Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Of lottery tickets and lightning

7 views
Skip to first unread message

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 9, 2007, 2:29:20 AM6/9/07
to
At about 22:57, there was a big bang, flash of light, all the relays on
the old DEC power supplied clicked, smoke came out of the computer
cabinet, but lights then remained on.


Lightning hit about 30m from our house on a 12kv line that feeds a
townhouse complex across the street from our backdoor neighbours.

Thankfully, there is a fuse between the point of lighting strike and the
upstream 12kv line that also feeds our house and it blew, but not before
allowing some of the surve to propagate on the 12kv line.

That pole is less than 5m from our backdoor neighbour's house.

4 ports on the cisco switch remain amber and are not working. One of
those ports was unused. One was connected to an IMAC on the top floor
(long ethernet cable). The imac's ethernet appears blown. My guess is
that a surge happened either on the imac or on the ethernet cable itseld
(electromagnetic stuff on a long wire) which burned the imac's ethernet
interface and the cisco switch's ports. (I would assume the switch is
built with hardware for each group of 4 ports).

Question: Is it more likely that the imac funneled a power surge to the
ethernet, or is it likely that the nearby lighting caused a current to
flow on the long ethernet cable, burning the ethernet interfaces at both
ends ?

The DSL modem retained DSL sync, but the PPPoE session was zapped when
the cisco switch went down and the router couldn't talk to the modem.


I haven't checked my lottery ticket (drawn 2 hours before lightning),
but I guess I should be a winner :-)

That telephone pole is amongst trees that separate our properties from a
park where there are very tall poles for park lighting. Always though
lightning would hit the tall park lights instead of hitting the shorter
trees next to us.

And the lightning did not hit the pole at its tallest portion. On top
is the relatively thin 12Kv line. It then goes down underground to the
nearby townhouse complex. A fuse links the thin overhead line to a
thicker insulated cable that goes underground to the townhouse complex.
Lighthning hit that insulated cable just before it goes in the metal
conduit that brings it underground.

Initially, it was thought lightning had hit the townhouse complex and
firetrucks were called in. But no visible damage was found.

This is "act of god", so the odds of getting any money back are quite low.

repatch

unread,
Jun 9, 2007, 11:22:27 AM6/9/07
to
On Sat, 09 Jun 2007 02:29:20 -0400, JF Mezei wrote:
> Question: Is it more likely that the imac funneled a power surge to the
> ethernet, or is it likely that the nearby lighting caused a current to
> flow on the long ethernet cable, burning the ethernet interfaces at both
> ends ?

Long ethernet cable, high impedance line = antenna
Lightning strike = very wideband, very high energy RF source

If the power surge had come into the MAC through the power line much more
then the ethernet interface would have been zapped.

This is a perfect example of why long runs of any cable usually are
current loops (i.e. phone lines), their low impedance makes them more
immune to inductive coupling. That said, when you're dealing with the
insane power levels of a lightning strike, even this very modest defense
is usually totally ineffective.

TTYL

chuckcar

unread,
Jun 9, 2007, 11:44:08 PM6/9/07
to
JF Mezei <jfmezei...@vaxination.ca> wrote in
news:b4215$466a48c0$cef8887a$19...@TEKSAVVY.COM:

You got off lucky. I talked to a woman once who had a strike go
*through* her house. Fried the TV, computer, stereo, phone and missed
her son by a couple of feet (went through near the roof). Lightning is
insane. You can't prevent it from doing damage period. 50MV and millions
of amps. Nothing has a chance.

--
(setq (chuck nil) car(chuck) )

DevilsPGD

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 2:07:36 AM6/10/07
to
In message <Xns994AF2C17...@194.177.96.26> chuckcar
<chuc...@nil.org> wrote:

>You got off lucky. I talked to a woman once who had a strike go
>*through* her house. Fried the TV, computer, stereo, phone and missed
>her son by a couple of feet (went through near the roof). Lightning is
>insane. You can't prevent it from doing damage period. 50MV and millions
>of amps. Nothing has a chance.

You can't prevent it, but you certainly can redirect it with a bit of
design forethought.

--
If quitters never win, and winners never quit,
what fool came up with, "Quit while you're ahead"?

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 3:37:30 AM6/10/07
to
chuckcar wrote:
You got off lucky. I talked to a woman once who had a strike go
> *through* her house. Fried the TV, computer, stereo, phone and missed
> her son by a couple of feet (went through near the roof)


By those standards, yes. But I just noticed that my second MAC is now
without sound in/out as well as video in/out. This was in the basement,
and that mac was fully connected to the stereo (video and audio). The
stereo still works though. But they are on different fuses.

Neighbour had a working ethernet for a few minutes on her computer and
then the ethernet went dead.

The tough one is the mac without ethernet. That means no appletalk, no
TCPIP to transfer the data on its disk. This is a mac that still has a
modem so I guess I could use dialup to connect to my server and backup
its drive that way.

Warren Oates

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 7:07:41 AM6/10/07
to
In article <1m4n63h3mlm9ch77r...@4ax.com>,
DevilsPGD <spam_na...@crazyhat.net> wrote:

> >You got off lucky. I talked to a woman once who had a strike go
> >*through* her house. Fried the TV, computer, stereo, phone and missed
> >her son by a couple of feet (went through near the roof). Lightning is
> >insane. You can't prevent it from doing damage period. 50MV and millions
> >of amps. Nothing has a chance.
>
> You can't prevent it, but you certainly can redirect it with a bit of
> design forethought.

Not a direct hit like that. Geez, but you see these people buying 29.99
surge suppressors "in case lightning hits my house." Most powerful force
on earth (well, in the sky, I guess).
--
W. Oates

Tony

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 11:09:29 AM6/10/07
to
Lucky nothing all he needed was a 2 dollar surge protector.

Tony

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 11:10:20 AM6/10/07
to
Chuck jinxed the senators.

chuckcar

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 3:30:49 PM6/10/07
to
JF Mezei <jfmezei...@vaxination.ca> wrote in
news:33ae9$466baa3e$cef8887a$13...@TEKSAVVY.COM:

Take it all in for service. You don't know *what* oculd be fried. And
for future reference: turn them all off when you hear thunder period.

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 6:00:27 PM6/10/07
to
chuckcar wrote:
> Take it all in for service. You don't know *what* oculd be fried. And
> for future reference: turn them all off when you hear thunder period.


I found out that my other mac also was damaged. Sound input and output
(on motherboard) was fried, as well as the video input/output card.


Both the macs that were damaged were powerred off at the time.

However, the stereo was turned on (that is where audio/video connection
to the mac is made).

Malcolm Ferguson

unread,
Jun 10, 2007, 9:52:18 PM6/10/07
to
JF Mezei wrote:
>
> The tough one is the mac without ethernet. That means no appletalk, no
> TCPIP to transfer the data on its disk. This is a mac that still has
> a modem so I guess I could use dialup to connect to my server and
> backup its drive that way.
Why wouldn't you just move the drive?

chuckcar

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 12:10:49 AM6/11/07
to
Malcolm Ferguson <Malcolm_Ferguson@NO_SPAM_PLEASEyahoo.com> wrote in
news:lemuj4-...@news.teksavvy.com:

Void the warrenty maybe? Unless the owner has his A+ that's a very real
possibility.

DevilsPGD

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 2:17:18 AM6/11/07
to
In message <466bdcbe$0$23092$c3e...@news.astraweb.com> Warren Oates
<warren...@gmail.com> wrote:

Not with a $29.99 surge suppressor, no, but yet it can be done with
proper earthing.

Lightning might be powerful, but it's still as lazy as the rest of us.

Tegger

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 9:01:25 AM6/11/07
to
chuckcar <chuc...@nil.org> wrote in
news:Xns994AF2C17...@194.177.96.26:


This happened to my boss two summers ago.

His wife was in the bedroom, which happens to have a skylight. For some
reason she looked up through the skylight, just in time to WATCH the
lightning bolt strike the house on the old TV antenna immediately next
to the skylight. Scared the crap out of her. As she watched the fireball
come down, she thought she was about to die.

The strike killed the outlets, and everything electrical that was
plugged in, but only on one side of the house. The repair bill was over
$25,000.


--
Tegger

j...@sympatico.ca

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 2:09:09 PM6/11/07
to

I am a strong proponent of the $25-$50 power bars due to having numerous
strikes at a distance that impacted hydro, phone and cable. One example
where it hit a tree about 250' from the house, went to the ground, found
its way into the underground cable tv, phone and hydro lines (blowing the
buried wires open in the process). The inexpensive APC power bars did the
trick, BUT sacrificed themselves in the process (which APC's 'insurance'
covered).

One PC had a cheapo $5 no name bar on it, and that PC was wasted...it came
in thru the PC power cord (you could see an arc mark on the motherboard 5V
power connectors) went down the ethernet line, blew 2 ports on the
ethernet switch (which was protected on the AC power side by a proper
power bar), and the port the on matching PC that was plugged into 2nd dead
port on the switch. The one UPS had it's primary side blown (transformer
pieces rattled in the case), but the batteries kept it's PC running.

So for those not-so-direct hits, cheap, decent, power bars and small UPSs
work in most instances, as long as every phone line, cable TV line and AC
line are protected.

Jeff

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 8:40:58 PM6/11/07
to
Silver lining to this:

Backdoor neighbour didn't have that much damage considering the
lighthing hit just a couple metres from his house. (many blown lighbulbs
!). However, his voice (but not DSL) went down.

So the Bell guy came around today. And I found out that we are plugged
onto the second remote in the area, the one with the RDSLAM :-)

Turns out that the lightning caused a piece of wire between the RDSLAM
and the voice cards to burn/short so his voice service was down, while
his DSL still worked.

