> "Raymond Daley" <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote in message > news:Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147368@fx17.am4...
> > "Agamemnon" wrote
> >> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal
> >> vs. Thal war and then after that they would return to their
> >> original humanoid form. So why not have the Daleks do just that
> >> now they've conquered Skaro
> > A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to
> > have forgotten.
> > Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly
> > tricked him.
> > So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone
> > royally fucked up.
> I don't think anybody fucked up. Moffat is as aware as any of us that
> Skaro was destroyed by the 7th Doctor. He chose to ignore it. If it
> worries you, you could always assume that McCoy's actions occurred in
> the future relative to Asylum. Alternatively, read John Peel's book,
> "War of the Daleks". In that, he reasoned that the planet the Doctor
> blew up wasn't Skaro, but was instead the planet Antalin.
The timeline as presented in the series has been put through the
wringer so much that I am surprised it even makes as much sense as it
does right now. That said: it also could be that they just destroyed an old or
alternative Skaro (with the current mainworld of the Daleks always
being called Skaro and maybe being skaroformed to have those homely acid
rains and red skies). Or a future version of Davros might have gone
back and kept Davros from being destroyed by replacing it with a planet
called Antalin in the nick of time. Or it might not even have been
Davros but some other group or individual from a species of scheming
mad cyborgs that just thought it might be nice to have that old home
planet saved.
Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>"Agamemnon" wrote
>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. Thal >> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid form. >> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have >forgotten.
>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly tricked >him.
>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone royally >f!@#$ed up.
>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in >development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with >several months ago.
They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
-- Member - Liberal International This is doc...@nl2k.ab.ca Ici doc...@nl2k.ab.ca
God,Queen and country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! http://www.fullyfollow.me/rootnl2k Quebec le 4 Sept 2012 ne votez pas pour le PQ!
> "Raymond Daley" <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote in message > news:Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147368@fx17.am4...
>> "Agamemnon" wrote
>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. Thal >>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid >>> form. So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered >>> Skaro
>> A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have >> forgotten.
>> Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly >> tricked him.
>> So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone >> royally fucked up.
> I don't think anybody fucked up. Moffat is as aware as any of us that > Skaro was destroyed by the 7th Doctor. He chose to ignore it. If it > worries you, you could always assume that McCoy's actions occurred in the > future relative to Asylum. Alternatively, read John Peel's book, "War of > the Daleks". In that, he reasoned that the planet the Doctor blew up > wasn't Skaro, but was instead the planet Antalin.
The only problem with that is that RTD destroyed the main premise of the book when he brought back Davros immediately after the 7th Doctor had destroyed his ship too in the same event that destroyed Skaro, and it can't work as a continuation from War of the Daleks either.
>> "Raymond Daley" <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote in message
>> news:Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147368@fx17.am4...
>> > "Agamemnon" wrote
>> >> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal
>> >> vs. Thal war and then after that they would return to their
>> >> original humanoid form. So why not have the Daleks do just that
>> >> now they've conquered Skaro
>> > A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to
>> > have forgotten.
>> > Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly
>> > tricked him.
>> > So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone
>> > royally fucked up.
>> I don't think anybody fucked up. Moffat is as aware as any of us that
>> Skaro was destroyed by the 7th Doctor. He chose to ignore it. If it
>> worries you, you could always assume that McCoy's actions occurred in
>> the future relative to Asylum. Alternatively, read John Peel's book,
>> "War of the Daleks". In that, he reasoned that the planet the Doctor
>> blew up wasn't Skaro, but was instead the planet Antalin.
> The timeline as presented in the series has been put through the
> wringer so much that I am surprised it even makes as much sense as it
> does right now.
Maybe Keith Topping should write another edition of the Dis-Continuity Guide?
> That said: it also could be that they just destroyed an old or
> alternative Skaro (with the current mainworld of the Daleks always
> being called Skaro and maybe being skaroformed to have those homely acid
So this would be something like New New New New New New Skaro then?
> rains and red skies). Or a future version of Davros might have gone
> back and kept Davros from being destroyed by replacing it with a planet
> called Antalin in the nick of time. Or it might not even have been
> Davros but some other group or individual from a species of scheming
> mad cyborgs that just thought it might be nice to have that old home
> planet saved.
Or that crazy Dalek saved it at the same time he saved Davros.
> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. Thal
>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid >>> form.
>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>forgotten.
>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly tricked
>>him.
>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone royally
>>f!@#$ed up.
>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>several months ago.
> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work properly?
>> "Raymond Daley" <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote in message >> news:Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147368@fx17.am4...
>>> "Agamemnon" wrote
>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. Thal >>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid >>>> form. So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered >>>> Skaro
>>> A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have >>> forgotten.
>>> Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly >>> tricked him.
>>> So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone >>> royally fucked up.
>> I don't think anybody fucked up. Moffat is as aware as any of us that >> Skaro was destroyed by the 7th Doctor. He chose to ignore it. If it >> worries you, you could always assume that McCoy's actions occurred in the >> future relative to Asylum. Alternatively, read John Peel's book, "War of >> the Daleks". In that, he reasoned that the planet the Doctor blew up >> wasn't Skaro, but was instead the planet Antalin.
>The only problem with that is that RTD destroyed the main premise of the >book when he brought back Davros immediately after the 7th Doctor had >destroyed his ship too in the same event that destroyed Skaro, and it can't >work as a continuation from War of the Daleks either.
10/10 .
