Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

"Original" Musicals?

0 views
Skip to first unread message

Andrew Leeds

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
I was looking through my CDs and I began to notice a trend. The
majority of musicals are based on either previous works or historical
figures and events. Can anyone think of truly "original" musicals. 2
lists are below - First are the "based on"s and then the "original"s.
Some things may be based on more than what I have listed. Please
correct me if these are wrong. It seems pretty sad to me. (they had to
write TWO musicals about the Peanuts gang?! two about some Phantom in
an opera house?! all right I can see writing 2 things about bible
issues. but did we really need 2 wild parties and a sequel to Bye Bye
Birdie?! We liked Bye Bye Birdie. It was fun, but I don't really care
about Albert and Rose. give me a break!)

(141 Shows)
110 in the Shade - Play
42nd Street - Film
Aida - Opera
Ain't Misbehavin - Old Music
All American - Book
Ambassador - Book
Applause - Film
Aspects of Love - Novel
Assasins - Historical
Annie Get Your Gun - Historical
The Apple Tree - Book
Annie - Cartoon
Annie Warbucks - Sequel to musical based on cartoon
Ballroom - Teleplay
Beauty and the Beast - Direct from the Movie
Ben Franklin In Paris - Historical
Best Little Whorehouse Goes Public - Sequel to musical
Big - Movie
Big Deal - Film
Big River - Book
Black and Blue - Old music
Boys from Syracuse - Shakespaere
Bring Back Birdie - Sequel to musical
Bright Lights, Big City - Film
The Baker's Wife - Film
Barnum - Historical
By Jeeves - Book
Buddy - Historical
Crazy For You - They stole the music!
Camelot - Book
Candide - Book
The Capeman - Historical
Captain's Courageous - Film
Carnival - Film
Carousel - Book
Carrie - Book
Cats - Book
Children of Eden - Book
Chicago - Play
Cyrano - Book
The Civil War - Historical
Damn Yankees - Book
The Dead - Book
A Day in Hollywood ... - Book
Drood - Book
Dear World - Play
Doonesbury - Cartoon
Do I Hear A Waltz - Play
Jekyll and Hyde - Book
Doll's Life - Play
Dreamgirls - Historical
Evita - Historical
Fame - Film
Fanny - Book
Fiddler on the Roof - Book
Flowers for Algernon - Book
Footloose - Film
A Funny Thing Happened ... - Plays
Godspell - Book
Golden Boy - Play
Goodbye Girl - Film
George M. - Historical
Goodtime Charley - Historical
Grand Hotel - Film
Greenwillow - Book
Gypsy - Book
Happy Time - Book
Hello Dolly - Historical
High Button Shoes - Book
High Society - Play
How to Succed - Book
I Can Get It For You Wholesale - Book
I Do! I Do! - Book
Into the Woods - Book
It's a Bird, It's a Plane .... - Cartoon
Jacques Brel ... - Old Music and Lyrics
Jane Eyre - Book
Jelly's Last Jam - Historical
Jesus Christ Superstar - Book
Joseph - Book
Kismet - Play
Kiss of the Spider Woman - Book
Kiss Me Kate - Shakespaere
La Cage - Film
Leader of the Pack - Historical and old Music
Les Miserables - Book
Little Shop - Film
Lion King - Film
Marilyn - Historical
Marlowe - Historical
Martin Guerre - Book
Miss Saigon - Opera
My Favorite Year - Film
Merrily We Roll Along - Play
Merlin - Book
Nine - Film
Oliver! - Book
On the 20th Century - Book
On the Town - Ballet
Once on this Island - Book
Out of This World - Legend
Parade - Historical
Pipe Dream - Book
The Phantom of the Opera -
Pippin - Historical
Prince of Central Park - Book
Purlie - Book
Promises, Promises - Film
Ragtime - Book
romance, Romance - Book
Raisin - Play
Rothschilds - Book
Saturday Night Fever - Film
The Secret Garden - Book
Seven Brides - Film
Sound of Music - Historical
1776 - Historical
Shogun - Book
Snoopy - Cartoon
Scarlett Pimpernell - Book
Sunday in the Park - Historical
Sunset Boulevard - Film
Sweet Charity - Film
Teddy and Alice - Historical
Titanic - Historical
Victor/Victoria - Film
West Side Story - Shakespaere
Will Rogers - Historical
The Wild Party - Book
You're a Good Man Charlie Brown - Cartoon

