Why the rupee is falling against the dollar

[B. Karthick]

These are extraordinary times. Analysts have described the events of
the last few days as the worst financial crisis ever to have hit the
world. Imprudent financial decisions, fed by greed and bad luck, have
seen global financial markets collapse. The bankruptcy, sale,
restructuring and merger of some of the world's largest financial
institutions has caused cataclysmic disruptions in the international
stocks and money markets.

In such a scenario, how could India have escaped unhurt? The global
crises saw Indian stock markets crash, but as soon as the United
States funneled in $700 billion into the American economy to revive
dying markets, India too saw some stability. However, the forex market
was a totally different ball game.

Even as the dollar strengthened, the Indian rupee began to fall
alarmingly. The Indian currency has fallen to the lowest level in
almost two years. At a low of 46.99 to the dollar this year that it
hit on September 16, the rupee lost almost 18 per cent against the US
currency!

To put things in perspective, the rupee was trading at about 39.40 to
the dollar in January this year.

So why is the rupee falling against the dollar, when the global
financial crisis should impact the United States the most?

There are several reasons.

Analysts say these are the reasons for the fall of the rupee. . .


The main reasons behind the fall of the rupee are an increased demand
for dollars due to a spurt in crude oil prices and the flight of
foreign funds from the Indian market. Demand for rupees,
simultaneously, has dipped because capital inflows are down.

The American sub-prime crisis that shook the global financial markets
has seen unprecedented bailouts and infusion of dollars into the US
economy. This infusion has been at a cost of many an emerging market,
from where funds have been pulled out to plough back into America.
India has been one of the worst hit countries on this count, as
foreign funds took flight, thereby making dollars scarce. The sudden
and colossal demand for the US greenback has seen it strengthen, while
the rupee's exchange rate has depreciated dramatically during the same
period.
India's stock market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of
India, has said that foreign investors sold more Indian shares than
they bought.
Global funds are said to have sold Indian shares to the tune of over
$9 billion more than they have bought this year. As demand for dollars
from importers increased and the US Treasury poured in almost $700
billion into the US economy to bail out drowning financial giants, the
Indian market saw an outflow of a huge amount of dollars leading to a
spurt in the dollar price against the rupee.

The growing Indian trade deficit and the large fiscal deficit are also
contributing to the fall of the rupee.
The higher price of imported goods, especially oil that is now ruling
at over $107 per barrel, has also led to an increase in domestic
inflation and a fall in the value of the Indian currency. High
inflation and a strong growth in the Indian economy have already
forced the RBI to raise interest rates.
The demand-supply balance and the fundamentals are against the rupee
India has seen a large amount of outflows from its financial markets.
India is a heavy importer of oil and the current spurt in crude oil
prices has impacted the rupee too.
Also, the decline in the value of the rupee has coincided with RBI
discontinuing its direct sales of dollars to oil firms in early July.

One more reason for the fall of the rupee, as propounded by some
economists, is the overseas non-deliverable forward (NDF) market that
is not sanctioned by the Reserve Bank of India.

An NDF is a non-deliverable forward contract where financial
institutions buy forward dollars (that is, they book dollars now for
delivery at a predetermined future date) in the Indian market and at
the same time sell a similar amount of dollars in an overseas market
-- or vice-versa -- so that on the delivery date they make a profit or
loss, which is the difference between both the rates.

What happens if the rupee keeps on falling?

As the rupee falls, foreign investors will want bigger returns for
their money to compensate for the higher risk. This means that the
Indian government, companies and individuals will have to pay more for
the money they borrow: in other words, higher interest rates.
A major problem with a falling rupee is that it will increase the
Indian government's burden of repaying and servicing foreign debt.
Another problem is that it might discourage foreign institutional
investment from pouring funds into the Indian markets.
Indian companies which could borrow from the overseas markets at
cheaper rates to finance their import and export needs will be badly
affected.

How can India control the value of the rupee in the international
market?

The Reserve Bank of India can sell dollars in the open market to bring
down the value of the US greenback, albeit slightly.

Normally, the RBI uses its Monetary Policy to defend the rupee's
value. Short-term interest rates changes do impact the value of the
rupee against other currencies. But, the RBI has mostly used the
policy to stabilise internal conditions, like steps to control rising
inflation.

However, if the Indian stock markets boom -- like they did in the last
couple of years -- more and more global funds would begin to invest in
India thereby strengthening the rupee as the demand for the dollar in
the local markets drops.

What has the RBI done?

The Reserve Bank of India is closely monitoring the developments in
the global as well as domestic financial markets and stands ready to
take such pre-emptive action as may be necessary to contain excess
volatility in the domestic financial markets.

In order to alleviate these transient pressures which are related
largely to external developments, the RBI has decided to take the
following measures:

(a) Forex Market

In the light of current developments in the foreign exchange markets,
as on some previous occasions, the Reserve Bank will continue to sell
foreign exchange (US dollar) through agent banks to augment supply in
the domestic foreign exchange market or intervene directly to meet any
demand-supply gaps. The Reserve Bank would either sell the foreign
exchange directly or advise the bank concerned to buy it in the
market. All the transactions by the Reserve Bank will be at the
prevailing market rates and as per market practice.

(b) Interest Rates on FCNR (B) Deposits

Currently, the interest rate ceiling on FCNR (B) deposits of all
maturities has been fixed at Libor/Euribor/Swap rates for the
corresponding maturities minus 75 basis points for the respective
foreign currencies. In view of the prevailing market conditions, it
has been decided:

to increase, with immediate effect, the interest rate ceiling on FCNR
(B) deposits by 50 basis points, i.e., to Libor/Euribor/Swap rates
minus 25 basis points.
to increase, with immediate effect, the interest rate ceiling on
NR(E)RA deposits by 50 basis points, i.e., to Libor/Euribor/Swap rates
plus 50 basis points.

But why do currency values fluctuate?

There are many participants in any foreign exchange market. These
entities -- like banks, corporations, brokers, even individuals -- buy
and sell currencies everyday.

Here too the universal economic law of demand and supply is
applicable: when there are more buyers for a currency than sellers,
its exchange rate rises. Similarly, when there are more sellers of a
particular currency than buyers, its exchange rate in the global
markets will fall. This does not mean people no longer want money; it
only means that people prefer to keep their wealth in some other form
or another currency.

Is there any hope for the rupee?

The Indian currency, however, has in the last two trading sessions
risen sharply against the dollar under the hope that foreign investors
will soon buy into the Indian stock markets.

With risk aversion among foreign investors declining, the Indian rupee
is likely to strengthen.


A temporary aberration?

Commerce Minister Kamal Nath has termed the Indian rupee's fall
against the dollar as a 'temporary aberration,' but said that the
lower value of the rupee will help boost export growth.

But even as foreign funds withdrew money from the Indian markets and
the oil prices kept going up, India's huge foreign currency reserves
-- pegged at $289 billion that is enough to cover for almost a year's
worth of imports -- have helped a lot, for even if FIIs take away
funds India will not face a solvency crisis like it did in the early
1990s.