So next time I have a problem, I know I can get Teksavvy to petition
Bell to move me to the local RDSLAM instead of having me connected all
the way to the CO.


Tony

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 10:15:24 PM6/11/07
to
Who ever honours a warranty today huh? You've got the 3rd world already here
everything made today in China busts before you can even use it. Warranties
huh? That's a good one.

Tony

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 10:17:51 PM6/11/07
to
We don't live in Florida. A little rain? Who cares? We don't get hurricane
season here.

Tegger

unread,
Jun 11, 2007, 10:38:58 PM6/11/07
to
JF Mezei <jfmezei...@vaxination.ca> wrote in news:d8efa$466deba0
$cef8887a$16...@TEKSAVVY.COM:

> Silver lining to this:
>
> Backdoor neighbour didn't have that much damage considering the
> lighthing hit just a couple metres from his house. (many blown lighbulbs
> !). However, his voice (but not DSL) went down.

My boss lost all his phone jacks (and his DSL).


>
> So the Bell guy came around today. And I found out that we are plugged
> onto the second remote in the area, the one with the RDSLAM :-)
>
> Turns out that the lightning caused a piece of wire between the RDSLAM
> and the voice cards to burn/short so his voice service was down, while
> his DSL still worked.
>
> So next time I have a problem, I know I can get Teksavvy to petition
> Bell to move me to the local RDSLAM instead of having me connected all
> the way to the CO.
>
>
>


Lightning really is nasty stuff, isn't it?

--
Tegger

w_tom

unread,
Jun 12, 2007, 1:01:48 PM6/12/07
to
Jeff demonstrates what happens once a surge is permitted inside a
building. It finds destructive paths everywhere. Do you install 100
plug-in protectors that are so overprices and so grossly undersized as
to fail? Of course not. Effective protection has always been about
earthing every wire inside every cable before it can enter the
building.

Meanwhile, 'whole house' protectors from responsible manufacturers
1) talk about the most important feature in protection - earthing,
2) provide protectors that earth surges and remain functional, 3)
provide so much better protection that the human does not even know
the surge existed.

Why did the power bar fail? It was so grossly undersized that its
protector components were disconnected as fast as possible. Why? To
avoid these 'scary pictures':
http://www.hanford.gov/rl/?page=556&parent=554
http://www.westwhitelandfire.com/Articles/Surge%20Protectors.pdf
http://www.ddxg.net/old/surge_protectors.htm
http://www.zerosurge.com/HTML/movs.html

Did the power bar provide protection? Well what protected every
GFCI, smoke detector, heating and cooling controls, etc? Were they
also on protectors? Every appliance already contains the protection
that would be provided by a power bar protector. Why are some
appliances damaged and others not? Depends on the surge path to
earth. That appliance with a power bar. Remove the power bar and its
internal protection probably would have saved that appliance.

Why did damage happen? No one can say where a surge entered until a
complete path to earth ground has been defined. AC electric being a
most common source of incoming and destructive surges. Telephone
lines being a most common source of outgoing surges because the telco
installs a 'whole house' protector on telephone lines (for free).
Those who saw damage on a phone line and assumed the surge enters on
the phone line typically don't even know about that telco installed
protector. A most common source of communication line failure -
incoming on AC electric and outgoing on a telephone line or router to
earth ground.

The least expensive and most effective protection for electronics is
to earth every incoming wire where it enters the building. One
protector instead of hundreds. Surges earthed before entering a
building means protection already inside all appliances is not
overwhelmed.

What provides the protection? Not a protector. A protector is
simply a device to connect to protection. Earthing provides the
protection. Lightning destroys electronics because those transistors
provided a good (and destructive) path to earth. Surges earthed
before entering a building therefore will not overwhelm protection
inside all electronic devices.

Those power bars, UPSes, etc ... where does it even claim to
provide protection from a typically destructive type of surge in
numerical specs? It does not. It claims protection from a type of
surge that is typically not destructive - then lets you assume all
surges are same.

A protector without that dedicated earthing connection - ineffective
protection often promoted by myths rather than by science. Earthing
is the protection. Ineffective protectors avoid all discussion about
earthing. It promotes myths.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 13, 2007, 11:43:56 AM6/13/07
to
w_tom wrote:


The best information on surges and surge protection I have seen is at:
http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf
- the title is "How to protect your house and its contents from
lightning: IEEE guide for surge protection of equipment connected to AC
power and communication circuits" published by the IEEE in 2005 (the
IEEE is the dominant organization of electrical and electronic engineers
in the US).
And also:
http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/practiceguides/surgesfnl.pdf
- this is the "NIST recommended practice guide: Surges Happen!: how to
protect the appliances in your home" published by the US National
Institute of Standards and Technology in 2001

The IEEE guide is aimed at those with some technical background. The
NIST guide is aimed at the unwashed masses.


>
> Why did the power bar fail? It was so grossly undersized that its
> protector components were disconnected as fast as possible. Why? To
> avoid these 'scary pictures':
> http://www.hanford.gov/rl/?page=556&parent=554
> http://www.westwhitelandfire.com/Articles/Surge%20Protectors.pdf
> http://www.ddxg.net/old/surge_protectors.htm
> http://www.zerosurge.com/HTML/movs.html

The hanford link talks about "some older model" power strips and
specifically references the revised US - UL standard, effective 1998,
that requires a thermal disconnect as a fix for overheating MOVs.
Overheating was fixed in the US in 1998. No reason to believe Canada is
different.

As fast as possible? Reputable companies engineer suppressors to
disconnect only when MOVs are failing. With very high ratings, which are
readily available, a plug-in suppressor is not likely to fail.

>
> The least expensive and most effective protection for electronics is
> to earth every incoming wire where it enters the building. One
> protector instead of hundreds. Surges earthed before entering a
> building means protection already inside all appliances is not
> overwhelmed.

To get maximum benefit from phone, CATV, ... entry protectors they have
to be connected in a “single point ground” system - phone, CATV, ...
protector connected with a short wire to the power system earthing wire
at the power service. With a large surge, the ground at the building
will lift above ‘absolute’ ground. You want all ground references to
lift together. The problem created by not having a “single point ground”
is illustrated in the NIST guide starting pdf page 40.

In the US (Canada is probably the same), many houses have signal entry
points distant from the power service allowing this hazard. In this case
the IEEE guide says “the only effective way of protecting the equipment
is to use a multiport protector”. But a wire from the phone entry NID
could be extended to the power service area, a 2nd NID installed, and
phone service distributed from there.

>
> Those power bars, UPSes, etc ... where does it even claim to
> provide protection from a typically destructive type of surge in
> numerical specs? It does not. It claims protection from a type of
> surge that is typically not destructive - then lets you assume all
> surges are same.

Absolute nonsense. MOVs are connected L-G, N-G, L-N. That is all the
possible combinations and all the surge modes. In addition the N-G bond
at power services converts common mode surges to transverse mode surges.

And plug-in suppressors certainly do claim to provide protection.

>
> A protector without that dedicated earthing connection - ineffective
> protection often promoted by myths rather than by science. Earthing
> is the protection. Ineffective protectors avoid all discussion about
> earthing. It promotes myths.

w_ promotes myths rather than science.

The IEEE guide explains plug-in suppressors work by CLAMPING the voltage
on all wires (signal and power) to the common ground at the suppressor.
Plug-in suppressors do not work primarily by earthing. The IEEE guide
explains connection to earth occurs elsewhere. (Read the guide starting
pdf page 40).

Note that all interconnected equipment needs to be connected to the
same plug-in suppressor, or interconnecting wires need to go through the
suppressor. External connections, like phone, CATV, ... also need to go
through the suppressor. Connecting all wiring through the suppressor
prevents damaging voltages between power and signal wires. These
multiport suppressors are described in both the IEEE and NIST guides. A
wireless router has major advantages for surge protection.

Ratings range from junk to very high. Plug-in suppressors with very high
ratings are readily available. And for $25-50. Everything I have read
indicates multiport suppressors with very high ratings are likely to
protect against anything but a very near strike, including the OP's hit.

Maximum protection involves attention to the connection to earth,
"single point ground" for power and signal services, power service
suppressors, and plug-in suppressors for expensive high risk equipment,
like wide screen TVs.

According to NIST guide, US insurance information indicates equipment
most frequently damaged by lightning is
computers with a modem connection
TVs, VCRs and similar equipment (presumably with cable TV
connections).
All can be damaged by high voltages between power and signal wires.

--
bud--

w_tom

unread,
Jun 14, 2007, 11:28:16 PM6/14/07
to
On Jun 13, 11:43 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> The best information on surges and surge protection I have seen is
> at:
>http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf
> - the title is "How to protect your house and its contents from
> lightning: IEEE guide for surge protection of equipment connected to AC
> power and communication circuits" published by the IEEE in 2005 (the
> IEEE is the dominant organization of electrical and electronic engineers
> in the US).
> And also:http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/practiceguides/surgesfnl.pdf
> - this is the "NIST recommended practice guide: Surges Happen!: how to
> protect the appliances in your home" published by the US National
> Institute of Standards and Technology in 2001
>
> The IEEE guide is aimed at those with some technical background. The
> NIST guide is aimed at the unwashed masses.

Bud will eventually turn this thread into name calling. His standard
'cut and paste' post to confuse. His citation Page 42 Figure 8 shows
how a plug-in protector - too far from earth ground and too close to a
TV - earths 8000 volts destructively through that TV. Bud
intentionally misrepresents what his citations state.

Protectors are not protection. Protectors are connecting devices
that earth surges. As Franklin demonstrated in 1752: earth so that
lighting does not find other destructive paths. Lightning that is not
shunted (diverted, connected, clamped, bonded) to earth will find
destructive paths via a church steeple, television, dishwasher, or ...
even wood may become a destructive path to earth.

A protector located where lightning enters a building (and 'less
than 10 foot' to earth) means current need not pass through a TV - as
in Bud's first citation Page 42 Figure 8. We call that effective
protection. Bud will say anything to avoid reality. Bud promotes for
plug-in protector manufactures. Being honest is not his objective.
Then he replies with insults. His above citations even contradict his
claims.

Bud's second citation is also blunt. Earthing (not the protector as
Bud claims) is the protection. From page 6 (Adobe page 8 of 24)
> You cannot really suppress a surge altogether, nor
> "arrest" it. What these protective devices do is
> neither suppress nor arrest a surge, but simply
> divert it to ground, where it can do no harm. So
> a name that makes sense would be "surge diverter"
> but it was not picked. So, for the rest of this
> booklet, we will stick to the most popular "surge
> protector".

Bud claims a plug-in protector will suppress (arrest, stop) a
surge. Will it stop what three miles of sky could not? That is
really what Bud claims when lightning is not diverted to earth long
before getting near to appliances.

How to identify ineffective protectors. Even Bud own citations
define what Bud says is not necessary for protection: earth ground.
The ineffective protector 1) has no dedicated earthing wire, and 2)
manufacturer avoids all discussion about earthing. Notice how Bud
also avoids any discussion about earthing even though IEEE Standards
defines only earthing as protection.

Protectors have met UL1449 standards for 20 years. Bud claims these
protectors do not meet UL1449. He won't say so directly because it's
not really true. His game: deception. Bud cannot deny reality in
those 'scary pictures'.

The story behind those pictures: A grossly undersized protector
either will try to provide protection OR must disconnect fastest to
meet UL1449 requirements. How to increase profits? Undersize it.
Then have it disconnect so quickly as to trigger a "protector failed"
lamp. When a grossly undersized protector fails, the naive will
recommend it to friends. So what protected adjacent electronics?
Does not matter. Ineffective protector has been promoted by myths.

Same surge confronted electronics and protector simultaneously.
Grossly undersized protector disconnected quickly. But same surge was
too small to overwhelm protection inside the appliance. Protection
inside an appliance provided protection. But the naive may assume,
"Protector sacrificed itself to save my computer." Of course not.
Protector was grossly undersized and had no earthing. Either it
disconnected quickly OR we have those 'scary pictures'. Disconnecting
quickly promote myths and more sales.

Meanwhile, properly sized and installed 'whole house' protectors
earth lightning surges. A homeowner should never know a surge existed
- if the protector is properly earthed and properly sized. But these
protectors do not have massive profit margins found in plug-in
protectors.

Responsible manufacturers (Square D, GE, Siemens, Intermatic, Cutler-
Hammer, Leviton, etc) sell properly sized 'whole house' protectors
that remain functional after each surge. Being close to earth ground
and distant from electronics means better protection. A grossly
undersized protector that fails (see its indicator lamp) did not
provide protection. Either it disconnects early or we have those
'scary pictures'.

Where is that undersized and 'scary' protector? On the rug behind a
cabinet? On a desktop full of papers? Remember - in direct
opposition to what Bud has posted - UL1449 has been standard for over
twenty years. Yet 'scary pictures' are a current problem. Same
protector may even earth 8000 volts destructively through an adjacent
TV - Bud's Page 42 Figure 8.

Jeff demonstrated what happens once a surge is permitted inside a
building. Surge inside a building finds destructive paths everywhere.
Do you install 100 plug-in protectors that overpriced and grossly
undersized? Of course not. Effective protection has always been
about earthing every wire before it can enter the building. Bud's
objective is to confuse. Even Ben Franklin demonstrated earthing as
essential to protection. Bud will say anything to convolute that fact
and those 'scary pictures'. 'Whole house' protectors (with dedicated
earthing wire) from above responsible manufacturers are sold in Lowes,
Home Depot, and electrical supply houses. Some for less than $50.
What makes them effective? A short connection to earth.

Bud's citations 'Page 42 Figure 8' and 'Adobe page 8 of 24 (paper
page 6)' demonstrate why plug-in protectors even contribute to
'powered off' appliance damage. No earth ground means no effective
protection. And then we have those 'scary pictures'.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 15, 2007, 4:04:36 AM6/15/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 13, 11:43 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
>> The best information on surges and surge protection I have seen is
>> at:
>> http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf
>> - the title is "How to protect your house and its contents from
>> lightning: IEEE guide for surge protection of equipment connected to AC
>> power and communication circuits" published by the IEEE in 2005 (the
>> IEEE is the dominant organization of electrical and electronic engineers
>> in the US).
>> And also:http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/practiceguides/surgesfnl.pdf
>> - this is the "NIST recommended practice guide: Surges Happen!: how to
>> protect the appliances in your home" published by the US National
>> Institute of Standards and Technology in 2001
>>
>> The IEEE guide is aimed at those with some technical background. The
>> NIST guide is aimed at the unwashed masses.
>

> Bud


> intentionally misrepresents what his citations state.

Read the sources and find out. I provide links.


> Bud promotes for
> plug-in protector manufactures. Being honest is not his objective.

I can only agree with w_ when he said "It is an old political trick.
When facts cannot be challenged technically, then attack the messenger."
My only association with surge protectors is I have some.

> Then he replies with insults.

How pathetic. w_ just called me a stooge for manufacturers.

>
> Bud's second citation is also blunt. Earthing (not the protector as
> Bud claims) is the protection. From page 6 (Adobe page 8 of 24)

What does the NIST guide actually say about plug–in suppressors?
They are "the easiest solution".
And:
"Q - Will a surge protector installed at the service entrance be
sufficient for the whole house?
A - There are two answers to than question: Yes for one-link appliances,
No for two-link appliances [equipment connected to power AND phone or
CATV or....]. Since most homes today have some kind of two-link
appliances, the prudent answer to the question would be NO - but that
does not mean that a surge protector installed at the service entrance
is useless."

>
> How to identify ineffective protectors. Even Bud own citations
> define what Bud says is not necessary for protection: earth ground.
> The ineffective protector 1) has no dedicated earthing wire, and 2)
> manufacturer avoids all discussion about earthing.

w_ has a religious belief (immune from challenge) that surge protection
must use earthing. Thus in his view plug-in suppressors (which are not
well earthed) can not possibly work. The IEEE guide explains plug-in

suppressors work by CLAMPING the voltage on all wires (signal and power)
to the common ground at the suppressor. Plug-in suppressors do not work

primarily by earthing. The guide explains earthing occurs elsewhere.

(Read the guide starting pdf page 40).

> Notice how Bud


> also avoids any discussion about earthing even though IEEE Standards
> defines only earthing as protection.

The IEEE guide was published by - the IEEE. The guide says plug-in
suppressors are effective.

>
> Protectors have met UL1449 standards for 20 years. Bud claims these
> protectors do not meet UL1449. He won't say so directly because it's
> not really true. His game: deception. Bud cannot deny reality in
> those 'scary pictures'.
> http://www.hanford.gov/rl/?page=556&parent=554
> http://www.westwhitelandfire.com/Articles/Surge%20Protectors.pdf
> http://www.ddxg.net/old/surge_protectors.htm
> http://www.zerosurge.com/HTML/movs.html

w_ can’t understand his own hanford link that is about "some older
model" power strips and says overheating was fixed with a revision to
UL1449. That was 1998.
But with no valid technical arguments all w_ has is pathetic scare tactics.

>
> The story behind those pictures: A grossly undersized protector
> either will try to provide protection OR must disconnect fastest to
> meet UL1449 requirements. How to increase profits? Undersize it.

An idiotic argument. Because he has no technical arguments w_ has to
argue using a “grossly undersized” suppressor. It is a red herring.
Suppressors with high ratings are readily available. But “grossly
undersized” is about half of w_’s “argument”.

>
> Meanwhile, properly sized and installed 'whole house' protectors
> earth lightning surges. A homeowner should never know a surge existed
> - if the protector is properly earthed and properly sized.

Whole house suppressors are magically “properly sized” but plug-in
suppressors are “grossly undersized”. What strong logic.


> Remember - in direct
> opposition to what Bud has posted - UL1449 has been standard for over
> twenty years.

w_’s own link says UL1449 was revised to fix overheating. If w_ was
competent at surge protection he would know the revision was 1998.

> Yet 'scary pictures' are a current problem.

A lie. Fixed in 1998.

> Same
> protector may even earth 8000 volts destructively through an adjacent
> TV - Bud's Page 42 Figure 8.

Lacking technical arguments w_ also has to lie about sources that
contradict his belief in earthing.
The illustration in the IEEE guide has a surge coming in on a CATV drop.
There are 2 TVs, one is on a plug-in suppressor. The plug-in suppressor
protects the TV connected to it. It does *not* contribute to damage of
the second TV, which is distant, not adjacent. It reduces the voltage at
the distant TV from 10,000V to 8,000V. The point of the illustration is
"to protect TV2, a second multiport protector located at TV2 is required".

> 'Whole house' protectors (with dedicated
> earthing wire) from above responsible manufacturers are sold in Lowes,
> Home Depot, and electrical supply houses. Some for less than $50.

w_, after requests from several people, has never provided a link to a
$50 suppressor. Or specs for one.
Yet another claim w__ can't back up with a link.

> What makes them effective? A short connection to earth.
>

> No earth ground means no effective
> protection.

And the statement of religious belief in earthing. The question is not
earthing - everyone is for it. The only question is whether plug-in
suppressors work.

Both the IEEE and NIST guides say plug-in suppressors are effective.
Read the sources.

Then read w_'s sources. Never any that say plug-in suppressors do NOT
work. Why no sources w_?

And never explained:
Why the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in
suppressors.
Why the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution".


Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work
Never any sources that say plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.
Twists opposing sources to say the opposite of what they really say.
Attempts to discredit opponents.
w_ is a purveyor of junk science.

