Steve
I too am in a production environment. I think that I will try this. I use
about 4-5 blades a year. This is expensive.
CN
Steve Russell wrote in message <388E99...@flash.net>...
---------------Lots of good info snipped for brevity or something like
that -----
Thanks Steve; You just lit up a light in my feeble brain. I've been
sharpening chain saw blades with a 12 volt hand sharpener in the woods
for years. Why haven't I thought about doing it on a band saw (Duh) I
usually get to sharpen a chain 5 or 6 times before they have to be put
on a machine to bring them back into line.
Think I'll go try it with my dremel
.
Thanks again
OB
(Land clearing Contractor for 25 years)
Type "robart right angle" in their search box.
In a recent posting, I commented that I resharpen my bandsaw bands on
the saw. Many of you have emailed me, asking for the details of this. It
is quite simple and does not require a lot of time or effort. Most of us
just replace the bands when they become dull. However, in a production
environment the frequent replacement of bands can be quite expensive.
When I first started turning full time, I quickly learned that I could
dull a bandsaw blade, (not Timberwolf blades) very quickly. Cutting wet
timber and species with a high silica content, (especially with the bark
still attached) dulls the band in short order. I looked at having the
bands resharpened professionally, but the cost was nearly the same as a
replacement band. :-0 Therefore, I began to investigate ways to
resharpen the bands myself. Every way I discovered required too much
time, effort or money. Most of the sharpening shops just laughed when I
said I wanted to resharpen the band... ON THE SAW! I think one guy is
still laughing and rolling around on the floor. :-(
There is not too much room to work under the guides and I wanted
something that was quick, small, lightweight, simple and reasonably
accurate. After crashing and burning with the sharpening shops, I had
just about given up. I can still hear them laughing. A few days later,
I lucked into several truckloads of Ash, Pecan-crete and Elm. However, I
only had one band left that was still sharp and I knew it would not last
long with bloody Pecan-crete. Yes, I could have just bought some new
bands, but being born in the year of the rat made me want to stretch a
little more life out 'em.
I poured over every tool I had in the shop, looking for ideas to sharpen
the band. Then it hit me... KA-Ching, the Dremel moto tool! Its small
size and lightweight, high RPM motor was just what I was looking for. At
first I tried to use the flat abrasive stones which worked, but did not
last very long. Then, I tried the thin abrasive cut-off wheels and my
problems were solved! They are quite durable and maintain their flat
face well after repeated usage.
So, here is the specifics:
First: I unplug the saw and put on a full face saftey shield and an
appropriate respirator to handle any of the metal dust that is
generated. Then, I set up a good strong light (100 watt) that
illuminates the bandsaw blade clearly. I use an adjustable height stool
to sit on that allows me to have my eyes inline with the cutting "zone".
Next, I fully rotate the band and check for cracks or other damage. If
anything shows up, I throw the blade out. I only resharpen bands that
are free of defects for saftey reasons.
Then, I mount a thin abrasive cut-off disk onto the appropriate mandrel
and chuck it into the moto-tool collet. I resharpen the band ON the saw,
with the tension set just enough to keep the band straight, whilst I am
rotating it. With my left hand, I advance the band by hand as each tooth
is resharpened. My right hand controls the moto-tool, (mine is variable
speed) which is set to the lowest speed. As each tooth is resharpened,
the band is rotated a bit to bring the next tooth into position.
The teeth on the bands are set in a particular way, depending on the
type of band and its intended usage. Some teeth are straight inline with
the body of the band, others curve right or left. As I resharpen the
teeth, I rotate the end (flat face) of the abrasive disk so it matches
the direction and curvature of the tooth. I touch the flat part of the
wheel lightly to the top of each tooth, making sure the contact sharpens
all the way to the end of the tooth. I repeat the process for each
tooth, making sure that the wheel contacts and follows the top of the
tooth correctly (this is very important). I want the resharpened surface
to feather into the shape of the tooth.
Since the resharpening process creates a bright polished top on the
tooth, it is easy to tell where you started and thus, where you need to
stop. My bands are 150" long and it takes me less than five minutes to
complete the process on a 3TPI band. Obviously, my resharpened bands are
not as good as "new" or even professionally resharpened bands. However,
they ARE sharp afterwards and allow me to continue cutting with a
minimum of downtime and expense. I can usually get about 8-10
resharpenings out of a blade before I pitch it in the rubbish bin. I
also pitch the abrasive disk after it has been used to resharpen 8-10
times. I would not use these resharpened bands to make any critical
cuts. You cannot duplicate a professional shaprening by this method, but
it works well for rough cuts and non-critical cutting (gross resaw work
and corner removal, etc).
