Account Options

  1. Sign in
The old Google Groups will be going away soon, but your browser is incompatible with the new version.
Google Groups Home
« Groups Home
Message from discussion 15 positions that minimize waste of pips in bear-off
The group you are posting to is a Usenet group. Messages posted to this group will make your email address visible to anyone on the Internet.
Your reply message has not been sent.
Your post was successful
 
From:
To:
Cc:
Followup To:
Add Cc | Add Followup-to | Edit Subject
Subject:
Validation:
For verification purposes please type the characters you see in the picture below or the numbers you hear by clicking the accessibility icon. Listen and type the numbers you hear
 
Stig Eide  
View profile  
 More options Apr 30 1996, 3:00 am
Newsgroups: rec.games.backgammon
From: Stig Eide <sti...@james.stud.unit.no>
Date: 1996/04/30
Subject: Re: 15 positions that minimize waste of pips in bear-off

Trice:

> Your 2 2 2 3 3 3 distribution is good, given a 15 checker
> position with a pip count of 48. (In fact, subject to these two
> constraints, I believe it is optimal, but I'm going on memory.)

It's close, but 1 2 3 4 3 2 is the optimal distribution.
As pointed out by several, we can't control the pipcount. And then
our initial posting with minimal pip-waste for 1-15 checkers left
is not of much value, except for the 000357 position which should
be the aim in the bear-in.
As a consequence Eirik made a table of optimal boards for all
possible combinations of pips and checkers left.
Interested can get a postscript-file by emailing him:
th...@stud.unit.no

Here's the optimal board for each pipcount, no matter
how many checkers left. Interestingly, fewest
checkers left is often not optimal:
The 48-pip board 000008 (8 men at 6point)
wastes 1.49 pips more than 000144.

You can always transform pipwaste to expected rolls left:
Just add the pipcount, and divide it with 8.1667.
Enjoy..    8-)

 1:100000(7.17)
 2:200000(6.17)
 3:110000(5.17)
 4:101000(4.62)
 5:000010(4.30)
 6:000001(4.21)
 7:010010(5.05)
 8:001010(5.26)
 9:001001(5.32)
10:000101(5.11)
11:000011(5.01)
12:000002(5.23)
13:001101(5.40)
14:001011(5.40)
15:000111(5.31)
16:000021(5.45)
17:000012(5.47)
18:001111(5.67)
19:000211(5.79)
20:001012(5.73)
21:000112(5.53)
22:000022(5.65)
23:000013(5.85)
24:001112(6.06)
25:000212(6.05)
26:000122(5.89)
27:000113(5.97)
28:000023(6.05)
29:001122(6.21)
30:000222(6.25)
31:000132(6.23)
32:000123(6.15)
33:000114(6.33)
34:000024(6.38)
35:001123(6.37)
36:000223(6.38)
37:000133(6.36)
38:000124(6.39)
39:000034(6.55)
40:001133(6.56)
41:000233(6.53)
42:000224(6.55)
43:000134(6.51)
44:000125(6.62)
45:000035(6.74)
46:001134(6.66)
47:000234(6.63)
48:000144(6.69)
49:000135(6.67)
50:001234(6.77)
51:001144(6.81)
52:000244(6.76)
53:000235(6.75)
54:000145(6.78)
55:000136(6.83)
56:001235(6.86)
57:001145(6.87)
58:000245(6.82)
59:000236(6.88)
60:000146(6.89)
61:001245(6.92)
62:000345(6.93)
63:000255(6.94)
64:000246(6.91)
65:000156(6.99)
66:000147(7.00)
67:001246(6.98)
68:000346(6.98)
69:000256(6.98)
70:000247(7.00)
71:001346(7.05)
72:001256(7.04)
73:000356(7.03)
74:000347(7.05)
75:000257(7.04)
76:000248(7.09)-001356(7.09)
77:001347(7.11)
78:001257(7.09)
79:000357(7.07)
80:000267(7.11)
81:000258(7.11)
82:000249(7.18)
83:000159(7.22)
84:00014A(7.35)
85:00005A(7.48)
86:00004B(7.68)
87:00003C(7.99)
88:00002D(8.47)
89:00001E(9.19)
90:00000F(10.17)
Where A,B,C,D,E and F represents 10,11,12,13,14 and 15 checkers.
Stig Eide
and
Eirik Milch Pedersen


 
You must Sign in before you can post messages.
To post a message you must first join this group.
Please update your nickname on the subscription settings page before posting.
You do not have the permission required to post.