Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

How much have the "401(k) plan" and IRA scheme contribute to the bull market gain of 1982-2000?

0 views
Skip to first unread message

je12j...@yahoo.com

unread,
Dec 8, 2008, 9:03:30 PM12/8/08
to
What is the rationale behind "10% penalty" if pulling money out of 401
(K) or IRA before 59-1/2 years old?

People can only put money into buy stocks, but not pull money out
until 59-1/2, with false assumptions that
(1) Future tax rates will always be lower than what is now
(2) Past performance of 70 years of stock market is the ballpark
numbers of future results
(3) "Investing" returns can always compound - what if the best
approach is putting money in money market fund inside 401(k)?
(4) Long-term investment (30-50 years) is always a gain

Rod Speed

unread,
Dec 10, 2008, 1:18:23 PM12/10/08
to
je12j...@yahoo.com wrote

> What is the rationale behind "10% penalty" if pulling money out of 401 (K) or IRA before 59-1/2 years old?

Its done that way to discourage people from taking their money out of retirement accounts.

> People can only put money into buy stocks, but not pull money out until 59-1/2,

They can however have the money in CDs or treasurys etc.

> with false assumptions that
> (1) Future tax rates will always be lower than what is now
> (2) Past performance of 70 years of stock market is the ballpark numbers of future results

You arent required to have that money in stockes.

> (3) "Investing" returns can always compound - what if the best
> approach is putting money in money market fund inside 401(k)?
> (4) Long-term investment (30-50 years) is always a gain

That isnt a false assumption.


0 new messages