Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

this

12 views
Skip to first unread message

Douglas Crockford

unread,
Aug 27, 2003, 2:10:19 AM8/27/03
to
I've noticed some confusion about the use of the this keyword. It is set for
each invocation of a function. There are 4 basic calling patterns:

1. foo()
2. bar.foo()
3. new foo()
4. foo.apply(bar)

In the first case, foo's this will be set to the global object (aka window).
This is an acceptable behavior for global functions, although null would have
been a better choice. This is very unfortunate behavior for inner functions,
because it makes it harder to write helper functions within a method.

In this second case, foo's this will be set to the bar object. This supports
calls to methods. Unlike some other languages (like Java), the use of this
within a method must be explicit.

In the third case, foo's this will be set to a new object that is linked to
foo.prototype. This supports constructor functions. Note that constructor
function must be called with the new prefix. If the new prefix is missing,
it degenerates to the first case, and the constructor will clobber the global
object.

In the fourth case, foo's this will be bar. This makes it possible to call a
function that is not a method of the object as though it is a method of the
object.

http://www.crockford.com

George M Jempty

unread,
Aug 27, 2003, 11:19:38 AM8/27/03
to
Douglas Crockford wrote:
> I've noticed some confusion about the use of the this keyword. It is set for
> each invocation of a function. There are 4 basic calling patterns:
>
> 1. foo()
> 2. bar.foo()
> 3. new foo()
> 4. foo.apply(bar)
>

<SNIP>

>
> In the fourth case, foo's this will be bar. This makes it possible to call a
> function that is not a method of the object as though it is a method of the
> object.

Have you ever heard of this 4th case being called "environmental
acquisition"? There's a paper on it at:

http://www.ccs.neu.edu/home/lorenz/papers/oopsla96/

There was also a python and smalltalk usenet thread about it a couple of
years ago; python because apparently Zope makes use of this concept. I
mentioned Javascript does too and that was the end of the thread ;)


0 new messages