Small bug worth a minor version

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Darázs Attila

unread,
Sep 2, 2010, 7:58:25 AM9/2/10
to OpenLoopz
Make the following check, before displaying an action in a context on
the main screen:
IF action.has_parent AND action.is_nextaction: SHOW action

In the current version, this is not checked, and all the actions in a
project are listed in the contexts although they are not actionable at
the moment (because there are required steps in a project before
them).

This would make the project aspect of OpenLoopz usable for me (and I
guess for others too).

Hope this helps, eagerly waiting for a fix! :)

--Attila

Attila Darazs

unread,
Sep 19, 2010, 7:27:46 AM9/19/10
to OpenLoopz
I found out after some tinkering in the settings, that if I enable
Show next actions only, and mark every single task "Next Action", then
I can get something similar to the desired result. Pretty
inconvenient, but at least it works.

Dying to get a fix version for this and the "projects don't set the
new next actions" bug.

Attila

Paul Drummond

unread,
Sep 22, 2010, 12:33:16 PM9/22/10
to open...@googlegroups.com
Hi Attila,

Sorry for the inconvenience - I know a new bug-fix release is long overdue but OpenLoopz Web is taking up all my time at the moment. I will hopefully find time to fix these bugs soon.

Regards,
Paul Drummond

Paul Drummond

unread,
Jan 13, 2011, 5:37:41 PM1/13/11
to open...@googlegroups.com
Hi Attila,

So I am finally getting round to looking at this but I am not sure I understand the problem properly. 

Lets say I have three actions (A, B and C) assigned to the "At Home" location context and I am currently at home.  A is the Next Action.

When I look at my home screen I only see Action A under "Next Actions" - the other actions will only be shown if they are Next Actions too.

Note that this behaviour assumes the "Show sub actions" setting is NOT ticked.

Regards,
Paul Drummond

Attila Darazs

unread,
Jan 14, 2011, 5:38:19 AM1/14/11
to OpenLoopz
I understand what you're saying, but don't you think that it's much
more usable to have my actions separated in contexts on the home
screen than to have them in a "Next Action" context, regardless of
context!

The problem:
- there are a bunch of tasks in my next action contexts, that are *not
actionable* by me *at the current place*, because next actions context
disregard location contexts, and
- there are another bunch of actions in different contexts that are
*not actionable* by me *at the current time* because they are not next
actions in a project.

So basically you have two messed up list where there are a lot of
actions that is not actionable. And as I understand, the goal of this
program would be to display me a home screen that has only and all the
actionable actions at the current place and time, making life easier.

However the current implementation can even lead to DEATH! A simple
explanation follows (neither "Show Next Actions Only" and "Show sub
actions" is checked):

Let's assume I have a location context called "OnThePlane", and
(ignore that planes move, so it can't really be a location context,
for the sake of drama).

I add an action "Put on parachute" to a project called "Sky diving"
and mark it as "OnThePlane" and "Next Action".
Next, I add another action to "Sky diving", called "Jump off
airplane", and mark it as "OnThePlane" too.

Now there are too scenarios. First I check my "Next Action" list when
I wake up in the morning and see "Put on parachute". My brain is still
foggy from waking up, but I do as it says. I go to wash my teeth,
check my next actions again, and see (if next actions automatic
selection would work, which don't at the moment, of course) that I
should jump of some airplane, but I'm not on one.

Second scenarios is that I get on an airplane, the context
"OnThePlane" comes up. I have a lot of actions on a plane, so I
randomly grab one, not really caring whether there's a small (Next) to
one or not, because there could be actions without projects too, that
doesn't have (Next) behind them. So I happen to choose "Jump of
airplane" before "Put on parachute" and I plummet to my death.

Poor me. RIP:
--Attila

Paul Drummond

unread,
Jan 19, 2011, 9:16:43 AM1/19/11
to open...@googlegroups.com
Ah, I understand what you are asking for now - thanks for the detailed
and humorous example ;-)

I have looked into providing a solution but unfortunately it won't be
feasible to provide a fix for the current 1.6.x. We are looking to
provide a more streamlined home screen for OpenLoopz 2.x which should
solve the problem or at least provide an alternative solution. More
details to come when OpenLoopz 2 is officially announced.

Regards,
Paul Drummond

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages