Are these the right changes? (courtesy of Al Stephens and DejaNews
archives) (1 line per bar)
Gmi / / /
Ami7 / D7 /
Gmi / / /
Emi7 / A7 /
Dmi / / /
Emi7 / A7 /
Dmi7 / G7 /
Cmi7 / F7 /
Bb7 / / /
Bb7 / / /
Eb7 / / /
Eb7 / / /
F#7 / / /
F#7 / / /
F7 / / /
Ami7 / D7 /
[repeat 1st 8 measures]
Bb7 / / /
Ab7 / G7 /
Cmi7 / / /
Ebmi7 / Ab7 /
Bb / / /
Gmi / C7 /
Cmi7 / F7 /
Bb / / /
TIA
--
Regards:
Joey Goldstein
Guitarist/Jazz Recording Artist/Teacher
Home Page: http://webhome.idirect.com/~joegold
Email: <joegold AT idirect DOT com>
I believe that's the key Jack Wilkins played it in
on "Trioart." And the sheet I have on it is also in Cm/Eb.
Brian
-----------------------------------------------------------
Got questions? Get answers over the phone at Keen.com.
Up to 100 minutes free!
http://www.keen.com
On Wed, 26 Jul 2000 20:39:34 GMT, Joey Goldstein <nos...@nowhere.net>
wrote in message <397F4C84...@nowhere.net> :
>
>What's the regular key, if any, for this tune? G minor?
>
>Are these the right changes? (courtesy of Al Stephens and DejaNews
>archives) (1 line per bar)
>
Joey,
I don't know what the *original* key is, but it seems to me that the
usual key is Eb (I think of it more as Eb than C minor)
Last week at Montreux we were trying to play as many tunes as we could
possibly think of so we wouldn't be repeating much. I thought to play
this tune so I wrote out some changes for my bassist. The are four
bars I'm not too sure about though, starting with the Ab7 in the first
ending. It works ok but I think it can be improved. Here is what I
wrote down last week:
Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / / / | Fm / Bb7 / |
Eb / / / | Bbm / Eb7 / | Ab7 / / / | Ab7 / / / |
Ebm / / / | Ab7 / / / | Dm7b5 / / / | G7 / / / |
Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / / / | Fm / Bb7 / |
Eb / / / | Bbm / C7+ / | Fm / / / | Abm / / / |
Eb / / / | Gm / C7 / | Fm / Bb7 / | Eb / (Dm7b5 G7) ||
I've seen a number of wildly different charts to this song, but I've
never seen one that entirely worked to my ear. -my own chart above
included :) I'd be interested in seeing other's variations too.
_________________________________________
Kevin Van Sant
jazz guitar
www.mindspring.com/~jazure/music.html - to buy my CDs and listen to J'Azure
www.onestopjazz.com - for a comprehensive index of internet jazz resources
www.onestopjazz.com/kvansant - for jazz guitar samples and info
--paul
Kevin Van Sant a écrit:
Hi Kevin, I happen to have a book « the best CHORD CHANGES for the best standard ever » written by Frank Mantooth. It is in the same key as yours. See if you find these changes an interesting variation.
Cm
/ Am7(b5) / | Dm11
/ G+7
/ | Cm /
/Bb / | Am7(b5) /
/D / |
Gm
/ E7(#9#11 / | Am7(b5)
/ D7(b5b9) / | Gm
/ Gb13 /
| Fm7 /
Bb13 / |
Eb
/ /
/ | Eb13sus /
/ / | Ab9
/ /
/ | Ab9sus / Ab9
/ |
Cm7(b5) /
/ /
| F13(#11) /
/ / |
B9 B9(#11) / /
| Bb9sus / G7/B /
|
Cm /
Am(b5) / |
Dm11 / G+7
/ | Cm /
/Bb / |
Am7(b5) / /D /
|
Gm /
E7(#9#11) / | Am(b5)
/ D7(b5b9) / | Gm
/ Gb13 /
| Fm7 /
Bb13 / |
Eb
/ Ab13
/ | Gm7(b5) / C+7(#9)
/ | Fm11 /
/
/ | Db9sus / Db9
/ |
Eb/Bb / /
/ | F13
/ F+9
/ | Bb9sus / Bb7(b9) /
| Eb
/ /
/ |
I have always had great playing Frank Mantooth's changes. You can buy this book at Hal Leonard Corporation and many other ones with improved changes.
