I think there are more minority superheros than religious ones.
Not that I want to see "The Teen Titans" become "The Christian
Crusaders, with their Happy Hindu friend and wacky Orthodox Jew
sidekick", but seems unrealistic that there would be none.
I'm not religious myself, but I know that for a large chunk of the
population, faith is an important part of their lives.
Huntress has a Christian Prostitute wardrobe, but that's about as far
is it goes. She isn't defined or motivated by her faith.
There would seem to be a lot of untapped ground for storytelling. I
wonder why it hasn't happened. So, what do you think: Agnostic/Athiest
writers trying to force their worldview on impressionable children, or
writers shying away from something that could be handled very badly
and offensively?
I, for one, would like to see some character get revamped as a Born
Again Christian, rather than the usual darker, angrier more violent
version. And not a religious zealot either -- tolerent, although
perhaps disapproving at times.
Plus, it would give writers a chance to answer the question that I
know we've all been pondering: "Did Jesus die for Superman's sins?"
--Gustavo
Nothing I can think of from DC or Marvel, and the only one that I can think
of at all is Ben Dunn's Warrior Nun Areala (Antarctic Press).
Arnold Kim
She's definitely Catholic, as evinced many times in her appearances, and
attends Mass too I think.
Nightcrawler is devoutly Catholic and Kitty Pryde is Jewish
The Titans discuss their faith in the first Brother Blood arc. IIRC Dick
states he believes but doesn't attend a church, and Wally is in much the
same situation, but is less certain
Deadman believes in a deity called Rama Kushna (Whom he has had
conversations with)
Nightshade is also a Catholic, and regularly took confession with the priest
assigned to the Suicide Squad.
> There would seem to be a lot of untapped ground for storytelling. I
> wonder why it hasn't happened. So, what do you think: Agnostic/Athiest
> writers trying to force their worldview on impressionable children, or
> writers shying away from something that could be handled very badly
> and offensively?
Or 3) agnostic/athiest writers who aren't trying to force a worldview on
anyone, but aren't interested in writing about religion, either.
The GA Plastic Man's origin always seemed to me to be a story of religious
conversion, with the religion strangely blacked out. Criminal is fatally
wounded, nursed back to health by monks whose goodness convinces him to
change the course of his life? Sounds like a conversion experience to me.
Dave Doty
----== Posted via Newsfeed.Com - Unlimited-Uncensored-Secure Usenet News==----
http://www.newsfeed.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! >100,000 Newsgroups
---= 19 East/West-Coast Specialized Servers - Total Privacy via Encryption =---
>[Huntress is] definitely Catholic, as evinced many times in her appearances,
>and attends Mass too I think.
>Nightcrawler is devoutly Catholic and Kitty Pryde is Jewish
Ever-lovin' blue-eyed Benjamin J. Grimm is also Jewish - by heritage
and childhood, if not by present practice.
>Wally is in much the same situation [as Nightwing], but is less certain
That would be before Wally discovered that God is really the Speed Force, and
Uncle Barry was the Messiah! Oh, wait, that never happened. Moving on . . .
Pre-Crisis, Superman worshipped (or studied and made use of rituals from the
worship of, at least) a god named Rao. Rao was apparently a Kryptonian
Sun-God, although it was implied several times that "Rao" was in fact the
Kryptonian name for the same One True God(TM) in which Terran Jews, Christians,
and Muslims believe. Post-Crisis, Supes has mentioned Rao - royally set
Zeus off once just by saying the name! Was that ever explored? - but hasn't
been seen to be active in Rao-worship. In the PZ Krypton storyline the
bad-guy movers and shakers were a Rao cult, IIRC.
What was Clark and Lois's wedding ritual, btw? Non-religious?
Non-denominational Christian? Something else? (Pre-Crisis, I don't recall any
details about Lois's wedding to CLARK on Earth-2, but there was a separate
ceremony in the Fortress with Superman done according to the Kryptonian
tradition. I still remember the lines "In the name of Rao, who shaped the sun,
. . ." (the bride's answer had "moons" in place of "sun". Maybe that whole
Sun=Man Moon=Woman thing was part of Kryptonian tradition, too, although it
seems unlikely somehow :)).
-Mark
In additions to the ones others mentioned, I thought of Zauriel, but I'm not
sure he *is* religious, as we'd understand it. Religion is an interpratation of
a truth that he actually *knows*.
