Problems migrating feed from Blogger to Wordpress and email subscriptions broken

[Ryan Wanger]

Just moved from Blogger to a custom wordpress, both using Feedburner.
Installed the Feedsmith plugin. I thought I did it correctly, however,
my subscribers dropped from 33 to 13 (all remaining were via email).
Plus, the email subscriptions are not being sent out, and if I try to
subscribe via email (via the link generated by feedsmith), it says:
"the feed does not have subscriptions by email enabled".

Feedburner tells me that I do indeed have email on (I never changed
it).

The site is http://www.thereluctanteater.com

In feedburner, the original feed was: http://thereluctanteater.blogspot.com
The feed address: http://feeds.feedburner.com/thereluctanteater

I changed the original feed to: http://www.thereluctanteater.com/feed/

The plugin is enabled and I have it pointing to:
http://feeds.feedburner.com/thereluctanteater

What's wrong? Can I get the emails sending out again? And can I get my
lost subscribers back? It appears that you can sign up for the feed
anew with no problem.