DBall
aok <a...@home.com> wrote in message news:wGhu7.141332$K6.66471653@news2...
Best regards
Luke
Bill
"Scooby Don't" <get...@hypocrites.com> wrote in message news:<3bba0...@mk-nntp-1.news.uk.worldonline.com>...
Jim
monic...@my-deja.com (Bill) wrote:
"Utter bilge. First, this set (like "Tree With Roots") may well be
sourced from fan-circulated CDRs -- "White Bear" discs (and their
predecessors) have shown a remarkable tendency to turn up shortly
after more extensive compilations of the same material have been put
together by fans. I first heard most of the material in 1998, and the
rest of it was circulating on tape and CDR more than a year ago. As
far as I can tell, the only commercial Dylan boots of the last few
years with material that wasn't taken from already-circulating
CDRs/tapes was on GBS3 and Genuine Live '66..."
"jbeck57143" <jbeck...@aol.com> wrote in message
news:e3209eaa.01100...@posting.google.com...
I suppose you'll respond to this with another barrage of equally disjointed
nonsense as I've become accustomed to, really I don't care, I have better
things to do than argue with silly people like you and if the only thing
that comes out of this is that one person is denied hearing this release on
either cd or cd-r (i.e. you) than it's all been tremendously worthwhile. :-)
"Bill" <monic...@my-deja.com> wrote in message
news:ddfe567.01100...@posting.google.com...
> Utter bilge. First, this set (like "Tree With Roots") may well be
> sourced from fan-circulated CDRs -- "White Bear" discs (and their
> predecessors) have shown a remarkable tendency to turn up shortly
> after more extensive compilations of the same material have been put
> together by fans. I first heard most of the material in 1998, and the
> rest of it was circulating on tape and CDR more than a year ago. As
> far as I can tell, the only commercial Dylan boots of the last few
> years with material that wasn't taken from already-circulating
> CDRs/tapes was on GBS3 and Genuine Live '66.
> Second, since the set wasn't out as of September 29, it would be
> rather difficult for this motley "lot of CD collectors" to come
> together and refuse to trade the set.
> Third, the only reason it might seem to "Scooby" that "a lot of
> cd collectors" are doing this is that he's reading old rmd threads
> while losing track of the various names he's been posting under --
> it's really just his echo, his shadow, and him.
> Fourth, according to "Scooby," in his last diatribe on the
> subject (only 3 days ago) "I urge cd collectors NOT to trade future
> commercially release product, such as the Guam Rolling Thunder
> rehearsals. I know this won't happen . . ." So when he said "a lot of
> CD collectors are refusing to copy this disc . . ." he was just making
> it up. Trying to pull the wool over your eyes. Lying through his
> teeth, some of the less charitable contributors to this group might
> say
@hypocrites.com> wrote in message
"Bill" <monic...@my-deja.com> wrote in message
news:ddfe567.01100...@posting.google.com...
> Third, the only reason it might seem to "Scooby" that "a lot of
> cd collectors" are doing this is that he's reading old rmd threads
> while losing track of the various names he's been posting under --
> it's really just his echo, his shadow, and him.
Incorrect. I've haven't posted on this newsgroup for several months. Mainly
because of personal issues but also I got fed up with having to have
pointless 'arguments' with people such as yourself who are ill-equipped to
respond to my comments in an intelligent and well thought out manner.
Unlike you, who counts the number of days between my posts and spends the
time trying to identify which posts are me under different pseudonyms. Don't
you have anything better to do? Somewhat scarily, you're right though, I
have, in the past, used alternate 'identitles' such as scoob and others I
can't even remember. So have a lot of other people here, so what? It doesn't
matter at all and doesn't detract from the content of my posts at all. I've
never attempted to sabotage this newgroup or set out to make unconstructive
posts or nonsensical, off-topic discussions, as other have from time to
time. I have, on occasion, had a laugh here and there and perhaps, with my
comments on commercial cd bootlegs, inadvertantly invoked the 'rage' of cd-r
collectors, who, for some unknown reason, have the right to make any
misinformed anti-commercial cd bootleg comment they like without comment or
critic from others. It's a newsgroup about Bob Dylan for God sake, a bit of
fun, Bill, something you seem to have no sense of. The worrying thing is
that you can actually be bothered to trace and make note of posts that you
believe are from me. Bizzarre.
