The reason I ask is that we have a lot of black bears around here, and I was
wondering if I could shoot one without harming it, but hurt it just enough
so it might remember not to come back.
Any advice and thoughts welcome. They get into everything, but in no way
are really dangerous to people -- so far. I'm just tired of chasing my
"bear proof" trash cans down the hill. :-)
Sheldon
--------------------------------------------------------------
Learn about rec.guns at http://www.recguns.net
Last call to win a Fulton Armory .308 Titan Carbine and defend
liberty at the same time! Details at http://myguns.net
--------------------------------------------------------------
--
Always remember:
Bull Connor was a Democrat!
I guess I could try loading my own cartridges and pull this off, but if the
bullet won't come out in a standard revolver you can just remove the
cartridge. A ball stuck in a black powder revolver is going to be a real
pain in the butt.
I'm still open to any ideas.
Thanks.
Don't discount the danger of a blackie. I thought I read somewhere that
more people are attacked by black bears than by grizzlies. Reportedly, the
trash bears can be the worst as they are quickly losing their fear of
humans. I'm not sure about a blackpowder revolver, but I think they make a
rubber bullet load for 12 gauge that the "bear chasers" working for the
state use to discourage them. Check with Fish and Game. They may be able
to recommend something effective and legal.
Sounds like a perfect way to piss them off enough that they will come after
you. ;-)
--
Cheers!
Alex.C
There are twelve million sheep in Ontario.
Problem is nine million of them think they are people.
Communication: The art of moving an idea from one mind to another, hopefully
without distortion.
#OK, here's the question. I'm getting a black powder revolver, and was
#wondering if I could put a really small load in the chamber so that it would
#hit a plywood backstop and bounce off?
#
#The reason I ask is that we have a lot of black bears around here, and I was
#wondering if I could shoot one without harming it, but hurt it just enough
#so it might remember not to come back.
#
#Any advice and thoughts welcome. They get into everything, but in no way
#are really dangerous to people -- so far. I'm just tired of chasing my
#"bear proof" trash cans down the hill. :-)
#
#Sheldon
#
#
All you need to do is approach the bear with the your black powder
revolver pointed in his/her direction and say in a clear, loud voice,
"If you don't move on, I'll blow your f**king head off". Works every
time ... unless the bear also has a black powder revolver, in which
case YOU move on.
#
#Just remember to grind the front sight off first.
#
It's still gonna hurt.
--
"Everything in excess! To enjoy the flavor of life, take big bites.
Moderation is for monks."
The sows get really touchy if their cubs are around.
John
#OK, here's the question. I'm getting a black powder revolver, and was
#wondering if I could put a really small load in the chamber so that it would
#hit a plywood backstop and bounce off?
#
#The reason I ask is that we have a lot of black bears around here, and I was
#wondering if I could shoot one without harming it, but hurt it just enough
#so it might remember not to come back.
#
#Any advice and thoughts welcome. They get into everything, but in no way
#are really dangerous to people -- so far. I'm just tired of chasing my
#"bear proof" trash cans down the hill. :-)
"They get into everything, but in no way
are really dangerous to people"
Unless you irritate one by shooting it with a squib load.
Like Gunny said garbage habituated black bears can be very dangerous.
An important step you can take is to eliminate the scent attraction
and possible/intermittant food reward they get for visiting your
garbage cans before they start visiting the house looking for dog
food, the dog, or members of your household. Once they no longer fear
people and approach you even if you're trying to scare them off I'd
say it's time to kill them. When that time comes you'll want
something more reliable and packing much more punch than the usual cap
and ball revolver; a traditional solution is a 12 gauge pump and
Brenneke slugs. It's been a few years since I read it but _Bear
Attacks: Their Causes and Avoidance_ by Herrero is quite good -
frightening and useful. Proceed with caution.
Use of a handgun is not near as effective as bear spray. Get the real
stuff.
Jul 2, 8:38 PM (ET)
VERNON, N.J. (AP) - A northwestern New Jersey man said he was mugged in his
driveway by a sandwich-craving bear. Henry Rouwendal said he was packing his
car last Friday when he was hit from behind and knocked to the ground. He
said the culprit was a black bear who took his Italian sandwich.
