Clean Code Discussion - Google Groups

Contact owners and managers

1–30 of 634

Welcome to the Clean Code discussion group. Here we discuss the Clean Code video episodes that appear on cleancoders.com.

The rules are simple:

No advertising.
No swearing.
No name-calling.
Be respectful and nice.
The only way to go fast, is to go well.
Sign up for the Clean Coders Slack workspace using this link.

0 selected

Paul Michael Reilly

2/20/20

Announcement

Clean Coders Slack workspace signup - Use Group Welcome Message

The open invitation to the Clean Coders Slack workspace is now included in the Clean Code Discussion

unread,

Announcement

Clean Coders Slack workspace signup - Use Group Welcome Message

The open invitation to the Clean Coders Slack workspace is now included in the Clean Code Discussion

2/20/20

Paul Michael Reilly, … Ashok Raju86

2/20/20

Clean Code Slack Workspace

Please add me to the group. Thanks! On Monday, February 17, 2020 at 8:29:30 PM UTC-8, reedlaw wrote:

p...@pajato.com

unread,locked,

Clean Code Slack Workspace

Please add me to the group. Thanks! On Monday, February 17, 2020 at 8:29:30 PM UTC-8, reedlaw wrote:

2/20/20

Jakub Kaczor

11/7/24

Implementation not derived from requirements in Clean Code Applied: We write a Web Server, ep. 5

In the mentioned episode, the authors implement a web server for their video hosting application. As

unread,

Implementation not derived from requirements in Clean Code Applied: We write a Web Server, ep. 5

In the mentioned episode, the authors implement a web server for their video hosting application. As

11/7/24

Colin Williams

2/6/24

When to write a Use Case

In episode 7, Uncle Bob talks about Use Cases and how stories become the titles for them. What I'

unread,

When to write a Use Case

In episode 7, Uncle Bob talks about Use Cases and how stories become the titles for them. What I'

2/6/24

Liviu Gelea, Łukasz Duda5

11/13/23

Usecases, entities and mixed storage

Lately I've been seeing a lot of interesting style that fits well with DDD. Here you will find an

unread,

Usecases, entities and mixed storage

Lately I've been seeing a lot of interesting style that fits well with DDD. Here you will find an

11/13/23

Erick Duarte, Josselin Tillay2

10/11/23

How to use/implement Use Cases in this case

I think you answer the question yourself when you say "implementing the same interface".

unread,

How to use/implement Use Cases in this case

I think you answer the question yourself when you say "implementing the same interface".

10/11/23

Dream Catcher

10/7/23

Nest.js Code Refactoring

I want to refactor these lines. Any advice would be appreciated. ``` @Controller('monday')

unread,

Nest.js Code Refactoring

I want to refactor these lines. Any advice would be appreciated. ``` @Controller('monday')

10/7/23

Terence Kent, … Norbert Nemes8

5/11/23

Trouble squaring the advice for Interface and Adapters & Frameworks and Drivers

Hi Terence! Sure. The problem I have with that diagram is that while it's technically correct, it

unread,

Trouble squaring the advice for Interface and Adapters & Frameworks and Drivers

Hi Terence! Sure. The problem I have with that diagram is that while it's technically correct, it

5/11/23

Erick Duarte

3/30/23

How to use/implement Use Cases in this case?

Hi everybody, Consider an Notification System that handles different notifications (Telegram,

unread,

How to use/implement Use Cases in this case?

Hi everybody, Consider an Notification System that handles different notifications (Telegram,

3/30/23

Kulagin, … Sam Stone4

2/26/23

Clean Coders Slack workspace link is dead

I see that many more organizations use Discord instead of Slack nowadays. For example, the last 2

unread,

Clean Coders Slack workspace link is dead

I see that many more organizations use Discord instead of Slack nowadays. For example, the last 2

2/26/23

Acácio Veit Schneider, Łukasz Duda5

12/6/22

How much should presenters know about the view?