When I first started doing this, I was resharpening cheap no-name
bandsaw bands. Later, I switched to Timberwolf bands which stayed sharp
significantly longer. I now resharpen my Timberwolf bands as well and
find that they stay sharp longer after resharpening than the cheap bands
I was using before. This has allowed me to consume only seven bands in
the last three and a half years. In a production environment where the
bandsaw is used extensively, this is quite remarkable, IMHO. Not to
mention the fact that I get eight to ten times the life of every band.
It does take practice to get good at this (what in turning does not)
but, when you do it can save you a lot of time and money. You need to
have a good eye and develop a fluid accurate motion with your wrist. If
you do give it a go, let me know how it turns out. Good luck to you and
best wishes in all of your turning endeavors.
Letting the chips fly...
Steven D. Russell
Eurowood Werks Woodturning Studio
The Woodlands, Texas
--
One of our Woodturning club members showed the effect, and explained his
method, of 'refreshing' a bandsaw blade only last month.
He removes the band and 'turns it inside out' and then replaces it on the
saw. He then starts the saw and 'just touches' a file to it. Turns it
the right way again and claims it is as good as new - certainly the cut
samples - before and after - supported his claim, and the way finding a
nail can take the points off, it seems reasonable that a file can replace
them on a band that is, in effect, running backwards.
My current blade is new so I haven't tried the method myself - yet.
Ken
Silverdale, Lancashire. UK
Are the teeth pointing up or backwards or both?
I'm intrigued I would like to try this. My blades are 93.5", and I have one
that is 14 tpi.
93.5 x 14 = lots of sharpening.
-David
Ken Davis <no-spam...@cix.co.uk> wrote in message
news:memo.20000126...@kdavisa.compulink.co.uk...
Sounds great but how exactly do you hold the file? Do you hold the file
off to each side to match the set of the saw? Could you use a stone
instead of a file as you do when resetting a ripsaw blade?
Rick
* Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet's Discussion Network *
The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!
> Can you type that again? I didn't understand it the first time I read
> it.
>
> Are the teeth pointing up or backwards or both?
>
> I'm intrigued I would like to try this. My blades are 93.5", and I
> have one
> that is 14 tpi.
>
> 93.5 x 14 = lots of sharpening.
--
I'll try. ;)
If you (very carefully - and gloves and face protection are advisable)
hold the blade and turn it so that what has been the outer surface is
turned to the inside, (it's going to spring a bit as the turn is
completed), when you replace it on the saw, the teeth at the table entry
will be facing the wrong way - upwards!
As far as I can tell, you hold the file across at 90 degrees to the blade
and just carefully slide it forward until is just touches and then
withdraw it.
Obviously, this is not going to correct any problems there may be with the
set of the teeth but it will give an instant point back to dulled teeth.
I've recently been given a few 1 1/2" square stones, so when I do try it,
I intend to use one of them rather than a file.
(I don't blame anyone for not understanding - at the chat, we all found it
a bit hard to follow but, from burning on the cut before to a clean cut
after, and *not* from some stranger trying to sell something, you tend to
get keen to understand it. ;) )
Ken
Silverdale, Lancashire. UK
Jim...
Ken Davis wrote in message ...
As I understand it, yes, and to sharpen the whole tooth you might have to
hit it a little extra hard the first time. I can tell you from experience
that this is fine. I have sharpened my bandsaw blades for years with a
sanding disk in a Dremel. I never swing the tool around for the right and
left teeth, just hit them all from the center. The results are excellent.
I like the Timberwolf blades for the kind of cutting I most often do -
trimming blanks chainsawn from logs. The Timberwolf blades have a deep
gullet and wide set which helps them breeze through wet timber without
binding.
-mike paulson, fort collins, co
I sharpen my blades with a dremel, sometimes on the back of the tooth
sometimes in the hook. Both ways work. When I saw this I had been
sawing a lot of MDF so the blade was quite blunt but still fairly new,
not sharpened before. I turned the blade, teeth pointing up, switched
on, touched with a bit of a square stone, not too hard or too long I
thought, got sparks, saw each tooth had a little bit of bright metal on
the point, blade felt nice and sharp to the fingers, turned blade back
again, tried a cut. Now I know what blunt really means. Had to check I
did turn the blade. What did I do wrong?
--
Terry
I understood from the original post that Steve positioned each tooth by
hand. The saw was unplugged. Then I read about sparks flying from a pocket
stone (I can't move my hand that fast). Touching a stone to the blade with
the saw running? Isn't that like trying to saw a rock in half? I can't for
the life of me figure out how one could expect to sharpen a blade with the
saw running. If this really works, I can't wait to stick my chain saw in
the dirt. Someone please straighten me out!