--
bud

w_tom

unread,
Jun 15, 2007, 10:57:33 AM6/15/07
to
On Jun 15, 4:04 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> "Q - Will a surge protector installed at the service entrance be
> sufficient for the whole house?
> A - There are two answers to than question: Yes for one-link appliances,
> No for two-link appliances [equipment connected to power AND phone or
> CATV or....]. Since most homes today have some kind of two-link
> appliances, the prudent answer to the question would be NO - but that
> does not mean that a surge protector installed at the service entrance
> is useless."

Two wire appliances (portable phone base station, answering
machine, computer modem, etc) demand that *all* incoming utilities be
earthed to the same point. Bud avoids that fact. Earthed either via a
direct wire (CATV, satellite dish) or via a 'whole house' protector
(telephone, AC electric)..

Telco installs a 'whole house' protector on each incoming phone line
for free. Will that protect portable phone base station or computer
modem? Of course not. AC electric has no earthing connection via a
'whole house' protector. If any incoming utility wire is not properly
earthed then damage may result. One 'whole house' protector will not
solve the problem. Every incoming utiity wire must be earthed. Any
surge permitted in the building means everything is at risk. One
'whole house' protector does not earth every incoming utility wire.

Example: many with computer modem damage assumed "surge came in on
my phone line". How? Telco installed a 'whole house' protector? But
surge enters on AC electric and obtains earth ground via a telco
installed protector. Damage on modem's telephone side is due to an AC
electric surge. One telco provided 'whole house' protector was not
sufficient. AC electric also requires an earthed 'whole house'
protector.

Demonstarted again is why every incoming utility must be earthed -
must connect to the same protection. If permitted inside a building on
any utility wire, then appliances are at risk of becoming that
destructive path to earth. Protection is a single point earth ground
- not some magic plug-in device that will "clamp to nothing".

No way around reality: his plug-in protectors do not even claim to
provide protection from the type of surge that typically causes
damage. Why so much silence? One need only look at what Bud
disparages; what he calls a religion. IEEE Standards and his guides
both state that earthing defines protection. No way around reality.
So Bud misrepresents the facts: including Page 42 Figure 8 in one
guide and Page 8 of 24 (paper page 6)
Yes, one 'whole house' protector on AC mains is not sufficient.
Every incoming utility must have either a 'whole house' protector or a
direct connection to earth. Every incoming utility must be earthed to
the same single point ground. No earth ground means no effective
protection. No way around reality no matter how often Bud disparages
those facts.

How to identify Bud's ineffective protectors. 1) No dedicated
earthing wire for that 'less than 10 foot' connection. 2)
Manufacturer (and Bud) avoid all discussion about earthing. These
protectors that don't even claim to protect from the typically
destructive surge are so massively profitable as to sell even in
Circuit City and Best Buy for over $100. Same circuit is also found
in protectors selling in grocery stores for much less - and still no
claim of protection.

Meanwhile safety problems for current technology power strip
protectors and UL1449 approval are demonstrated in these 'scary
pictures'. This remains reality no matter how Bud tries to spin
myths:

But manufacturer does not even claim to protect from the typically
destructive surge. Profits - not protection - are the agenda. No
earth ground means no effective protection. Undersizing it means even
higher profits - and promotes myths that sell more power strip
protectors.

j...@sympatico.ca

unread,
Jun 15, 2007, 1:23:09 PM6/15/07
to
No question stopping it before entering the house is the way to go, but
since most people won't go to that degree, some sort of protection is
better than none. And it is a lot easier to say to someone to get some
decent power bars (since they probably have to put a power bar on the
computer, etc. anyhow). There is enough evidence that the protection they
provide does work in particular situations, but it is not ideal, I agree
with you there.

Jeff

w_tom

unread,
Jun 15, 2007, 6:35:16 PM6/15/07
to
On Jun 15, 1:23 pm, j...@sympatico.ca wrote:
> No question stopping it before entering the house is the way to go, but
> since most people won't go to that degree, some sort of protection is
> better than none. And it is a lot easier to say to someone to get some
> decent power bars (since they probably have to put a power bar on the
> computer, etc. anyhow). There is enough evidence that the protection they
> provide does work in particular situations, but it is not ideal, I agree
> with you there.

What is this evidence that power bars protected anything? We hear
this often. Something was damaged. But a computer connected to a
power bar protector was not damaged. That proves the power bar did
something? Of course not. What protected smoke detectors? What
protected the dishwasher? What protected the furnace? Were these
also protected by 'invisible' power bar protectors? Protection inside
the computer probably protected the computer.

Damning is what a power bar protector claims. Its numeric specs
don't even claim to provide protection. So what protected the
computer? Numeric specs for the computer define internal protection.

How to kludge protection using a power bar protector? First, find a
wall receptacle that is closest or attached to the breaker box.
Second, cut the power bar's power cord as short as possible. Third,
plug the modified power bar protector into that receptacle. It may
not be ten feet to earth ground. But at least it is shorter to earth
AND distant from electronics.

Page 42 Figure 8 - power bar protector creates damage because it is
too close to electronics and too far from earth ground. Those three
steps kludge (create) an undersized 'whole house' protector to maybe
provide protection. Important is the protector must be significantly
closer to earth ground than to electronics.

Upgrading earthing is so simple. Often required anyway in older
houses that are missing that earth ground. In one case, a home that
was missing earthing exploded when electricity found another path to
earth via the gas meter. When a neutral wire failed in utility's
transformer, a missing earth ground could not save the house.
Earthing necessary to make a protector effective is also necessary for
a long list of other human safety issues. IOW that earthing is so
critical as to not be too difficult.

The bottom line remains: earthing is necessary for human safety.
That earthing installed with care so as to also provide surge
protection. Then a 'kludged' power strip (with 'cut short' power
cord) may provide some computer protection.

What is a decent power bar? Obviously that answer must come with
electrical reasons for WHY. Are big name products from APC, Monster
Cable, Tripplite, etc 'decent power bars'? Then one can say why by
citing numeric specs. Where in those specs are numbers that define
them as 'decent'?

A best power bar is a $3.50 power strip that has no surge protector
components and has its most critical electrical component - a 15 amp
circuit breaker. Then the power bar will not undermine or bypass
protection already inside the computer.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 16, 2007, 10:26:03 AM6/16/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 15, 4:04 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
>> "Q - Will a surge protector installed at the service entrance be
>> sufficient for the whole house?
>> A - There are two answers to than question: Yes for one-link appliances,
>> No for two-link appliances [equipment connected to power AND phone or
>> CATV or....]. Since most homes today have some kind of two-link
>> appliances, the prudent answer to the question would be NO - but that
>> does not mean that a surge protector installed at the service entrance
>> is useless."
>
> Two wire appliances (portable phone base station, answering
> machine, computer modem, etc) demand that *all* incoming utilities be
> earthed to the same point. Bud avoids that fact.

Bullcrap. I have often talked about not only grounding to a single point
but a “single point ground”. The difference is a “single point ground”
by definition uses *short wires* to make the connection from phone,
CATV, ... entry protectors to the earth connection wire at the power
service. They have to be short to prevent a surge earth current on the
connecting wire from producing a large voltage difference between the
signal and power wires.

The IEEE guide (starting pdf page 40) provides an example of what can
happen if the interconnecting wires are too long - thousands of volts
between CATV cables and power wires. In many houses the phone, CATV, ...
service entry points are distant from the power service making a short
interconnect impossible. In that case the IEEE guide says “the only

effective way of protecting the equipment is to use a multiport

protector.” This protection is also illustrated in the IEEE example.
(Another method is to run the phone wire from the entry NID to the power
service area and install a 2nd NID, then distribute the phone wires from
there.)

Note that even if the signal entry protectors are near the power
service, the entry protectors may not be connected with short wires to
the power service earth connection wire.

With a large surge, the house ground reference will rise above
‘absolute’ earth potential. The goal is for the power, phone, CATV, ...
to rise together.

According to NIST guide, US insurance information indicates equipment
most frequently damaged by lightning is
computers with a modem connection
TVs, VCRs and similar equipment (presumably with cable TV
connections).
All can be damaged by high voltages between power and signal wires.

>

> Example: many with computer modem damage assumed "surge came in on
> my phone line". How? Telco installed a 'whole house' protector? But
> surge enters on AC electric and obtains earth ground via a telco
> installed protector. Damage on modem's telephone side is due to an AC
> electric surge. One telco provided 'whole house' protector was not
> sufficient. AC electric also requires an earthed 'whole house'
> protector.

In the IEEE example above (starting pdf page 40) a surge entered on CATV
and exited on power. The damage was caused by not having a “single point
ground” - short bonding wires. A suppressor on the power service would
not have helped at all.

>
> No way around reality: his plug-in protectors do not even claim to
> provide protection from the type of surge that typically causes
> damage.

Absolute nonsense. Plug-in suppressors have MOVs from H-G, N-G, H-N.
That is all possible combinations and all possible surge modes. In
addition the N-G bond at US and Canadian services convert common mode
power surges to transverse mode.

Everything I have read in technical sources indicates multiport plug-in
suppressors with high ratings can protect against any surges but a very
near lightning strike.

> Why so much silence? One need only look at what Bud
> disparages; what he calls a religion. IEEE Standards and his guides
> both state that earthing defines protection. No way around reality.

The question isn’t earthing. The only question is whether plug-in
suppressors work. No way around reality - both guides say they do.

> So Bud misrepresents the facts: including Page 42 Figure 8 in one
> guide and Page 8 of 24 (paper page 6)

I encourage people to read the sources. Unfortunately w_ is not able to
understand the sources because they conflict with his religious belief
in earthing.