Rouwendal said he kicked the bear in the snout and throat.
He said the bruin made off with the bread, salami and other meats but left
behind the lettuce, onions and tomatoes.
Vernon Township police said it's the first time a bear has attacked a person
in the rural community in more than 25 years.
The state Environmental Protection Department so far has classified it as an
"incident" and not an attack.
Frank
# Shooting a game animal with a firearm might be a problem if they are not a
# threat or are out of season. You need to find out what is legal in your
# state.
# George in Las Vegas
I think in most states if it's on your property and it's behavior is
destructive you're good to go. In VA bear and deer were year round on farms
as they were considered agricultural pests. In KY, where I am now if it's on
my property it's mine. That probaly does not include federally protectd
species, some of the avian types of which keeping looking at my chickens,
though they have yet to do anything yet. I beleive I have an adequate
solution should they become a problem. A shotgun and a large fire pit for
garbage and where we put (small) livestock that expire.
--
Always remember:
Bull Connor was a Democrat!
# OK, here's the question. I'm getting a black powder revolver, and was
# wondering if I could put a really small load in the chamber so that it would
# hit a plywood backstop and bounce off?
#
# The reason I ask is that we have a lot of black bears around here, and I was
# wondering if I could shoot one without harming it, but hurt it just enough
# so it might remember not to come back.
#
# Any advice and thoughts welcome. They get into everything, but in no way
# are really dangerous to people -- so far. I'm just tired of chasing my
# "bear proof" trash cans down the hill. :-)
#
# Sheldon
Advice: Don't even *CONSIDER* it.
Thoughts: A really good way to turn a garbage-raiding bear from "not
dangerous" to "deadly dangerous" is to piss them off. Shooting them with
a light load such as you seem to be contemplating is a good way to do
that.
Advice, part 2: It's my considered opinion that shooting at a bear with
anything smaller than a "full strength" .30-06 or more potent rifle, or
a 12 gauge loaded with slugs, is something that should only be done as a
desperation measure taken when a more suitable weapon is unavailable and
Mr(s). bear is in the process of trying to turn you into dinner.
Anything less, in my opinion, constitutes nothing more or less than a
fancy way of trying to commit "suicide-by-bear".
--
Email shown is deceased. If you would like to contact me by email, please
post something that makes it obvious in this or another group you see me
posting in with a "how to contact you" address, and I'll get back to you.
Whether you're talking human or animal if they're worth shooting, they are
worth killing. Loud noises will sometimes scare a bear off, especially if
it's a young bear unused to people. You might be better served with a 12
ga. shotgun loaded with heavy rifled slugs. If you insist on using a black
powder pistol, it better be a .44 caliber Walker Colt loaded to the max,
although a .577 howdah pistol might be better.
-Raf
This will give you a nice report, plenty of smoke and fire. If you end
up needing real defensive power, you are going to have to make a
tactical advance. (Run like hell.)
Use a brass rod and a hammer and beat like hell. Even if you forget
powder (what dumb-ass would do that?) you can still remove the nipple
and fit a brass rod slender enough to hammer the ball out. The worse
is getting a ball stuck in the forcing cone of a Remington revolver.
That can be a real pain.
Naw. You just put the whole thing in your blacksmithing forge and heat it
until the lead runs out. LOL
Black bears are hamless, until they decide not to be. Then they can be
deadly. They outweigh you. They outrun you. They outfight you. They can
absorb a lot of punishment and still keep coming. The problem with black
bears is that no one can predict their behavior. If you are commited to
nonlethal methods then I still think a Fish and Game rubber 12 gauge shell
followed by real 12 gauge slugs in a pump shot gun are the way to go. Hit
them in the ass with the rubber bullet and depending on the results, watch
them run, or be prepared to defend your life with the slugs. It's too bad
it comes to that sometimes. After all, they aren't "evil". They are just
following their instincts and trying to get a meal the easiest way possible.
John
So what I'm saying to you is don't point and discharge a weak loaded
firearm at what could potentionally be a dangerous animal, unless your
intention is to kill that animal with the first shot. That's one of the
last things I'd want to do, is make a dangerous animal such as a bear
mad, then not be able to follow up with a killing shot.
I can attest to that with first hand experience.
I accidently got to close to a sow and cub a few years ago, just
didn't see
them as I was working. Sow got real bent out of shape and stood up
growling
to impress me and scare me. It worked. If my dogs hadn't been near
by I
think she might have ate my butt for lunch. Dogs harrassed her back
into
the woods.
Randy
# Simply cover the top of your trash with powdered ,hot cayenne
# pepper...that should keep their noses out of your trash!
#
would an electric fence charger work?
I also saw a thing on PBS about a company that makes bear-proof metal boxes
to store your trash cans in. they fasten to concrete pads.
He hasn't had one opened by a bear to date.
--
Jim Yanik
jyanik
at
kua.net
#OK, here's the question. I'm getting a black powder revolver, and was
#wondering if I could put a really small load in the chamber so that it would
#hit a plywood backstop and bounce off?
Sure.
#The reason I ask is that we have a lot of black bears around here, and I was
#wondering if I could shoot one without harming it, but hurt it just enough
#so it might remember not to come back.
Or piss it off and have it come after you.
#Any advice and thoughts welcome. They get into everything, but in no way
#are really dangerous to people -- so far. I'm just tired of chasing my
#"bear proof" trash cans down the hill. :-)
Put your trashcans where the bear can't get them.
#Simply cover the top of your trash with powdered ,hot cayenne
#pepper...that should keep their noses out of your trash!
I used to hang condoms filled with ammonia and covered with peanut
butter from my fruit trees. It took each bear one time to decide they
didn't like my apples.
# Back when I was a young-un my grandfather and father told me that I
# should never, NEVER point a firearm at any living thing unless I
# intended to kill it. That's kind of a cover all statement. In other
# words, never point a gun at a human, unless it's a bad guy intent on
# killing you. Don't shoot at noises in the brush while hunting, be sure
# of your target and what's behind it. Don't shoot at animals unless you
# intend to kill and eat it.
#
# So what I'm saying to you is don't point and discharge a weak loaded
# firearm at what could potentionally be a dangerous animal, unless your
# intention is to kill that animal with the first shot. That's one of the
# last things I'd want to do, is make a dangerous animal such as a bear
# mad, then not be able to follow up with a killing shot.
#
My family got a chuckle out of this as I related it to them.
Basically
My wife and I carry nines on our CCW. I would not shoot the bear with a nine.
I sometimes carry a .44 Mag around the farm in a holster. Only if I had no
other option and a life was clearly in danger human or domestic animal.
If I had time for a long gun, I think the thuty-thuty would be the minimum. I
have other .30 cal rifles - .303, 30-06, .308, 8mm. I have 7.62 x 39 but they
are a bit weaker than the the thuty-thuty and the bullets don't seem as good,
FMJ vs softpoints.
That or the 870 with slugs which is my general purpose, noise in the baryard
at night, buck and slugs in the Sidesaddle gun.
Frank
#
# Just remember to grind the front sight off first.
#
And don't forget the grease..... ;)
)
I took a trail ride trip to the National Forest in New Mexico - a place
called Valle Vidal - a year or two ago.
On the way in to the campsite at 8000ft+ the truck startled a couple
of cubs across the dirt road and down the steep bank, so we knew there
were bear around.
The campsite was equipped with bear-proof trash dumpsters: you could
open one to dump trash but you couldn't reach in to get anything out.
Those bear proof dumpsters seemed to be a commercial proposition, not
custom-built.
The park ranger advice was "Don't leave food out if you don't want a
night visit."
We had horses tethered on a high line. They are likely to tell you if
bear come by.
Brian W
.
That just might work! I'll think I'll confirm this tactic by telling my
daughter's boy friend to give it a try.
I saw a PBS show some years back. It showed folks living on Kodiak island
who had outhouses rather than bathrooms They all carried 44 magnums (as a
minimum) to the outhouses. Apparently the Browns on Kodiak are the largest
Browns in existence.