(47 Shows)
Allegro - Original
Anyone Can Whistle - Original
The Act - Original
Baby - Original
Bells Are Ringing - Original
Best Little Whorehouse - Original
Billion Dollar Baby - Original
Blood Brothers - Original
The Boy Friend - Original
Brigadoon
Bubbling Brown Sugar - Original
Bye Bye Birdie - Original
Cabaret - Original
Can-can - Original
Celebration - Original
City of Angels - Original
Chess - Original
Chorus Line - Original
Company - Original
Falsettos - Original
Fantasticks - Original
Finian's Rainbow - Original
Floyd Collins - Original
Funny Girl - Original
The Grind - Original
Hair - Original
Hello Again - Original
I Love My Wife - Original
Is There Life After High School - Original
Legs Diamond - Original
Mail - Original
Mack and Mabel - Original
The Magic Show - Original
Me and My Girl - Original
Milk and honey - Original
Of Thee I Sing - Original
On a Clear Day - Original
Pacific Overtures - Original
Pal Joey - Original
Paint Your Wagon - Original
Plain and Fancy - Original
Rags - Original
The Rink - Original
Rent - Original
Side Show - Original
Smile - Original
Song and Dance - Original


Jesse Jones

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Andrew Leeds wrote:

> lists are below - First are the "based on"s and then the "original"s.
> Some things may be based on more than what I have listed. Please
> correct me if these are wrong. It seems pretty sad to me. (they had to
> write TWO musicals about the

> (47 Shows)

> Cabaret - Original

Straight play, previously a book: I Am the Camera.

> Floyd Collins - Original

Historical

> Hello Again - Original

Play: La Ronde

> Rent - Original

Opera: La Boheme


KennethNY

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Cabaret is actually based on the Berlin stories of Christopher Isherwood and
John Van Druten's play, I AM A CAMERA.

You could also point to MUSIC MAN, PAINT YOUR WAGON, ON A CLEAR DAY... and
BRIGADOON as originals, although apparently BRIGADOON was partly inspired by
some European fable.

nick3594

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
SIDE SHOW is based on the true life story of the Hilton sisters who were a
famed vaudeville act and starred in 2 movies.

"Andrew Leeds" <a...@cs.stanford.edu> wrote in message
news:397D6785...@cs.stanford.edu...

Michael Callery

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Some others to move to the top list:

The Fantasticks

Based on a French play - Rostand's Les Romanesques

Pal Joey

Based on short stories by John O'Hara

And virtually all of the "biographical" musicals like Funny Girl, Legs
Diamond, etc. which are however loosely based upon someone's life which
I think fits your "Historical" category ... at least as well as Barnum does.

I'd also argue that Company was not originally conceived as a musical --
the short plays that were magically combined were already written,
though not produced. So as different as the musical is, it was initially
a series of short plays.

Don't see any reason why it's sad to base a musical on previously
published, performed, or whatever material.

Mike

Jesse Jones wrote:


>
> Andrew Leeds wrote:
>
> > lists are below - First are the "based on"s and then the "original"s.
> > Some things may be based on more than what I have listed. Please
> > correct me if these are wrong. It seems pretty sad to me. (they had to
> > write TWO musicals about the
>

MAdollfan

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Wasn't Best Little Whorehouse based on a magazine article about an actual event
and the musical just fictionalized it?
Mack and Mable as well as Funny Girl were as "historical" as Will Rogers and
some of the others you put into this category as they were about real people.