I'm a cd collector of long standing, I know a great deal of other
people who share my sentiments with regard to the issue on hand. I share
comments and information here with the intention of helping people who are
interested in collecting commercial cd bootlegs because I know what I'm
talking about. I was once criticized for suggesting that a newbie might
prefer to start looking around for original cds rather than cd-rs. I was
simply suggesting that there's an alternative to cd-r trading that a newbie
might not be aware of. Apparently, though, I made a mistake because this is
'not allowed' to be discussed on this newsgroup. cd-r trading is fine, but
mention 'illegal' cds and your worse than the Devil. I was also criticised
when I corrected someone who had said that Scorpio had copied The Genuine
Bootleg Series from a fan-produced cd-r peoject, (which they hadn't) which
is just ridiculous. If I hadn't made the comment, the original post would
have gone unquestioned. Sorry if you, or others don't like it, but I'm not
intimidated by the apparent cd-r 'mob mentallity' that dominates RMD, I'll
stand up and voice my opinion and say what I believe, and in the name of
freedom of speech, I strongly encourge other to do the same. I also post
comments when theres a lack of information and/or misinformation about cd
releases here and on websites, ( such as your 'guide') primarily because of
the fact that, although you might not like it, I am far more 'well
connected' when it comes to cd bootlegs that you are and far more of an
'expert' than you are simply due to the fact that I actually am a cd
collector and you obviously aren't. (Several comments and on your site are,
in fact, mine and several 'forthcoming' releases on your updates page, had
in the first instance, become more general public knowledge directly because
of a comment made by me.) If it wasn't for myself and Ramblin' Man,
virtually no pre-release information regarding commercial cd releases would
ever be posted on this newsgroup. In the distant past, I have circulated
some cd-r copies of otherwise unavailable cd bootlegs before anyone else
did, but not any more, I , and from what I can gather, other cd collectors,
are becoming increasingly sick of the anti-cd collector sentiment that is
constantly being touted within this and other newsgroups and cd-r trading
circles and people such as yourself who seem to 'target' any comment made
about a cd release with the usual 'I had it on cd-r two years ago, it's
nothing new' derisional crap without having any knowledge of the actual
content.
As for the cd Vs. cd-r 'issue', Phill Townsend, perhaps the most
authoritive voice on Dylan commercial cd bootlegs there is ( although I know
he wouldn't say that himself) argued about this issue long before I ever
made a public comment about it, but I suppose you wouldn't know about that.
I believe you're suggesting that others who have posted similar pro-cd
comments, ie chalawler, 'Village Green' ( in what I believe was his only
ever post, although there may be more under different names, you'll be
better informed on that than me, Bill, seeing as you take the time to find
these things out :-) ) and Ramblin' Man are, in fact, me. Is that what
you're saying? (If that were the case, I'm apparently the only cd collector
out there and the only possible source for the Guam Rehearsals cd. Which is
bad news for cd-r traders.) In reality, these are some of the more
recognisable RMD cd collectors who are, in fact, real life human beings who,
unsurprisingly to everyone out there (except you) aren't me. I do hope they
will verify this here independently. They have, and I'm sure they will, also
echo my sentiments without any encouragement from me whatsoever, regardless
of whether they choose to circulate this disc or not ( it's entirely their
choice, i'm just expressing an opinion and a suggestion to other cd
collectors, who may or may not agree/support my action.) That puts pay to
your 'his echo, his shadow and him' nonsense, doesn't it?
