In our last episode of [alt.wedding], Dawn Precour wrote:
> Hi everyone, > I am keeping my name. I do not believe in hyphenating. My thoughts are > that it is my name, I have not borrowed it until I marry. We are > sharing our lives together, but, we are still separate in our union. I > often see in wedding announcements, under the picture it will say > (example) Mrs. Thomas Main, formerly Dawn Precour. As if your idenity is > totally gone. Please understand that this is right for me, I respect > others choices and beleive fully that we all need to do what is right > for us at the time. > Dawn (&Thomas Dec. 28, 1996)
I always thought I would keep my name and hyphenate, but that has decidedly become a no option plan. 1. My brother will carry on the family name so that's ok in that vein, 2. It just doesn't work. Maybe if Doug's last name was anything but what it is, but Jennie Johnson-Jackson just doesn't work for us *grin*
Jennie (and Doug) Aug '97 -- _.-------Commercial e-mail will be read at a cost of AUS$25 each-------. _ // I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed | \X/ or numbered! My life is my own. - No.6 to No.2, "The Prisoner" | `----As always, my university has no idea at all of what I am saying----'
> I always thought I would keep my name and hyphenate, but that has > decidedly become a no option plan. 1. My brother will carry on the family > name so that's ok in that vein, 2. It just doesn't work. Maybe if Doug's > last name was anything but what it is, but Jennie Johnson-Jackson just > doesn't work for us *grin*
> Jennie (and Doug) Aug '97 > -- > _.-------Commercial e-mail will be read at a cost of AUS$25 each-------. > _ // I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed | > \X/ or numbered! My life is my own. - No.6 to No.2, "The Prisoner" | > `----As always, my university has no idea at all of what I am saying----'
So what are you planning to do? There are lots of other options too. Like creating a new name from pieces of your names or choosing a name in one of your families, an ancestor or another name that has died out or about to or means something to you. Or you could always jsut keep your own name, just like it is.
My husband and I took my mother's maiden name. We liked the way it sounded with our names, it gave us the same name, a family name. Yet at the same time, we didn't feel as though we were giving up our "identities." We both changed our names to make a commitment to being a family..by both changing them I don't feel that one person's identity is subsumed under the other's. It was also a good choice for us as well, as our parents are divorced and neither of us are particularly close to our fathers, nor were we particularly thrilled to have our fathers' last names.
By the way, are you from Australia? I ask because my husband is from Melbourne.
I'm very confused as to what I'm going to do. I always thought I'd keep my own name after I was married but now that I'm really GETTING married I'm considering changing it (hyphenating isn't really an option for me either -- it's like the Johnson-Jackson thing, only it's Williams-Wagner). My fiance isn't in a position professionally to change his name (though he offered to do so, bless his heart) and he says that he'd actually prefer that I keep mine but that of course he'll support whatever decision I make. I'm not (yet) in a professional position to suffer from a name change, and I like the idea of our future family all having the same name, but I also agree that I haven't "borrowed" my own family name and that my identity shouldn't soley be tied to that of the man I marry. Besides, I like my name as it is already. The most attractive option I've encountered so far is taking one another's names as additional middle names. I still have over half a year to decide but we've been engaged for a year already and I'm no closer to a decision now than I was then. I'd appreciate hearing other people's experience with this since it's never been a problem that my family or friends have encountered.....
thanks,
Allison Williams (Allison Wagner? Allison Wagner Williams? AAAAARRGH!) (& David) July 6, 1997
Your fiance sounds like mine. He also is supportive of whatever I finally choose about my name. I have almost decided that I will keep all three of my names (first, middle, last), and add his last name also. I won't be Michelle Miller, nor Michelle Shutt, but Michelle C. Miller Shutt. Kind of a mouthful, I know, but the best I've come up[ with so far. As for your situation, IMHO, Allison Wagner Williams (without the actual hyphen) sounds neat. It sort of rolls off the tongue. And you'd still using both names.
> > I always thought I would keep my name and hyphenate, but that has > > decidedly become a no option plan. 1. My brother will carry on the family > > name so that's ok in that vein, 2. It just doesn't work. Maybe if Doug's > > last name was anything but what it is, but Jennie Johnson-Jackson just > > doesn't work for us *grin*
> > Jennie (and Doug) Aug '97 > > -- > > _.-------Commercial e-mail will be read at a cost of AUS$25 each-------. > > _ // I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed | > > \X/ or numbered! My life is my own. - No.6 to No.2, "The Prisoner" | > > `----As always, my university has no idea at all of what I am saying----' > So what are you planning to do? There are lots of other options too. > Like creating a new name from pieces of your names or choosing a name in > one of your families, an ancestor or another name that has died out or > about to or means something to you. Or you could always jsut keep your > own name, just like it is. > My husband and I took my mother's maiden name. We liked the way it > sounded with our names, it gave us the same name, a family name. Yet at > the same time, we didn't feel as though we were giving up our > "identities." We both changed our names to make a commitment to being a > family..by both changing them I don't feel that one person's identity is > subsumed under the other's. It was also a good choice for us as well, as > our parents are divorced and neither of us are particularly close to our > fathers, nor were we particularly thrilled to have our fathers' last > names. > By the way, are you from Australia? I ask because my husband is from Melbourne. > Kimber
Well we could combine our names and make it into something that is a mix of johnson and jackson, but the 'son' part is already the same so I don't see how that will work...it's ok though, i like his last name and have no problem. I mean at least my initials won't change.
No I am not aussie, I come from Canada. Doug and I met over the internet and i decided to come over here after i graduated from uni to meet him. We hit it off instantly (we knew about ten min after meeting each other we would get married and he proposed on our 6 month anniversary of being together in aus). Doug is from Melbourne, born and raised though. If you guys make it back here we'll have to get in touch.
Jennie (and DOug) Aug '97 PS: pllease excuse any spelling errors or lack of proper capitalizatin, i just worked a 16 hour shift and am not really with it, plus i have to get up again in 5 hours to get ready for a 9 am shift so I am saying goodnight *SNORE*) -- _.-------Commercial e-mail will be read at a cost of AUS$25 each-------. _ // I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed | \X/ or numbered! My life is my own. - No.6 to No.2, "The Prisoner" | `----As always, my university has no idea at all of what I am saying----'
If you're afraid of "losing" a name, and you're not afraid of saddling your child with a name that no one has ever heard of, you may be able to turn a maiden name into a first name.
My fiance's parents did that to him - his name (Bolton) is his grandmother's maiden name, and his father's middle name. I like his name, although it has to be repeated when he's introduced, and he makes himself crazy everytime he sees one of those "personalized" items racks in gift shops, because they never have his name.
Janet (& Bolton, 2/1/97) **taking his last name, moving my last name to my middle name.
> > I always thought I would keep my name and hyphenate, but that has > > decidedly become a no option plan. 1. My brother will carry on the family > > name so that's ok in that vein, 2. It just doesn't work. Maybe if Doug's > > last name was anything but what it is, but Jennie Johnson-Jackson just > > doesn't work for us *grin*
> > Jennie (and Doug) Aug '97 > > -- > > _.-------Commercial e-mail will be read at a cost of AUS$25 each-------. > > _ // I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed | > > \X/ or numbered! My life is my own. - No.6 to No.2, "The Prisoner" | > > `----As always, my university has no idea at all of what I am saying----'
> So what are you planning to do? There are lots of other options too. > Like creating a new name from pieces of your names or choosing a name in > one of your families, an ancestor or another name that has died out or > about to or means something to you. Or you could always jsut keep your > own name, just like it is.
> My husband and I took my mother's maiden name. We liked the way it > sounded with our names, it gave us the same name, a family name. Yet at > the same time, we didn't feel as though we were giving up our > "identities." We both changed our names to make a commitment to being a > family..by both changing them I don't feel that one person's identity is > subsumed under the other's. It was also a good choice for us as well, as > our parents are divorced and neither of us are particularly close to our > fathers, nor were we particularly thrilled to have our fathers' last > names.
> By the way, are you from Australia? I ask because my husband is from Melbourne.
This has been something Ive been thinking about for a while now.. There is only one cousin who will carry on my father's name and Ive always felt that that wasnt enough..
Not to mention that I am a keen Genealogist and would like my children to know their mother's name..
so how does this sound:
Marianna Kleytman-Hill? or Marianna Kleytman Hill
personally I like the hyphen, and I think the names sorta go together ;)
I have kept my name and added my husband's, but I did not hyphenate it. The reason? First, I don't feel like I am a hyphenated individual, and second, I don't really like the way it looks! I admit, it is a little unwieldy (Juliet Ugarte Hopkins), it is a bear for people to enter it into computer programs (like at the doctor's office, etc.), and I always have to repeat myself when giving my name, but I think those are silly reasons not to keep both. I've only had it for a year, but it can't be all that bad...look at Hillary Rodham Clinton!
I haven't made a final decision yet, but I think I'm going to keep ALL of my names, including my middle one, so I'll just have four. I feel no need or desire to get rid of one of the names my parents gave me.
julie...@aol.com wrote: > I have kept my name and added my husband's, but I did not >hyphenate it. The reason? First, I don't feel like I am a hyphenated >individual, and second, I don't really like the way it looks! I admit, it >is a little unwieldy (Juliet Ugarte Hopkins), it is a bear for people to >enter it into computer programs (like at the doctor's office, etc.), and I >always have to repeat myself when giving my name, but I think those are >silly reasons not to keep both. I've only had it for a year, but it can't >be all that bad...look at Hillary Rodham Clinton!
imagne how much fun that was for me- I got divorced in the states and kept his last name cuz I liked it better. I came here and they all wanted my anme and I am ike "wendey malone" and then they see my birth certificate and can't figure out why a single woman would ahve a different last name. after trying to explain repeatedly that "wendey heitmann" does not technically exist anymore I said hell with it and did it their way. Now I am rather glad about it, especially since I found out I couldn't ahve my new husband's name... something about using my ex's name while married to another guy... yuck.
-wendey (in montreal too!) 11/23/96
In article <warlunds-0612961246400...@advance-28-44.concordia.ca>, warlu...@coral.concordia.ca (Sarah Hamilton Warlund) wrote:
> According to the law in Quebec we have to keep our maiden name. If we want > to change our name to the husband's name or a hyphenated version, we have > to go through all the legal proceedings (and money) to change our name. > Some people informally change their name but still have to use their > maiden name for health insurance (government paid) and all other > government stuff.
> However, the children can have any combination of the parents name: > father's only, mothe'rs only, mother's-father's, father's-mother's. The > only restriction is that the name cannot have more than one hypen. So it's > good for this generation, but the next generation? Who knows.
> Sarah in Montreal
> In article <19961206004300.TAA09...@ladder01.news.aol.com>, > julie...@aol.com wrote:
> > I have kept my name and added my husband's, but I did not > > hyphenate it. The reason? First, I don't feel like I am a hyphenated > > individual, and second, I don't really like the way it looks! I admit, it > > is a little unwieldy (Juliet Ugarte Hopkins), it is a bear for people to > > enter it into computer programs (like at the doctor's office, etc.), and I > > always have to repeat myself when giving my name, but I think those are > > silly reasons not to keep both. I've only had it for a year, but it can't > > be all that bad...look at Hillary Rodham Clinton!
> -- > ************************ > Sarah Hamilton Warlund > warlu...@coral.concordia.ca
In article <warlunds-0612961246400...@advance-28-44.concordia.ca>, warlu...@coral.concordia.ca (Sarah Hamilton Warlund) wrote:
> According to the law in Quebec we have to keep our maiden name. If we want > to change our name to the husband's name or a hyphenated version, we have > to go through all the legal proceedings (and money) to change our name. > Some people informally change their name but still have to use their > maiden name for health insurance (government paid) and all other > government stuff.
> However, the children can have any combination of the parents name: > father's only, mothe'rs only, mother's-father's, father's-mother's. The > only restriction is that the name cannot have more than one hypen. So it's > good for this generation, but the next generation? Who knows.
> Sarah in Montreal
What if the parents want to give the children a combined name, made up of both their names? Is this legal?
According to the law in Quebec we have to keep our maiden name. If we want to change our name to the husband's name or a hyphenated version, we have to go through all the legal proceedings (and money) to change our name. Some people informally change their name but still have to use their maiden name for health insurance (government paid) and all other government stuff.
However, the children can have any combination of the parents name: father's only, mothe'rs only, mother's-father's, father's-mother's. The only restriction is that the name cannot have more than one hypen. So it's good for this generation, but the next generation? Who knows.
