Its very nice to hear from someone that has talent to play both PA an
CBA, I am actually thinking of buying a PA, now that I am only a CBA
player, thanyou for sharing Frank.
Hi Gino,
Thank you for your response. I don't know if it is talent that I have
or just a desire and determination to play both systems.
I am better at reading music and also increasing my knowledge of
scales, chords and chord inversions on the PA keyboard.
I then try to transfer what I learn to the CBA. I guess that is
natural since I started out on PA. Also I only speak English and here
in USA
there is much more educational material based on a piano style
keyboard. I really love the range of notes available within the span
of my hand
on the CBA though and that is part of its attraction for me.
I am curious of why you are interested in playing the PA in addition
to your CBA?
Best regards,
Frank
I would be interested to know what types of music you play on your CBA
and
Frank, I completely switched from the Diatonic to the CBA, so, I have
done some changes myself, I learned how to read music about 1 year ago
an it has been a large step in my life, seeing you can play both, mabe
I will use a B system also? I play a C-systm, but I think I can do
both mabe, however. The reason I would also like to try the PA is
because I want to have the have the same feeling Beethoven had when he
was sitting in front of th Piano, I have a lot of Beethoven, Mozart,
an Chopin, that I think would fit more better on a PA
accordion.......Chopin, "prelude". I want to try an play the music
exactly the way it is written with the most feeling..
ANything like that, you would be better off with a CBA converter, maybe a
bayan. The only way you would get the same feeling as Beethoven or Chopin is
probably with and actual piano. The Right hand on a PA is so much more
limited than either a piano or a CBA. The long reach possible on a CBA, if
you use the thumb, can somewhat make up for the limits of the left hand on a
Stradella system, and with a free bass CBA you could make a stab at the
classical piano repertoire.
This discussion makes me think of Lidia Kaminska. She plays a Zero
Sette B-system CBA (she's known as a bayanist, although she uses the
term "accordion" when speaking about it.) That instrument, with its
converter bass and seven chin switches, in addition to fifteen treble
switches on the grille, weighs thirty-five pounds! But she plays a
lot of transcriptions of Bach and other Baroque music as well as
pieces written for the accordion -- all seated.
Take care.
Alan
--
If you really want to bug me via email, remove the "_fish" from the address above.
__
You can read the FAQ for alt.binaries.karaoke at:
http://members.chello.nl/~j.a.komrij/faq.html
Take care.
Alan
That's what I would do, if I had a heavuy accordion. or use a stand. Trying
to save my knee until I qualify for Medicaid, then will try to see about an
artificial one. I play some classical stuff using the Stradella and a PA
keyboard, which the more I have attempted it, the more I find possible.
Freebass? The layout is different from the stradella, so I would have
to learn it all over agin right? Or does the convertor drop the chords
with the same layout??
Take care.
Alan
I don't know these different free bass layouts, but I think they are similar
to the right-hand CBA layout. I never yet played the converter or
single-note bass. I have found it possible to play a lot of classical
repertoire using Stradella, some of which seemed impossible until I got
better at it. there is a lot of stuff that just should be p[layed on piano
and organ, though. Organ is more adpatable, but how, for instance would you
play the Beethoven "Hammerklavier" sonata on the accordion? Few people can
even do it on th piano. OTOH "sonata" problem to play a waltz. I won't tell
you the classical repertoire I play because it is Haydn's "Surprise
Symphony".
On Dec 17, 3:34 pm, "ike milligan" <accordion...@mindspring.com>
wrote:
> "Alan Sharkis" <cartilaginous_f...@optonline.net> wrote in message