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to a...@cs.stanford.edu
Not all of your sources are correct. Some which you have listed
as "original" are based on historical events. BYE BYE BIRDIE was
based on Elvis going into the army, remember? ROMANCE, ROMANCE is
based on a play, not a book. CAROUSEL is based on a play. HELLO
DOLLY is based on a play. GRAND HOTEL is actually based on a
play. CABARET is based on a book. FUNNY GIRL is historical. MACK
AND MABEL is historical. PACIFIC OVERTURES is historical. RENT is
based on an opera. Is LEGS DIAMOND historical? And APPLAUSE is
actually based on a short story. FANTASTICKS is based on a play.
Isn't SIDE SHOW historical?

Andrew Leeds wrote:
>
> Applause - Film
> Carousel - Book
> Grand Hotel - Film
> Hello Dolly - Historical
> Romance, Romance - Book


> Bye Bye Birdie - Original
> Cabaret - Original

> Fantasticks - Original
> Funny Girl - Original
l> Legs Diamond - Original
> Pacific Overtures - Original

brapo32

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Actually Brigadoon is based on the short story Germelshausen
written by Friedrich Gerstacker in 1862.

There is no new. Well maybe Gilgamesh.

Don

-----------------------------------------------------------

Got questions? Get answers over the phone at Keen.com.
Up to 100 minutes free!
http://www.keen.com


Joanna B. Durso

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Andrew Leeds wrote:

>The majority of musicals are based on either previous >works or historical
figures and events.

I can understand why you'd take issue with musicals based on previous works,
but why does it bother you when they're based on history? I think that's one
way to a) help people relate to musicals and/or b) to teach people about
important events or figures which may have been forgotten or ignored.

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
He NEVER said it bothered him at all! He only was
making a point.

"Joanna B. Durso" wrote:


>
> Andrew Leeds wrote:
>
> >The majority of musicals are based on either previous >works or historical
> figures and events.
>

Karen Horn

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
nick3594 <nick...@optonline.net> wrote:
: SIDE SHOW is based on the true life story of the Hilton sisters who were a

: famed vaudeville act and starred in 2 movies.

If the guy is counting "Barnum" as "historical" then SS would qualify
as "historical" too based on the same logic.

Karen

Andrew Leeds

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to

So, here is an updated list. Thanks to all who have made corrections. there
have been many AMAZING musicals based on other things. I am just shocked to
see how many are not actually "Original." This does not seem to be as much the
case with plays. Just surprised.

(142 Shows)


110 in the Shade - Play

1776 ? Historical
42nd Street - Film


A Day in Hollywood ... - Book

A Funny Thing Happened ... ? Plays


Aida - Opera
Ain't Misbehavin - Old Music
All American - Book
Ambassador - Book

Annie - Cartoon


Annie Get Your Gun - Historical

Annie Warbucks - Sequel to musical based on cartoon

Applause - Film
Aspects of Love - Novel
Assasins - Historical

Ballroom - Teleplay
Barnum ? Historical


Beauty and the Beast - Direct from the Movie
Ben Franklin In Paris - Historical
Best Little Whorehouse Goes Public - Sequel to musical
Big - Movie
Big Deal - Film
Big River - Book
Black and Blue - Old music

Boys from Syracuse ? Shakespaere
Brigadoon ? Book (based on the short story Germelshausen)


Bright Lights, Big City - Film
Bring Back Birdie - Sequel to musical

Buddy - Historical
By Jeeves - Book
Bye Bye Birdie - Historical
Cabaret ? Play (I am a Camera)
Camelot - Book
Candide ? Book


Captain's Courageous - Film
Carnival - Film

Carousel - Play


Carrie - Book
Cats - Book

Chicago - Play


Children of Eden - Book

Crazy For You - They stole the music!