Let's get to the bottom of this Bill, could the REAL reason you feel the
need to comment negatively and attempt to discredit every post that I make
be because not only are you completely anti-commercial bootleg cd to such an
extent that you even believe that a cds artwork is 'immoral', but more
significantly because I damadged your obviously considerable ego by daring
to suggest that the commercial cd content of your guide wasn't very good and
now you've gone into a child-like sulk? In all honesty, and without a hint
of tounge-in-cheek fun-poking, I appreciate that a lot of hard work and
effort went into your site and it's designed to be informative and helpful,
but, as a cd collector, and therefore a certain type of specific collector
that would use your site, I find some of the comments regarding cds
bafflingly misguided. As a cd collector, I'm sorry, but I can't just take
your comments seriously because you show evidence that you don't know what
you're talking about again and again.The comment about the 'Tree With Roots'
release is yet another fine example. I would dig up other examples, but I
really don't wan't you or your pointless arguments to take up my time any
futher than I feel is necessary.
Instead of taking this as constructive criticism, and looking at ways that
you could improve the Guide to cater for cd (specific) collectors, who
generally don't make inter-format comparisons, and wouldn't avoid a cd in
favor of a more complete/better sound quality cd-r, you choose to declare
war on me or something, calling me a liar and so forth. Really, Bill, if I'd
have known you took criticism so poorly I wouldn't have said anything,
besides it was a while ago now and you really should get some councelling or
something to help you get over it. Oooh, look I can see you turning red...
:-)
DBall
Tracklist from Ramblin' Man's post on 19th September 2001. ( Thanks RM for
typing this out, couldn't be bothered myself ) -
DISC ONE
REHERSALS FOR "THE NIGHT OF THE HURRICANE 2"
STUDIO INSTRUMENT RENTAL, LOS ANGELES, 22ND AND 23RD JANUARY 1976 22ND
JANUARY 1976; YOU AIN'T GOING NOWHERE; OH SISTER (1); OH SISTER (2);
SARA (1); MOZAMBIQUE. 23RD JANUARY 1976; JUST LIKE A WOMAN (1); JUST LIKE A
WOMAN (2); WHEN I
PAINT MY MASTERPIECE; MAGGIES FARM (1); MAGGIES FARM (2); ONE TOO MANY
MORNINGS (1); ONE TOO MANY MORNINGS (2); ROMANCE IN DURANGO; ISIS (1); ISIS
(2); POSITIVELY 4TH STREET; OH SISTER (3); OH SISTER (4); ONE MORE CUP OF
COFFEE; SARA (2); JUST LIKE A WOMAN (3); HURRICANE.
DISC TWO
TOUR REHEARSAL, BELLEVUE BILTMORE HOTEL, CLEARWATER, FL. 15TH APRIL 1976
"THE TRIO TAPE" (STONER/WYETH/RIVERA) JUST LIKE TOM THUMBS BLUES (1); THE
SUN IS SHINING; LAY LADY LAY; ONE MORE
CUP OF COFFEE (1); IT TAKES A LOT TO LAUGH, IT TAKES A TRAIN TO CRY; BALLAD
OF HOLLIS BROWN; HOLD ME IN YOUR ARMS; MOZAMBIQUE; IDIOT WIND; ONE MORE CUP
OF COFFEE (2); SHELTER FROM THE STORM; JUST LIKE TOM THUMBS BLUES (2); ISIS;
RITA MAE; I THREW IT ALL AWAY.
DISC THREE
DRESS REHEARSALS WITH FULL ROLLING THUNDER REVUE FOR 1976 TOUR. BELLEVUE
BILTMORE HOTEL, CLEARWATER, FL. 17TH APRIL 1976 I THREW IT ALL AWAY; GOING
GOING GONE (1); GOING GOING GONE (2); GOING GOING GONE (3); ONE MORE CUP OF
COFFEE (1); ONE MORE CUP OF COFFEE (2); TOMORROW IS A LONG TIME; MOZAMBIQUE
(1); MOZAMBIQUE (2); MOZAMBIQUE (3); LAY LADY LAY; IDIOT WIND; I'LL BE YOUR
BABY TONIGHT (1); I'LL BE YOUR BABY TONIGHT (2); MAGGIES FARM; ONE TOO MANY
MORNINGS; SEVEN DAYS; GOING GOING GONE (4).