Claude.
Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / C7b9/ | Fm / Bb7 / |
Bbm7/ / / | Eb7 / / / | Ebm7 / / / | Ab7 / / / |
Dbm11 / Gb13 / | Cm7 / F7 / | B9 / / / | Dm7b5 / G7+ / |
Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / C7b9/ | Fm / Bb7 / |
Bbm7 / / / | Gm7b5 / C7+ / | Fm / / / | Abm / Db7 / |
Eb / G7+ / | Cm7 / F9 / | Fm / Bb7 / | Eb / (Dm7b5 G7) ||
Gene
For How deep is the Ocean?
It lists the original key ( I wonder is original synonymous with
standard?) as: F
< VBG >
TJ
--
Please remove the word NOSPAM from my E Mail address when replying.
Thank you
Take a tune like Softly as in a morning sunrise....Orginal key is
Em...Standard Key is Cm.
My Funny valentine? Orinal Key is like....D I believe....
All those all show tunes were oringinally in weird keys to accomadate the
singers.
Steve
TJ <tjbe...@nospamsympatico.ca> wrote in message
news:398060E...@nospamsympatico.ca...
Like all those big-band charts are in 15 flats to accommodate all those horn
players who have to subtract 13 flats to get into concert key, and to
accommodate whatever the current average upper reach might be for lead
trumpet.
:-)
> Seldom is original the same as standard...
>
> Take a tune like Softly as in a morning sunrise....Orginal key is
> Em...Standard Key is Cm.
And it was a tango, originally!
Phil
>
> My Funny valentine? Orinal Key is like....D I believe....
>
> All those all show tunes were oringinally in weird keys to accomadate the
> singers.
>
Cm / / / | G7+5/B / / / | Cm7/Bb / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / Gb7 / | Fm / Bb7 / |
Eb7 / / / | / / / | Ab7 / / / | Ab7 / / / |
B7 / / / | B7 / / / | Bb7 / / / | Dm7b5 / G7+5+9|
Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / / / | Fm / Bb7 / |
Eb7 / / / | Gm7b5 / C7+ / | Fm / / / | Abm / Db7 |
Eb / G7+5 | Cm7 / F7 / | Fm / Bb7 / | Eb / (Dm7b5 G7) ||
Let me know how you like these changes.
I heard this line cliche used in a Coleman Hawkins version too
> Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / Gb7 / | Fm / Bb7 / |
> Eb7 / / / | / / / | Ab7 / / / | Ab7 / / / |
> B7 / / / | B7 / / / | Bb7 / / / | Dm7b5 / G7+5+9|
I thought the Eb7, Ab7, B7 changes were 'standard' till
this thread started. The changes I'm using for those
8 bars are
Eb / / / | Bb-7 / Eb7 / | Ab7 / / / | Ab7 / / / |
B7 / / / | B7 / / / | Ab-7 / Db7 / | Dm7b5 / G7+5+9|
I usually play the B7 as lydian dominant, but the Coleman
Hawkins recording is C (or D#) diminished.
Bob Valentine
> Here is what I
> wrote down last week:
>
> Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
> Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / / / | Fm / Bb7 / |
> Eb / / / | Bbm / Eb7 / | Ab7 / / / | Ab7 / / / |
> B7 / / / | B7 / / / | Bb7 / A7| Ab7/ G7/|
>
> Cm / / / | Dm7b5 / G7 / | Cm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / |
> Gm / / / | Am7b5 / D7 / | Gm / / / | Fm / Bb7 / |
> Eb / / / | Db7 C7+ / | Fm / / / | Abm / / / |
> Eb over Bb /G7 over Bbass| Cm / F7/ | Fm / Bb7 / | Eb / (Dm7b5 G7) ||
>
>
--
Mark Eisenman
To order my CD "The Chant" go to
http://www.samcd.com/
or
http://www.absound.ca/music/search/search.html
and SEARCH for Mark Eisenman
Please Visit My site:
http://www.yorku.ca/faculty/academic/eisenman/default.html
for upcoming appearances:
http://www.yorku.ca/faculty/academic/eisenman/upcoming.html
MARK EISENMAN
276 WILLOW AVE. TOR. ONT.
CANADA M4E-3K7
PHONE: 416-694-6688
FAX: 416-690-0587
e-mail: eise...@yorku.ca