-- Member - Liberal International This is doc...@nl2k.ab.ca Ici doc...@nl2k.ab.ca
God,Queen and country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! http://www.fullyfollow.me/rootnl2k Quebec le 4 Sept 2012 ne votez pas pour le PQ!
>"The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message >news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. Thal
>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid >>>> form.
>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>forgotten.
>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly tricked
>>>him.
>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone royally
>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>several months ago.
>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
>What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work properly?
Recall Maydryn Undead?
-- Member - Liberal International This is doc...@nl2k.ab.ca Ici doc...@nl2k.ab.ca
God,Queen and country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! http://www.fullyfollow.me/rootnl2k Quebec le 4 Sept 2012 ne votez pas pour le PQ!
> "The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message > news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. >>>> Thal
>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid >>>> form.
>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>forgotten.
>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly >>>tricked
>>>him.
>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone >>>royally
>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>several months ago.
>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
> What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work > properly?
You're right - he is making even less sense than usual. I think the Yadsbot needs rebooting...
>> "The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message >> news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. >>>>> Thal
>>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid >>>>> form.
>>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>>forgotten.
>>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly >>>>tricked
>>>>him.
>>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone >>>>royally
>>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>>several months ago.
>>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
>> What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work >> properly?
>You're right - he is making even less sense than usual. I think the Yadsbot >needs rebooting...
Not at all. And then there is the server.
-- Member - Liberal International This is doc...@nl2k.ab.ca Ici doc...@nl2k.ab.ca
God,Queen and country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! http://www.fullyfollow.me/rootnl2k USA petition to dissolve the Republic and vote to disoolve it in November 2012
> In article <G6ednQe7r7IkPtvNnZ2dnUVZ8gOdn...@eclipse.net.uk>,
> Agamemnon <agamem...@hello.to.NO_SPAM> wrote:
>>"The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message
>>news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. >>>>> Thal
>>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid
>>>>> form.
>>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>>forgotten.
>>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly >>>>tricked
>>>>him.
>>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone >>>>royally
>>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>>several months ago.
>>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
>>What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work >>properly?
>>> "The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message
>>> news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>>>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>>>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs.
>>>>>> Thal
>>>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid
>>>>>> form.
>>>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>>>forgotten.
>>>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly
>>>>>tricked
>>>>>him.
>>>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone
>>>>>royally
>>>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>>>several months ago.
>>>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>>>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies >>>> shows.
>>> What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work
>>> properly?
>>You're right - he is making even less sense than usual. I think the >>Yadsbot
>>needs rebooting...
>"The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message >news:k27csv$ith$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>> In article <G6ednQe7r7IkPtvNnZ2dnUVZ8gOdn...@eclipse.net.uk>,
>> Agamemnon <agamem...@hello.to.NO_SPAM> wrote:
>>>"The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message
>>>news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>>>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>>>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs. >>>>>> Thal
>>>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid
>>>>>> form.
>>>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>>>forgotten.
>>>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly >>>>>tricked
>>>>>him.
>>>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone >>>>>royally
>>>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>>>several months ago.
>>>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>>>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies shows.
>>>What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work >>>properly?
>> Recall Maydryn Undead?
>...and an auto responder now.
LOL ;-)
-- Member - Liberal International This is doc...@nl2k.ab.ca Ici doc...@nl2k.ab.ca
God,Queen and country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! http://www.fullyfollow.me/rootnl2k USA petition to dissolve the Republic and vote to disoolve it in November 2012
>"The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message >news:k27uhb$noh$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>> In article <DOK1s.311071$YL5.185...@fx11.am4>,
>> Stephen Wilson <stephen.wilson2004nos...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>> "The Doctor" <doc...@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca> wrote in message
>>>> news:k25jl5$ijm$1@gallifrey.nk.ca...
>>>>> In article <Ywq1s.277735$wF1.147...@fx17.am4>,
>>>>> Raymond Daley <raymond.da...@ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>>>>>"Agamemnon" wrote
>>>>>>> The Daleks were created survive the radiation caused by the Dal vs.
>>>>>>> Thal
>>>>>>> war and then after that they would return to their original humanoid
>>>>>>> form.
>>>>>>> So why not have the Daleks do just that now they've conquered Skaro
>>>>>>A few reasons. Firstly, the elephant in the room people seem to have
>>>>>>forgotten.
>>>>>>Sly McCoy's Doctor destroyed Skaro. Or rather Davros did when Sly
>>>>>>tricked
>>>>>>him.
>>>>>>So unless this episode involved Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey, someone
>>>>>>royally
>>>>>>f!@#$ed up.
>>>>>>Secondly. It's probably already been done.
>>>>>>I can tell you full well for a fact I personally have a short story in
>>>>>>development that revolved exactly around this idea that I came up with
>>>>>>several months ago.
>>>>> They to document the Whoniverse correctly.
>>>>> That being said Mawdryn Undead was the first time inconsistencies >>>>> shows.
>>>> What? Are you using online translation software that doesn't work
>>>> properly?
>>>You're right - he is making even less sense than usual. I think the >>>Yadsbot
>>>needs rebooting...
>> Not at all. And then there is the server.
>Rubbish auto-responder you're using.
LOL!
-- Member - Liberal International This is doc...@nl2k.ab.ca Ici doc...@nl2k.ab.ca
God,Queen and country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! http://www.fullyfollow.me/rootnl2k USA petition to dissolve the Republic and vote to disoolve it in November 2012
