Criticism over plan to hold symbolic Ashwamedha Yaga

41 views
Skip to first unread message

Shreyas

unread,
Feb 21, 2012, 1:40:17 AM2/21/12
to bvpar...@googlegroups.com
Of late, the Bangalore bureau of "The Hindu" also seems to have joined the ranks of the pseudo-secular,
supposedly rational , english media. There has been plenty of one-sided coverage of the Karnataka State's
proposal to introduce Srimath Bhagavath Geetha as a optional subject in schools. Now this.
 
Perhaps interested and erudite members may consider writing to "The Hindu" countering this with
appropriate pramanas from related texts.
 
Regards,
-Shreyas
 
 
 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Samartha Ramashrama Seva Trust is organising it at a cost of around Rs. 8 cr.

Getting ready:Preparations for the symbolic Ashwamedha Yaga are in full swing near Doddapura in Hassan taluk.
Getting ready:Preparations for the symbolic Ashwamedha Yaga are in full swing near Doddapura in Hassan taluk.

A section of progressive thinkers, writers and artists have criticised plans to organise a symbolic Ashwamedha Yaga near Doddapura on Hassan-Arsikere Road in Hassan taluk.

The Samartha Ramashrama Seva Trust, which came into existence recently, is organising the event at a cost of nearly Rs. 8 crore.

The preparations for the event are in full swing at ‘Saketapura'.

Large crowds expected

The yaga, which is scheduled to be held between February 29 and March 7, is expected to attract lakhs of people, including politicians.

About 1,500 priests are expected to take part in religious programmes every day during the event, which would be held under the guidance of Rama Avadhoota. Avadhoota, a native of Belur taluk, set up the trust with the help of` a few followers.

Sridhar of the trust claimed that the event was being organised for the welfare of mankind.

The proposed event has invited the wrath of many progressive thinkers and writers. Well-known artist and progressive thinker K.T. Shivaprasad criticised it strongly. “It is nothing but a waste of money.” Writer and advocate Ja. Ho. Narayanaswamy said that India's growth had been obstructed by rigid minds that conducted yagas.

“India is the country that showed what spirituality is to the world. The essence of spirituality is that whatever is godly is within everybody. It is sad that vested interests are fooling the public in the name of such yagas and yagnas,” he said.

Environmentalist and social activist H.P. Mohan alleged that political parties were behind organising the mega event. “Otherwise, such an event could not have been organised. It is well known that such yagas will not do anything good for mankind. Then where is the need to spend so much money,” he asked.

He pointed out that the State Government had recently cancelled Hoysalotsava celebrations citing drought in the district. “It is strange that when farmers are suffering, we are witnessing an event to be held at a cost of crores of rupees,” he said.


  • The event is being organised for the welfare of mankind: trust

  • It is nothing but a waste of money, says

    K.T. Shivaprasad

VKG

unread,
Feb 21, 2012, 6:25:54 PM2/21/12
to bvpar...@googlegroups.com
Ashwamedha Yaaga.

The name evokes some mythological and logical interest.
Why is the Yajna required at first place?
Who is eligible to do that?
What is the usage?
(Next question is directed towards religious/ dharmik persons?)
Which scripture stipulates the conduct?
And
What is the procedure to be adopted?
What are the resources required? Are they available?
--
As I had the first hand interaction, with some of the organisers, including the motivator/ initiator; and had an occasion to listen to their statements.

After all this, I did not have a reason to change my perception that Conduct of Ashwamedha Yaaga is futile and unnecessary, as Smruti Granthas (Sounaka etc.) has explicitly banned this in Kali Yuga.
Parayanam is quite sufficient, to achieve what ever meaningful merit, may occur.

In the absence of right resources, such events could be the subject of mock, for obvious reasons. We are witnessing it.
VKG

Hnbhat B.R.

unread,
Feb 21, 2012, 9:06:44 PM2/21/12
to bvpar...@googlegroups.com
After all this, I did not have a reason to change my perception that Conduct of Ashwamedha Yaaga is futile and unnecessary, as Smruti Granthas (Sounaka etc.) has explicitly banned this in Kali Yuga.
Parayanam is quite sufficient, to achieve what ever meaningful merit, may occur.

In the absence of right resources, such events could be the subject of mock, for obvious reasons. We are witnessing it.
VKG


I remember "राजा सार्वभौमोऽश्वमेधेन यजेत" as quoted from my memory of some commentary quoting it, authorizes kings willing to become सार्वभौम, and as Udayana quotes, it is meant : 
  1. "अश्वमेधेन यजेतमृत्युब्रह्महत्यातरणकाम" ...

 to overcome death, and Brahmahatya sin. 

Anyhow it is काम्यकर्म and if the first is true, or even the second, it is not performed without the specific purpose to be served. And today there are no kings, but king-makers and for their benefit, there is no smRuti that prescribes it. The end itself justifies the propriety of the means adopted to achieve it.


--
Dr. Hari Narayana Bhat B.R. M.A., Ph.D.,
Research Scholar,
Ecole française d'Extrême-OrientCentre de Pondichéry
16 & 19, Rue Dumas
Pondichéry - 605 001


Hnbhat B.R.

unread,
Feb 21, 2012, 9:12:58 PM2/21/12
to bvpar...@googlegroups.com

Hnbhat B.R.

unread,
Feb 21, 2012, 9:14:46 PM2/21/12
to bvpar...@googlegroups.com
I am sorry for my previous message. I think the topic doesn't confirm to the objectives of the forum for discussion as it lies outside academic purpose.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages