divided mortgage interest deduction

[Grip]

Hi All,

I recently learned that my mother in law is having tax issues. I have
her convinced to see a professional but it's going to take a few weeks
(she's visiting on vacation).

She lives in her own home with a mild mortgage in Maryland. Five years
ago, she jointly (1/3 share) bought a second home in West Virginia.
She owns it with her nephew and his wife. The each may spend a month
there a year total. All three are on the title (Tenants in Common, I
think) and all are on the mortgage. The WV house is never rented out.

For the past five years, she has been writing a check to the couple
for her share of the mortgage payment. She has been deducting the 1/3
prorated amount of the interest on the cabin (as well as the regular
mortgage) from her taxes. Her nephew has been claiming their 2/3 share
on his taxes.

The IRS is calling foul and saying the deductions aren't documented
enough. She doesn't have more detail than that and the paperwork isn't
accessible for a couple weeks. She wouldn't say outright, but I think
she's been told she's on the hook for $15K including penalties, etc.

Any perspective of how much trouble mom-in-law is in?

Thanks,
G

--
<< ------------------------------------------------------- >>
<< The foregoing was not intended or written to be used, >>
<< nor can it used, for the purpose of avoiding penalties >>
<< that may be imposed upon the taxpayer. >>
<< >>
<< The Charter and the Guidelines for submitting posts >>
<< to this newsgroup as well as our anti-spamming policy >>
<< are at www.asktax.org. >>
<< Copyright (2011) - All rights reserved. >>
<< ------------------------------------------------------- >>

[ira smilovitz]

On Thursday, February 9, 2012 10:12:32 AM UTC-5, Grip wrote:
> Hi All,
>
> I recently learned that my mother in law is having tax issues. I have
> her convinced to see a professional but it's going to take a few weeks
> (she's visiting on vacation).
>
> She lives in her own home with a mild mortgage in Maryland. Five years
> ago, she jointly (1/3 share) bought a second home in West Virginia.
> She owns it with her nephew and his wife. The each may spend a month
> there a year total. All three are on the title (Tenants in Common, I
> think) and all are on the mortgage. The WV house is never rented out.
>
> For the past five years, she has been writing a check to the couple
> for her share of the mortgage payment. She has been deducting the 1/3
> prorated amount of the interest on the cabin (as well as the regular
> mortgage) from her taxes. Her nephew has been claiming their 2/3 share
> on his taxes.
>
> The IRS is calling foul and saying the deductions aren't documented
> enough. She doesn't have more detail than that and the paperwork isn't
> accessible for a couple weeks. She wouldn't say outright, but I think
> she's been told she's on the hook for $15K including penalties, etc.
>
> Any perspective of how much trouble mom-in-law is in?
>
> Thanks,
> G

It's possible the issue arose because she entered the mortgage interest on the wrong line of Schedule A. She should have used line 11 and not line 10.

If the facts are as you presented them, she doesn't have a problem. All she needs to do is show that her name is on the deed and mortgage and document that her payments to the nephew and wife equal 1/3 of the payments made for the mortgage.

Ira Smilovitz
Leonia, NJ

[Gene E. Utterback, EA, ABA]

>"Grip" wrote in message
>news:d087a898-28c6-45dd...@y10g2000vbn.googlegroups.com...

>
>Hi All,
>
>I recently learned that my mother in law is having tax issues. I have
>her convinced to see a professional but it's going to take a few weeks

>she's visiting on vacation).

>
>he lives in her own home with a mild mortgage in Maryland. Five years

>go, she jointly (1/3 share) bought a second home in West Virginia.

>he owns it with her nephew and his wife. The each may spend a month

>here a year total. All three are on the title (Tenants in Common, I

>hink) and all are on the mortgage. The WV house is never rented out.
>
>For the past five years, she has been writing a check to the couple
>for her share of the mortgage payment. She has been deducting the 1/3
>prorated amount of the interest on the cabin (as well as the regular
>mortgage) from her taxes. Her nephew has been claiming their 2/3 share
>on his taxes.
>
>The IRS is calling foul and saying the deductions aren't documented
>enough. She doesn't have more detail than that and the paperwork isn't
>accessible for a couple weeks. She wouldn't say outright, but I think
>she's been told she's on the hook for $15K including penalties, etc.
>
>Any perspective of how much trouble mom-in-law is in?
>
>Thanks,
>G

She shouldn’t be in any trouble. In order to deduct mortgage interest on
your main and second home you need to meet 2 conditions - 1) You have to
have a legal obligation to pay the mortgage; and 2) you have to actually
have paid the mortgage. So for example, if my brother and I owned a home
jointly but he paid all the mortgage payments and I took care of all the
yard and housework, HE could deduct the mortgage interest but I could not -
because I didn't pay anything.

In your situation the IRS is being obtuse (likely because of the economy and
their need to collect as much as they however they can). But as long as she
can document that she paid her share you should be fine. Though you may
need to take this case to appeals to get it resolved.

Without actually seeing the IRS notice I cannot give you exact advice, BUT I
would recommend that you respond to the IRS and tell them that she is on the
mortgage and has paid her share. You may also want to take a look at the
rules for filing a claim for costs due to an unreasonable delay for two
reasons. First, you have to notify the IRS that you may seek costs,
secondly - this usually get the attention of a supervisor which can help
resolve the case quicker.