Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

What sewing machine should I buy?

5 views
Skip to first unread message

E in MN

unread,
May 8, 2006, 2:10:34 PM5/8/06
to
Hi everybody,

I'm about to start doing more sewing, and am in need of a new machine (I'm
still using my mothers first Singer she bought in the early 1960s!).

I used to sew and design costumes and clothing in college (28 years ago -
gack!), but have only done an occasional project since then, which is why I
could get by with the Singer.

My plans are to sew mostly simple garments from natural fabrics, cotton
weave, cotton knits, silks, etc. I also want to roll hem silk -- I am a silk
painter, and would love to make my own scarves. I don't need to quilt or do
fancy embroidery, but I'd love something that is simple to use and produces
elegant results (I have hand problems, so easy is important).

I'm willing to spend up to $400 or so. Less would be better, but I don't
want to skimp and be sorry later.

What do you wise and helpful people suggest?

Thanks you!

Elizabeth

Phaedrine

unread,
May 8, 2006, 4:28:10 PM5/8/06
to
In article <C084F3CA.3D66%efo...@comcast.net>,

Reliable and durable sewing machines cost more than that these days. So
you might wish to consider a quality used machine instead. Of paramount
importance are the dealers and the expertise of their technicians
whether you are buying a new or used machine regardless of brand. This
is a great topic of discussion these days as there are many horror
stories about unqualified techs. You should definitely ask local people
who sew and who have their machines serviced regularly (yes, that is
also a must.... the annual checkup and oiling). I can personally vouch
for the older, metal Berninas--- 930, 1130, 1230--- all a good bet,
though even the 20-25 year old ones often fetch over $500.

Others here can recommend reliable older models in other brands.

Phae

--
I fear me you but warm the starved snake,
Who, cherished in your breasts, will sting your hearts. (Henry VI, Shakespeare)

Message has been deleted

_ p @juno.com Cappy

unread,
May 9, 2006, 9:34:49 AM5/9/06
to
What model Singer do you have? Some of the old all-metal gear machines are
so much sturdier than a lot of new machines. And if it does all that you
need it to do, why get a new one? Take it and get it serviced. Those old
machines can purr with very little upkeep...

I learned on a 1929 model 15 (I think that's the number... either that or a
99) but my favorite machine is a 1923 201 that I can use in a treadle or as
an electric. Nice big throat for quilting, does nice button holes... real
work horse...

So new isn't always "better..." grin

Cappy

"E in MN" <efo...@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:C084F3CA.3D66%efo...@comcast.net...

Taria

unread,
May 9, 2006, 10:32:44 AM5/9/06
to
My Bernina 930 is a wonderful machine but I think they go for more than
$400. 830 is a similar machine with a few less bells and whistles and
no stretch stitches. Neither are computer models.
Singer 401, 403, 500 or 503 machines are great old work horses and well
within your price range.
Check out your local sewing machine shop and see what they have
available used.
Taria

CypSew

unread,
May 9, 2006, 12:32:14 PM5/9/06
to
The same thing, Cappy, with my 1961 Singer Slant Needle, except I can not
use it as a pedal, wish I could. It uses cams to make beautiful decorative
stitches, and there are so many different presser feet available today that
weren't when I first got this beauty in the 80s, from a lady who was being
moved to a nursing home and her daughter did not want it. I use it probably
as much or more than any of my other machines.
Emily.


E in MN

unread,
May 9, 2006, 2:32:23 PM5/9/06
to
Thanks for all the responses!

My current machine is a Singer Style-O-Matic 328, which needs approximately
$100 worth of repairs before I can use it (regular maintenance which I've
overlooked for years, plus the bobbin winder is broken). Once it's repaired,
it has attachments to do everything that I want to do.

The only reason I'm even considering a new machine is that I have hand and
joint problems, and I know I would sew more if the machine were lighter and
easier to operate. All those little screws on the Singer can cause me pain,
and even the foot pedal is hard to operate sometimes.

Went out yesterday and looked at Janomes and Vikings. Found a Janome Jem
Platinum 760 for $499, and a new Viking Huskystar C10 on sale for $449. The
Huskystar has 11 one-touch buttonholes!

I hate to spend this kind of money, but maybe it's a good investment. I may
check out Sears -- I hear they have a Janome and of course, Singers.

Any other ideas or feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

Angstriddenly,
Elizabeth

Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to send

unread,
May 9, 2006, 3:01:39 PM5/9/06
to
E in MN wrote:

>
> Any other ideas or feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!


***DON'T*** get a Huskystar *holding nose* It won't hold up -- it's a
classic oriental sailing ship.

The Janome Jem is a very lightweight machine.

Try to find a nice dealer with a nice selection of older machines to get
far more bang for the buck than you might otherwise get. I found an 80s
era machine that is the love of my life and it only cost me $129.

If you lived in the SF Bay Area, I'd sell you my Singer 500A for about a
third of what I paid for it (I bought it used a few years ago), because
my Singer 401A is now the second love of my life, and it's so close to
the 500 that I have no interest in the 500 any more.

_ p @juno.com Cappy

unread,
May 9, 2006, 3:24:16 PM5/9/06
to
I have to agree with you on some of the newer presser feet... But I think
I've only lusted after the rolled hem foot and a teflon foot for the 201.
Everything else I can do, not necessarily the best or the fastest, with the
regular presser foot.

Cappy

"CypSew" <cyp...@att.net> wrote in message
news:iu38g.70450$eR6....@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net...

Taria

unread,
May 9, 2006, 3:38:06 PM5/9/06
to
500 was basically the 401 with zipped up styling.
There are some photos still on my webpage along
with some links for older machine info:
http://home1.gte.net/res6mc9p/tlw/taria/pages/index.htm
Taria

Phaedrine

unread,
May 9, 2006, 3:53:56 PM5/9/06
to
In article <iu38g.70450$eR6....@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>,
"CypSew" <cyp...@att.net> wrote:

I remember those. We had them in our high school.... Slant-O-Matics,
weren't they, or did that name come later? I guess I never understood
what the slant was supposed to do. Do you know? They were nice
machines. I did manage to get a home ec course in my freshman year.
Our teacher had purple hair and a wart on her tongue that was a bit
distracting. She was, however, an awesome teacher who made us learn the
art of easing by doing set-in sleeves without basting..... only pins.
If you had even the tiniest wrinkle you had to rip it out and start over
again. One of my friends, a fellow Girl Scout, did not like this
procedure and cut down the height of her sleeve cap to get it to ease in
better. She got away with it too. :)

When I set out to buy my first machine, I had no idea what I wanted so I
rented machines until I found one that I really liked. I rented a lot
of machines before I settled on one. It was a great way to find out
what I liked and not. I wonder if any places still let you do that.

Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to send

unread,
May 9, 2006, 4:29:32 PM5/9/06
to
Taria wrote:
> 500 was basically the 401 with zipped up styling.

Yup. I was delighted to get my 500, but I'll tell ya, with the 400 it
was love at first pedal, and I cannot explain why. It took me totally
by surprise.

Taria

unread,
May 9, 2006, 5:12:15 PM5/9/06
to
I think the fussiness of the 500 just isn't as efficient.
They had it right when they made the 401 and should have
left a good thing alone!
Taria

Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to send wrote:

Taria

unread,
May 9, 2006, 5:13:14 PM5/9/06
to
You mean a narrow hem type foot?
Email me if so.
Taria
Message has been deleted
Message has been deleted

Kate Dicey

unread,
May 9, 2006, 6:26:50 PM5/9/06
to
E in MN wrote:

> Thanks for all the responses!
>
> My current machine is a Singer Style-O-Matic 328, which needs approximately
> $100 worth of repairs before I can use it (regular maintenance which I've
> overlooked for years, plus the bobbin winder is broken). Once it's repaired,
> it has attachments to do everything that I want to do.
>
> The only reason I'm even considering a new machine is that I have hand and
> joint problems, and I know I would sew more if the machine were lighter and
> easier to operate. All those little screws on the Singer can cause me pain,
> and even the foot pedal is hard to operate sometimes.

I understand this very well. I bought my mum a new light weight Singer
117 last year for this reason. Mum has rheumatism in her thumbs and
could no longer lift the old heavy machine she had. She passed it back
to me, and I gave her this light plastic easy to use modern one, with
which she is delighted. :)


>
> Went out yesterday and looked at Janomes and Vikings. Found a Janome Jem
> Platinum 760 for $499, and a new Viking Huskystar C10 on sale for $449. The
> Huskystar has 11 one-touch buttonholes!
>
> I hate to spend this kind of money, but maybe it's a good investment. I may
> check out Sears -- I hear they have a Janome and of course, Singers.
>
> Any other ideas or feedback would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!
>
> Angstriddenly,
> Elizabeth
>

I love my Husqvarna Lily 550! :) But I also love my 1909 Jones hand crank!


--
Kate XXXXXX R.C.T.Q Madame Chef des Trolls
Lady Catherine, Wardrobe Mistress of the Chocolate Buttons
http://www.katedicey.co.uk
Click on Kate's Pages and explore!

CypSew

unread,
May 10, 2006, 12:38:30 AM5/10/06
to
When DS and his DW moved to MD, I looked for a rental machine and was told
dealers no longer rented machines. Then I checked in several places, all
said the same thing. I had rented several when first married and was moving
often.
The slant supposedly helps a person see what he/she is sewing better, I
don't know if it's true or not. Yes, it is called a Slant-O-Matic. I first
used a Slant-O-Matic in the mid-50s when I worked at a Singer store.
Emily


E in MN

unread,
May 10, 2006, 12:45:50 AM5/10/06
to
Thanks again to everybody -- I finally made a decision.

After going back and forth all day, I finally decided on the Huskystar C10
(don't be mad, Melinda!). It's a brand new model to replace the Huskystar
219. They dropped the price to $399, so I went back for a long test drive
today, and fell in love.

It's sturdy, has more construction and decorative stitches than I will ever
use (a total of 60), and has a very good warranty. It comes with a training
DVD, and I get a free two hour class from my dealer in perpetuity (meaning I
can retake the class again later if I forget stuff).

I looked seriously at the Singers and Janome Harmony 8080 at Sears. They had
a serious clearance price on the Janome, but I just didn't like the warranty
or the construction. Also, it has fewer stitches. And I liked some of the
more advanced features of the Huskystar, like mirroring, needle up-down,
stitch knotting, and a memory. Also, The Huskystar C10 is light enough for
me to carry and has a great hard cover. Very, very elegant design.

Better still, I can use all my old Singer presser feet and bobbins!

I'm smitten.

Again, thanks for listening, and for offering your experience and advice.

Breathing a sigh of relief (with no buyers remorse!),
Elizabeth


CypSew

unread,
May 10, 2006, 1:15:57 AM5/10/06
to
Elizabeth,
Congratulations on your purchase. A DVD and classes plus a good warranty is
the best any person can get with a machine today.
Enjoy and be sure to post examples of your projects, so we can all enjoy
them.
Emily


Phaedrine

unread,
May 10, 2006, 12:00:31 PM5/10/06
to
In article <a7e8g.44293$Fs1....@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>,
"CypSew" <cyp...@att.net> wrote:

Wow, I did not realize they had been around for that long. It's a shame
about no rentals... men can rent just about any piece of machinery they
want for doing stuff around the house--- up to and including back hoes.
I think that lack of sewing machine rental is discrimination against
women! We need to rise up, ladies, and ..... and..... well..... express
our indignation! ;) The demand probably fell off is my guess.

Phaedrine

unread,
May 10, 2006, 12:02:29 PM5/10/06
to
In article <C086DA2E.4002%efo...@comcast.net>,

E in MN <efo...@comcast.net> wrote:

> After going back and forth all day, I finally decided on the Huskystar C10
> (don't be mad, Melinda!). It's a brand new model to replace the Huskystar
> 219. They dropped the price to $399, so I went back for a long test drive
> today, and fell in love.


Congratulations!! May you have many happy hours with it. Be sure to
keep us posted on your projects. :)

medley

unread,
Aug 27, 2009, 9:29:38 PM8/27/09
to
medley had written this in response to
http://www.sewgirls.com/textiles/Re-What-sewing-machine-should-I-buy-1332-.htm
:

> E in MN wrote:

> classic oriental sailing ship.

-------------------------------------

Is is possible for me to get a photograph of your Singer 328. I bought
one in 1963 and would love to "photoshop" it to put in my sewing room. It
was a great machine. I have had a Bernina 830(1973) , 930 and 200 and
each are great machines. I have friends that have had great luck with
Janomes. It pays to buy as much machine as you can afford and from a good
dealer.

##-----------------------------------------------##
Delivered via http://www.sewgirls.com/
Sewing Community of the Net
Web and RSS access to your favorite newsgroup -
rec.crafts.textiles.sewing - 3883 messages and counting!
##-----------------------------------------------##

0 new messages