On Mon, 20 Aug 2012 14:44:12 -0400, "Jeffrey Hamilton"
<
bbere...@cogeco.ca> wrote:
>Bill wrote:
>Me either, this particular killer, received his weapon as a brand NEW member
>of the Afghan Frontier Police and immediately turned it upon and murdered
>his allies...
Which makes you wonder how he got his hands on the ammunition...
Initial weapons training should be in the hands of the locals by now.
It's not as if they don't know how to shoot...
>> Now and again an Afghan soldier/policeman will shoot a member of the
>> allied forces because they wish to kill an infidel.
>
>Gosh, business as usual, eh ?
>
>I honestly believe we need to break that particular cycle, William.
Nobody has managed yet.
>
>> It is one of the inevitable costs of training an Afghan army/police
>> force.
>
>Maybe we need to introduce them to the concept, "Fuck with our people and
>we'll eradicate YOUR *species*.
The USSR tried that one.
It didn't work.
>From this point on, I believe I do recognize your points that your making.
>
>> The best solution found was to get the European/non Muslim trainers to
>> learn the local language, spend a lot of time with their charges and
>> become part of the local landscape and keep a tight control of all
>> ammunition and military stores.
>
>I honestly believe we need to protect, OUR culture.
You miss the point almost exactly.
The Taliban honestly believes that it is their culture that needs
protecting.
They're not closing schools and killing unveiled women because they're
trying to change things.
The people whose culture is looking really fragile here is theirs, not
ours...
The Taliban leaders aren't stupid. Plenty of them have spent time in
other countries.
They look at India and Indonesia and see the secular, rich and
successful Muslims living the good life, and it scares them.
They see people like Baron Alli, openly gay, secular and a Socialist
millionaire (I know, but the guy obviously has a lot of
contradictions in his life) and they want to kill him far more than
they want to kill US soldiers in Afghanistan.
They see almost without belief Baroness Warsi, a Tory peer, an
unveiled woman and a British cabinet minister and they really do want
her dead.
Now they know their own people see these rich secularised highly
honoured Muslims in the West and they know their people want 'some of
what they've got'. Their society is going to die unless they can kill
what will change it.
>
> > To do this the British 'between the wars' had a one year training
>> period and a three year operational tour as standard for all officers
>> followed by a second tour at some later point as a senior officer.
>> Senior training NCOs were postings from Muslim troops from within the
>> Indian Army.
>
>Call me 'old fashioned' William, but I happen to believe that, compulsary
>military service, might be an advantage to our nations, in more ways than
>one.
No.
It's an expensive way of producing soldiers whose level of training is
poor and who may not be committed to the cause you ant them to fight
for.
There's no doubt that the British conscripts wanted to defeat Germany,
their families were being bombed and their way of life was in danger.
There's no doubt that those same conscripts were utterly ineffective
fighting Jewish terrorists/freedom fighter in 1945/7 because they
knew damn well that they were being the 'bad guys'.