#
#I wish I could. There was no bear ordinance when they built my house, so
#there is no place to put a trashcan where the bear can't get to it. The
#cans are bear proof, and no bear has ever gotten in. They just pick them up
#and toss them around.
You can't build one? Many bear proof trash enclosures are
commercially available as well.
#
#I had a roommate who carried a .44 magnum in her backpack for bears.
How did she plan to get the bear to wait while she took off her pack
and pulled out the .44?
By the way, what's the difference, if any, between "ground red pepper"
and "ground cayenne pepper"? Packages labeled "red" rather than
"cayenne" seem a lot cheaper, or larger for the same price. Is it the
same stuff, or not?
Bill Larkins, volunteer, George Washington and Conecuh National Forests
email: trash...@GWForest.com
That worked for a few times, then the bears got wise to it and started
taking the trash bags out of the barrels and leaving the ammonia bags
behind.
#
#"Bill Swafford" <skee...@sbcglobal.net> wrote in message
#news:h2r6u4$isb$1...@news.albasani.net...
## You can't build one? Many bear proof trash enclosures are
## commercially available as well.
##
#This would take some thought.
Heaven forbid! Actually think or do work?
He told me - I was in High School - that a bear can have its heart
blown out and continue to run. The bear has a distributed nervous
system and is a hunting killer.
His plan was simply to bleed down the Grizzly and keep out of his
way. The bear killed two horses in their stalls two days before.
We got our ride back out of the wilderness area but never heard who
won. I bet on the Ranger.
Martin
Tastes just like pork.
ROFLMAO, are you serious? The bear, mind you, I said BEAR, will turn and
look at you and think, "Should I chew on you now, or later for that?"
come on......
Doug
Seriously though, fencing is cheap and it would work I'm sure.
I think I'd want the reassurance of those other 5 full-power loads, just
in case the rubber ball ticks Smokey off!
# the homeowners association.
There's your problem.
I'd rather have the bears.
# # using BP. A .177 or .22 pellet should raise a blood blister without doing
# any
# # permanent harm to the bear.
#
# I think I'd want the reassurance of those other 5 full-power loads, just
# in case the rubber ball ticks Smokey off!
I think if I were going to shoot at an animal, number of legs
irrelevant, that could seriously injure or kill me at a whim, I wouldn't
want to merely scare or sting it. If at all possible, I want it down,
disabled, or dead with the first shot. Otherwise, the SOB can _have_ my
damn garbage.
I'll build a better enclosure in the morning.
Have you thought of putting a shock collar on the bear, and an
electronic fence around your property? It would work opposite of
keeping your dog -inside-, it would keep the bear -outside-.
Sounds like a good way to commit suicide, errm, bearcide.
# Any advice and thoughts welcome. �They get into everything, but in no way
# are really dangerous to people -- so far. �I'm just tired of chasing my
# "bear proof" trash cans down the hill. �:-)
Try energizing your trash cans with your 110 volt house power. The
bear will think twice next time.
Not a safe amount of gun. And hollow points are not suitable for bear.
Solid rounds in 44 mag in a handgun, or a 12 gauge slug, or a centerfire
rifle in something like 30-06. I don't personally believe in a level
playing field when dealing with critters which might actually eat you if
they win the fight. I still remember the case in Alaska of the regional
head of the CDC who tried to fight off a sow with a .270 (he was hunting
deer), actually shot her successfully, and the coast guard found his half
eaten body in a brush pile once they shot her dead from a helicopter the
next day (the .270 round was in her body).
# "Sheldon" <shel...@sopris.net> wrote:
# #
# # OK, here's the question. �I'm getting a black powder revolver, and
# was # wondering if I could put a really small load in the chamber so
# that it would # hit a plywood backstop and bounce off?
# #
# # The reason I ask is that we have a lot of black bears around here,
# and I was # wondering if I could shoot one without harming it, but
# hurt it just enough # so it might remember not to come back.
#
# Sounds like a good way to commit suicide, errm, bearcide.
#
#
# # Any advice and thoughts welcome. �They get into everything, but in
# no way # are really dangerous to people -- so far. �I'm just tired of
# chasing my # "bear proof" trash cans down the hill. �:-)
how about a trash can enclosure?
like a metal cabinet,anchored to the ground.
