Frankfurt stock prices are incorrect

[Hugo Blanc]

I have reported many stocks from the Frankfurt stock market that have
all incorrect data (historical and stock prices)!
Does someone know why is this happening?
Thanks,

[Karolina (Google Finance team)]

Hello Hugo, which stocks in particular?

[Hugo Blanc]

Deutsche Bank, BMW, for instance. This is the data shown by Google Finance:

http://www.google.com/finance/historical?q=FRA:DBK 

May 30, 2012	29.01	29.41	28.58	28.95	38,432
May 29, 2012	29.21	29.51	28.75	29.15	25,323
May 28, 2012	29.60	29.86	29.00	29.11	20,470
May 25, 2012	29.00	29.71	28.82	29.30	71,805
May 24, 2012	29.17	29.29	28.58	28.88	29,387
May 23, 2012	29.05	29.29	28.65	28.95	41,570
May 22, 2012	29.45	29.76	28.65	29.58	41,619
May 21, 2012	28.42	29.05	28.42	28.95	30,602
May 18, 2012	27.71	29.32	27.71	28.50	57,956
May 17, 2012	29.10	29.19	27.79	28.43	40,695
May 16, 2012	29.00	29.65	28.63	28.69	67,210
May 15, 2012	29.90	30.31	29.08	29.24	75,523
May 14, 2012	30.79	30.80	29.73	30.00	52,792
May 11, 2012	30.80	31.25	30.10	30.88	39,397
May 10, 2012	30.63	31.70	30.36	31.28	51,391
May 9, 2012	31.00	31.00	29.80	30.50	50,307
May 8, 2012	31.77	31.77	30.50	30.53	69,336
May 7, 2012	29.90	31.85	29.90	31.82	70,649
May 4, 2012	31.10	31.86	30.69	31.15	55,757
May 3, 2012	32.23	32.30	30.96	31.16	60,891
May 2, 2012	33.21	33.49	31.78	32.28	67,779
Apr 30, 2012	33.53	33.78	32.85	32.90	33,167
Apr 27, 2012	32.80	34.01	32.18	33.48	55,593
Apr 26, 2012	33.65	33.95	32.07	33.25	87,088
Apr 25, 2012	33.65	34.68	33.57	34.32	37,336
Apr 24, 2012	33.25	33.58	32.24	33.37	57,874
Apr 23, 2012	34.05	34.10	32.74	33.20	54,710
Apr 20, 2012	33.83	35.07	33.78	34.30	27,571
Apr 19, 2012	34.70	35.34	33.70	33.70	52,861
Apr 18, 2012	35.38	35.52	34.58	34.68	28,469

and this is the correct data:

Timestamp	Trade Open	Trade High	Trade Low	Trade Close	Trade Volume
5/30/2012	28.925	29.48	28.52	28.825	6637968
5/29/2012	29.45	29.54	28.74	29.23	5698037
5/28/2012	29.695	29.89	29.055	29.165	3830628
5/25/2012	29.15	29.73	29.05	29.39	6928389
5/24/2012	29.2	29.315	28.55	29.08	6282706
5/23/2012	28.85	29.34	28.64	28.84	7296851
5/22/2012	29.195	29.8	28.625	29.66	6987335
5/21/2012	28.465	29.055	28.4	28.95	6856715
5/18/2012	28	29.35	27.95	28.465	10142295
5/17/2012	29.075	29.24	27.735	28.49	6968699
5/16/2012	28.85	29.645	28.58	29.06	9024640
5/15/2012	30.05	30.34	29.065	29.375	8330572
5/14/2012	30.79	30.79	29.715	29.88	7352262
5/11/2012	30.7	31.29	30.09	31.165	8642839
5/10/2012	30.74	31.705	30.33	31.23	8676043
5/9/2012	30.875	30.9	29.785	30.415	8196361
5/8/2012	31.55	31.55	30.55	30.76	6375881
5/7/2012	30.05	31.635	29.91	31.55	6719768
5/4/2012	31	31.915	30.58	31.08	8167601
5/3/2012	32.105	32.41	30.985	31.23	10115112
5/2/2012	33.48	33.5	31.75	32.06	8949308
4/30/2012	33.57	33.655	32.775	32.87	6226946
4/27/2012	32.2	34.04	32.11	33.5	9220939
4/26/2012	33.46	33.61	32.075	33.195	12970170
4/25/2012	33.81	34.745	33.805	34.135	7274274
4/24/2012	33.265	33.59	32.235	33.42	7233783
4/23/2012	34	34.04	32.735	32.98	7415658
4/20/2012	33.955	35.2	33.75	34.48	8703340
4/19/2012	35.18	35.445	33.9	33.9	13361916

Kind regards,

Hugo Garcia

[Hugo Blanc]

for BMW, Google data:

Date	Open	High	Low	Close	Volume
May 30, 2012	63.70	63.70	61.79	62.12	3,048
May 29, 2012	62.91	64.71	62.90	64.00	8,959
May 28, 2012	62.43	63.10	62.12	62.38	2,226
May 25, 2012	62.00	62.60	61.49	61.82	3,606
May 24, 2012	62.52	62.73	61.40	61.70	9,607
May 23, 2012	62.55	62.80	61.67	62.07	9,153
May 22, 2012	62.32	63.59	62.32	63.43	9,428
May 21, 2012	60.86	62.55	60.86	61.92	7,919
May 18, 2012	61.34	62.12	60.93	60.94	17,844
May 17, 2012	64.50	64.83	62.60	62.83	18,564
May 16, 2012	65.66	66.92	64.66	66.28	13,347
May 15, 2012	66.78	67.28	65.72	66.22	21,390
May 14, 2012	66.95	67.23	66.00	66.61	19,445
May 11, 2012	65.97	67.50	65.66	67.21	15,293
May 10, 2012	68.00	68.32	66.00	66.42	17,070
May 9, 2012	67.75	68.37	66.36	67.75	14,764
May 8, 2012	70.39	70.39	66.96	67.86	28,394
May 7, 2012	67.80	70.40	66.95	70.40	28,057
May 4, 2012	71.30	71.80	68.74	69.33	12,791
May 3, 2012	72.50	73.90	71.25	71.60	80,085
May 2, 2012	72.62	72.89	70.28	71.48	10,571
Apr 30, 2012	72.12	72.64	71.73	71.83	11,224
Apr 27, 2012	70.90	72.46	70.57	72.06	13,688
Apr 26, 2012	69.51	71.38	69.51	71.00	15,282
Apr 25, 2012	67.80	70.00	67.68	69.70	13,698
Apr 24, 2012	67.42	68.03	67.38	67.42	7,388
Apr 23, 2012	69.44	69.44	66.45	67.29	16,275
Apr 20, 2012	68.40	69.89	68.03	69.56	14,535
Apr 19, 2012	69.55	70.02	68.28	68.28	21,060
Apr 18, 2012	69.75	70.36	68.99	69.38	13,477

and the correct data:

Timestamp	Trade Open	Trade High	Trade Low	Trade Close	Trade Volume

5/30/2012	63.61	63.74	61.66	62.01	2858769
5/29/2012	63.13	64.79	62.98	64	2426478
5/28/2012	62.44	63.42	62.02	62.28	1201981
5/25/2012	62.01	62.62	61.4	61.9	1634898
5/24/2012	62.44	62.58	61.25	61.98	2459775
5/23/2012	62.71	62.83	61.53	61.81	2670776
5/22/2012	62.77	63.76	62.48	63.43	2880567
5/21/2012	61.48	62.66	61.39	61.77	2362798
5/18/2012	61.81	62.24	61.02	61.31	4288518
5/17/2012	64.8	64.88	62.37	62.73	2629253
5/16/2012	65.31	67.16	64.57	66.53	4103589
5/15/2012	66.95	67.3	65.5	66.17	2965273
5/14/2012	67.23	67.35	65.91	66.44	2222874
5/11/2012	65.82	67.6	65.51	67.6	2729961
5/10/2012	68.1	68.28	65.9	66.24	4070960
5/9/2012	67.8	68.5	66.36	67.7	2938800
5/8/2012	69.3	69.73	66.88	67.35	2917030
5/7/2012	67.1	70.25	66.89	70.05	2454028
5/4/2012	71.62	71.86	68.73	68.99	2956169
5/3/2012	71.81	73.95	71.11	71.68	5130666
5/2/2012	72.64	72.91	70.29	71.07	2681607
4/30/2012	72.31	72.67	71.61	71.81	1892410
4/27/2012	70.8	72.5	70.51	72.13	2623097
4/26/2012	69.63	71.44	69.3	71.25	3749825
4/25/2012	67.95	70.08	67.83	69.68	2337231
4/24/2012	67.3	68.11	66.97	67.6	1937241
4/23/2012	68.8	68.84	66.4	67	2617648
4/20/2012	68.41	69.97	67.82	69.84	2618937
4/19/2012	69.79	70.25	68.25	68.32	2865183

[Hugo Blanc]

No answer? Google still shows wrong data for the Frankfurt market everyday. Nobody has realized? I can't believe it!

[Karolina (Google Finance team)]

Hello Hugo, thank you for the additional information. I've checked and our prices are definitely correct. I think you were looking at the Xetra prices (http://www.google.com/finance?q=ETR:BMW) instead of the Frankfurt Floor Trades prices (http://www.google.com/finance?q=FRA:BMW). Our historical prices for FRA:BMW match the data you identified as correct (see here: http://www.google.com/finance/historical?q=FRA:BMW). 

 - Karolina