On Tue, 11 Jan 2022 09:02:22 -0800 (PST), Cindy Hamilton
<
angelica...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>On Tuesday, January 11, 2022 at 11:49:22 AM UTC-5, Dave Smith wrote:
>
>> Pot roast usually has some onion, celery and carrot added to the
>> braising liquid for flavour. Stew usually has potatoes, carrots, and
>> other vegetables to make a more complete meal.
>
>Usually, but not universally. Sometimes beef stew is just braised
>chunks of beef with other flavorings. My husband doesn't like
>cooked carrots (so I don't add chunks of carrot) and prefers his
>served over noodles (so I don't add potatoes). It still beef stew,
>though.
I cook both stew and pot roast with lots of veggies, celery, carrots,
potatoes, green beans, onions and garlic of course. Sometimes chunks
of squash and eggplant, and romas, parsley and dillweed too. I'll
sometimes serve it over egg noodles and still add potatoes for next
time. We always have lots of greenbeans from the garden, cut to one
inch lengths, not cooked but frozen. We both like cooked carrots. My
wife likes garlic but not onions, I peel and remove the ends but cook
them whole, adds good flavor but she won't eat them, I do. I enjoy
whole onions cooked in stew or pot roast.
>> > With my old pot roasts, never any browning first and nothing used to
>> > thicken the water after cooking. Just a spoon of plain weak beef broth
>> > spooned over the mess on the plate. It was always so very bland and,
>> > imo, the perfect way to ruin a nice chunk of beef.
I always brown meat for stew or pot roast. I've never added beef
broth, braised beef adds plenty beef flavor. Where will I get beef
broth when cooking stew or pot roast? I don't want any mystery
broth in my cooking.
>> > Any pot roast I have cooked was browned on all sides before the braising
>> liquid was added. Onion, garlic and carrot are added for flavour and the
>> liquid is thickened near the end.
>
>Gary just won't give up on it. I'm not going to give up on poking him about
>it, either.
>
>Cindy Hamilton
I always brown meat on all sides too, adds a lot more beefy flavor
than simmering beef in water.