Hi Łukasz, Thank you very much for your responses, it helped a lot to clear out some things :)

unread,

How much should presenters know about the view?

Hi Łukasz, Thank you very much for your responses, it helped a lot to clear out some things :)

12/6/22

nabil ouachi, … Marco Tedone6

12/5/22

Episode 19 - Advanced TDD Part 1 - Mistakes on refactoring

I hope the green bands are still available :-) I made the class public and moved it to the "src/

unread,

Episode 19 - Advanced TDD Part 1 - Mistakes on refactoring

I hope the green bands are still available :-) I made the class public and moved it to the "src/

12/5/22

徳川武, deepbl...@gmail.com4

10/19/22

If the Use Cases must NOT extend the Entities, on which layer of Clean Architecture must be the entities with application-specific properties?

Yes, that is the UI. (I included presenters in the UI layer since it's where they belong). You

unread,

If the Use Cases must NOT extend the Entities, on which layer of Clean Architecture must be the entities with application-specific properties?

Yes, that is the UI. (I included presenters in the UI layer since it's where they belong). You

10/19/22

徳川武

10/11/22

Why the "Use Cases" and "Request and Response Models" are the different sections of the "Business rules" chapter?

Dear everybody, collecting the information about "Which Clean Architecture Areas do Gateways

unread,

Why the "Use Cases" and "Request and Response Models" are the different sections of the "Business rules" chapter?

Dear everybody, collecting the information about "Which Clean Architecture Areas do Gateways

10/11/22

徳川武, … Damian Rossney3

10/3/22

Which Clean Architecture Areas do Gateways interfaces and their implementations belong to?

This is a good question. In my opinion these concepts are better explained in Uncle Bob's talks.

unread,

Which Clean Architecture Areas do Gateways interfaces and their implementations belong to?

This is a good question. In my opinion these concepts are better explained in Uncle Bob's talks.

10/3/22

Pavel Gatilov, … DarkTrick5

7/17/22

Clean Architecture: Gateways (DB, external services) have to violate the Dependency Rule

> You'd write a class that derives from it implements it and call it MySqlPersistence or

unread,

Clean Architecture: Gateways (DB, external services) have to violate the Dependency Rule

> You'd write a class that derives from it implements it and call it MySqlPersistence or

7/17/22

Angga, … Łukasz Duda4

11/19/21

Why Use Case use class form rather than only method?

why do this? with class you can apply command design pattern see some benefits: decouples object that

unread,

Why Use Case use class form rather than only method?

why do this? with class you can apply command design pattern see some benefits: decouples object that

11/19/21

Sebastian Gozin

11/6/21

Event Driven Architecture... but aren't events just a technical detail?

I may be conflating events with messages but as far as I know an event driven architecture will use

unread,

Event Driven Architecture... but aren't events just a technical detail?

I may be conflating events with messages but as far as I know an event driven architecture will use

11/6/21

Orlovsky Consulting GbR

7/11/21

Reading Uncle Bob book Agile Software Development Principles, Patterns, and Practices by Robert C Martin

Hi folks! I reading book Agile Software Development Principles, Patterns, and Practices by Robert C

unread,

Reading Uncle Bob book Agile Software Development Principles, Patterns, and Practices by Robert C Martin

Hi folks! I reading book Agile Software Development Principles, Patterns, and Practices by Robert C

7/11/21

Erandir Junior, … Łukasz Duda9

3/4/21

Adapters and Infrasctructure

So, this is my biggest question about this, how far can I faithfully follow the image proposed by

unread,

Adapters and Infrasctructure

So, this is my biggest question about this, how far can I faithfully follow the image proposed by

3/4/21

Ponsuganth Muthuraman

2/23/21

A Chat with "Uncle Bob" Mr. Martin || Spotlight Lecture || Shaastra, IIT Madras

Hello Clean Code enthusiasts! Shaastra Spotlight brings to you an exciting fireside chat with a

unread,

A Chat with "Uncle Bob" Mr. Martin || Spotlight Lecture || Shaastra, IIT Madras

Hello Clean Code enthusiasts! Shaastra Spotlight brings to you an exciting fireside chat with a