#
# Try energizing your trash cans with your 110 volt house power. The
# bear will think twice next time.
Yeah,and when a kid or trash collector touches it and dies,then where are
you?
Use a fence charger.
--
Jim Yanik
jyanik
at
kua.net
BrianW
#
#Would it be possible to load the first cylinder of a .357 mag with a
#blank, and have the other 5 loaded with hollowpoints (in case the bear
#gets aggressive)?
Yes, it would be possible. However, blanks are ineffective against
aggressive bears.
Bad idea. What if a kid walks by and touches it?
Do you have an attorney?
As it was mentioned, do not use hollow points for bear. They will expand in
the fat and not make it to the vital areas. Use some solid non expanding
bullets. You must drive the bullet through the fat and reach the viatl areas
.. Hopefully clip the spine to stop him.
And who will bell the cat?
-Raf
--
Misifus-
Rafael Seibert
Photos: http://www.flickr.com/photos/rafiii
home: http://www.rafandsioux.com
Hollowpoints?
Isn't the skull of a Bear (think charging) like 6-8" of spongy bone?
That makes sense. You need a round that will get past the layer of fat
and hit something important.
Put a sign on the can, "Danger! Do not touch! 110 Volts!"
People will be able to read it ... the bear won't.
Doubt it would work.
Martin
The fishing guides in Alaska have the first couple of rounds in the shotgun
as rubber bullets. The next are all lethal rounds. Plus they carry 44 mags
and 454 casuls as backup.
# # Yeah,and when a kid or trash collector touches it and dies,then
# where are # you?
#
# Put a sign on the can, "Danger! Do not touch! 110 Volts!"
#
# People will be able to read it ... the bear won't.
Some kids might not be able to read it,others simply won't(or may miss the
sign),and some will test it to see if it's true.
Or one kid pushes another against it.
--
Jim Yanik
jyanik
at
kua.net
I think that the general consensus is that using a gun to just scare a
bear
is the quickest way to find yourself on MTV's Jackass.
Oh ok ... those are valid points. Not a good idea ... I think that
the shock collar / e-fence proposal would be better.
#Oh ok ... those are valid points. Not a good idea ... I think that
#the shock collar / e-fence proposal would be better.
How, pray tell do you get the shock collar on the bear?
# On Fri, 10 Jul 2009 13:29:06 +0000 (UTC), "Scott M. Kozel"
#<koz...@comcast.net> wrote:
#
#
# #Oh ok ... those are valid points. Not a good idea ... I think that
# #the shock collar / e-fence proposal would be better.
#
# How, pray tell do you get the shock collar on the bear?
Very carefully.
Frank
And unlike grizzlies, black bears can climb trees, so that avenue of
escape won't work. They are also not as picky as grizzlies. Grizzlies
will rip you up and walk away as soon as you are dead. Black bears will
eat you. We are fortunate that they are shy and prefer to avoid contact
with people, but never imagine that means they are not dangerous.
To answer the OP, a bear getting into garbage should be killed.
Relocating them won't work, because they will just find another garbage
can. Most states will allow home owners to kill dangerous animals.
Contact your department of fish and wildlife to get a permit.
--
For email, replace firstnamelastinitial
with my first name and last initial.
Sneak up on him, set up a diversion, and slip it on him while he is
not looking,
Or call your local Humane Society, and ask them to do it for you.
# On 11 Jul 2009, you wrote in rec.guns:
#
# # On Fri, 10 Jul 2009 13:29:06 +0000 (UTC), "Scott M. Kozel"
# #<koz...@comcast.net> wrote:
# #
# #
# # #Oh ok ... those are valid points. Not a good idea ... I think that
# # #the shock collar / e-fence proposal would be better.
# #
# # How, pray tell do you get the shock collar on the bear?
#
# Very carefully.
Or you can just wait to do it while the bear is busily engaged in shoving
the black powder revolver with the light loads in it up your posterior. ;-)
You just walk up and offer him a picnic basket.
Robert
How would it get a gun in the first place?
Robert