On 5/24/13 2:26 PM, in article nWQnt.173752$i%3.10...@fx10.fr7, "Goblin"
<
bytes...@googlemail.com> wrote:
> On 24/05/13 22:06, GreyCloud wrote:
>> And also very interesting in the fact that since 1998 I was advocating for
>> Linux till I decided to get a new PC with Win7 on it. I was in good stead
>> till then.
>>
> No. All it takes is anyone to look back at how you post. You are very
> different from someone who merely makes a choice and uses another solution.
This is very subjective. I would like to see some examples... phrases he
used to use and then stopped when he started using Windows, for example.
To me his style is very much the same and his beliefs are very much the same
- including in areas where he and I disagree.
> In anycase, even Hadron didn't believe you were the real "Greycloud"....I
> personally see it as no relevance since its HOW you post, not the topic you
> are posting about.
I see no reason to think he is not the real him. None at all. Nor any
evidence to suggest it. I also know for an absolute fact that people are
often - very often - accused of being someone they are not. Dozens of people
have been accused of being my socks... and I know for an absolute fact that
are not. They hold on to these beliefs even when shown absolute proof of
their error - such as when Onion Knight and I not only did one Skype with
each other but did another with Brad cc Wiggins. The idea I could somehow
use both voices in real time is just absurd... but the claims of him being
my sock are still spread in COLA.
I think what happens is dishonest people see others as being dishonest...
and honest people see people as being honest. I trust GreyCloud because I am
trustworthy. This does not mean I do not look at evidence or question
people, but even with folks as off-the-wall and offensive as Bilk, I do not
say outright he is making things up, I *question* his claims. Only when it
became apparent that his claims were self-contradictory and utter nonsense
he could not explain did I state categorically that his claims were clearly
false. Since then he has finally admitted he did not even do any research on
his claims - he is merely stating what he thinks others have told him. But I
still would give him the benefit of the doubt and give him a chance to
explain, for example, why the video he speaks of is not referenced in any TV
Guide anyone can find.
I give people chances because I believe people, in general, are honest and
good. I see people as I am. It takes a lot for me to "write someone off"...
my weakness is I give people too many chances (a weakness some Usenet
predators have exploited).
>> And you still use a broad paint brush to label everyone that disagrees with
>> the herd
>>
> Well time and again the "herd" is proved not to exist since there's diversity
> of opinion between FOSS users here
I do not think anyone says there is not diversity. But what is true is that
the vast majority of the following untrue (or at best baseless) claims are
accepted by each herd member (or, at best, not questioned):
* MS has secret deals to stop OEMs from selling Linux pre-installed.
* Apple claims to have invented the "rounded rectangle".
* Desktop Linux serves people as well as the competition.
* Apple never innovated anything.
* Samsung has not been copying Apple's products.
* Apple and MS are struggling / dying companies.
* MS has a monopoly on the desktop.
* Snit is anti-choice (as are others they accuse).
* Snit is anti-Linux (as are others they accuse).
* Snit uses sock puppets (as do others they accuse).
* Stallman's views on kids and sexuality are fine.
* Stallman's doubletalk about "Freedom" is coherent and makes sense.
* MS is evil to have blocked Linux years ago, but Google is fine to
block Aliyun OS *now*.
* When an organization moves to a Linux based product it is always a
good move. When they move away from one it is always a bad move.
* Even though some herd members post membership lists of who is in
the herd, all herd members deny the herd even exists.
* If you recognize there are downsides to massive amounts of distros,
then you must want to be told how to use it and believe everyone
feels the same way.
Again: some herd members have questioned some of these (perhaps more notably
Homer with his calling Google out on the Aliyun OS BS). But even in that
case Homer pretty quickly dropped it and moved back to attacking MS for
deals they had years ago... and pretended they were still in effect but
"secret" even though the evidence directly shows OEMs can and do offer
competing OSs.
I also frequently post examples of herd members posting for the apparent
reason to please the rest of the herd. Not one of my claims has been shown
to be wrong.
So the idea that there is no herd is sorta silly... it is very well
established by fairly detailed and objective evidence.
> ...what is agreed though are there are certain types of Microsoft advocates.
I think there are folks who prefer MS products for some things, but of the
people in COLA there are few if any who push MS for all things. Who does not
speak highly of Linux on in the server room and in embedded devices? Who
says Linux is not a good solution for portable devices? Who is pushing MS to
the point of saying it is always the best for everyone?
There may be some... but I would like to see the evidence.
> There are those like Marti, who is a nice chap and choses to use a Microsoft
> product, then theres you. There's flatfish and there's all the others who
> can't post in a decent way and seek only to make peoples lives miserable here.
Look at the COLA "advocates". They post attacks on a regular basis... heck,
I doubt you can find a single day in the last year where the advocates have
not posted something nasty and generally untrue about me (not to mention
Hadron or flatfish or others). This does *not* excuse the behavior of those
outside of the herd who also make attacks, but let us not pretend the COLA
"advocates" are the good guys in COLA. They are false "advocates" who are
very vicious. Even the ones who generally are not, such as TomB, can be
pushed to be when they get out of line. I quoted Stallman and he reacted to
this and the pushing of the herd by contacting my Usenet provider and trying
to have my account cancelled. When was the last time any of the "trolls" did
anything that grotesquely wrong?
>> What happened to Marti happened to me as well... just to set the record
>> straight.
>>
> Really? Yet Marti doesn't behave like you. Why is that?
--
"It was probably the HEMI-DIMENSIONAL ALIENS that were following MJ-12
around and were attracted to the PROTATIONAL FIELD generated by your
spinning hard drive." - Mark S Bill
"Maybe I am that way because people kept telling me I was mentally ill. But
I never was. I just saw monsters. Them." - Mark S. Bilk