2/23/21

Fabio Ono Tavoloni, Paul Michael Reilly4

12/29/20

Clean Code Series - Part I Explained

Hey guys how are you? This is Part 2 of a new series of articles talking about the concepts of Clean

unread,

Clean Code Series - Part I Explained

Hey guys how are you? This is Part 2 of a new series of articles talking about the concepts of Clean

12/29/20

Tobias Strandberg, … Paul Michael Reilly5

11/6/20

Clean Architecture demystified

Hi Paul, I took your advice! I'm now looking forward to some more feedback :) Regards, Tobias On

unread,

Clean Architecture demystified

Hi Paul, I took your advice! I'm now looking forward to some more feedback :) Regards, Tobias On

11/6/20

Souji Tendo, … Tobias Strandberg3

11/4/20

Clean Architecture with REST api

Hi, this is something that took me a long time to figure out. If you're still interested, please

unread,

Clean Architecture with REST api

Hi, this is something that took me a long time to figure out. If you're still interested, please

11/4/20

Mohammed AMHEND, … Sara ezati7

7/20/20

DDD/CQRS Vs Clean Architecture

Dear Uncle, Hope you are doing well, I have some doubt yet, BCE architect is a presentation tier Arch

unread,

DDD/CQRS Vs Clean Architecture

Dear Uncle, Hope you are doing well, I have some doubt yet, BCE architect is a presentation tier Arch

7/20/20

Rudi Hammad2

6/4/20

Number of arguments according to Uncle Bob

Hi this is a duplicate, please feel free to delete my threads in the forum in you want. All this was

unread,

Number of arguments according to Uncle Bob

Hi this is a duplicate, please feel free to delete my threads in the forum in you want. All this was

6/4/20

Enoc Gutierrez

2/20/20

Re: [CC:3889] Re: Clean Code Slack Workspace

Hi, Please add me to slack group! Thank you. regards. On Thu, 20 Feb 2020 at 02:51, Ashok Raju <

unread,

Re: [CC:3889] Re: Clean Code Slack Workspace

Hi, Please add me to slack group! Thank you. regards. On Thu, 20 Feb 2020 at 02:51, Ashok Raju <

2/20/20

ACP, Łukasz Duda2

2/16/20

Clean Architecture - Responders and Response Interfaces

Hi I use concrete response classes, but conceptualy they represent abstract interface to use cases.

unread,

Clean Architecture - Responders and Response Interfaces

Hi I use concrete response classes, but conceptualy they represent abstract interface to use cases.

2/16/20

Paul Michael Reilly, … Vincent White8

11/27/19

CC Slack Invite

Would it be possible to repost the invite link? It appears to be dead. On Wednesday, 8 May 2019 15:37

unread,

CC Slack Invite

Would it be possible to repost the invite link? It appears to be dead. On Wednesday, 8 May 2019 15:37

11/27/19

Christopher Gardner

11/16/19

Abstract Entities

In the Clean Architecture, UB talks about abstract entities that the database layer implements. I

unread,

Abstract Entities

In the Clean Architecture, UB talks about abstract entities that the database layer implements. I

11/16/19

Jordan Walker, Łukasz Duda2

11/14/19

Should domain entities hold foreign keys or the related objects themselves?

Hi Jordan, Identity is not only database-related. Identity generated by database is only one of a few

unread,

Should domain entities hold foreign keys or the related objects themselves?

Hi Jordan, Identity is not only database-related. Identity generated by database is only one of a few

11/14/19

Cláudio Antônio Peanho

8/14/19

Hello, Please add me to the group. Regards, -- Cláudio Antônio Peanho

unread,

Hello, Please add me to the group. Regards, -- Cláudio Antônio Peanho

8/14/19