But the Thames-Clyde Express left from St Pancras.
Tim
IIRC part of the story is that the hero, Richard Hannay, leaves the
train whilst it is on the Forth Bridge. An AFIK, the Thames-Clyde
Express did not cross the Forth.
It's St Pancras in the book.
--
Arthur Figgis Surrey, UK
~~~~
Didn't the Waverley get quite close?
Ken Ward.
I've not seen the film(s), but the Forth Bridge doesn't feature in the
book, which is set in Galloway. However an advertising poster recently
on display at my local station would suggest LNER locos and the Forth
Bridge do appear in a recent stage version of it.
The Kenneth More version (mid 50s) had the Forth bridge scene in, not sure
about the earlier version.
--
Graeme Wall
This address not read, substitute trains for rail
Transport Miscellany at <www.greywall.demon.co.uk/rail>
At least 3, 30s, don't know who played the lead, 50s with Kenneth More and 90s(?) with Robert Powell.
> At least 3, 30s, don't know who played the lead, 50s with Kenneth More and
> 90s(?) with Robert Powell.
Robert Donat, 1935...
Paul
And in the book he does leave from St Pancras.
E.
As Mr Figgis says, the Forth Bridge doesn't feature in the book (though
there are 3 films and a recent TV adaptation - by coincidence, the Donat
version was broadcast last night). That was Hitchcock's idea. In the
book, Hannay changes trains at Dumfries, He had a ticket to Newton
Stewart, but the manner of his leaving the second train is described
thus:
"About five o'clock the carriage had emptied, and I was left alone as I
had hoped. I got out at the next station, a little place whose name I
scarcely noted, set right in the heart of a bog. It reminded me of one
of those forgotten little stations in the Karroo. An old stationmaster
was digging in his garden, and with his spade over his shoulder
sauntered to the train, took charge of a parcel and went back to his
potatoes. A child of ten received my ticket, and I emerged on a white
road that straggled over the brown moor."
--
http://gallery120232.fotopic.net/p9683810.html
(155 345 at Manchester Victoria, 13 Oct 2000)
For God's sake, it's a Hitchcock classic! and a railway classic.
And Glasgow trains still leave from Euston.
--
As through this world I've rambled, I've met plenty of funny men,
Some rob you with a sixgun, some with a fountain pen.
Woody Guthrie
At that time, competing trains departed for Scotland from Kings Cross
(for the Great Northern Railway/North Eastern Railway/North British
Railway services, primarily to Edinburgh and the East Coast via Berwick)
from St Pancras (for Midland Railway services via Carlisle) and from
Euston (for London & North Western Railway services via Carlisle).
Much of the action of the original novel takes place in the wilds of
Galloway in south-west Scotland, served by the Glasgow and South Western
Railway. This railway had a strong relationship with the Midland
Railway, thus someone heading to Galloway _would_ have left London from
St Pancras.
In any film that was true to the book, the Forth Bridge wouldn't appear
at all, because this is considerably to the north and east of Galloway,
just west of Edinburgh on the North British Railway.
--
Jeremy Double <jmd.n...@btinternet.com> {real address, include nospam}
Rail and transport photos at
http://www.flickr.com/photos/jmdouble/collections/72157603834894248/
Presumably it is a very large stage.
"Chris Tolley" <cj.t...@bogus.co.uk (ukonline really)> wrote
>
> "About five o'clock the carriage had emptied, and I was left alone as I
> had hoped. I got out at the next station, a little place whose name I
> scarcely noted, set right in the heart of a bog. It reminded me of one
> of those forgotten little stations in the Karroo. An old stationmaster
> was digging in his garden, and with his spade over his shoulder
> sauntered to the train, took charge of a parcel and went back to his
> potatoes. A child of ten received my ticket, and I emerged on a white
> road that straggled over the brown moor."
>
Buchan could have had in mind Gatehouse-of-Fleet station, which was 7 miles
from the small town after which it was named - in the period before closure
only 3 trains per week (all down trains)were shown in the public timetable
as calling. Or possibly Loch Skerrow, a crossing loop and unadvertised
halt - but this didn't have any road access.
http://www.railbrit.co.uk/Portpatrick_Railway/frame.htm
Peter
>
>
> "Chris Tolley" <cj.t...@bogus.co.uk (ukonline really)> wrote
> >
> > "About five o'clock the carriage had emptied, and I was left alone as I
> > had hoped. I got out at the next station, a little place whose name I
> > scarcely noted, set right in the heart of a bog. It reminded me of one of
> > those forgotten little stations in the Karroo. An old stationmaster was
> > digging in his garden, and with his spade over his shoulder sauntered to
> > the train, took charge of a parcel and went back to his potatoes. A child
> > of ten received my ticket, and I emerged on a white road that straggled
> > over the brown moor."
> >
> Buchan could have had in mind Gatehouse-of-Fleet station, which was 7 miles
> from the small town after which it was named
A colleague of mine bought the station as a holiday cottage. He always
claimed it was the one Buchan referred to.
Interesting. Is there any way of knowing if any of the trains in, say,
1913, were due to call at around 5pm?
--
http://gallery120232.fotopic.net/p9632870.html
(33 103 at Southampton Central, 13 May 1985)
>Interesting. Is there any way of knowing if any of the trains in, say,
>1913, were due to call at around 5pm?
According to my 1929 Bradshaw (a few years later than 1913, of course),
the 2.35pm from Dumfries stopped at Gatehouse of Fleet at 4.12pm on
weekdays (one of only three trains a day to do so).
--
Paul Terry
1914. Scudder was killed late on May 23rd, all the action is in less
than a month, and the final paragraph opens "Seven weeks later, ..., we
went to war." That was 4th August 1914, so the /Ariadne/ was taken
*about* June 16th. That agrees with the death of Karolides late on June
15th, pitting the taking on the 17th I think.
--
(c) John Stockton, Surrey, UK. ?@merlyn.demon.co.uk Turnpike v6.05 MIME.
Web <URL:http://www.merlyn.demon.co.uk/> - FAQish topics, acronyms, & links.
Proper <= 4-line sig. separator as above, a line exactly "-- " (SonOfRFC1036)
Do not Mail News to me. Before a reply, quote with ">" or "> " (SonOfRFC1036)
In 1910 it was also an arrival at 4.12pm [the station then was named
Dromore]
Or this
<http://www.visitsouthwestscotland.com/attractioninfo.asp?attractID=5>
referred to in an earlier thread.
Sam