"Alan Cooper" <amcoo...@SPAMoptonline.net> wrote
[among other stuff snipped]
> Never thought much of Denis Matthews' Mozart.
> How do others feel?
>
Gosh, that brings back memories from my teens. Our village library had a large record
collection, not at all typical for a small upstate town. Therein lies a story and maybe
I'll tell it here sometime.
My first serious girlfriend was having a go at K. 310, and we resorted to the library to
hear how Schnabel and others dealt with it. We found his six HMV sides a finely
sustained account which answered most of her questions. We would have left it at that,
except that four sides of Denis Matthews were also on hand, and newly arrived, two
Columbia 78s of Dinu Lipatti's performance. Well, these were new and shiny, we had
to hear 'em, this pianist completely unknown to us. I won't say that the warmth and loft
of Lipatti's playing eclipsed Schnabel, but it was a close-run contest. Matthews was
sampled last and was found by comparison to be so sedate that we never got beyond
the first movement. So there's one primordial reaction for you, formed not later than 1952.
jdw