DISC FOUR
MISCELLANEOUS 1976 REHEARSALS STUDIO INSTRUMENT RENTAL, LOS ANGELES, 23RD
JANUARY 1976; LAY LADY LAY SHANGRI-LA STUDIOS, MALIBU, CA WITH ERIC CLAPTON
AND RON WOOD 30TH MARCH 1976; SPANISH IS THE LOVING TONGUE/ADELITA; IDIOT
WIND. TOUR REHEARSALS, BELLEVUE BILTMORE HOTEL,CLEARWATER, FL. APRIL 1976;
I'LL BE YOUR BABY TONIGHT; WHERE DID VINCENT VAN GOGH? ; I PITY THE POOR
IMMIGRANT (1); BLOWIN' IN THE WIND (1); I PITY THE POOR IMMIGRANT (2);
BLOWIN' IN THE WIND (2); STUCK INSIDE OF MOBILE WITH THE MEMPHIS BLUES AGAIN
(1); STUCK INSIDE OF MOBILE WITH THE MEMPHIS BLUES AGAIN (2). DRESS
REHEARSALS WITH FULL ROLLING THUNDER REVUE FOR 1976 TOUR. BELLEVUE BILTMORE
HOTEL, CLEARWATER, FL. 17TH APRIL 1976; SARA; JUST LIKE TOM THUMBS BLUES; IT
TAKES A LOT TO LAUGH IT TAKES A TRAIN TO CRY; YOU ANGEL YOU (1); YOU ANGEL
YOU (2)
REHEARSAL APRIL 1976; STUCK INSIDE OF MOBILE WITH THE MEMPHIS BLUES AGAIN
SPECIAL RIDER DEMO RECORDING, CLEARWATER 17TH APRIL 1976; SEVEN DAYS
REHEARSAL FOR "HARD RAIN" TV SPECIAL, COLARADO HOTEL MAY 20TH/21ST 1976;
JUST LIKE A WOMAN (1); JUST LIKE A WOMAN (2); TANGLED UP IN BLUE (1);
TANGLED UP IN BLUE (2). REJECTED TV SPECIAL PERFORMANCES, BELLEVUE BILTMORE
HOTEL, CLEARWATER, FL. 22ND APRIL 1976; ONE MORE CUP OF COFFEE; MOST LIKELY
YOU'LL GO YOUR WAY (AND
I'LL GO MINE)
"DBall" <dbal...@pipeline.com> wrote in message
news:9pf2nn$nq1$1...@nntp9.atl.mindspring.net...
DBall
Scooby Don't wrote...
http://monicasdude.tripod.com/DYLAN76.htm
Bill
"DBall" <dbal...@pipeline.com> wrote in message news:<9pf2nn$nq1$1...@nntp9.atl.mindspring.net>...
http://monicasdude.tripod.com/DYLAN76.HTM
Bill (who's in need of case-sensitivity training . . .)
"DBall" <dbal...@pipeline.com> wrote in message news:<9pf2nn$nq1$1...@nntp9.atl.mindspring.net>...
Jim Beck
2. All of the April-May 1976 material has been circulating freely
for more than seven years. It was listed in Dundas '94, as well as on
Olof Bjorner's pages.
3. Some of the January 1976 material has also been circulating
since 1994 (if not earlier); the remainder has been circulating for
more than a year and a half. Again, refer to Dundas and Bjorner.
4. A significant portion of this material has already circulated
on CD. Check out
http://www.angelfire.com/wa/monicasdude/CDGuideD.htm
under "Day Before The Hurricane" and "Days Before Hard Rain." Check
out
http://monicasdude.tripod.com/DYLAN76.HTM
from my old tapes reviews pages for my comments on a somewhat
different selection of excerpts.
5. "Scooby's" comment that May 1976 recordings predate the 1976
Rolling Thunder tour demonstrates the unreliability of his
information. He's shilling for a boot seller, and he's neither
particularly good at it or particularly honest about it. He's a
malignant troll-for-profit.
Bill
"Scooby Don't" <get...@hypocrites.com> wrote in message news:<9pflu2$kse$1...@newsg3.svr.pol.co.uk>...
Bill
jbeck...@aol.com (jbeck57143) wrote in message news:<e3209eaa.01100...@posting.google.com>...
Anne!
"Scooby Don't" <get...@hypocrites.com> wrote:
>
> If your intended goal is to humilite me
>in some way,