--
Jon Schilling
Ridgefield, Wa USA (10 miles north of Portland, Ore)
Danny Luttrell <wdlut...@erols.com> wrote in message
news:86vuoj$6io$1...@bob.news.rcn.net...
Danny Luttrell wrote in message <86vuoj$6io$1...@bob.news.rcn.net>...
> Ken
> I wasn't suggesting that you could set teeth with the file! What I was
> wondering is how you should hold the file to sharpen at the correct
> angle, given that bandsaw teeth are set to the left, right and set
> straight as well, on the one blade. If you just hold the file against
> the front, so to speak, wouldn't you be just sharpening the `inside'
> edge of the left and right set teeth? Maybe this doesn't matter,
> anyway! I'm going to try this tomorrow so I'll report (probably from
> the hospital) how I went.
> By the way, the bit I mentioned about using a stone as you do when
> sharpening a ripsaw referred to the practice of evening up the ripsaw
> teeth with a stone while the ripsaw is running, prior to setting and
> sharpening. The stone works really well in this respect. It seems to me
> that it would also be easier than a file (and probably safer) for your
> bandsaw sharpening method. I would think any old grinder wheel would do.
>
> Rick
--
Rick
My comment about setting the teeth was just an afterthought.
I tried to answer both yours and Dave's (dgri...@nbnet.nb.ca)queries
together - given that I haven't actually tried using the method myself yet
- but I think probably Jim's (jba...@island.net)report on it, now he has
tried it is better than any more waffle from me. ;)
It's given me a lot more confidence for when I do try, anyway, and *might*
make your trip to the hospital a bit less likely. ;)))
Ken
Silverdale, Lancashire. UK
R
I look forward to hearing your results.
After re-reading Steve's original post, I find that I missed the fact that
he appears to be grinding the side opposite the factory grind side.
Danny
-David
Ken Davis <no-spam...@cix.co.uk> wrote in message
news:memo.20000127...@kdavisa.compulink.co.uk...
> In article <flOj4.1656$pa6....@sodalite.nbnet.nb.ca>,
> dgri...@nbnet.nb.ca (David Griffin) wrote:
>
> > Can you type that again? I didn't understand it the first time I read
> > it.
> >
> > Are the teeth pointing up or backwards or both?
> >
> > I'm intrigued I would like to try this. My blades are 93.5", and I
> > have one
> > that is 14 tpi.
> >
> > 93.5 x 14 = lots of sharpening.
>
> --
>
> I'll try. ;)
> If you (very carefully - and gloves and face protection are advisable)
> hold the blade and turn it so that what has been the outer surface is
> turned to the inside, (it's going to spring a bit as the turn is
> completed), when you replace it on the saw, the teeth at the table entry
> will be facing the wrong way - upwards!
> As far as I can tell, you hold the file across at 90 degrees to the blade
> and just carefully slide it forward until is just touches and then
> withdraw it.
> Obviously, this is not going to correct any problems there may be with the
> set of the teeth but it will give an instant point back to dulled teeth.
> I've recently been given a few 1 1/2" square stones, so when I do try it,
> I intend to use one of them rather than a file.
This method sounds very interesting. I have heard of some turners who do
this, but I was never able to get a clear description of the process. I
plan to give this method a go (reversing the band and "touching-up" the
band teeth on the saw, whilst it is running) with some of my fine tooth
bands.
My method of sharpening the individual teeth is too time consuming with
fine toothed bands. As I stated, on a 150" 3TPI band, I can have it back
up to snuff in less than five minutes. There is a point where my method
is to labor intensive in a production environment. However, this new
method seems to solve the problem of "touching-up" the higher tooth
count bands. I plan to give it a go!
You can give it a try, but once it's been done, that blade can never be
properly sharpened.
--
That sounds likely to me and I *think* I pointed out that I was passing on
a tip I'd been given but *hadn't yet* tried myself - though I do intend to
do so.
Steve makes the point that the bands he does by hand are 150" 3TPI and I'd
have serious doubts about trying the reversing and file/stone method on
that type of blade. First - they are expensive enough to buy new for
proper sharpening cost to be viable. The average hobbyist's, at only a
few ukp new and nearly as much to sharpen, isn't, IMHO, so any lengthening
of the band life is better than scrapping it. (Providing the attempt
doesn't end in a visit to the local A & E! ;) )
Second, Steve sharpens his own blades. Again, *many* hobbyists would
probably not have the ability or confidence to do this and Steve himself
doesn't fancy the idea of doing it to the finer gauge bands and does
intend to try the reversing method on such bands.
Ken
Silverdale, Lancashire. UK