> No earth ground means no effective
> protection.
>

> How to identify Bud's ineffective protectors. 1) No dedicated
> earthing wire for that 'less than 10 foot' connection. 2)
> Manufacturer (and Bud) avoid all discussion about earthing.

The required statement of religious belief in earthing.


The IEEE guide explains plug-in suppressors work by CLAMPING the voltage

on all wires (signal and power) to the common ground at the suppressor,
not earthing. The guide explains earthing occurs elsewhere. (Read the

guide starting pdf page 40).

> These


> protectors that don't even claim to protect from the typically
> destructive surge are so massively profitable as to sell even in
> Circuit City and Best Buy for over $100.

For anyone with minimal reading skills manufacturers certainly do claim
to provide surge protection.

And I recently bought a major brand plug-in suppressor for $25 with
ratings of 590J and 30,000A per MOV, 1770J and 90,000A total. But w_
only buys Monster products.

>
> Meanwhile safety problems for current technology power strip
> protectors and UL1449 approval are demonstrated in these 'scary
> pictures'. This remains reality no matter how Bud tries to spin
> myths:
> http://www.hanford.gov/rl/?page=556&parent=554

Lacking technical arguments w_ repeats the lie yet again. His own
hanford source says said overheating was fixed. That was in 1998.


The question is not earthing - everyone is for it. The only question is
whether plug-in suppressors work.

Both the IEEE and NIST guides say plug-in suppressors are effective.
Read the sources.

Never seen - a source that says plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.
Where are the links w_? There must be thousands of them.

And still never explained:
Why do the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in
suppressors.
Why does the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution".


Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work
Never any sources that say plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.
Twists opposing sources to say the opposite of what they really say.
Attempts to discredit opponents.

w_ is still a purveyor of junk science.

--
bud


w_tom

unread,
Jun 17, 2007, 8:07:40 PM6/17/07
to
On Jun 16, 10:26 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> Bullcrap. I have often talked about not only grounding to a single point
> but a "single point ground". The difference is a "single point ground"
> by definition uses *short wires* to make the connection from phone,
> CATV, ... entry protectors to the earth connection wire at the power
> service. They have to be short to prevent a surge earth current on the
> connecting wire from producing a large voltage difference between the
> signal and power wires. ...

That short connection to earthing is what a shunt mode protector
'clamps' to. Now Bud claims earthing is necessary to make a protector
effective? Previously he claimed a protector works by clamping to
nothing. Now a protector works by shunting (clamping, bonding,
connecting) to earth?

One properly earthed 'whole house' protector means protection
inside all appliances is not overwhelmed. That earthed protector
means a surge is not inside the building seeking earth, destructively,
via appliances. An properly earthed 'whole house' protector will not
shunt (clamp, divert, connect) a surge destructively to earth 8000
volts through the TV (Page 42 Figure 8).

A 'whole house protector costs maybe $1 per protected appliance.
Plug-in protector cost tens of times more money - and does not even
claim to protect from the typically destructive surge. How could it?
Where is the deciated earthing wire?

As demonstrated by Page 42 Figure 8 - worst place for a plug-in
protector is adjacent to electronics. But that is also why engineered
facilities put the protector close to earth and far from electronics.
Telcos may even put that protector up to 50 meters distant from
electronics - because telcos need even better protectors; not what Bud
recommends.

If you learn these realities, then Bud did not do his job - promote
plug-in protectors. Bud must post incessantly so that you will waste
money on excessively profitable and typically undersized protectors.
What sometimes happens when protectors are undersized even with
UL1449? 'Scary pictures':

UL1449 only means these scary pictures occur less often. Bud
forgets that reality.

'Scary pictures' are another reason why responsible homeowners earth
a 'whole house' protector from manufacturers that are more responsible
such as Square D, GE, Leviton, Intermatic, Cutler-Hammer, Siemens,
etc. Such protectors are sold even in Lowes and Home Depot - some for
'less than $50. How much money does Bud want you to waste on a plug-
in protector that can even contribute to damage of adjacent
appliances? Monster Cable sells what Bud recommends for $100 or
$150. $150 per protected appliance? Others such as APC, Tripplite,
Belkin, Panamax, etc use the same electrical circuit - and no
effective earthing.

A protector is only as effective as its earth ground. Earthing is
what the effective protector clamps / shunts / diverts / connects /
bonds to. No way around reality of shunt mode protectors. A
protector is only as effective as its earth ground. No earth ground
means no effective protection. Suddenly Bud acknowledges earthing.

j...@sympatico.ca

unread,
Jun 17, 2007, 8:35:08 PM6/17/07
to
The evidence is when the powerbar or UPS fails (such as won't power on,
just blows the internal breaker when it is reset, has physical internal
damage, etc.), yet the device after it continues to function when put
connected to a new power source... and yes, some unprotected devices were
damaged (unprotected TV, and some X10 modules). This is first hand
evidence in mulitple situations... and APC was happy to replace the
damaged power bars and UPS in all of them.

Since most people won't go to the degree of protecting the house as you
describe, some protection is better than none.

It is safe to say we all have our opinions here, so I am going to leave it
at that.. it is heading off topic for can.internet.highspeed.

Jeff

Bud--

unread,
Jun 18, 2007, 10:58:34 AM6/18/07
to
w_tom wrote:

>
> A protector is only as effective as its earth ground.

> A
> protector is only as effective as its earth ground. No earth ground
> means no effective protection.


The required religious belief in earthing.

The question is not earthing - everyone is for it. The only question is

whether plug-in suppressors work. The IEEE guide explains plug-in
suppressors work by clamping, not earthing, and that earthing occurs
elsewhere.

w_ has still not found a link to a source that says plug-in suppressors
are NOT effective.
*Where are the links w_?*

But both the IEEE and NIST guides say plug-in suppressors are effective.
Read the sources.

And still never explained:


Why do the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in
suppressors.
Why does the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution".

*Why no answers w_?*

Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work
Never any sources that say plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.
Twists opposing sources to say the opposite of what they really say.

Invents opinions and attributes them to opponents.

w_tom

unread,
Jun 18, 2007, 7:26:51 PM6/18/07
to
On Jun 18, 10:58 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> w_ has still not found a link to a source that says plug-in suppressors
> are NOT effective.
> *Where are the links w_?*

Bud shows effective protectors in:
http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf
Page 42 Figure 8. The plug-in protector effective earths a surge
through the adjacent TV. 8000 volts effectively destroys the TV
because the protector is too far from earth ground and too close to a
TV. w_tom need not provide any more citations. Bud provides
citations that demonstrate the plug-in protector is effective as
destroying adjacent electronics.

Where are the links? Bud provided them. Page 42 Figure 8. 8000
volts destructively across the TV. Bud calls that effective
protection. Reality calls it ineffective.

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 19, 2007, 1:55:09 AM6/19/07
to
I want to thank those who provided links to various documents about
lightning protection. Lots to think about and some research in the house
to ensure everything is grounded properly and obviously purchase of some
protectors (and I now understand how they work !).

Still not clear about how to protect ethernet and serial lines though.

Heck I hadn't even considered the problems that can happen to an air
conditioner.

w_tom

unread,
Jun 19, 2007, 10:11:15 AM6/19/07
to
On Jun 19, 1:55 am, JF Mezei <jfmezei.spam...@vaxination.ca> wrote:
> Still not clear about how to protect ethernet and serial lines though.

Install for serial port and ethernet lines something equivalent to
what the telco installs for free. For example, this product connects
each wire to earth via RJ-45 connections:
http://www.tripplite.com/products/product.cfm?productID=151
Note the necessary earthing wire.

For communication circuits, a protector must also have low
capacitance. One device that accomplishes this is called a Sidactor:
http://www.littelfuse.com/cgi-bin/r.cgi/new_prod_landing.html?LandingID=1

For serial port lines such as RS-232, a protector voltage may be 50
volts clamped to earth. For telephone lines, the same device (as
installed for free by the telco) would be 300 volts clamped to earth.
The RJ-45 type protector for ethernet is only 7.5 volts clamped to
that earthing wire. Sidactors vary from 130 volts to 400 volts.
Various protectors to be selected based upon electrical
characteristics of that communication port such as its trigger or let-
through voltage.

Probably a days worth of technical facts and discussions about
earthing were listed in reply to H. W. Stockman in
alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus on 30 Mar 2005 entitled "UPS unit
needed for the P4C800E-Deluxe"
http://makeashorterlink.com/?X61C23DCA

To better appreciate the nuances of earthing, review highly regarded
application notes from Polyphaser. Important for earthing is a
connection that has no sharp bends, no splices, short as possilbe
('less than 10 feet'), separated from other non-earthing wires, not
inside metallic conduit, and not connected to other earthing wires
until all meet as the single point earthing electrode.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 19, 2007, 12:01:17 PM6/19/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 18, 10:58 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
>> w_ has still not found a link to a source that says plug-in suppressors
>> are NOT effective.
>> *Where are the links w_?*
>
> Bud shows effective protectors in:
> http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf
> Page 42 Figure 8. The plug-in protector effective earths a surge
> through the adjacent TV. 8000 volts effectively destroys the TV
> because the protector is too far from earth ground and too close to a
> TV. w_tom need not provide any more citations. Bud provides
> citations that demonstrate the plug-in protector is effective as
> destroying adjacent electronics.

Repeating yet again:


"The illustration in the IEEE guide has a surge coming in on a CATV
drop. There are 2 TVs, one is on a plug-in suppressor. The plug-in
suppressor protects the TV connected to it. It does *not* contribute to
damage of the second TV, which is distant, not adjacent. It reduces the
voltage at the distant TV from 10,000V to 8,000V. The point of the
illustration is "to protect TV2, a second multiport protector located at
TV2 is required"."

Saying the plug-in suppressor damaged the distant TV is a lie.

