Stanley Grenz e Star Trek
Hytok
(...)
Review: Stanley Grenz - A Primer on Postmodernism
I participate in a small number of online communities. The one I have
always found most rewarding is TMF � The Motley Fool. I can�t recommend it
highly enough. People from all over the world come together there to share
knowledge about everything from finance and investing to home-brewed beer.
Each of these boards generates a community of relationships � friends and
rivals come there to be challenged and to grow.
Along with learning to manage my personal finances, I have been drawn to
two religious communities on TMF � "Christian Fools" and �Faith in a
Postmodern World.� I joined the latter community because I liked the people
who built it, and I hoped to learn more about postmodernism in general, and
Christian living in a postmodern context in particular.
Since my own education did not include an introduction to postmodernism,
(or at least we didn�t call it that in Pennsyltucky in the �seventies,)
I�ve always felt ignorant participating in the conversation. Over time, it
became apparent that many others on the board were as vague in their
understanding as I was. Many expressed an understandable reluctance to
change a place of lively conversation into a forum for arid academic and
philosophical esoterica. A friend recommended a resource to me, and I
promised to read it and share some of the information and insights gleaned
from the journey. What follows is the fulfillment of that promise.I hope
you may find something useful in the course of our trip together.
Review: Stanley Grenz - A Primer on Postmodernism
Grenz, Stanley J., A Primer on Postmodernism, William B Eerdmans Publishing
Co., Grand Rapids, 1996.
Stanley Grenz died in March of 2005. He was 54 years old. He left a legacy
of bridge-building. His life's work reflects a ministry to the church - a
mission to call her to carry the Gospel to the world of the present - not
to let the news of Christ be lost in nostalgia for the way things used to
be. He was passionate about helping the church to look through the lens of
postmodernism, and to discover ways to minister to a generation that was
raised while looking through this lens. His Primer has become a touchstone
for anyone in the church seeking to carry on this missionary calling.
In the preface to Primer Grenz describes his objective:
�to assist students, church leaders, youth workers, and even colleagues in
understanding the attitude or mind-set that is becoming increasingly
prevalent in North American, especially (but not exclusively) on university
campuses. (p ix)
Grenz' subject is not a simple one, and Primer is not always a simple read.
In spite of the challenge of wrapping his arms around the principles of
postmodernism, he was often successful in giving this old English major a
glimpse of the often-nebulous face of this culture shaping movement.
Primer opens with a review of the article Grenz first published in the 1994
edition of Crux, a quarterly religious journal published by Regent College
in Vancouver, BC. In "Star Trek and the Next Generation: Postmodernism and
the Future of Evangelical Theology, Grenz proposes that contrasting the
original series with its latter incarnation can offer insight into the
differences between the modern and the postmodern points of view.
Captain James Tiberius Kirk�s Enterprise reflected the modern world that
produced it. The ship�s personnel were nearly all human. Their mission was
�to boldly go where no man has gone before.� The use of the male gender
here is not so much sexist as it is anthropocentric. The universe that
Kirk�s starship explores has humankind at its center. The modern principle
that �man is the measure of all things� reigns in Star Trek. The series
emphasized diversity, but human diversity: explorers of multiple
nationalities whose planetary civilization had advanced enough to enable
them to work together to explore and discover the nature of �the final
frontier.�
Kirk was the ultimate rugged individualist, trusting his gut, his
experience, and his passionate nature far more than the counsel of small
circle of advisors. Warrior, poet, orator, lover: he was a Renaissance man.
The modern ideal is no swashbuckler. A strong individual whose approach to
the universe was reasoned and dispassionate, the unfailingly logical Mr.
Spock represented the modern emergence of science as the real
problem-solver for humanity. In spite of the fiery courage of their
Captain, the humans on the enterprise were ultimately able to pursue their
mission thanks to the rational expertise of their half-Human/half-Vulcan
Science Officer.
Jean Luc Picard�s Next Generation Enterprise is a very different place that
its predecessor. Their new mission � to boldly go where no one has gone
before � is more than a nod to politically correctness. Man � humankind �
is no longer the measure of all things on the Enterprise. The crew�s
diversity now includes beings from all over the galaxy. Far beyond the
familiar multi-cultural nature of Kirk�s crew, Picard leads an inter
galactic team. At his side are a diverse team of advisors. Unlike Kirk,
Picard�s second in command, Riker - his �Number One� - is present and
prominent. The team includes the blind engineer, Geordi, the fierce Klingon
security officer, Worf and the ship�s beautiful and motherly physician,
Beverly Crusher. Instead of the super-human strength and intelligence of
Spock, Picard has the assistance of the android, Data. Data�s character is
very different than that of his Vulcan predecessor. Even though he is a
machine, Data desires a more holistic understanding of what it means to be
alive. Where Spock finds human emotional life to be an obstacle, or at best
�fascinating,� Data actually wants to experience that life.
Like Commander Riker, Counselor Troi has no real antecedent on the original
crew. Her empathic abilities bring compassion and emotion to the forefront.
Rather than being an obstacle to reason, emotion and feelings are
considered to be integral parts of life on the new Enterprise.
Next Generation�s great villain is the Borg, a collective intelligence that
robs beings of their emotional selves and integrates them into something
that is not a community but an enormous machine of conquest. In the
original series, the universe is an often mystifying, but rarely mystical
place. Next Generation introduces the supernatural Q, a recurring
omnipotent visitor from �the continuum�.
Grenz hypothesis is that Next Generation reflects the postmodern changes
that began to occur in our culture in the decades between the launch of the
original NBC series in 1966 and the generation that saw its release in
first-run syndication in 1987. Our culture is moving away from one that
idealizes reason, science, and individual achievement. Postmodernism leads
us toward a more inclusive view of our existence - one that includes not
only reason, but also intuition, emotion, and individual perceptions in the
context of community.
The conclusion of Primer�s first chapter sums up what Grenz feels is the
importance of the church considering postmodernism:
We dare not fall into the trap of wistfully longing for a return to the
early modernity that gave evangelicalism its birth, for we are called not
to minister to the past, but to the contemporary context�.
Postmodernism poses many dangers. Nevertheless, it would be ironic �
indeed, it would be tragic � if evangelicals ended up as the last defenders
of a now dying modernity. (p 10)
In this tribute to Granz, written on the blog Generations in Conversation
soon after his death, the Star Trek comparison is described this way:
The first chapter gives us the beautiful metaphor for modernism and
postmodernism - Star Trek as a series. The first series - boldness and
certainty. The second series - humility, subtlety and uncertainty.
As the modern world changes, postmodern thinking will influence everything
about our culture. As a people called to be in the world, but not of the
world, Christians need to understand how to negotiate the postmodern
landscape, even if it never becomes our true home.
Peace,
pennsy
--
Jolan Tru
Filippo "Hytok" Simone
http://perestroika.iobloggo.com/