On Sep 23, 11:27Â am, anim8rFSK <
anim8r...@cox.net> wrote:
>
> Why does quitting have to be a permanent thing? Â They don't have kids.
> Why not schedule an annual adventure, say every July, whenever people
> take vacations anyway? Â Except in the rare instance, like this episode,
> where the danger threatens them in their time, there's no reason the
> Doctor can't just pick them up on the next scheduled July 1, no matter
> where or when they're headed for.
>
It's not really about them having literal speicific things to do that
it interferes with. It's really about the fact that they can't fully
commit to living on earth and having a normal life when they know that
they could always slip off back into the Doctor's world and never come
back.
That's the big thing here; the Doctor keeps telling people "We can go
and have adventures and i'll bring you right back to when you left so
you can go on with your mundane normal life afterward," but that's
only half-true, because even if the Doctor manages to get you home to
the right place and time, *you* aren't the same. Just as one small
example, I'd hate to be the first patient Rory has to help the day
after his anniversary, when he's suddenly two months out-of-practice.
Adn will Amy really remember she's got to pick her bridesmaid's dress
up at the shop this afternoon, if they call her in the morning, but at
lunch she pops off for six months saving galaxies?
(I may have it backwards, but my recollection is that in 'The Chase',
the Doctor allegedly tries to send Ian and Barbara back to 1963, and
misses by a bit, leaving them in 1965. In the Target Novelization,
otoh, the Doctor _intentionally_ sends them back to 1965, because
between Ian's tan and their new more worldly outlook, people would get
To Talking if they just showed up back at work the next day two years
older)
> And why wouldn't Rory's dad go with them? Â Shirley they can find
> somebody to water the plants for them.
It seems like you have a tendency to take people entirely literally
and only at face-value. WHen Rory's dad says that he needs to water
the plants, watering the plants is a *metaphor*. He means that he's
fully committed to his life in the "real world" and, unlike Rory and
Amy, he isn't willing to just put "real life" on hiatus.
Actually gave me a lot of respect for Rory's dad, since we know that
he *is* the kind of guy who could handle himself running off on galaxy-
saving adventures, but he doesn't yield to the temptation to run away
from it all. (Reminds me a bit of Grace in that respect).
It's kind of a shame that Rory and Amy are leaving *now*, since these
past three stories are the first time I've fully liked and respected
them.