--
Dave
The Official Absentee of EU Skiffeysoc
http://www.eusa.ed.ac.uk/societies/sesoc
Four-and-twenty Lib Dems came down from Inverness,
And when the vote was counted there were four-and-twenty less.
-Rory Bremner, 7/3/04
Black Lightning, as written by his creator (pardon the pun), Tony Isabella, was
a devout Christian, IIRC. Too bad DC decided to throw that out and make him a
cold-blooded murderer....
http://www.silverbulletcomicbooks.com/features/107042750449064.htm
Anyhow...you might be interested in Mark Millar's forthcoming, "Chosen". To
read a bit about it, please go here...
http://www.silverbulletcomicbooks.com/features/107419514831683.htm
...and scroll down a bit.
Enjoy!
BRY
>"Gustavo Wombat" <Gustav...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
>news:6dc8909e.04042...@posting.google.com...
>> I'm not religious myself, but I know that for a large chunk of the
>> population, faith is an important part of their lives.
>> Huntress has a Christian Prostitute wardrobe, but that's about as far
>> is it goes. She isn't defined or motivated by her faith.
>She's definitely Catholic, as evinced many times in her appearances, and
>attends Mass too I think.
>Nightcrawler is devoutly Catholic and Kitty Pryde is Jewish
Marvel has plenty of (real-world) religious characters: Wolfsbane,
Firebird ...
>What was Clark and Lois's wedding ritual, btw? Non-religious?
>Non-denominational Christian? Something else?
The officiator (if that's the word) was a Protastant minister, I think, but
there wasn't anything specific to one religion in the ceremony, and it took
place in the decidedly non-denominational Metropolis Chapel of United Faiths.
> So, what do you think: Agnostic/Athiest writers trying to force their
> worldview on impressionable children, or writers shying away from
> something that could be handled very badly and offensively?
Companies not wanting to raise the issue, out of fear of losing readers
(either through offending someone, or by having people say "I'm not
(Particular Faith), I don't want to read about someone who is").
--
Johanna Draper Carlson
Reviews of Comics Worth Reading -- http://www.comicsworthreading.com
Blogging at http://www.comicsworthreading.com/blog/cwr.html
Jesse Custer... uh, believes that God exists.
Swamp Thing met Jes... nevermind.
I think Donna Troy went to church once.
Regards,
Justin
http://www.uatu.net
"Gustavo Wombat" <Gustav...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:6dc8909e.04042...@posting.google.com...
>I can't think of any major superheroes that strongly believe in any
>real faith, and that surprises me. Certainly not in the DC Universe.
>
>I think there are more minority superheros than religious ones.
>
>Not that I want to see "The Teen Titans" become "The Christian
>Crusaders, with their Happy Hindu friend and wacky Orthodox Jew
>sidekick", but seems unrealistic that there would be none.
>
>I'm not religious myself, but I know that for a large chunk of the
>population, faith is an important part of their lives.
Huh, no one's brought up Daredevil yet, who's faith has often played a
prominent role in his own comic.
There was a nice conversation between Magma and Empath one time, when she
tells him about meeting Hercules. He ponders whose faith is greater, her's,
because she has met one of her deities (Well, demi-deity, but you get the
idea), or his, because he has faith in something he's never seen (Despite
the fact that Empath was a sociopathic sadist up until about this point
(Thank you Ms Simonson!) and was about as Un-Christian as it's possible to
imagine)
Strange how many villains are seemingly empowered by demons, and how few
heroes are seemingly empowered by God (Well, not in the same, "Hands on"
approach as say Sabbac or Mephisto.)
There's also a God of Dreams, IIRC, which is how he percieves Morpheus the
Sandman (Morpheus was touched by his faith, and granted him a specific dream
of a specific place, which J'onn seemed honoured by)
And the Spectre (Jim Corrigan) was resurrected by God directly IIRC so
he kind of HAD to be.
"Jeremy Henderson" <hel...@tampabay.rr.com> wrote in message
news:v8gg80d93646ftsg7...@4ax.com...
A couple thoughts
Thor would have to believe in his faith. So there is at least one. (Is that
what you meant by "certainly not in the DC universe")
As to why we don't see them. There is an expression "Never discuss religion
or politics". Presumable because it will always lead to a disagreement at
the least and a major blowout is not uncommon. Some things people believe so
strongly that nothing will sway them. If you suggest that they may be wrong,
it won't be taken well.DC and Marvel are avoiding the issue so as not to
piss off half of their readers. (although they don't seem to be too averse
to stating an opinion on the political issues)
Pete
Just happened to think of a couple more.
I think the Spectre would be pretty religious.
Some one mentioned Plastic Man's origin, So I think Dr. Strange might
qualify as his back story is similar.
It's likely because politics are seen as something about which reasonable
men may reasonably disagree- but when you get in to issues of religion, many
folks are still of the feeling that to disagree with their particular
faith/sect/cult/holy books is to court damnation.
Dave
---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.659 / Virus Database: 423 - Release Date: 15/04/2004
> I can't think of any major superheroes that strongly believe in any
> real faith, and that surprises me. Certainly not in the DC Universe.
Obsidian was a veritfied Catholic while Jade was Protestant (but no
particular denomination named). This information came out of one of the
earlier issues of Infinity, Inc.
> I think there are more minority superheros than religious ones.
It's hard to say. The major heroes don't get into this because comic
writers are probably worried about offending people. Minor heroes (or
those without their own books) don't have the chance to let you know
about their religious affiliations (or lack of).
> Not that I want to see "The Teen Titans" become "The Christian
> Crusaders, with their Happy Hindu friend and wacky Orthodox Jew
> sidekick", but seems unrealistic that there would be none.
Atom-Smasher is Jewish. There was a member of JLE named Maya who was, I
think, Hindu.
> I'm not religious myself, but I know that for a large chunk of the
> population, faith is an important part of their lives.
>
> Huntress has a Christian Prostitute wardrobe, but that's about as far
> is it goes. She isn't defined or motivated by her faith.
Do we know that? (I don't, because I haven't read anything with her in
it outside of the first issue of her series and her appearances in JLA.)
> There would seem to be a lot of untapped ground for storytelling. I
> wonder why it hasn't happened. So, what do you think: Agnostic/Athiest
> writers trying to force their worldview on impressionable children, or
> writers shying away from something that could be handled very badly
> and offensively?
>
> I, for one, would like to see some character get revamped as a Born
> Again Christian, rather than the usual darker, angrier more violent
> version. And not a religious zealot either -- tolerent, although
> perhaps disapproving at times.
I'd rather not have the Born Again Christian, but instead someone who
has a solid faith and who is willing to show it.
> Plus, it would give writers a chance to answer the question that I
> know we've all been pondering: "Did Jesus die for Superman's sins?"
We all know he did. He came (again), died, and arose to help us.
> A couple thoughts
>
> Thor would have to believe in his faith. So there is at least one. (Is
> that what you meant by "certainly not in the DC universe")
This sort of goes against the idea of "faith". Thor doesn't have a
faith associated with him. He's just there. Since an ever-growing
number of stories have him act as nothing more than an average child
(super-powered, of course), it's hard to imagine he sees himself as
anything other than just a person.
> As to why we don't see them. There is an expression "Never discuss
> religion or politics". Presumable because it will always lead to a
> disagreement at the least and a major blowout is not uncommon. Some
> things people believe so strongly that nothing will sway them. If you
> suggest that they may be wrong, it won't be taken well.DC and Marvel
> are avoiding the issue so as not to piss off half of their readers.
> (although they don't seem to be too averse to stating an opinion on
> the political issues)
True, but being highly political in comics seems to be fairly new. It
could be that views on religious expression will change.
> True, but being highly political in comics seems to be fairly new. It
> could be that views on religious expression will change.
Depends on what you mean by "new." The highly political Green
Lantern/Green Arrow, often cited as a turning point in DC's approach to
comics with its "relevance", came out in 1970.
> I can't think of any major superheroes that strongly believe in any
> real faith, and that surprises me. Certainly not in the DC Universe.
Pre-Crisis, Gim Allon - Colossal Boy was Jewish.
Brother Voodoo is rather obvious with his faith.
Jesse Custer believed that God existed.
===
= DUG.
===
Although, one assumes was Catholic before he died to end up in Purgitory.
===
= DUG.
===
I'm assuming a bit here but, since Thor is a scandanavian god wouldn't there
be a religion or faith with people who worship him? (with a name like
Henrikson, I should know more about this subject. :^) ) Of course, since
Thor knows for a fact that he's a god, faith might not be an accurate term.
>
> > As to why we don't see them. There is an expression "Never discuss
> > religion or politics". Presumable because it will always lead to a
> > disagreement at the least and a major blowout is not uncommon. Some
> > things people believe so strongly that nothing will sway them. If you
> > suggest that they may be wrong, it won't be taken well.DC and Marvel
> > are avoiding the issue so as not to piss off half of their readers.