Cyrano - Play
Damn Yankees - Book
Dear World - Play


Do I Hear A Waltz - Play

Doll's Life - Play

Doonesbury - Cartoon
Dreamgirls - Historical
Drood - Book
Evita - Historical
Fame ? Film
Fanny - Book
Fantasticks ? Play (Rostand's Les Romanesques)


Fiddler on the Roof - Book
Flowers for Algernon - Book

Floyd Collins - Historical
Footloose - Film
Funny Girl - Historical
George M. - Historical


Godspell - Book
Golden Boy - Play
Goodbye Girl - Film

Goodtime Charley - Historical
Grand Hotel - Play


Greenwillow - Book
Gypsy - Book

Happy Time - Play
Hello Again ? Play (La Ronde)
Hello Dolly ? Play


High Button Shoes - Book
High Society - Play
How to Succed - Book
I Can Get It For You Wholesale - Book

I Do! I Do! - Play


Into the Woods - Book
It's a Bird, It's a Plane .... - Cartoon
Jacques Brel ... - Old Music and Lyrics
Jane Eyre - Book

Jekyll and Hyde - Book

Jelly's Last Jam - Historical
Jesus Christ Superstar - Book
Joseph - Book
Kismet - Play

Kiss Me Kate - Shakespaere


Kiss of the Spider Woman - Book

La Cage - Play


Leader of the Pack - Historical and old Music

Legs Diamond - Historical
Les Miserables - Book
Lion King - Film
Little Shop - Film
Mack and Mabel - Historical
Marilyn - Historical
Marlowe ? Historical
Martin Guerre - Book
Merlin - Book


Merrily We Roll Along - Play
Miss Saigon - Opera
My Favorite Year - Film

Nine - Film
Oliver! - Book
On the 20th Century - Book
On the Town - Ballet
Once on this Island - Book

Out of This World ? Legend
Pal Joey ? Book (based on short stories by John O'Hara)


Parade - Historical
Pipe Dream - Book

Pippin - Historical
Prince of Central Park - Book

Promises, Promises - Film
Purlie - Book
Ragtime - Book
Raisin ? Play
Rent ? Opera (La Boheme)
Romance, Romance - Play


Rothschilds - Book
Saturday Night Fever - Film

Scarlett Pimpernell - Book
Seven Brides - Film
Shogun - Book
Side Show - Historical
Snoopy - Cartoon


Sound of Music - Historical

Sunday in the Park - Historical
Sunset Boulevard - Film
Sweet Charity - Film
Teddy and Alice - Historical

The Apple Tree - Book

The Baker's Wife - Film

The Capeman - Historical


The Civil War - Historical

The Dead - Book


The Phantom of the Opera -

The Secret Garden - Book

The Wild Party - Book
Titanic - Historical
Victor/Victoria - Film
West Side Story - Shakespaere
Will Rogers - Historical
You're a Good Man Charlie Brown - Cartoon

(57 Shows)
13 Daughters - Original
A Family Affair - Original
Allegro - Original
Ankles Aweigh - Original


Anyone Can Whistle - Original

Baby - Original
Beg, Borrow or Steal - Original


Bells Are Ringing - Original
Best Little Whorehouse - Original
Billion Dollar Baby - Original
Blood Brothers - Original

Brigadoon
Bubbling Brown Sugar - Original

By The Beautiful Sea - Original


Can-can - Original
Celebration - Original

Chess - Original
Chorus Line - Original
City of Angels - Original

Company - Original
Drat the Cat - Original
Falsettos - Original


Finian's Rainbow - Original

Flahooley - Original
Follow the Girls - Original


Grind - Original
Hair - Original

Happy Town - Original
Hot Spot - Original
I Had a Ball - Original


I Love My Wife - Original
Is There Life After High School - Original

Kwamina - Original
Little Mary Sunshine - Original
Mail - Original


Me and My Girl - Original

Milk and honey ? Original


Of Thee I Sing - Original
On a Clear Day - Original
Pacific Overtures - Original

Paint Your Wagon - Original
Plain and Fancy - Original
Rags - Original

Sail Away - Original
Smile - Original
Song and Dance ? Original
Steel Pier - Original
Texas L'il Darlin - Original
The Act - Original


The Boy Friend - Original

The Magic Show - Original

The Music Man - Original
The Nervous Set - Original
The Rink - Original
The Student Gypsy - Original
Top Banana - Original
Wildcat - Original

Don Goodner

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
Best Little Whorehouse was basically hisorical. There WAS a Chicken Ranch,
and Marvin Zindler closed her down... though I don't think he actually sang
any songs about it.


hample/ywny

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
In article <397DF5AB...@cs.stanford.edu>, a...@cs.stanford.edu wrote:

Below there are a few more corrections.


> A Day in Hollywood ... - Original
> Bright Lights, Big City - Book
> Captain's Courageous - Book
> Doll's Life - Play (actually more an original since it is a sequel to
the play --though I think it does make use of Ibsens notes for an
unwritten sequel)
> Dreamgirls - Original (okay based on historical)
> Fanny - Films
> How to Succed - Book (though the book was a parody advice book and in no
way contributed plot or characters so this is essentially an original)
> On the 20th Century - Play


> On the Town - Ballet

> Pippin - Historical (only in the LOOSEST sense)
> Is There Life After High School - Original (Yes though based on the
non-fiction book of the same title)

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to a...@cs.stanford.edu
PACIFIC OVERTURES is historical. It's about Admiral Perry's
invasion of Japan!!

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to a...@cs.stanford.edu
APPLAUSE is based on a short story which was turned into
the film ALL ABOUT EVE which became the musical APPLAUSE.

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to a...@cs.stanford.edu
CATS is based on poems by T.S. Elliot.

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to a...@cs.stanford.edu
MY FAVORITE YEAR is historical. Behind the scenes
at YOUR SHOW OF SHOWS - Sid Caesar/Imogene Coca
Mel Brooks, Woody Allen, etc.

Richard C. Wall

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to a...@cs.stanford.edu
ROTHSCHILDS is historical.

MSMoore

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
"Tommy"....Original, non?


Carolyn Marie

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
hample/ywny wrote:

> In article <397DF5AB...@cs.stanford.edu>, a...@cs.stanford.edu wrote:
>
> Below there are a few more corrections.
>

> > A Day in Hollywood ... - Original
>

You're right that the first part was original, although most of the songs in
the revue weren't new. But the second half was sorta kinda based on a short
play by Chekov called "The Boor", which has the Samovar-like lawyer coming to
the rich widow's house to collect a debt, etc. I forget how it ends. But as
Dick Vosburgh or Frank Lazarus, I think, said at the time, "It's based loosely
on that play, so loosely you can hear it rattle."

This is one of the shows I wish I'd seen in its day, and not just because I
adore David Garrison and Priscilla Lopez so much. I recall that my theatre
club at Bronx Science had a choice between that and Sweeney Todd at the end of
one semester for discount tickets. Now, Sweeney opened up new vistas for me,
but I wish I could have seen Priscilla's Harpo play the bicycle wheel just
once...

"He's the legal eagle who can boast
Quite the most
Limited brain!
So hail the lawyer with the big cigar!
No one's luckier than Samovar!
'Yes, I was born beneath a lucky Czar!'
Oh what a night in the Ukraine!"

And the libretto was printed up by Samuel French and is side-splitting!

Carolyn

David Lawver

unread,
Jul 25, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/25/00
to
> Fantasticks - Original

Based on Edmund Rostand's The Romancers...

--
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
David Lawver dmla...@facstaff.wisc.edu
"Paranoia can reduce security." --Nick Maclaren

Jean Prouvaire

unread,
Jul 26, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/26/00
to
Andrew Leeds wrote:

> I was looking through my CDs and I began to notice a trend. The
> majority of musicals are based on either previous works or historical
> figures and events.

It's rather "worse" than that even...

