Alternate 'You Never Give Me Your Money' Beatles
BibsBro
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9g-lS8KpX3A&feature=rec-rev-rn-1r-1
I never heard this before.
I wonder why it wasn't on Anthology?
BibsBro
Stephen X. Carter
wrote:
Let It Be soundtrack???
--
steve.hat.stephencarter.not.com.but.net
Nothing is Beatle Proof!!
Mr Kite posters and more at http://www.zazzle.com/mr_kite*
Mr Kite posters and more at http://www.zazzle.co.uk/mr_kite*
brilton
> On Thu, 10 Dec 2009 22:06:19 -0500, "BibsBro" <Bib...@taxachusetts.com>
> wrote:
>
>
>> Alternate 'You Never Give Me Your Money' Beatles
>>
>> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9g-lS8KpX3A&feature=rec-rev-rn-1r-1
>>
>> I never heard this before.
>>
>> I wonder why it wasn't on Anthology?
>>
>
> Let It Be soundtrack???
>
No. This track is one of a batch of semi-finished "Abbey Road" tracks
which have been booted as far back as the late 70s. The first bootleg I
know of had the Abbey Road songs on side one, and a tape of Paul and
Donovan on side two.
richforman
Really cool to hear, thanks a lot. Some great piano playing from
Paul's part and what a cool jam it evolves into at the end.
richforman
Dimitrios Paskoudniakis
"BibsBro" <Bib...@taxachusetts.com> wrote in message
news:XP6dnXlzFK6xKrzW...@supernews.com...
If you put every take/alternate version of every Beatles song out on
Anthology, you might get to Anthology 100. Since there were only 3
Anthology two-disc packages, they had to be very choosy. Further, Abbey
Road is limited to Anthology 3 along with the White Album and Let It Be.
There are only so many alternate tracks that can make it to Anthology 3. I
guess this one lost out to the other tracks given this constraint. If they
decide to release Anthology 4 through 100, it will probably be there.
BibsBro
"Dimitrios Paskoudniakis" <gree...@yeahright.com> wrote in message
news:hg098l$nmn$1...@news.eternal-september.org...
Cool!
Anthology 4...Anthology 5...Anthology 6...Anthology 7...Anthology
8...Anthology 9...Anthology 10...Anthology
11....................................
I'll start saving my pennies.
I'd love to have a cd with alternate versions like 'You Never Give Me Your
Money' !
Phred
=========
After a hiatus with vinyl boots, I started gathering them again on CD
after logging onto RMB in the early 90s. One of my first purchases
was a set of Japanese discs that had the full official releases of
albums with about a half dozen each of corresponding boots added to
them respectively. Abbey Road contained this one.
I *did* have this demo of YNGMYM on vinyl and carried around on
cassette in my car for years. And was delighted to have a better
version on CD. The original vinyl was the gatefold double album
"Sweet Apple Tracks"
Nil
> I *did* have this demo of YNGMYM on vinyl and carried around on
> cassette in my car for years. And was delighted to have a better
> version on CD. The original vinyl was the gatefold double album
> "Sweet Apple Tracks"
I have a vinyl booleg by that title, but it's all stuff from the Let It
Be Twickenham Film Studios sessions and YNGMYM isn't on it. Pretty hard
to listen to - badly recorded and boring.
I have a CD bootleg called "Alternate Abbey Road" that has this early
mix of YNGMYM.
LookingGlass
This demo clears up the question for me that Paul is singing "Any
*jobber* got the sack..." It's quite clear.
RichL
Yes, I noticed that too.
D Finnigan
>
> This demo clears up the question for me that Paul is singing "Any
> *jobber* got the sack..." It's quite clear.
>
I always heard it as jobber. It was "yellow lorry slow" that I couldn't make
out until I read the printed lyrics.
Jeff
It was always that way for me. Strange lyric indeed!
D Finnigan
My guess is that it was sung that way to fit the tune.
Paul's saying, "any job he had, he always got sacked."
rwalker
I always got that sense from the lyrics, but heard it as "had a job
and got the sack." Probably because jobber is not a common word in
American English.
Lizz Holmans
wrote:
>
>I always got that sense from the lyrics, but heard it as "had a job
>and got the sack." Probably because jobber is not a common word in
>American English.
More often heard as a 'jobbing plumber, or carpenter, or electrician'
or whatever. An independent contractor, not tied to a company.
Lizz 'I never tie anyone in my company' Holmans
--
Whatever happened to linoleum floors, petroleum jelly and two world wars?
http://www.fannation.com/blogs/show/826793-cricket-she-wrote
AllaBest
> On Mon, 14 Dec 2009 15:21:19 -0500, rwalker <rwal...@despammed.com>
> wrote:
>
> >I always got that sense from the lyrics, but heard it as "had a job
> >and got the sack." Probably because jobber is not a common word in
> >American English.
>
> More often heard as a 'jobbing plumber, or carpenter, or electrician'
> or whatever. An independent contractor, not tied to a company.