Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Cleanup of Embedded images??

85 views
Skip to first unread message

guthrie

unread,
Dec 19, 2006, 3:44:00 PM12/19/06
to
On my machine I have over 176 MB of .jpg/.gif files in the Embedded
folder, some more than 4 years old. But when I do a scan for all
"Embedded" files specified in .mbx files, I only find 365 of them, a
small part of the actual 2880 files kept.

I do not want ot orphan any real links from any either Imap or local
mail folders, but how should/could I do some cleanup?

Shouldn't Eudora delete Embedded images when an EMail is deleted??

Han

unread,
Dec 19, 2006, 9:08:27 PM12/19/06
to
"guthrie" <grgu...@gmail.com> wrote in news:1166561040.326434.135000
@i12g2000cwa.googlegroups.com:

You may need to choose compact mailboxes from the special menu.

--
Best regards
Han
email address is invalid

guthrie

unread,
Dec 19, 2006, 9:58:44 PM12/19/06
to
I do that regularly; I don't think it does this.

Edward Reid

unread,
Dec 20, 2006, 12:29:35 AM12/20/06
to
I have the same problem and no good solution. However:

guthrie wrote:
> Shouldn't Eudora delete Embedded images when an EMail is deleted??

Things like this have to be done very carefully. For example, my
filters make a copy of most of my incoming email into an archive
folder. When I'm through processing the email, I delete the copy that's
in my inbox. Eventually it gets deleted from the trash. Yet I still
have a copy. Clearly the criterion has to be, not "the message is
deleted" or "the message is emptied from the trash", but "no more
copies of the message exist".

I even archive my junk mail, though separately -- mostly for
statistics, although a couple of times I've rescued, weeks later, good
email that I missed in my first scan through the junk mailbox. However,
in this case I would like to delete all the embedded images for the
archived junk. That's difficult too.

Edward

John H Meyers

unread,
Dec 20, 2006, 7:05:31 PM12/20/06
to
Previously, guthrie wrote:

> Shouldn't Eudora delete Embedded images when an EMail is deleted??

On Tue, 19 Dec 2006 23:29:35 -0600, Edward Reid wrote:

> Things like this have to be done very carefully. For example, my
> filters make a copy of most of my incoming email into an archive
> folder. When I'm through processing the email, I delete the copy that's
> in my inbox. Eventually it gets deleted from the trash. Yet I still
> have a copy. Clearly the criterion has to be, not "the message is
> deleted" or "the message is emptied from the trash", but "no more
> copies of the message exist".

That is indeed very important, yet with options such as
"delete from server when emptied from trash" and
"delete attachments when emptying trash,"
if *any* copy of a message is trashed
(or even if a *partially* downloaded copy that was truncated
by the option "skip messages over [ ]K in size" is trashed),
then the corresponding server message or locally stored attachment
is deleted anyway, even if other copies of the same message
exist within the Eudora mail folder,
basically because Eudora apparently can't identify what messages
are really associated with the same original source message,
or else doesn't want to take the time which could be required
to determine that.

I don't know whether the "delete attachments when emptying trash"
option applies to embedded images as well, but if it does,
then it would be subject to the very same pitfall,
so you should bear all of this in mind
when setting each of the above options.

The IMAP behavior might possibly also differ from the POP behavior,
complicated by the fact that there may be both remote and local
mailbox files (guthrie always uses IMAP, while I always use POP).

"Brana" recently posted a new URL to his collection of Eudora plugins,
one of which scans all mailboxes, looking for duplicate storage
of the same original message (for eliminating all but one of each,
even though there might be reason to sometimes put a copy of one
message in two or more places); it's conceivable that there might
be interest in a plugin for the removal of all embedded images
*and* attachments which are no longer referenced by any messages
(or has this already been done?) Perhaps very many $14 sales
could be generated if there's a lot of interest in this :)

-[ ]-

Brana Bujenovic

unread,
Dec 28, 2006, 12:50:22 PM12/28/06
to
"John H Meyers" <jhme...@nomail.invalid> wrote in
news:op.tkvuj...@isdept23.ia.mum.edu:

> "Brana" recently posted a new URL to his collection of Eudora plugins,
> one of which scans all mailboxes, looking for duplicate storage
> of the same original message (for eliminating all but one of each,
> even though there might be reason to sometimes put a copy of one
> message in two or more places); it's conceivable that there might
> be interest in a plugin for the removal of all embedded images
> *and* attachments which are no longer referenced by any messages
> (or has this already been done?) Perhaps very many $14 sales
> could be generated if there's a lot of interest in this :)

Hello there:

Delete Duplicates for Eudora provides Scan Special Folders: To use it just
select Embedded Files folder (just below mailboxes panel), and hit Scan
Embedded Files. It shouldn't take very long for embedded files are usually
small in size.

When I changed the host I updated the site a little bit. Plugins page is
not 100% done yet, but all the plugins are listed.

You can now download Delete Duplicates for Eudora from here:
http://www.download.com/Delete-Duplicates-for-Eudora/3640-2368_4-
10598022.html

===============================
E-Gadgets Home Page
-------------------------------
http://e-gadgets.freehostia.com
===============================

John H Meyers

unread,
Dec 29, 2006, 5:25:49 PM12/29/06
to
On Thu, 28 Dec 2006 11:50:22 -0600, Brana wrote:

> Delete Duplicates for Eudora provides Scan Special Folders:

> To use it just select Embedded Files folder...

The issue in this thread is to remove *unreferenced* items
(embedded and/or attachments), rather than only *duplicates*;
does your existing plugin have such an option?

Thanks for your input.

-[ ]-

Brana Bujenovic

unread,
Dec 29, 2006, 6:18:12 PM12/29/06
to
"John H Meyers" <jhme...@nomail.invalid> wrote in
news:op.tlcdx...@lib2.library.mum.edu:

Ah ok, I didn't pick up that.
For orphaned attachments check out the Attacher plugin. To start the
program click Tools/Orphaned Attachments. Note, that scan is very slow.

Which mailbox is currently scanned is displayed on Eudora-status bar.

Note also, it's not for embedded files, it's just for attachments.

John H Meyers

unread,
Dec 29, 2006, 10:00:42 PM12/29/06
to
On Fri, 29 Dec 2006 17:18:12 -0600, Brana Bujenovic kindly wrote:

> For orphaned attachments check out the Attacher plugin.

> Note it's not for embedded files, it's just for attachments.

If you happen to find it easy to extend this to embedded images,
I guess that there's someone who would appreciate it :)

Thanks again for the very useful info (and plugins).

-[ ]-

Brana Bujenovic

unread,
Dec 30, 2006, 10:08:12 AM12/30/06
to
"John H Meyers" <jhme...@nomail.invalid> wrote in
news:op.tlcqn...@w2kjhm.ia.mum.edu:

> If you happen to find it easy to extend this to embedded images,
> I guess that there's someone who would appreciate it :)
>
> Thanks again for the very useful info (and plugins).
>

Sure. Do check this address in about one month
http://e-gadgets.freehostia.com

I hope to find some time to update Mailbox Tools for Eudora.
The site will be
http://e-gadgets.freehostia.com/mte.htm

0 new messages