Cabaret - book
Floyd Collins - historical
Funny Girl - historical
Hello Again - book
Legs Diamond - historical?
Mack and Mabel - historical
Rent - Original - opera
Side Show - historical?

This phenomenom isn't confined to musical theatre though. For example
"best picture" Oscars tend to go to adapted material. (According to one
of my books from 1930 to 1990 only 9 best picture awards went to movies
with original screenplays.) Most telemovies and mini series are
adaptions of one sort or another, I think.

IMO there are two main reasons for this trend:

1. Artistically, it's more difficult to write something new than to
adapt an existing work - particularly if the work is strong to begin
with. A lot of the hard work (character creation, plot etc) is already
done and the creative team can concentrate on the aspects that make the
story a musical (words, lyrics, book etc).

2. Commercially, it's safer to adapt an existing property with audience
recognition.


--

Remove "SPAMFREE" from e-mail address to reply.
____________________________________________________________________

Beyond the barricades: Les Miserables news, resources and recordings
http://www.thebarricades.com http://www.thehungersite.com
____________________________________________________________________

Brian Hayes

unread,
Jul 26, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/26/00
to

"MSMoore" <msm...@lewiston.com> wrote in message
news:8llbb5$k92$1...@news.fsr.net...
> "Tommy"....Original, non?
>

Tommy, well it's wasnt a play to start with it was a rock opera, but never
performed, how do you categorize it?

I have five originals...

Do Black Patent LEather Shoes Really Reflect Up?
Starmites
Starlight Express- I assume this is pretty original, no?
Rocky Horror Show-Isnt this an active topic?
GREASE- Umm HELLOO! Does no one remember this show? ;)

Come on, there have to be more, let's think...

Brian

Stephen Farrow

unread,
Jul 26, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/26/00
to
Andrew Leeds wrote:

> I Love My Wife - Original

Nope - the Samuel French edition says it's based on a play by Luis Rego,
though it doesn't give the title.

Stephen

--
Will men ever get pregnant? And if they do, will they opt for
shoulder-tie dungarees, or play safe with Peter Pan collar-type loose
smocks? Whatever they decide, there's bound to be a documentary about
it. And possibly a tea towel.
- Victoria Wood

Kaffitimi

unread,
Jul 26, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/26/00
to
Andrew Leeds wrote:

> I Love My Wife - Original

Nope - the Samuel French edition says it's based on a play by Luis Rego,
though it doesn't give the title.

Stephen
+++++++++++++++++
The Playbill didn't id it either. Suskin says it is Viens Chez Moi, J'Habite
Chez une Copine by Rego and Didier Kaminka.

Stephen Farrow

unread,
Jul 26, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/26/00
to
Andrew Leeds wrote:

> Doll's Life - Play

Should probably be in the 'originals' column - it's an original plot
that takes up where "A Doll's House" leaves off. None of it is directly
adapted from Ibsen's play - it just uses some of the same characters.

> How to Succed - Book

I think someone else has already said this - the book is essentially a
spoof self-help manual (and a very funny one, IIRC) that doesn't contain
any of the characters found in the musical (never mind any kind of
plot). This one probably technically belongs in the 'originals' column
as well, even though it's based on/inspired by a book.

> romance, Romance - Book

Sort of - the first half is an adaptation of a Schnitzler short story
("Der Kleine Komodie"), and the second half is an adaptation of Jules
Renard's play "Pain de Ménage".

> Sunday in the Park - Historical

This one definitely belongs in the "originals" column. Act One is *not*
in any way a biography of Seurat (Dot is an invented character who is
partly inspired by Madeleine Knobloch, the mother of Seurat's child);
it's partly about the process of creating a painting, and partly about
the idea that this painting freezes a diverse and unrelated group of
characters into a single moment for all time. Act Two, of course, is
something else again. I'd call it an original work inspired by a
painting, rather than by historical events.

> Hello Again - Original

Based on Schnitzler's "La Ronde".