Provide an explanation of how the plug-in suppressor made the condition
at the distant TV [8,000V] any worse than if the plug-in suppressor was
not present [10,000V].

Having no technical arguments w_ has to twist the IEEE guide to say the
opposite of what it actually says.


And still never seen - a link to a source that says plug-in suppressors
are NOT effective.
*Still links w_?* There must be thousands of links *if* you are right.

Both the IEEE and NIST guides say plug-in suppressors are effective.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 19, 2007, 1:27:31 PM6/19/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 19, 1:55 am, JF Mezei <jfmezei.spam...@vaxination.ca> wrote:
>> Still not clear about how to protect ethernet and serial lines though.
>
> Install for serial port and ethernet lines something equivalent to
> what the telco installs for free. For example, this product connects
> each wire to earth via RJ-45 connections:
> http://www.tripplite.com/products/product.cfm?productID=151
> Note the necessary earthing wire.

But Tripplite says to connect the earthing wire to workstations - how
could the device possibly work if it doesn’t have a “less than 10 foot
connection to earth”?

In a surge event the potential between different “ground” points can be
thousands of volts. Carefully consider where you connect the ground
lead. Connection to the equipment the com line connects to should be
good. You probably need a device at each end of the line.

>
> For communication circuits, a protector must also have low
> capacitance. One device that accomplishes this is called a Sidactor:
> http://www.littelfuse.com/cgi-bin/r.cgi/new_prod_landing.html?LandingID=1

A component - good if you want to roll-your-own.

>
> For serial port lines such as RS-232, a protector voltage may be 50
> volts clamped to earth. For telephone lines, the same device (as
> installed for free by the telco) would be 300 volts clamped to earth.
> The RJ-45 type protector for ethernet is only 7.5 volts clamped to
> that earthing wire. Sidactors vary from 130 volts to 400 volts.
> Various protectors to be selected based upon electrical
> characteristics of that communication port such as its trigger or let-
> through voltage.
>
> Probably a days worth of technical facts and discussions about
> earthing were listed in reply to H. W. Stockman in
> alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus on 30 Mar 2005 entitled "UPS unit
> needed for the P4C800E-Deluxe"
> http://makeashorterlink.com/?X61C23DCA

I particularly like the response to w_’s post: “After now seeing the
later portions of the thread, it has become abundantly clear that
"w_tom" is a troll, subtype: frothing loon.”

At least 4 of the links are now bad. You may want to remove this link
from your repertory w_.

----------------
Other answers to protection:

If using a plug-in suppressor, connect everything to the same plug-in
suppressor so there are no interconnecting wires going to equipment not
connected to that suppressor This is usually practical for RS-232. Use
suppressors with adequate ratings.

I think the IEEE guide said some plug-in suppressors have modules for
various com lines that can be added.

Use wireless routers.

Use fiber optic links (not likely in a house).

>
> To better appreciate the nuances of earthing, review highly regarded
> application notes from Polyphaser. Important for earthing is a
> connection that has no sharp bends, no splices, short as possilbe
> ('less than 10 feet'), separated from other non-earthing wires, not
> inside metallic conduit, and not connected to other earthing wires
> until all meet as the single point earthing electrode.
>

The practice I have seen everywhere is to connect the earthing wire from
phone, CATV, ... to the earthing wire from the power service near the
power service, not at the earthing electrode. A large surge current to
earth will in all cases lift the house "ground" above 'absolute' earth
potential. You want the grounds for power, phone, CATV, ... to rise
together - short interconnects.


One thing in your house you might want to check in particular is if you
have a “single point ground” - as in the paragraph above.

--
bud--

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 19, 2007, 4:25:49 PM6/19/07
to
Bud-- wrote:
> Both the IEEE and NIST guides say plug-in suppressors are effective.
> Read the sources.

There is a caveat to this.

plug-in supressors are effective only for the device very near to them.

The issue I think with the 2 TV example is that by having 2 supperssors
(one for each TV) at some distance to each other does not garantee that
there will not be any voltage differences between the 2 sites and hence
does not garantee that no current will flow through the coax that links
those 2 separate sites in the house.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 20, 2007, 11:04:44 AM6/20/07
to
JF Mezei wrote:
> Bud-- wrote:
>> Both the IEEE and NIST guides say plug-in suppressors are effective.
>> Read the sources.
>
> There is a caveat to this.
>
> plug-in supressors are effective only for the device very near to them.

At least everything has to connect to the same plug-in suppressor or
external connections (phone, CATV, ethernet)have to go through the
suppressor. You can't extend that very far.

>
> The issue I think with the 2 TV example is that by having 2 supperssors
> (one for each TV) at some distance to each other does not garantee that
> there will not be any voltage differences between the 2 sites and hence
> does not garantee that no current will flow through the coax that links
> those 2 separate sites in the house.

Quite right. If you get a surge event you can pretty well guarantee
there will be a voltage difference between the 2 suppressors. But that
is exactly why you need multiport suppressors. Everything has to be
plugged in to the same suppressor or external connections (in particular
CATV) must go through the suppressor. The case is made very clearly in
the IEEE guide for people, like you, who read it. It is also in the NIST
guide. And I made this point in my first post. It is probably not well
understood by users, although manufacturers are likely to explain it for
those who RTFM.

As noted in another post, US insurance information indicates equipment
most likely to be damaged by lightning is computers with modem
connection and TV related equipment - presumably with CATV connection.
All can be damaged by surge between signal and power and can be
protected with multiport suppressors. One would suspect that the damaged
equipment did not have a good single point ground at service entrances.


----------------------
Another guide you might be interested in is:
http://www.eeel.nist.gov/817/pubs/spd-anthology/files/Troubleshoot%20PQ.pdf
It is particularly good on surges generated by power line switching,
which are generally the most damaging surges after lightning. It was
written by Francois Martzloff, the author of the NIST guide, for phone
service reps for co-op power utilities, and is more technical than the
IEEE guide
Among Martzloff's comments: "In fact, the major cause of TVSS [surge
suppressor] failures is a temporary overvoltage, rather than an
unusually large surge."


In the unlikely event that you are looking for even more, Martzloff has
an surge protection anthology at:
http://www.eeel.nist.gov/817/pubs/spd-anthology/
It includes a large number of sources.

One, in particular is:
http://www.eeel.nist.gov/817/pubs/spd-anthology/files/Neutral%20earthing.pdf
Which describes where the surge current goes in near worst case
lightning strikes to a house.

Another is:
http://www.eeel.nist.gov/817/pubs/spd-anthology/files/Revisiting.pdf
Investigates the energy absorbed in plug–in suppressors at different
distances from the power service and different surge strengths. The
surge will produce arc-over at the service at about 6,000V (US), which
can dissipate a lot of the surge energy. In most cases surprisingly
little energy makes it to the plug-in suppressor.

--
bud--

w_tom

unread,
Jun 20, 2007, 10:07:15 PM6/20/07
to
On Jun 20, 11:04 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> At least everything has to connect to the same plug-in suppressor or
> external connections (phone, CATV, ethernet)have to go through the
> suppressor. You can't extend that very far.

Bud is now back to claiming his 'six ports' solution. Bud made
these claims years ago. Bud assumes heat ducts, wood floor, linoleum,
some wall paints, and even concrete are not conductive. Since they
are conductive, then 'six port' protection cannot exist. As his own
paper notes, if only one port is conductive, then the entire
protection system is defeated. Even one kid connecting his X-box to a
TV defeats that protection. House occupants must be taught
engineering principles? Yes, for his six port solution to work. And
it still costs tens (many a hundred) times more money per protected
appliance. Ineffective - and costs more money.

Martzloff even notes problems with a solution that only exists in-
vitro. Martzloff's first conclusion in his 1996 paper defines
reality:
> Conclusion:
> 1) Quantitative measurements in the Upside-Down house clearly
> show objectionable difference in reference voltages. These occur
> even when or perhaps because, surge protective devices are
> present at the point of connection of appliances.

Same conclusion is demonstrated on Page 42 Figure 8 in another Bud
citation:
http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf

Not only does a plug-in protector earth 8000 volts destructively
through an adjacent TV. A plug-in protector may need protection
provided by a properly earthed 'whole house' protector:
> AC and signal surge protectors at the building entrance...
> collect the major part of the lightning surge currents coming
> in on external wiring, and direct them harmlessly into the
> building ground. They also limit the surge voltages that get
> inside the building, and greatly reduce the burden on the
> point-of-use protectors, at the equipment.

What happens when the 'burden' is too large on grossly undersized
plug-in protectors? 'Scary pictures':

Even Martzloff notes this problem with plug-in protectors. Bud just
forgets to cite Martzloff's above and first conclusion.

Meanwhile Bud's claim of 'clamping to nothing' is contradicted by
his citation, paragraph 5.0 on page 45:
> ... all surge currents which come in from AC wiring and
> signal connections are disposed of via the AC (green
> wire) ground, back to the building ground.

Using other quotes from his citations, more examples of Bud's
contradiction are posted in a reply to newsgroup alt.comp.hardware
entitled "Lightning protection" on 20 Jun 2007 at:
http://tinyurl.com/2l3mfb

Even Martzloff says plug-in protectors can contribute to damage of
adjacent electronics. Martzloff does not mention that a kid with an X-
box can also completely compromise plug-in protection. Bud ignores
that problem - pretends it does not exist. Just like he ignores no
manufacturer numerical specs claim what Bud posts. Just more reasons
why responsible homeowners earth only one 'whole house' protector from
any of many 'responsible' manufacturers (names posted previously).
With a 'whole house' protector, an Xbox kid need not be taught
electrical engineering.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 21, 2007, 12:09:03 PM6/21/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 20, 11:04 am, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
>> At least everything has to connect to the same plug-in suppressor or
>> external connections (phone, CATV, ethernet)have to go through the
>> suppressor. You can't extend that very far.

> House occupants must be taught
> engineering principles?

In w_’s opinion, to use a plug-in suppressor you have to engineer the
whole room it is in.
w_ really must write to the 6 EE authors of the guides and point out
their neglect of this issue.


> Martzloff's first conclusion in his 1996 paper defines
> reality:

w_ forgets to mention that Martzloff said in the same document:
"Mitigation of the threat can take many forms. One solution. illustrated
in this paper, is the insertion of a properly designed surge reference
equalizer [multiport plug-in surge suppressor]."

>
> Same conclusion is demonstrated on Page 42 Figure 8 in another Bud
> citation:
> http://omegaps.com/Lightning%20Guide_FINALpublishedversion_May051.pdf
>
> Not only does a plug-in protector earth 8000 volts destructively
> through an adjacent TV.

The lie repeated.
But still not explained - how does the plug-in suppressor made the

condition at the distant TV [8,000V] any worse than if the plug-in
suppressor was not present [10,000V].

>

> What happens when the 'burden' is too large on grossly undersized
> plug-in protectors? 'Scary pictures':
> http://www.hanford.gov/rl/?page=556&parent=554

The 2nd lie repeated.
w_’s hanford link says overheating was fixed by a UL revision. That was
in 1998.

>
> Using other quotes from his citations, more examples of Bud's
> contradiction are posted in a reply to newsgroup alt.comp.hardware
> entitled "Lightning protection" on 20 Jun 2007 at:
> http://tinyurl.com/2l3mfb

More of the same drivel from w_.

> Just like he ignores no
> manufacturer numerical specs claim what Bud posts.

Just as w_ can’t understand the IEEE and NIST guides or Martzloff, he
can’t understand manufacturer specs.


Both the IEEE and NIST guides say multiport plug-in suppressors are
effective. Read the sources.

Then read w_'s sources that says plug-in suppressors are NOT effective
- there are none.
*Why no links w_?* Still can’t find any.


And still never explained:
Why do the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in

suppressors?
Why does the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution"?
Why did Martzloff say in the “surging” paper "One solution. illustrated
in this paper, is the insertion of a properly designed surge reference
equalizer [multiport plug-in surge suppressor]”?
*Why no answers w_?*

Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work
Never any sources that say plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.

Twists opposing sources to say the opposite of what they really say -
IEEE guide, Martzloff, hanford.

w_tom

unread,
Jun 22, 2007, 1:09:41 PM6/22/07
to
On Jun 19, 10:11 am, w_tom <w_t...@usa.net> wrote:
> Probably a days worth of technical facts and discussions about
> earthing were listed in reply to H. W. Stockman in
> alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus on 30 Mar 2005 entitled "UPS unit
> needed for the P4C800E-Deluxe"
> http://makeashorterlink.com/?X61C23DCA

Many links that expired in that previous post are corrected.

An industry benchmark in protection is Polyphaser. Their app notes
don't discuss a product line. Polyphaser is about real protection.
Polyphaser instead discuss earthing - extensively - since earthing
(not a protector) provides the protection:
http://www.polyphaser.com/technical_notes.aspx
Another real world provider of hardware protection also provides
extensive app notes:
http://www.mtlsurgetechnologies.com/downloads/tans/index.htm

Figure from an industry professional demonstrates the concept.
Destructive transients enter even via underground wires. Each of two
structures has it own single point earth ground. For even better
protection, those two grounds are connected by an underground wire:
http://www.erico.com/public/library/fep/technotes/tncr002.pdf

A more complex discussion with numbers entitled "Safe Coordination
Between Power and Communication Surge Protection":
http://www.terracon.com.au/includes/products/downloads/ERA-Paper.pdf

A utility provides further description of bad, ugly and good
solutions to single point earthing:
http://www.cinergy.com/surge/ttip08.htm

Figure from the National Institute of Standards and Technology
demonstrate how multiple earthing points would contribute to damage of
a fax machine:
http://www.epri-peac.com/tutorials/sol01tut.html ????

TD1003: How to make a "single point ground" when ...
http://tinyurl.com/3y747k

w_tom

unread,
Jun 22, 2007, 1:17:27 PM6/22/07
to
On Jun 21, 12:09 pm, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> More of the same drivel from w_.
>
> Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work

Yep. They work just fine putting 8000 volts destructively through
that adjacent TV. Bud's own citation - Page 42 Figure 8. Bud also
forgets to mention: plug-in power strip manufacturers do not even
claim to protect from the typically destructive surge. Why does Bud
forget to mention that? It does not even claim to provide that
protection? His own citations say why.

Bud's citations state a protector needs earth ground. Diverting to
earth is repeatedly mentioned. Bud denies it. Bud claims "clamping
to nothing" works just fine. So the adjacent power strip protector had
to clamp to earth 8000 volts destructively through a TV - Page 42
Figure 8. How curious. Martzloff says the same thing in his 1996
IEEE paper. Why does Bud also ignore Martzloff's very first
conclusion in that paper? Why does Bud ingore Page 42 Figure 8. Why
does Bud pretend that current technology protectors still may create
those 'scary pictures' ... when plug-in proectors are grossly
undersized.

Bud promotes for plug-in protector manufacturers. His reality is
not concerned with homowner's safety or effective protection. Take a
three fifty power strip. Add some ten cent parts. Sell it for $25 or
$150 dollars. Bud must pervert facts. Profits being too high to be
honest.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 24, 2007, 1:47:49 PM6/24/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 21, 12:09 pm, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
>> More of the same drivel from w_.
>>
>> Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work
>
> Yep. They work just fine putting 8000 volts destructively through
> that adjacent TV. Bud's own citation - Page 42 Figure 8.

And having no technical arguments w_ repeats the lie again.

But w_ still has not not explained how the plug-in suppressor made the
condition [8,000V] at the distant TV any worse than if the plug-in

suppressor was not present [10,000V].

w_ just continues to repeat the same drivel.


But he still can't find a source that says plug-in suppressors are NOT
effective.
*Still no links w_?*

Both the IEEE and NIST guides say multiport plug-in suppressors are
effective. Read the sources.

And still never explained by w_:


Why do the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in
suppressors?
Why does the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution"?
Why did Martzloff say in the “surging” paper "One solution. illustrated
in this paper, is the insertion of a properly designed surge reference
equalizer [multiport plug-in surge suppressor]”?

*Simple questions - still no answers w_?*

Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work

Never any sources that say plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.
Twists opposing sources to say the opposite of what they really say -

IEEE guide, Martzloff.
Still tries to discredit opponents.

JF Mezei

unread,
Jun 24, 2007, 6:08:20 PM6/24/07
to
Bud-- wrote:
> But w_ still has not not explained how the plug-in suppressor made the
> condition [8,000V] at the distant TV any worse than if the plug-in
> suppressor was not present [10,000V].

This was explained in the IEEE document.

Say you have a CD player on a surge suppressor. Your amplifier is not.

10000 volts enter the system.

If neither units are on surge prtection, there will not be a voltage
difference between the two units as they both rise to 10000 volts, and
this, no current flowing on the audio lines.

If one of the two has surge supression, then there will be a large
voltage difference between the stereo and CD and current will flow on
the audio line from the stereo to the CD unit thus damaging the low
voltage audio circuitry.

Bud--

unread,
Jun 25, 2007, 2:11:32 PM6/25/07
to


You are correct. It is nice that someone has read the guide and
understands it.

But w_'s comment is specific to the IEEE guide "Page 42 Figure 8". In
that example the plug-in suppressor reduced the risk at the distant 2nd
TV. It did not put "8000 volts destructively through that adjacent TV" -
the surge did that. Although the suppressor reduced the risk, the
purpose of the illustration is "to protect TV2, a second multiport
protector located at TV2 is required". What w_ said is simply not true.

In the example w_ uses, the 10kV surge differential is the result of a
surge entering on the CATV service, not the clamping action of a plug-in
suppressor as in your example. The clamping action in the IEEE
illustration produces no risk to the distant TV.

w_'s argument is that plug-in suppressors never work because they have
an inadequate earth connection. *w_ must then discredit the IEEE guide
and twist what it says because the guide contradicts him.*


If w_ made the argument you made, I would repeat what I said in my 1st
post - all equipment must be connected to the same suppressor or
interconnecting lines need to go through the suppressor. But that is not
what w_ said.


A minor point, you wouldn't get 10kV on power wiring inside the house.
There would be arc-over at about 6kV (US) at the panel or receptacles.
Clamping action at a plug-in suppressor would lower that voltage at the
suppressor with respect to the system "ground" at the power panel.

--
bud--

w_tom

unread,
Jun 28, 2007, 12:33:24 PM6/28/07
to
On Jun 22, 1:09 pm, w_tom <w_t...@usa.net> wrote:

> On Jun 19, 10:11 am,w_tom<w_t...@usa.net> wrote:
>> Probably a days worth of technical facts and discussions about
>> earthing were listed in reply to H. W. Stockman in ...
>> http://makeashorterlink.com/?X61C23DCA

Adding more corrections to that 22 Jun 2007 post:

TD1003: How to make a "single point ground" when ...
http://tinyurl.com/3y747k

TD1023: Multiple I/O port protection, Single Point Ground
considerations.
http://www.polyphaser.com/NR/rdonlyres/C1565001-F81A-4AC2-A98F-E88B8037F988/189/TD1023.pdf

Another from Polyphaser demonstrates same type damage from an incoming
buried wire :
TD1026: Telephone room grounding and protection
http://tinyurl.com/38v2dv
> Lightning strikes somewhere across the street close to the
> below grade West cable vault. ... The first line of defense
> is the telco protection panel, but the panel must be connected
> to a low resistance / inductance ground. There was no adequate
> ground available in the telephone room.