> > (although they don't seem to be too averse to stating an opinion on
> > the political issues)
>
> True, but being highly political in comics seems to be fairly new. It
> could be that views on religious expression will change.
>
Perhaps they are already, since the Fantastic Four went to heaven to meet
God an issue or two ago. (Who God turned out to be not withstanding)
Pete
> "Gustavo Wombat" <Gustav...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:6dc8909e.04042...@posting.google.com...
> > I can't think of any major superheroes that strongly believe in any
> > real faith, and that surprises me. Certainly not in the DC Universe.
>
> Nothing I can think of from DC or Marvel, and the only one that I can think
> of at all is Ben Dunn's Warrior Nun Areala (Antarctic Press).
Err.. Did you forget about Nightcrawler, a devout catholic who at some
times was even a priest?
> "Brian Doyle" <No_...@freeserve.co.uk> writes:
>
> >[Huntress is] definitely Catholic, as evinced many times in her appearances,
> >and attends Mass too I think.
>
> >Nightcrawler is devoutly Catholic and Kitty Pryde is Jewish
>
> Ever-lovin' blue-eyed Benjamin J. Grimm is also Jewish - by heritage
> and childhood, if not by present practice.
>
> >Wally is in much the same situation [as Nightwing], but is less certain
>
> That would be before Wally discovered that God is really the Speed Force, and
> Uncle Barry was the Messiah! Oh, wait, that never happened. Moving on . . .
>
> Pre-Crisis, Superman worshipped (or studied and made use of rituals
> from the worship of, at least) a god named Rao. Rao was apparently
> a Kryptonian Sun-God, although it was implied several times that
> "Rao" was in fact the Kryptonian name for the same One True God(TM)
> in which Terran Jews, Christians, and Muslims believe.
I always thought that this was pretty clear. Rao used to be a sun-god,
but later experienced a shift in terminolgy and become a symbol for
"God". The Krypton Miniseries even repeated the Noah's ark story and
IIRC there once was a Kryptonian Jesus Christ analogue, a bringer of
peace who died for his belief in peace, love and understanding.
> Post-Crisis, Supes has mentioned Rao - royally set Zeus off once
> just by saying the name!
Cool. When did that happen?
> The GA Plastic Man's origin always seemed to me to be a story of religious
> conversion, with the religion strangely blacked out. Criminal is fatally
> wounded, nursed back to health by monks whose goodness convinces him to
> change the course of his life? Sounds like a conversion experience to me.
Not necessarily. I'm atheistic, but I've no problem in seing the
goodness in Christian (and others) deeds and consider it normal to
work together with all who have ethical standards and ideas of helping
their common man. As long as joining them isn't a prerequiste of
receiving this help or working with them on projects, that is,
>I seem to remember that Barry Allen was a Christian.
>He may have been Catholic, but that's a bit fuzzy in my memory.
It seems to be ground rule that Christians in comics almost always
are.
I have a suspicion that this is because the founding fathers of the
American Comics industry are so very often Jewish that Catholicism is
the easily identifiable alternative. Low church protestants don't have
as many obvious shticks.
FWIW: Cannonball was at least sometimes southern Baptist.
-------------------------------------
York BSAC Web Page:
http://website.lineone.net/~york_bsac
> I have a suspicion that this is because the founding fathers of the
> American Comics industry are so very often Jewish that Catholicism is
> the easily identifiable alternative.
I think it's more likely because Catholicism providing more good visuals
and story hooks. (What few religious-themed stories we have seem to
revolve around confessionals to an unusual degree.)
A very reluctant convert IIRC. He was a scientist who rejected the concept
of magic for manyyears before eventually find his role.
The Brother Blood wears something which is apparently the Robe of Christ,
though it's power has been corrupted by his intents.
The Phantom Stranger is tied in with God in some respect, various origins
have included him being an angel who stayed neutral when Lucifer rebelled
(And thus being accepted by neither side) and another that he is the
legendary Wandering Jew.
And how could I have forgotten Marvel's one attempt to create a definitely
God-empowered character; Illuminator, an actively Christian hero whose power
came from a force of Universal goodness that was, IIRC, God. Lasted two
issues, I believe.
