Hi everyone,
I've only been a member for a few months now, but I see some recurring themes on the mailing list and in person about workshop tools being left out, misused, broken, etc. I have some ideas that are relatively minor changes, but I think they might be quite helpful in making the workshop nicer.
I apologise if some of these ideas seem a bit draconian. I am trying to focus on making the hackspace workshop nice in the long-term, and I think that our relatively laissez-faire attitude may be hurting us a little bit. I also apologise for the length of the email, but I thought it was better than separating them into different threads.
***** Change hackable-by-default to do-not-hack by default.
(probably best to do in conjuction with the move to 445 Hackney Road, because it needs more space)
The main purpose of this change is to prevent people taking parts that would save a lot of effort in projects that have high value for the hackspace (e.g., fixing the lathe) and using them for a personal project. This happened recently, apparently -- there was a potential new motor for the green lathe, including control board, but somebody grabbed a proprietary wire it used, so now somebody (probably mentar) has to reverse-engineer it.
As for machine tool parts/spares being hacked, I haven't noticed it happen myself, but I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's probably happened quite a few times. Lots of lathe parts are not clearly part of a lathe, for example, and if left out could be mistaken for junk.
This sounds like a big change, but I don't think it will be huge. As I see it right now, most things in the workshop are already do-not-hack by default: member boxes, all the big machines, hand tools, the workshop tables themselves, drill bits, saw blades and other cutting tools, and replacement parts for machines. My idea is to replace do-not-hack stickers with separate storage areas for hackable machines and parts v.s. projects in progress, as well as labelling the shelves/bins for hardware/supplies that can be used to hack. If it's not labelled, do not hack.
That means that tool parts that are accidentally left out (which even the best of us do from time to time) will be less likely to be hacked.
And the rule of never leaving your project out in the space stays the same. Put it into your member box if it fits, and if not, mail the list and put it into the do-not-hack project area. Unless--if it's related to fixing/improving something for the hackspace, then keep it next to the thing needing fixing.
Obviously, we need to maintain the same vigilance against people taking up storage space for projects that never get done. So we would still need some kind of stickers or register for personal projects that are too big to fit into member boxes.
Again, this needs more space, so if we decide to do it, it's best to wait for 445 hackney road.
***** Policing the workshop to prevent tool abuse.
A lot of people seem quite resigned to tools being misused and broken. Perhaps I am just a bright-eyed and bushy-tailed new member, but gee golly, I think that having a nice, functioning workshop is something worth fighting for. I don't like showing the workshop to visitors and explaining that we have lots of nice tools, but half of them are broken.
I really like the idea of Sol's tool access control, yet it's a technological solution to a people problem, and suspect it won't completely solve it.
I think that the average hackspace member is quite averse to face-to-face confrontation. When someone is misusing a tool, we don't want to be the bad guy who says they should stop, and that maybe they can't actually finish their project right here and now. But we all know that stopping someone from misusing a tool to finish one project can mean that 10 other projects get done because the tool is still working. I think we should emphasize that fact, and encourage people to speak up for the hackspace. For example, it would be quite nice to have a big poster saying "Keep the hackspace hacking!" and explaining all this, so that when you stop somone abusing a tool, you can just point to the poster as a higher authority.
Solexious and others have done a great job emphasizing how fragile the laser cutter is, but most tools are fragile in their own way, and while they are not as expensive as laser cutter optics, they do add up.
We should make it clear that it's ok to stop someone doing their project if it looks like they don't know how to use a tool. It's great if someone is there to help them use it properly, but if not, that's too bad. Try not to think of it as being mean to one person, but as standing up for every other member of the hackspace.
I know some members are already doing this. I just think we want to encourage more people to feel comfortable doing it.
***** Discouraging haste.
This relates strongly preventing tool abuse. Getting people to slow down and work carefully in the short term means a nicer hackspace in the long term. I think it would be good to emphasize these points:
* If you need it done quickly, the hackspace may not be the best place. You may have to pay somebody in exchange for speed.
* Hackspace time is valuable, but if you cannot finish everything today, please accept that. Don't rush.
* Some things can't be done in the hackspace without abusing tools. Don't try! Keeping tools working is more important than finishing your project.
* Poor planning on your part does not constitute an emergency for the hackspace.
* Hofstadter's Law: It always takes longer than you expect, even when you take into account Hofstadter's Law.
* Budget time for cleanup. Don't work up until the moment you have to leave.
I may have a poster printed with these.
Thoughts? Apologies in advance if these have been discussed many times before.
Cheers,
Aaron Sokoloski (asoko)
TLDR: I liek lathe.