Oscar. His forays into commercial releases as an artist
however occupy a very tiny niche, largely unsuccessful despite their
lyrical wit and melodic inventiveness. Undoubtedly his supporters
among the nominating committee looking to justify his candidacy would
point to his songwriting reputation, as they also did with the even
more undeserving Leonard Cohen and Laura Nyro, along with the equally
idiosyncratic Tom Waits, but in all four cases if outside
contributions as a writer are his most lasting legacy to rock it's
clearly not enough to warrant repeated looks by the Hall. These types
of quirky outsiders seem clearly designed to offset the committee's
reputed lack of enthusiasm for the more recent dominant candidates
from styles outside their comfort zone. Would it be a stretch to
suggest that they are even offered up to draw votes away from those
more polarizing figures from the rap realm by the aging voting body
members who share their discomfort with the directions rock 'n' roll
has taken? Is that too drastic a conspiracy theory for your gentle
minds to handle? Hmmm, well consider that Nyro's dubious election
denied the far more deserving Eric B. & Rakim last year, while Waits
presence bumped L.L. Cool J in 2010, and Cohen was deemed a suitable
alternative for the decaying fossils on with a ballot so they did not
have to have to vote for somebody named Afrika Bambaataa back in '08,
who undoubtedly would’ve frightened them half to death. Will Newman do
the same to the next candidate listed here this year?
N.W.A