417,000 cancers forecast for
Fukushima 200 km contamination zone by 2061
Scientific Secretary of the European Committee on Radiation Risk (ECRR), Professor Chris Busby, has released calculations of the cancer incidence to be expected in fallout areas of Japan. Using data from the International Atomic Energy Agency and official Japanese web sites he has used two methods to estimate the numbers of cancer cases. He compares these results with estimates derived from ICRP modelling.
The "Tondel" Method is
based on a conservative study by Martin Tondel in northern
Sweden. This examined cancer incidence during 10 years after
Chernobyl. It differentiated the varying levels of land
contamination and found that the disease increased by 11% for
each 100 kiloBecquerels of fallout per square metre of land
surface. Professor Busby has applied this factor to the zone
up to 100 km from the reactors, where IAEA has reported, on
average, 600kBq per sq.m radioactivity. In the 3.3 million
population of this 100 km zone a 66% increase over and above
the pre-accident rate is predicted in 10 years. This implies
103,329 extra cancers due to the Fukushima exposures between
2012 and 2021.
Similarly applying the "Tondel" method to the ring between 100
km and 200 km from Fukushima (population 7.8 million but lower
concentrations of fallout) 120,894 extra cancers are to be
expected by 2021.
Assuming permanent residence and no evacuation the total predicted yield according to the "Tondel" method is thus 224,223 in ten years.
The second method is
derived from weighting factors advised by the ECRR on the
basis of the different ways in which different radionuclides
behave in biological systems. This predicts 191,986 extra
cancers in the 0 - 100km circle and 224,623 in the outer ring.
Probably half of these will be expressed in the first ten
years and the remainder between 10 and 50 years.
Assuming permanent residence and no evacuation the total
predicted yield according to the second method will be 416,619
of which 208,310 will appear in the first ten years. There is
thus good agreement between the two methods.
The ICRP method predicts 6158 additional cancers in 50 years which, among the 2½ million cancer cases expected normally in that population over half a century, would be invisible and deniable.
The report with all methods, assumptions and data is a pdf linked from the front page.
Professor Chris Busby on Russia Today
Professor Busby deconstructs media favourites Wade Allison, George Monbiot and other "experts". An acknowledgement about Dr. Richard Wakeford is included.