A similar explanation: Middle-America demographics to the contrary, Jews
growing up in "Metropolis" are likely to come into contact with far more
Catholics than any other Christians. I personally went through elementary
school believing this was the norm.
Bill Bickel
http://www.comicsidontunderstand.com
http://www.missing-kids.us
http://www.lawsuit-of-the-week.com
John
___
John Adcox
Click below for Mythology, Philosophy, Literature, Writing References and more.
http://jadcox.home.mindspring.com
The Spectre is the "Redemption" of God, or the "Wrath of God"
depending on old or new. I always took the original Spectre to being
hard core damnation christian. (which is only a small part of the
Christian message, but the part that is most dramatic, and thus sadly
emphasised....the real Good News is God loving us, living as one of
us, and paying the price for our sins..which is death, on himself,
just so we can be with him, and him with us)
Huntress wears a cross, and has refered to her Faith in God.
Daredevil has prayed and is very Catholic. A whole arc by Miller was
intitled "Born Again" and used heavy Christain symbolism. The first
arc of the relaunch by Quesada was about the Catholic church.
Captain America has been generic Christian and Jewish or agnostic
depending on the writer at the time.
Shadowcat/Kitty Pride is Jewish, and wore (wears?) a Star of David.
Cannonball has talked about attending church (assumed Protestent since
he's from Kentucky).
Sunspot was a Catholic.
Shang-Chi(sp?), the Master of Kung-Fu is a Buddest.
On a related side note: I'm amazed at how few characters/heroes have
been motivated by their faith especially a Christian faith. One of
the main tenents of the Christian faith is loving and helping others.
Since heroes do that (help others) I would think more would have the
"why do they do what they do" being part their faith. Also,as a
Christian, one of the things we are taught is we all have "talents" or
gifts from God, and what we do with those talents is our gift back to
God. I would think some "heroes" would use their super powered gifts
as gifts back to God.
Dreighton
arnold kim wrote:
> "Gustavo Wombat" <Gustav...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:6dc8909e.04042...@posting.google.com...
>
>>I can't think of any major superheroes that strongly believe in any
>>real faith, and that surprises me. Certainly not in the DC Universe.
>
>
> Nothing I can think of from DC or Marvel, and the only one that I can think
> of at all is Ben Dunn's Warrior Nun Areala (Antarctic Press).
>
> Well, NightCrawler was in the process of becoming a Catholic Priest
there for a while, just off the top of my head.
AJSolis wrote:
> Let's see, there's the jewish Shadowcat, Firebird is christian. Storm is
> probably still a pagan. There's shaman from alpha flight, naturally a believer
> in shamanism.
Shamanism? Is that a word?
Yes.
It might be that they do but they practice humility and don't ever talk
about it. (Although there are thought balloons in comics.)
Pete
>
> Dreighton
Come to think of it,, the Confessor himself was originally a Catholic priest
who is bitten by a vampire but tries to continue doing good despite his
"undead" status. You might want to look up the TPB of that Astro City storyline
(I think the title is "Confession").
"You can't kill the truth. Well, actually, you CAN kill it...but it'll come
back to haunt you later." (Capt. John Sheridan)
The issue of Marvel's Thor being worshipped as an actual god was pretty much
ignored in the series until recently, but current Thor writer Dan Jurgens has
gotten heavily into it in the last couple of years, with a storyline in which
Thor, who has replaced Odin as ruler of Asgard, brings Asgard to Earth and sets
himself up as ruler of Earth for its own good. A Thor cult is started, based
on Thor actually being able to perform "miracles" for the people of Earth, and
it comes into conflict, eventually violent, with Christianity and other
established religions.
Good. But the origin of the stereotype isn't hard to spot - the non-fanatic
Christians don't tend to be very visible in the media. Squeaky wheels and all
that. So most non-Christians probably have a very slanted view of Christianity,
imagining that the Fallwells and Robertsons are typical.
>"You can't kill the truth. Well, actually, you CAN kill it...but it'll come
>back to haunt you later." (Capt. John Sheridan)
The thread topic plus your B5 quote combine to remind me of the
"What is Earth's religion?" episode (pre-Sheridan), in which we find out
that Earth is apparently unique among the galactic civilizations in not
having a single religion shared by all Terrans.
Actually that was the point of their characterisation, they were portrayed
as fanatics - handing out pamphlets on a street corner and unliked by a
population that saw them as pushy, but later appeared as good people.
===
= DUG.