> Pacific Overtures - Original

Based on historical events, and preceded by an (I think unproduced)
straight play by John Weidman.

Adam Stephanides

unread,
Jul 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/27/00
to
Stephen Farrow wrote:
>
> > How to Succed - Book
>
> I think someone else has already said this - the book is essentially a
> spoof self-help manual (and a very funny one, IIRC) that doesn't contain
> any of the characters found in the musical (never mind any kind of
> plot). This one probably technically belongs in the 'originals' column
> as well, even though it's based on/inspired by a book.

IIRC a lot of the ploys used by Finch are taken from the book (e. g.
refusing a promotion so you'll appear to be putting the company's good
ahead of your own, pretending to have the same alma mater as your boss).

--Adam

MUSCGAY

unread,
Jul 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/27/00
to
ROMANCE/ROMANCE is actually based on two different sources, consisting as it
does of two one-act musicals. The first act, "The Little Comedy" is based on a
short story by Schnitzler - (also entitled "The Little Comedy" and pre-dating
La Chiusa's adaptation of Schnitzler's play "La Ronde" for HELLO, AGAIN). The
second act of ROMANCE is based on a play by French playwright Jules Renard,
entitled "Pain de Menage (Household Bread). Both source materials were
written at the turn of the last century but the authors of ROMANCE decided to
contemporize the second piece, setting it in the present.


RBuck406

unread,
Jul 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/27/00
to
>but the authors of ROMANCE decided to
>contemporize the second piece, setting it in the present.

>I was wondering how long you'd let that one go on! Woofs..
>
>
>
>
>
>

BethanyT80

unread,
Jul 27, 2000, 3:00:00 AM7/27/00
to
If people are saying that Bye Bye Birdie is historical, then I'd put Chess in
that catagory too. I'm not too familiar with the show but isn't it based on
Bobby Fischer's chess match against the Russian?
>
>I was looking through my CDs and I began to notice a trend. The
>majority of musicals are based on either previous works or historical
>figures and events. Can anyone think of truly "original" musicals. 2
>lists are below - First are the "based on"s and then the "original"s.
>Some things may be based on more than what I have listed. Please
>correct me if these are wrong. It seems pretty sad to me. (they had to
>write TWO musicals about the Peanuts gang?! two about some Phantom in
>an opera house?! all right I can see writing 2 things about bible
>issues. but did we really need 2 wild parties and a sequel to Bye Bye
>Birdie?! We liked Bye Bye Birdie. It was fun, but I don't really care
>about Albert and Rose. give me a break!)
>
>(141 Shows)

>110 in the Shade - Play
>42nd Street - Film

>Aida - Opera
>Ain't Misbehavin - Old Music
>All American - Book
>Ambassador - Book
>Applause - Film
>Aspects of Love - Novel
>Assasins - Historical
>Annie Get Your Gun - Historical
>The Apple Tree - Book
>Annie - Cartoon

>Annie Warbucks - Sequel to musical based on cartoon
>Ballroom - Teleplay

>Beauty and the Beast - Direct from the Movie
>Ben Franklin In Paris - Historical
>Best Little Whorehouse Goes Public - Sequel to musical
>Big - Movie
>Big Deal - Film
>Big River - Book
>Black and Blue - Old music
>Boys from Syracuse - Shakespaere

>Bring Back Birdie - Sequel to musical
>Bright Lights, Big City - Film

>The Baker's Wife - Film
>Barnum - Historical
>By Jeeves - Book
>Buddy - Historical

>Crazy For You - They stole the music!
>Camelot - Book
>Candide - Book
>The Capeman - Historical

>Captain's Courageous - Film
>Carnival - Film
>Carousel - Book

>Carrie - Book
>Cats - Book
>Children of Eden - Book
>Chicago - Play
>Cyrano - Book

>The Civil War - Historical
>Damn Yankees - Book
>The Dead - Book
>A Day in Hollywood ... - Book
>Drood - Book
>Dear World - Play
>Doonesbury - Cartoon

