I am assuming that "drowning plants" or "over watering" or "waterlogged
roots" is referring to a lack of dissolved or atmospheric oxygen in the
rhisoshpere, not to over watering per say. As the nutrient solution
temperature rises, cellular metabolism & respiration increases in the
rhisosphere (i.e. higher growth rates). However, there is an upper limit
because D.O. is temperature dependent(as is air or any gas/vapor dissolved
in a liquid) so as the temperature of the nutrient solution rises, D.O.
decreases. At sea level(D.O. is also pressure dependent) water at 1 deg, 20
deg, & 25 deg C (34,68 & 77 deg F) will hold 14, 9.0 & 8.2 ppm of D.O.(at
3000' & 6000' these numbers are reduced by 10% & 20% respectively).
Therefore, the optimal root zone temperature for most plants is in the 20 to
23 deg C range(68-75 deg F) assuming D.O. saturation. Higher D.O. levels
allow for a warmer nutrient solution which in turn increases yield. The
nutrient solution in my greenhouse hydroponic system is held at 74 F & is
continually aerated to 12 ppm. Although considered a micro nutrient due to
its low levels in solution, D.O. is assimilated at a higher rate than any
other nutrient, & thus needs to be continually replaced.
The atmosphere is approximately 20% oxygen(200,000 ppm). As such, the
nutrient solution is only a minor source (1-5 %)of rhisospheric oxygen. The
main reason to aerate the solution is to kill off anaerobic pathogens,
pythium for example. This is especially important in closed (recirculating)
hydro systems. Moreover, oxygen affects the electrical charges (ionic
balance)in the water & nutrients to lower the energy needed for
assimilation.
Some plants can grow very well with their roots completely submerged in
water if the dissolved oxygen is adequate. Rice is grown in this manner, but
it's genetics have evolved to grow well in low dissolved oxygen. Trying to
grow tomato or cucumber in this manner would result in poor yields because
to achieve high growth rates with such voracious plants, the roots must
receive far higher levels of oxygen than available in solution alone, even
if supersaturated with O2 mechanically via aerators or chemically via
hydrogen peroxide.
This is where aeroponics, or hydroponics using a high field capacity
medium (high air space) excel. Aeroponics bath the roots directly in air. In
hydroponics, rock wool or perlite for example, will hold at least 20% & 30%
air respectively (unless submerged in water) even if irrigated continuously.
These percentages can be increased to as high as desired by using a
combination of moisture & E.C. meters to control the irrigation sequence,
but increasing media air content will significantly raise the E.C.(ppm) of
the nutrient solution so one must approach this method very carefully! A
less accurate but simpler & less expensive method is to adjust the "off"
portion of a cycle timer sequence by weighing the media between irrigation
cycles; again beware of rising E.C.
So, the moral of this story is: feed the roots as much oxygen as
possible to avoid " drowning " your plants.
Happy gardening.
Ian