===
I thought it was unique in that it embraced the differences (remember the
Centuri had many religions, house gods and the like - but had wiped out
the other major race on the planet (Not that humans didn't))
===
= DUG.
===
>> AJSolis wrote:
>Yes.
But it's more a thing you do, isn't it, not a belief.
I haven't been following this thread closely, but someone surely has
mentioned Zauriel, who was an angel of the Heavenly Host.
Brenda
--
---------
Brenda W. Clough
http://www.sff.net/people/Brenda/
Recent short fiction: PARADOX, Autumn 2003
http://home.nyc.rr.com/paradoxmag//index.html
Upcoming short fiction in FIRST HEROES (TOR, May '04)
http://members.aol.com/wenamun/firstheroes.html
Yes, but it was asked he had a faith or a knowledge...
===
= DUG.
===
MJR> Post-Crisis, Supes has mentioned Rao - royally set Zeus off once
MJR> just by saying the name!
PB> Cool. When did that happen?
It was in _Man_of_Steel_ during Mark Schultz's run. But we never found out
why Zeus hates Rao . . . new creative team, idea dropped, yada yada.
-Mark
It came to me right after I've made the post. By then, someone else had
already mentioned it, so my adding it would be redundant.
Arnold Kim
That's not my interpretation of the Centauri. The Centauri are
polytheistic -- worshiping many gods -- rather than poly-religious --
having multiple religions. In a polytheistic society there may be a
hierarchy of gods, and people may pray to specific gods, but the
belief is in _all_ of the gods. In ancient Rome there weren't battles
between believers in Jupiter and Apollo over which was the "true"
faith. (In fact the Romans were notorious for adopting various gods
as circumstances demanded. The hierarchy of gods that _we_ think of
as the Roman gods were in fact borrowed entirely from the Greeks while
the original Roman religion tended to focus on household deities.)
This is significantly different from the acceptance of diversity
exhibited by the humans which allowed for different interpretations of
divinity, both monotheistic and polytheistic, to co-exist with limited
friction.
--
Brent McKee
To reply by email, please remove the capital letters (S and N) from
the email address
"If we cease to judge this world, we may find ourselves, very quickly,
in one which is infinitely worse."
- Margaret Atwood
"Nothing is more dangerous than a dogmatic worldview - nothing more
constraining, more blinding to innovation, more destructive of
openness to novelty. "
- Stephen Jay Gould (1941-2002)
But I think the question is "did he die only for the sins of Earth people?"
Given that many people think Jesus is specific to only their particular
faith, including one particular group in the US that actually has a number!
Given that Earth mythology/heaven/afterlife/gods/mystical realm is often
portrayed in DC as specific to the particular planet that you are on. Even
the Hosts of Heaven and God seem to be specific to Earth. Lobo's adventures
being the exception.
In the modern age they have effectively bound all the most powerful
characters to Earth. Superman used to roam the Universe, as did the JLA and
at times the Spectre. Now they are boxed in as effectivle as the GA Superman
in his "better place".
--
"There is right and wrong in the Universe and it is not too hard to tell the
difference"
Michael Wood
Reply to: BLOCKm...@hotmail.com (remove BLOCK to reply)
The entire JLA went to heaven, purgatory (limbo?) and hell in a story
arc--but natch, there were no lasting impact on them or society.
-- Ken from Chicago
Also, I think Matt "Daredevil" Murdock is Catholic. He's always hanging
around cathedrals.
-- Ken from Chicago
> >> Shamanism? Is that a word?
>
> >Yes.
>
> But it's more a thing you do, isn't it, not a belief.
Not really, according to my dictionary, it's a belief system from Northern
Asia that accepts that the world is pervaded by good and evil spirits which
can only be controlled or influenced by the shamans, or any similar religion
involving forms of spiritualism.
> The thread topic plus your B5 quote combine to remind me of the
> "What is Earth's religion?" episode (pre-Sheridan), in which we find out
> that Earth is apparently unique among the galactic civilizations in not
> having a single religion shared by all Terrans.
Though there's also an episode of "Alien Nation" where Sykes assumes that
the Newcomers are all the same religion (Worshippers of Seleen and Endarko
like George and his family), and one of the Newcomers asks "Why should we
be? Humans certainly aren't"
Terry Pratchett discusses in "Carpe Jugulum" what sort of true, insightful
religion is it that _can't_ inspire it's members like that, and is it worth
the having if it can't?
As we find out, the world probably isn't ready for a Granny Weatherwax who
has found religion, and Nanny Ogg has, in the words of one god "An approach
to showing respect to her deity which would make an aetheist green with
envy"
>On a related side note: I'm amazed at how few characters/heroes have
>been motivated by their faith especially a Christian faith. One of
>the main tenents of the Christian faith is loving and helping others.
>Since heroes do that (help others) I would think more would have the
>"why do they do what they do" being part their faith. Also,as a
>Christian, one of the things we are taught is we all have "talents" or
>gifts from God, and what we do with those talents is our gift back to
>God. I would think some "heroes" would use their super powered gifts
>as gifts back to God.
The impression I get of Superman (most notably in the Kismet story following
the Blaze/Satanus War) is that he *is* motivated at least partly by religious
faith (at least inasmuch as that's part of being "raised right" in Kansas), he
just doesn't talk about it much.
But yeah, it is odd that out of the three most noticably Christian superheroes
(Nightcrawler, Daredevil and Huntress) one is motivated largely by circumstance
(being a mutant) and the other two began their careers seeking revenge.
--
Dave
The Official Absentee of EU Skiffeysoc
http://www.eusa.ed.ac.uk/societies/sesoc
Four-and-twenty Lib Dems came down from Inverness,
And when the vote was counted there were four-and-twenty less.
-Rory Bremner, 7/3/04
>> >Yes.
Ah - I thought that was Animism.
Animism would seem to be the belief that natural objects, phenomena and the
universe itself have desires and intentions.
So Shamanism is that there are objects and spirits, Animism seems to be that
there are spirits within the objects themselves.
I imagine the actual difference is greater and more subtle than that though.
A Thor cult? Why just one? I´m sure it was american!
The neonazis would be delighted to know Thor existied(at least until he
noticed them), has anyone ever written anything about that?
Then we have the existing pagans and new age believers.
Then there is most of the population in the scandinavian countries who
never was interested in Jesus anyway. It´s less than a hundred years ago
that people stopped believing in Näcken,skogsrån and trolls.
Christmas is just Midwinter feast with a few amens slapped on to it, the
important thing is the pig meat!
And we still celebrate midsummer with maypoles(the english mixed things
up it should be mayfire and midsummerpole) and all.
So if Tor just showed up we would turn back instantly,also the weather
is a big deal to us scandinavians:-)
Wasn´t Thors original mission in Midgard to learn humility and gain
belief?
Then why go to USA when you have the whole northern europe waiting for
your comeback?
Not to mention what would happen if Thor actually meet Zeus for real:-)
Gods as superheroes is an interesting concept to bad that no one
actually uses it.
Marvel should let a scandinavian write Thor sometime.
But Oeming sounds very good he has done his research, I just hope he
doesn´t use shakespeak!
"I wish I didn´t have to wear these absurd scraps of cloth" Storm in X-men#109
"Always remember, there is this man with a typewriter." Deadpool
>
> I haven't been following this thread closely, but someone surely has
> mentioned Zauriel, who was an angel of the Heavenly Host.
True, but it doesn't follow that he's Christian or even religious in any
way that's meaningful to regular people. I see Zauriel the same way as
gods. He's the subject of the religion, but not part of it.
Same here in Scotland (or rather the kelpie, the Sidhe and trow). OTOH, most of
the Scots folk who believed in this stuff would have considered themselves good
Christians. The minister might disagree, but if you were going to live your
life by what a Scottish minister said, you'd never do *anything* 8-).
>Christmas is just Midwinter feast with a few amens slapped on to it, the
>important thing is the pig meat!
Ah, Hogswatchnight 8-).
>And we still celebrate midsummer with maypoles(the english mixed things
>up it should be mayfire and midsummerpole) and all.
>So if Tor just showed up we would turn back instantly,also the weather
>is a big deal to us scandinavians:-)
>Wasn´t Thors original mission in Midgard to learn humility and gain
>belief?
>Then why go to USA when you have the whole northern europe waiting for
>your comeback?
I'm not sure it was to gain belief, but it was certainly to learn humility.
Going to a country where you'll be worshipped seems like a bad idea in this
situation 8-)...
> A Thor cult? Why just one? I´m sure it was american!
....
> Then why go to USA when you have the whole northern europe waiting
> for your comeback?
For starters, because the USA are richer and more powerful than
Northern Europe. But *would* Northern Europe wait for Thor? I was
under the impression that they were get as post-Christian as Germany
and other Middle European countries.