>Do I Hear A Waltz - Play
>Jekyll and Hyde - Book
>Doll's Life - Play
>Dreamgirls - Historical
>Evita - Historical
>Fame - Film
>Fanny - Book

>Fiddler on the Roof - Book
>Flowers for Algernon - Book
>Footloose - Film
>A Funny Thing Happened ... - Plays

>Godspell - Book
>Golden Boy - Play
>Goodbye Girl - Film
>George M. - Historical
>Goodtime Charley - Historical
>Grand Hotel - Film

>Greenwillow - Book
>Gypsy - Book
>Happy Time - Book
>Hello Dolly - Historical

>High Button Shoes - Book
>High Society - Play
>How to Succed - Book
>I Can Get It For You Wholesale - Book
>I Do! I Do! - Book

>Into the Woods - Book
>It's a Bird, It's a Plane .... - Cartoon
>Jacques Brel ... - Old Music and Lyrics
>Jane Eyre - Book
>Jelly's Last Jam - Historical
>Jesus Christ Superstar - Book
>Joseph - Book
>Kismet - Play
>Kiss of the Spider Woman - Book
>Kiss Me Kate - Shakespaere
>La Cage - Film

>Leader of the Pack - Historical and old Music
>Les Miserables - Book
>Little Shop - Film
>Lion King - Film
>Marilyn - Historical
>Marlowe - Historical
>Martin Guerre - Book

>Miss Saigon - Opera
>My Favorite Year - Film
>Merrily We Roll Along - Play
>Merlin - Book

>Nine - Film
>Oliver! - Book
>On the 20th Century - Book

>On the Town - Ballet
>Once on this Island - Book
>Out of This World - Legend

>Parade - Historical
>Pipe Dream - Book
>The Phantom of the Opera -
>Pippin - Historical
>Prince of Central Park - Book
>Purlie - Book
>Promises, Promises - Film
>Ragtime - Book
>romance, Romance - Book
>Raisin - Play

>Rothschilds - Book
>Saturday Night Fever - Film
>The Secret Garden - Book
>Seven Brides - Film

>Sound of Music - Historical
>1776 - Historical
>Shogun - Book
>Snoopy - Cartoon
>Scarlett Pimpernell - Book

>Sunday in the Park - Historical
>Sunset Boulevard - Film
>Sweet Charity - Film
>Teddy and Alice - Historical
>Titanic - Historical
>Victor/Victoria - Film
>West Side Story - Shakespaere
>Will Rogers - Historical
>The Wild Party - Book
>You're a Good Man Charlie Brown - Cartoon
>
>(47 Shows)
>Allegro - Original

>Anyone Can Whistle - Original
>The Act - Original
>Baby - Original

>Bells Are Ringing - Original
>Best Little Whorehouse - Original
>Billion Dollar Baby - Original
>Blood Brothers - Original
>The Boy Friend - Original
>Brigadoon
>Bubbling Brown Sugar - Original
>Bye Bye Birdie - Original
>Cabaret - Original

>Can-can - Original
>Celebration - Original
>City of Angels - Original
>Chess - Original
>Chorus Line - Original
>Company - Original
>Falsettos - Original
>Fantasticks - Original

>Finian's Rainbow - Original
>Floyd Collins - Original
>Funny Girl - Original
>The Grind - Original
>Hair - Original
>Hello Again - Original

>I Love My Wife - Original
>Is There Life After High School - Original
>Legs Diamond - Original
>Mail - Original
>Mack and Mabel - Original

>The Magic Show - Original
>Me and My Girl - Original
>Milk and honey - Original

>Of Thee I Sing - Original
>On a Clear Day - Original
>Pacific Overtures - Original
>Pal Joey - Original

>Paint Your Wagon - Original
>Plain and Fancy - Original
>Rags - Original
>The Rink - Original
>Rent - Original
>Side Show - Original
>Smile - Original
>Song and Dance - Original

0 new messages