Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Older metal windows won't close

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Kompu Kid

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 10:33:33 AM10/8/08
to
Hello All:

Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
buildup did not help.

I have photos of the windows at:

http://cid-eb85de77506ba8ba.spaces.live.com/photos/cns!EB85DE77506BA8BA!108/

I think the windows are slightly warped over time --this is a 60-year-
old home. I am thinking that if he can replace the pins in hinges (one
of the hinges is marked with "B") with a smaller diameter one, the
"A" side of the window would be slightly pushed out, and the "D" edge
then would get to touch the mating frame (it now stands 1/4" or so
away).

Alternately if the lateral edges can be bent inwards a bit this would
also get the Edge D closer. But I cannot think of an easy way of
bending these edges in a controlled manner, and without breaking the
glass...

Any recommendations?

Thanks!

Deguza

Norminn

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 11:25:03 AM10/8/08
to
Kompu Kid wrote:

Can you remove the brace at the bottom of the window? Looks like it
also has heavy paint
build-up ...... hard telling from here, but if the brace has thick paint
on it, it might be pushing
on the hinge when it closes. As for bending the frame, take out the
glass, bend, replace
glass. Have you used a straight-edge to make sure only one edge of the
frame is not straight?
Glass shouldn't bend much, so perhaps the mating edge against "D" is
also warped (with,
perhaps, too much weight from above?). Perhaps the framing is warped
from too much
wind against the open window over time?

mkir...@rochester.rr.com

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 11:26:22 AM10/8/08
to
Kompu Kid wrote:
> Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
> substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
> thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> buildup did not help.

> Any recommendations?

Sadly, the only real solution is to replace them, or leave them shut.

My last apartment had those crappy aluminum casement windows.

Kompu Kid

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 12:03:21 PM10/8/08
to
On Oct 8, 8:25 am, Norminn <norm...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> Kompu Kid wrote:
> >Hello All:
>
> >Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
> >substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
> >thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> >buildup did not help.
>
> >I have photos of the windows at:
>
> >http://cid-eb85de77506ba8ba.spaces.live.com/photos/cns!EB85DE77506BA8...

We did remove the arm at one point but it was not blocking anything.
This arm opens and closes the window when the crank handle is rotated.

Deguza

Kompu Kid

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 12:07:30 PM10/8/08
to

Wish these were aluminum, it would be easy to bend them. These are
steel.

Deguza

Lou

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 12:47:22 PM10/8/08
to

"Kompu Kid" <deg...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:9b7a31d6-c5b0-4934...@i18g2000prf.googlegroups.com...

> Hello All:
>
> Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
> substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
> thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> buildup did not help.
>
> I have photos of the windows at:
>
> http://cid-eb85de77506ba8ba.spaces.live.com/photos/cns!EB85DE77506BA8BA!108/
>
> I think the windows are slightly warped over time --this is a 60-year-
> old home. I am thinking that if he can replace the pins in hinges (one
> of the hinges is marked with "B") with a smaller diameter one, the
> "A" side of the window would be slightly pushed out, and the "D" edge
> then would get to touch the mating frame (it now stands 1/4" or so
> away).

The title of this post is "Older metal windows won't close" - it's not
obvious from the pictures that the window frames are metal. You don't say
what the metal is, but I'll bet it's aluminum.

I doubt that the aluminum and glass have warped on their own. More likely,
in my estimation, is that the house has settled since the windows where
installed, and the dimensions/orientation of the frame have changed over the
years.

Possibly, taking the windows off the house entirely, and reinstalling them
as though they were new (shiming and sawing as needed), would fix the
problem - unless of course, the house continues to settle.

Kompu Kid

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 1:13:19 PM10/8/08
to
On Oct 8, 9:47 am, "Lou" <lpog...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> "Kompu Kid" <deg...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
>
> news:9b7a31d6-c5b0-4934...@i18g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
>
>
>
> > Hello All:
>
> > Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
> > substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
> > thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> > buildup did not help.
>
> > I have photos of the windows at:
>
> >http://cid-eb85de77506ba8ba.spaces.live.com/photos/cns!EB85DE77506BA8...

>
> > I think the windows are slightly warped over time --this is a 60-year-
> > old home. I am thinking that if he can replace the pins in hinges (one
> > of the hinges is marked with "B") with a smaller diameter one, the
> > "A" side of the window would be slightly pushed out, and the "D" edge
> > then would get to touch the mating frame (it now stands 1/4" or so
> > away).
>
> The title of this post is "Older metal windows won't close" - it's not
> obvious from the pictures that the window frames are metal.  You don't say
> what the metal is, but I'll bet it's aluminum.
>
> I doubt that the aluminum and glass have warped on their own.  More likely,
> in my estimation, is that the house has settled since the windows where
> installed, and the dimensions/orientation of the frame have changed over the
> years.
>
> Possibly, taking the windows off the house entirely, and reinstalling them
> as though they were new (shiming and sawing as needed), would fix the
> problem - unless of course, the house continues to settle.
>
> > Alternately if the lateral edges can be bent inwards a bit this would
> > also get the Edge D closer. But I cannot think of an easy way of
> > bending these edges in a controlled manner, and without breaking the
> > glass...
>
> > Any recommendations?
>
> > Thanks!
>
> > Deguza

They are steel windows. And I think you are right about the cause. I
also think that removing and reinstalling the windows can help.
However, this is beyond my and the nephew's skill set... Having some
else do it would be costly--this is the first home nephew got, and he
does not have much funds left to hire someone.

What do you think of putting slightly undersized pins at the hinges--
say 10 or 20 mil smaller in diameter? This would make the Edge A go
out slightly, which in turn should get Edge D closer to the window
frame when closing.

Deguza

Al Bundy

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 3:03:46 PM10/8/08
to
On Oct 8, 10:33 am, Kompu Kid <deg...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> Hello All:
>
> Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
> substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
> thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> buildup did not help.
>
> I have photos of the windows at:
>
> http://cid-eb85de77506ba8ba.spaces.live.com/photos/cns!EB85DE77506BA8...

>
> I think the windows are slightly warped over time --this is a 60-year-
> old home. I am thinking that if he can replace the pins in hinges (one
> of the hinges is marked with "B") with a smaller diameter one, the
> "A" side of the window would be slightly pushed out, and the "D" edge
> then would get to touch the mating frame (it now stands 1/4" or so
> away).
>
> Alternately if the lateral edges can be bent inwards a bit this would
> also get the Edge D closer. But I cannot think of an easy way of
> bending these edges in a controlled manner, and without breaking the
> glass...
>
> Any recommendations?
>
> Thanks!
>
> Deguza

Clearly nothing is warped because it is steel. Changing to smaller
pins will only make the window sloppy. The opportunity to move the
window that way is very minimal. The window is not moving to the left
as it should when cranked in. Assuming all the edges are clean of
paint as you say, I believe those main brackets that mount to the
house or frame are either bent or out of adjustment. If you can clean
all the paint off where they mount, you may see slots that have
gradually allowed the window to fall out of the original mounting
position. Clean everything up and remount it properly. Check similar
windows on the house to compare measurements of the distance from the
bracket to the closing edge.

SteveBell

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 6:20:24 PM10/8/08
to
Kompu Kid wrote:

These old casement windows have a tendency to hang up. The gears in the
mechanism get a little worn, the hinges get a little dirty, and the
whole thing gets balky. One symptom of a worn mechanism is that the
window has lots of play--you can move it in and out with your hand
without turning the crank. The window shouldn't move more than half an
inch this way.

Others have recommended cleaning off the paint. I concur. The
mechanisms should never have been painted, but everyone does it for
some reason.

My recommendation: Replace the mechanism, assuming they're worn. You'll
have to hunt for the hardware.

--
Steve Bell
New Life Home Improvement
Arlington, TX

Big Al

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 8:03:31 PM10/8/08
to

"SteveBell" <res...@online.newsgroup.invalid> wrote in message
news:xn0fw6qm...@news.motzarella.org...


If these are common windows in his neighborhood, the local hardware stores
should have parts. Have a rental house with them and even the Home Depot and
True Value in the neighborhood have parts for the windows.

Guy I know has these windows. He cut off all the brackets and had new
sliding double pane windows made that fit into the old frame. In his house
the frame were buily into the brick. Would have been a mess to get them out
completely.

Al


Lou

unread,
Oct 8, 2008, 8:50:02 PM10/8/08
to

I didn't think it would be cheap to hire someone else. On the contrary,
I think it would probably be expensive enough to warrant buying new
windows and having them installed properly.

> What do you think of putting slightly undersized pins at the hinges--
> say 10 or 20 mil smaller in diameter? This would make the Edge A go
> out slightly, which in turn should get Edge D closer to the window
> frame when closing.

I don't know - I'm far from an expert and can't tell from your pictures.
I don't think it would be all that hard to try it, though.

You say this is a first home - if nephew doesn't have the money to fix
it properly as yet and needs to get through the winter, I suppose you/he
might try some temporary patch, like heavy tape over the gap to stop, or
at least slow down, the leaking air.

> Deguza

Smitty Two

unread,
Oct 9, 2008, 1:50:31 AM10/9/08
to
In article
<9b7a31d6-c5b0-4934...@i18g2000prf.googlegroups.com>,
Kompu Kid <deg...@hotmail.com> wrote:

> I first
> thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> buildup did not help.

Maybe it's the camera angle, but I see a hell of a lot of paint,
everywhere. If you removed 2 coats out of the 17 that are on there,
maybe it wasn't enough.

Kompu Kid

unread,
Oct 12, 2008, 3:35:43 AM10/12/08
to
On Oct 8, 10:50 pm, Smitty Two <prestwh...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> In article
> <9b7a31d6-c5b0-4934-93c7-5d6170dbe...@i18g2000prf.googlegroups.com>,

You are right. That particular picture was taken before removing the
paint.

Deguza

Kompu Kid

unread,
Oct 12, 2008, 3:38:03 AM10/12/08
to
On Oct 8, 3:20 pm, "SteveBell" <resp...@online.newsgroup.invalid>
wrote:

> Kompu Kid wrote:
> > Hello All:
>
> > Windows at my nephew's home won't close unless one pushes it with
> > substantial force from outside. I looked into it a bit. I first
> > thought it was paint buildup, but ruled this out after cleaning the
> > buildup did not help.
>
> > I have photos of the windows at:
>
> http://cid-eb85de77506ba8ba.spaces.live.com/photos/cns!EB85DE77506BA8...

I would have expected at least one or two of them to have problems,
interesting enough, *all* the mechanisms are in top shape.
Deguza

0 new messages