>Dan <dan.t...@tiscali.se> writes:
>
>> A Thor cult? Why just one? I惴 sure it was american!
> ....
>
>> Then why go to USA when you have the whole northern europe waiting
>> for your comeback?
>
>
>For starters, because the USA are richer and more powerful than
>Northern Europe.
Which means that the resistance is more powerful there.
Christians was less welcome in Rome than anywhere else.
> But *would* Northern Europe wait for Thor? I was
>under the impression that they were get as post-Christian as Germany
>and other Middle European countries.
By post-Christian do you mean secular? Sure, we are secular, in fact we
was among the first to have a secular society. However belief in
"something" is like 80%. If Thor showed up he could be that "something".
The difference is that we got christianity for tax reasons, not because
the people believed in it. It never real took hold here.
"I wish I didn愒 have to wear these absurd scraps of cloth" Storm in X-men#109
Leanan Sidhe seems to be closest to skogsrå.(Skogsrå was a beautiful
female wood spirit with cowtail and hollow or bark covered back, she
lured woodsmen and charcoalburners to run after her deeper into the
woods so they got lost and died from exhaustion, there is also many
tales about those who got away)
>the Scots folk who believed in this stuff would have considered themselves good
>Christians. The minister might disagree, but if you were going to live your
>life by what a Scottish minister said, you'd never do *anything* 8-).
>
>>Christmas is just Midwinter feast with a few amens slapped on to it, the
>>important thing is the pig meat!
>
>Ah, Hogswatchnight 8-).
>
>>And we still celebrate midsummer with maypoles(the english mixed things
>>up it should be mayfire and midsummerpole) and all.
>>So if Tor just showed up we would turn back instantly,also the weather
>>is a big deal to us scandinavians:-)
>>Wasn´t Thors original mission in Midgard to learn humility and gain
>>belief?
>>Then why go to USA when you have the whole northern europe waiting for
>>your comeback?
>
>I'm not sure it was to gain belief, but it was certainly to learn humility.
Maybe that was from Earth X then.
>Going to a country where you'll be worshipped seems like a bad idea in this
>situation 8-)...
The Ultimates earth seems much more likely:-)
But Thor is has passed that humility lesson now.
> On 25 Apr 2004 15:12:19 +0200, Peter Bruells <p...@ecce-terram.de> wrote:
>
> >Dan <dan.t...@tiscali.se> writes:
> >
> >> A Thor cult? Why just one? I´m sure it was american!
> > ....
> >
> >> Then why go to USA when you have the whole northern europe waiting
> >> for your comeback?
> >
> >
>> For starters, because the USA are richer and more powerful than
>> Northern Europe.
> Which means that the resistance is more powerful there.
Okay..
> By post-Christian do you mean secular?
The secularity of nations who were Christian, took part in Enlightment
and share values with Christianity w/out believing in God, partly
keeping the trappings
> Sure, we are secular, in fact we was among the first to have a
> secular society. However belief in "something" is like 80%. If Thor
> showed up he could be that "something". The difference is that we
> got christianity for tax reasons, not because the people believed in
> it. It never real took hold here.
Really? I was under the impression that Swedish Lutherans were quite
willing to bringe their take on Christianity on German
Catholics. Stats tell me that 86% percent of the population are stil
protestant, while in Germany catholics and protestants combined barely
reach 65%. And didnt you drop the state religion until 2000?
Johnny
> On a related side note: I'm amazed at how few characters/heroes have
> been motivated by their faith especially a Christian faith. One of
> the main tenents of the Christian faith is loving and helping others.
> Since heroes do that (help others)
In the Artemis:Requiem miniseries, there was a temporary group of temporary
heroes who called themselves the Hellenders, IIRC. They seemed to be on
some kind of religious mission to fight demons. I seem to remember that at
some point in the story they had to duck into a church and fetch some holy
water. Not sure if this constitutes "motivated by the Christian faith," but
it seemed something.
There was a nicely done Christian supergroup in "Astro City" in the
Confessor storyline. For that matter, the original Confessor was a
Christian vampire who mortified his flesh with Christian symbols to keep his
evil urges at bay. He ended up staked in the story but his sidekick carried
on his legacy.
--
Wenn Prinz Adam sein Zauberschwert in die Luft streckt und die Zauberformel:
"Bei der Macht von Grayskull!" ausruft, verwandelt er sich in He-Man, den
stärksten Mann des Universums.