Chris F.A. Johnson (
cfajo...@cfaj.ca) writes:
> On 2014-11-17, Chris F.A. Johnson wrote:
>> This is Rotating Quiz 162. Entries must be posted by Sunday,
>> November 23, 2014 at 10 PM (Eastern Standard Time).
>
> Here are the answers; scores will be posted shortly.
They did not make it to my server. Nor have I see RQ 163. So just in case,
Chris forgot about it, I took the freedom to score the quiz which I did not
enter myself.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Total
Mark Brader X X X - X X X ½ X X 8½
Marc D - - - - X - - - X X 3
Dan Blum - X X X X X X X X ½ 8½
Dan Tilque - X X X X - X - X - 6
Peter Smyth - X - - - X - X X - 4
Rob Parker - - X - X - X - X - 4
Pete - - - - X - X - - - 2
Calvin - - X - - - - - X - 2
Mark B gets ½ on question 8 for entering Whitestead of Whitehead.
Dan Blum entered Lagrange for the last question. Mark pointed out that
this seems to be an answer that fits the bill. I looked up the two men in
my Swedish encyclopedia from the 1950s, and while there is a short
sentence on the motion of planets in the article on Lagrange, there is a
lot more in the article on Laplace.
Declining to laziness, I also checked Wikipedia, and I get the same
impression. Lagrange was also working in this field, but Laplace did
the major work. I eventually decided that Lagrange was only worth a
half point.
This puts Mark and Dan on the same total score. Chris had stated:
In case of a tie, the first tiebreaker will be whoever scored
the most points on the hardest questions (defined post-facto
as the ones which the fewest people got any points on). Second
tiebreaker will be posting order.
Mark was the only one to #1 correct, and he was also the first to
enter.
Thus, by my scoring, RQ 163 is Mark Brader's. However, let's give
Chris a day or two to make his final verdict.
--
Erland Sommarskog, Stockholm,
esq...@sommarskog.se