Examples of numerous earthing methods so that cell phone electronics
routinely suffer direct lightning strike without damage:
(see ground network on page 14)
http://www.primoinc.com/Files/Ground_fault_testing.pdf
http://www.leviton.com/pdfs/spdrefman/spdrefman.pdf

Fundamentals on Lightning Protection Grounding and Surge
Suppression
http://members.cox.net/pc-usa/station/grounding.htm
http://members.cox.net/pc-usa/station/basics.htm
http://members.cox.net/pc-usa/station/ground3.htm


Some testimony from industry professionals with extensive
experience:
http://www.telebyteusa.com/primer/ch6.htm
See Section 6.4: WHEN SHOULD YOU WORRY ABOUT LIGHTNING?
> Conceptually, lightning protection devices are switches to
> ground. Once a threatening surge is detected, a lightning
> protection device grounds the incoming signal connection
> point of the equipment being protected. Thus, redirecting
> the threatening surge on a path-of-least resistance
> (impedance) to ground where it is absorbed.
> Any lightning protection device must be composed of two
> "subsystems," a switch which is essentially some type of
> switching circuitry and a good ground connection-to allo
> dissipation of the surge energy.


http://www.harvardrepeater.org/news/lightning.html
> Well I assert, from personal and broadcast experience spanning
> 30 years, that you can design a system that will handle *direct
> lightning strikes* on a routine basis. It takes some planning
> and careful layout, but it's not hard, nor is it overly
> expensive. At WXIA-TV, my other job, we take direct lightning
> strikes nearly every time there's a thunderstorm. Our downtime
> from such strikes is almost non-existant. The last time we
> went down from a strike, it was due to a strike on the power
> company's lines knocking *them* out, ...
> Since my disasterous strike, I've been campaigning vigorously
> to educate amateurs that you *can* avoid damage from direct
> strikes. The belief that there's no protection from direct
> strike damage is *myth*. ...
> The keys to effective lightning protection are surprisingly
> simple, and surprisingly less than obvious. Of course you
> *must* have a single point ground system that eliminates all
> ground loops. And you must present a low *impedance* path for
> the energy to go. That's most generally a low *inductance*
> path rather than just a low ohm DC path.


Sun Microsystems also describes this widely understood concept:
Planning guide for Sun Server room
Section 6.4.7 Lightning Protection:
http://docs.sun.com/source/805-5863-13/ch6.html
> Lightning surges cannot be stopped, but they can be diverted.
> The plans for the data center should be thoroughly reviewed to
> identify any paths for surge entry into the data center. Surge
> arrestors can be designed into the system to help mitigate the
> potential for lightning damage within the data center. These
> should divert the power of the surge by providing a path to
> ground for the surge energy. Protection should be placed on
> both the primary and secondary side of the service transformer.
> It is also necessary to protect against surges through the
> communications lines. The specific design of the lightning
> protection system for the data center will be dependent on the
> design of the building and utilities and existing protection
> measures.


Above discuss the secondary protection system. Homeowner must also
inspect his primary protection system:
http://www.tvtower.com/fpl.html

Electronic transient damage is typically from external events. In
simpler terms, every wire entering the appliance is connected to a
large 'antenna' system that is also on utility poles. Those AC
utility and telephone wires are no different than antennas connected
to communication system (when discussing protection). And so we learn
from those who most often suffer direct strikes without transistor
damage. Some testimonies on protection effectiveness and the
principles that make transistor protection effective:
http://scott-inc.com/html/ufer.htm
http://www.psihq.com/iread/strpgrnd.htm
http://www.psihq.com/iread/ufergrnd.htm
http://www.arcelect.com/lightnin.htm
http://www.dbstalk.com/ekb/87 (What is a "ground block" for?)


http://www.eham.net/articles/6848?ehamsid=61915ecd56a94ff1e861e080ac23c416
Electrical Code vs. Good RF Grounding by K9KJM on 22 November 2003
followed by discussion.
> Those who say "nothing will withstand a direct lightning strike"
> are very misinformed. My towers take direct lightning hits most
> every big storm. So do most all tall commercial towers. With NO
> damage!

Bill Otten testimony of enhanced grounding for lightning protection:
http://home1.gte.net/res0958z/

Orange County Emergency Response system in Apopka FL upgraded by
installing earth grounds:
http://www.psihq.com/AllCopper.htm

Another electrical engineer who I am told is highly regarded in the
stereo industry:
http://www.svconline.com/mag/avinstall_surge_protectionthe_enemy/

Same principles also apply to boat protection:
http://www.thomson.ece.ufl.edu/lightning/

Protectors are only connecting devices to earth ground. "... with
the prerequisite however that the tower is adequately earthed."
Protectors for high voltage transmission lines do same in this ABB
video:
http://tinyurl.com/2bwlhn

Is your earthing adequate or do you need deeper grounding? "Deep
Earth Grounding vs Shallow Earth Grounding":
http://www.cpccorp.com/deep.htm

However from USAF MIL-STD-1542B
> This Standard, MIL-HDBK-419, and MIL-STD-188-124 do not
> recommend the use of deep wells for the achievement of
> lower impedance to earth. Deep wells achieve low dc
> resistance, but have very small benefit in reducing ac
> impedance. The objective of the earth electrode subsystem
> is to reduce ac and dc potentials between and within
> equipment. If deep wells are utilized as a part of the
> earth electrode subsystem grounding net, the other
> portion of the facility ground network shall be connected
> to them."

Bud--

unread,
Jun 29, 2007, 1:39:36 PM6/29/07
to
w_tom wrote:

>
> Adding more corrections to that 22 Jun 2007 post:
>

w_ makes no mention, so apparently he still hasn’t found a link that
says pug-in suppressors are NOT effective. What a surprise.

About 1/3 of his links are about commercial/ham antennas - a fetish for
w_. May be of interest if you plan to construct a 100 foot lightning
rod (aka tower antenna) in your yard and connect it to your wide screen
TV. Not useful for the rest of us.

Some links are useful if you plan to install a 10,000 line telephone
‘switch’ in you basement. Or a commercial raised floor computer room.

Some others may actually be generally useful.

But nothing specific about plug-in suppressors - w_ is just changing
the subject.

Oh, except
> http://www.leviton.com/pdfs/spdrefman/spdrefman.pdf
includes plug-in suppressors.

Look at the IEEE and NIST guides - both say multiport plug-in
suppressors are effective.

Still never explained by w_:


Why do the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in
suppressors?
Why does the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution"?
Why did Martzloff say in the “surging” paper "One solution. illustrated
in this paper, is the insertion of a properly designed surge reference
equalizer [multiport plug-in surge suppressor]”?

*Simple questions - why no answers w_?*

--
bud--

w_tom

unread,
Jun 30, 2007, 10:42:41 AM6/30/07
to
On Jun 29, 1:39 pm, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
> About 1/3 of his links are about commercial/ham antennas - a fetish for
> w_. May be of interest if you plan to construct a 100 foot lightning
> rod (aka tower antenna) in your yard and connect it to your wide screen
> TV. Not useful for the rest of us.

Bud who is dependent on grossly excessive profits from undersized
plug-in protectors will say anything to protect those sales.
Meanwhile, every household appliance is connected to something
electrically equivalent to antennas. Every appliance connects to
utility wires at the street. A strike down the street to AC electric
wires (overhead or underground) is a direct strike into household
appliances. Just like lightning striking an antenna.

Where was lightning protection for householf appliances first
learned? Same soltution to protect radio stations also protects
household appliances. Bud knew that when posting his myths.

Bud makes this same bogus claim only to protect profits. He
receives this same response which he must ignore. Bud knows a radio
station antenna is struck and carries that surge into radio
electronics for the same reason that AC electric wire is struck and
carries that surge into household appliances. Destructive surge seeks
earth ground. Either a surge is earthed before entering a building;
or surge gets earthed destructively through electronics. Page 42
Figure 8 shows how a plug-in protector can earth a surge 8000 volts
destructively through a TV. Surge damage because the protector is too
close to TV and too far from earth ground. Lessons learned even by
early 20th Century ham radio operators - the technology that well
proven.

Bud knows he is lying. Even his own citaion - Page 42 Figure 8 -
demonstrates how a plug-in protector contributes to adjacent appliance
damage - 8000 volts destructively. But if he keeps posting
deceptions, then sales will get promoted. Neither honesty nor ethics
is Bud's objective. He is promoting plug-in protectors. No earth
ground means no effective protection. He must deny that reality.

Bud--

unread,
Jul 2, 2007, 9:45:52 AM7/2/07
to
w_tom wrote:
> On Jun 29, 1:39 pm, Bud-- <remove.BudN...@isp.com> wrote:
>> About 1/3 of his links are about commercial/ham antennas - a fetish for
>> w_. May be of interest if you plan to construct a 100 foot lightning
>> rod (aka tower antenna) in your yard and connect it to your wide screen
>> TV. Not useful for the rest of us.
>


Sill no source that says plug-in suppressors are NOT effective. w_'s
long list of links is just changing the subject.
*Still can't find relevant links links w_?*

But both the IEEE and NIST guides say multiport plug-in suppressors are
effective.

And still never explained by w_:


Why do the only 2 examples of protection in the IEEE guide use plug-in
suppressors?
Why does the NIST guide says plug-in suppressors are "the easiest solution"?
Why did Martzloff say in the “surging” paper "One solution. illustrated
in this paper, is the insertion of a properly designed surge reference
equalizer [multiport plug-in surge suppressor]”?

*Simple questions - no answers from w_.*


Bizarre claim - plug-in surge suppressors don't work

No sources that say plug-in suppressors are NOT effective.
Twists opposing sources to say the opposite of what they really say.
Tries to discredit opponents.

0 new messages