So you're saying that if the health department didn't exist and this
picture went public like it did, Taco Bell would (or might) be less
inclined to take serious action against the perpetrator of this incident?
That's a ridiculous assertion. Also, I am 99% sure the health department
didn't even register an infraction against the restaurant for this. They
can't, they didn't witness it and have no grounds to charge the restaurant
with anything at all.
Even if they did witness this, and many other infractions like it, do you
know that the health department *still* can't shut the restaurant down?
The fact of the matter is that the health department really doesn't have
any teeth. There has to be an immediate threat to public health for the
inspector to actually take action to close the place down. In the end, if
an inspector witnessed what happened, they might have been able to
downgrade the restaurant from an A rating to a B. That would teach them a
lesson, I'm sure. Even if they could shut the place down, if some damned
kid working in the back licked a bunch of taco shells in front of an
inspector, do you think that warrants shutting the place down immediately
for? Or should they maybe have the manager fire the kid, fix the problem,
and carry on like they did before?
In the end, it is nearly impossible for an inspector to witness something
like this and they can do nothing as a result of a picture. All they can
do is continue to waste your money, do a piss poor job of inspection, send
out a pile of gibbering monkeys who really don't know anything about
restaurant work, and give you warm feelings that you are somehow more safe
as a result of your wasted time and money.
Take a look at the scenario you've just provided; it illustrates perfectly
the complete and utter futility of the various health departments in the
US. I've actually personally dealt with some people from this (Kern
County) health department myself, and I can tell you, I haven't been
impressed with their knowledge.
If a government bureaucracy is doing nothing to help you and is throwing
your money down an endless sinkhole while making it more difficult for
business to operate, don't you think it is the very definition of useless
and should be cut?
> > I've also said that in the absence of a health department (a useless,
> > bloated agency that does nothing well besides spend money, get in the way
> > of legitimate business, and give the ignorant masses warm fuzzies), one or
> > more private organizations would step up to fill the gap and certify
> > restaurants their own way. In time, through competition, we would find a
> > much better way to protect the public than a bloated, wasteful,
> > bureaucracy.
> >
> > To support my argument, I'll point you to the USDA meat standards, which
> > changed due to large food producers wanting their formerly "select" grade
> > beef to be included in the "choice" grade. That's why you can buy choice
> > beef from one place and have it be completely different than the high
> > choice you get from somewhere else. Prime, is thankfully not sullied yet.
> > When the USDA did this, private organizations (like Certified Black
> > Angus) stepped up and began doing their own grading. When you buy a steak
> > with the "Certified Black Angus" label, you aren't necessarily buying a
> > cut from a Black Angus cow, you are buying a superior grade of beef that
> > is what choice used to be.
>
> Pardon me for being a pessimist but I don't really believe that an
> industry certification is as believable as a government certification.
Backwards really. A government certification is bullshit. What does the
government bureaucracy lose if they make an inaccurate reading of a
threat? Did even a single government agent lose their job as a result of
all of the breakouts of E.Coli or others (not to mention things like Libya
or 9/11)? A private organization has *far* more to lose. If their
certification turns out to be fake or not up to standard, they could lose
their business, at the very least someone would lose their job over it.
Government schleps have nothing to lose, nothing, and they don't care if
you get sick. Do they care how long you wait in line at the DMV? The
Post Office? Police have no duty to protect you, Risky, why do you think
a health department does?
> I also doubt that the certification you're speaking of is anything other
> than a marketing ploy. Black Angus isn't just a different grade of meat.
> It's a different kind of cow. There can't be much to the certification in
> terms of rigorousness. It's an apples and oranges comparison.
Sorry, it's not "Certified Black Angus" it's actually "Certified Angus."
Most cows in the country are Angus, and "Certified Angus" does not
actually mean they are technically Angus. The certification is about the
grade of meat and it is very trusted, they grade only choice (old choice
with stricter standards) and prime beef. So when you see "Certified
Angus" you can be sure that it is a top quality beef, but you can't be
sure of the breed.
> In any case, if industry participants are able to prevail upon regulators
> to lower standards what is the magic wand that prevents them from
> prevailing upon their own fellow industry participants if they decide to?
Good question. Corruption will exist everywhere, does in public and
private sectors. The difference in public sectors is that there is no one
to blame or fire, in private sectors, I imagine they would need to be more
vigilant to retain public trust or they run the risk of losing their
business. Will the health department ever lose their business if they
mess up? How many outbreaks before we hear about a regulator stepping
down?
> In the example you provide why hasn't the industry established it's own
> certification for the former standard of the "choice" grade? It's because
> it would require a rigorous testing regimen and, most important, they
> don't want it and are happy with the lowered standard.
>
> The public should be asking why the standard was lowered. If activists
> made an issue of this they would be labeled "big government" oppressors by
> the industry.
All this was answered. The industry has established a grade and it is
very successful and popular. Go buy yourself a "choice" steak from
Walmart, then go to a higher end grocery and buy a "Certified Angus" steak
that isn't prime. Grill them both and taste them and you'll plainly taste
the difference between public sector certification and private sector.
I choose private every damned time.
Bottom line: Health Department can't prevent these things, private sector
is already proving they can take care of these things themselves. Health
Department wastes money and time doing no good at all, private sector
can't waste money by definition. Why persist?
Follow :)