Sarah in Montreal
In article <19961206004300.TAA09...@ladder01.news.aol.com>,
julie...@aol.com wrote: > I have kept my name and added my husband's, but I did not > hyphenate it. The reason? First, I don't feel like I am a hyphenated > individual, and second, I don't really like the way it looks! I admit, it > is a little unwieldy (Juliet Ugarte Hopkins), it is a bear for people to > enter it into computer programs (like at the doctor's office, etc.), and I > always have to repeat myself when giving my name, but I think those are > silly reasons not to keep both. I've only had it for a year, but it can't > be all that bad...look at Hillary Rodham Clinton!
-- ************************ Sarah Hamilton Warlund warlu...@coral.concordia.ca
i'll be keeping my name. mostly because my last name is long and polish and cannot possibly sound good hyphenated.
my ex wanted me to hyphenate my name with his, but his name was long and east european as well, which would have given me more consonants than any one human being should have.
i'm still so surprised that people my age (25) are shocked that i'm not changing my name. don't see what the big deal is, really.
in answer to your question kimber, sort of. you just can only have a maximum of *two* last names. they don't care what combo or who's last name it is (I think it has to somehow be derived from the parents though) as long as there are no more than two last names.
-wendey
In article <moose-0612961245240...@aragorn181.nuts.nwu.edu>, mo...@merle.acns.nwu.edu (Kimber & Cesar Rodgers) wrote:
> In article <warlunds-0612961246400...@advance-28-44.concordia.ca>, > warlu...@coral.concordia.ca (Sarah Hamilton Warlund) wrote:
> > According to the law in Quebec we have to keep our maiden name. If we want > > to change our name to the husband's name or a hyphenated version, we have > > to go through all the legal proceedings (and money) to change our name. > > Some people informally change their name but still have to use their > > maiden name for health insurance (government paid) and all other > > government stuff.
> > However, the children can have any combination of the parents name: > > father's only, mothe'rs only, mother's-father's, father's-mother's. The > > only restriction is that the name cannot have more than one hypen. So it's > > good for this generation, but the next generation? Who knows.
> > Sarah in Montreal
> What if the parents want to give the children a combined name, made up of > both their names? Is this legal?
fastrada wrote: > i'm still so surprised that people my age (25) are shocked that i'm > not changing my name. don't see what the big deal is, really.
In contrast, I'm getting LOTS of shocked responses when people find out (my age AND older -- I'm 23) that I'm changing my name to his. What can I say -- I've always dreamed of having a last name that I didn't have to spell or pronounce several times EVERY time I give it to someone (even the contract for the purchase of my wedding gown has it horrible misspelled!). My last name is Dockstader (Dock-stay-der), and his is Morgan. I think it's perfect. And I'm not going to do the Dockstader-Morgan thing, either, which everybody jokes about. Heck, my last name alone doesn't even fit for Publishers' Clearing House!! Anyway, I'm finding it sort of amusing that everyone is really surprised that I'm changing it. Since when did it become out of the ordinary to do the traditional thing? (the answer is probably since I went to school at the flaming liberal institution of UC Berkeley and managed to surround myself with liberal friends even in the conservative stronghold of William and Mary (grad school)) :P
Jennifer (who's been using the name "Morgan" to order pizza, at least, for going on two years now!) and Dave 5/24/97
In article <19961210031200.WAA03...@ladder01.news.aol.com>,
buffy...@aol.com wrote: > I plan to drop my middle name and use my last name as my middle name. As > in Carolyn Kelly Beauchesne. Hyphenating seems so 80's.
Why does hyphenating seem like an 80s thing? I've never thought of it this way.
> > i'm still so surprised that people my age (25) are shocked that i'm > > not changing my name. don't see what the big deal is, really.
> In contrast, I'm getting LOTS of shocked responses when people find out > (my age AND older -- I'm 23) that I'm changing my name to his. What can > I say -- I've always dreamed of having a last name that I didn't have to > spell or pronounce several times EVERY time I give it to someone (even > the contract for the purchase of my wedding gown has it horrible > misspelled!). My last name is Dockstader (Dock-stay-der), and his is > Morgan. I think it's perfect. And I'm not going to do the > Dockstader-Morgan thing, either, which everybody jokes about. Heck, my > last name alone doesn't even fit for Publishers' Clearing House!! > Anyway, I'm finding it sort of amusing that everyone is really > surprised that I'm changing it. Since when did it become out of the > ordinary to do the traditional thing? (the answer is probably since I > went to school at the flaming liberal institution of UC Berkeley and > managed to surround myself with liberal friends even in the conservative > stronghold of William and Mary (grad school)) :P
> Jennifer (who's been using the name "Morgan" to order pizza, at least, > for going on two years now!) and Dave > 5/24/97
I'm also doing the traditional thing and am taking my fiance's last name (Ott) and dropping mine (Behrens), partly for the same reasons that Jennifer mentioned. Our families seem in no way surprised and probably expected that, but my colleagues at work (R&D Center) find that hard to believe! I guess it all depends on your background...
Gesa (who will still have the trouble of spelling her first name for EVERYONE she gives it to!)
> > i'm still so surprised that people my age (25) are shocked that i'm > > not changing my name. don't see what the big deal is, really.
> In contrast, I'm getting LOTS of shocked responses when people find out > (my age AND older -- I'm 23) that I'm changing my name to his. What can > I say -- I've always dreamed of having a last name that I didn't have to
I have resisted adding my two cents in this thread for quite a while, but I am in a mood today.
While I was in college, I decided to change my name legally from Knoll to Knoll-Carlson; joining my last name (my father) and my step father's. For 7 years I went by this name. When I started a new job, they had my desk set up as Carlson. I decided, great, no hyphen to deal with, so I used the hyphenated name as my legal name and the trancated name on business cards and the like. What a nightmare. Due to corporate databases, no one can find me in the office phone book because they do not know my legal name. But I had gotten tired of using such a long name after only a few years.
I am usually not a very traditional person, but I am planning on taking Joe's name because I believe that when you have children, it is nice to have a name all family members have. I love my middle name, so I am keeping that and loosing the complicated last name. I always hated growing up that my "parents" name was different from mine and all the questions I had to explain.
This is why I am changing my name. Prior to our engagement, I kept telling Joe he needed to marry me so I could get a short last name.
: I plan to drop my middle name and use my last name as my middle name. As : in Carolyn Kelly Beauchesne. Hyphenating seems so 80's.
I plan on either keeping all my names and merely adding his name to the end (Catherine Elizabeth Byland Weeks) or dropping my current middle name and using my last name as a middle name. Either way, I'll go by Cathy Weeks.
I'm keeping my last name when I get married, after years of saying "No, it's not a joke" or"Yes, it is really my last name.." I don't see how I can really have another. Besides, his last name is Castruita and I still don't think I pronouce it as well as he :)
In article <58kk8a$1...@news.missouri.edu>, ccca...@black.missouri.edu
(Cathy Byland) wrote: > I plan on either keeping all my names and merely adding his name to the > end (Catherine Elizabeth Byland Weeks) or dropping my current middle name > and using my last name as a middle name. Either way, I'll go by Cathy > Weeks.
I really don't mean to be rude, but I fail to understand how transfering from being "Cathy Byland" to "Cathy Weeks" constitutes "keeping your name" (nothing personal Cathy, just needed an example :). I am not opposed to people changing their names after marriage, I just don't understand why so many people firmly believe they are "keeping their name" when they do this. In deciding to "go by Cathy Weeks" you are most definitely *not* keeping your name, since the Byland is no longer there on a daily basis. If that isn't changing your name, then I don't know what is.
I really don't mean to be rude, I'm just trying to understand this phenomenon. I have never experienced it anywhere except on this newsgroup, and I was hoping someone could explain this to me.
Irene Antonenko wrote: > > "But using your maiden name as a middle name isn't > >keeping your name! .... I really don't mean to be rude, I'm just trying > > to understand this phenomenon. I have never experienced it anywhere > > except on this newsgroup, and I was hoping someone could explain this to me.
To which Dorothea Rovner responded:
> Well, I can try, although you seem rather hostile. FWIW, my mother > did this, and I plan to do it also (not least because my middle name is > pretty silly) <Snip of more reasons why Dorothea chose to do this>. > > I hope this is a start toward understanding and tolerance.
LOL! Uh, Dorothea, just another perspective ... from my desk *you* seem a teensy bit defensive about this subject, not Irene! She expressed an opinion you may not agree with, but I'm pretty amused you found her "hostile" when she also prefaced that opinion with a "flame disclaimer" and then invited people to explain their point of view on the subject.
Right back at you with your own words when I say that I hope THIS is a start toward understanding and tolerance :) --Erin (Who happened to keep her name for business and sentimental reasons, but personally doesn't have any agendas -- personal or political -- that make her care about what the rest of the female population chooses to do when they get married.)
Well, I know for myself there was a specific reason I "kept" my maiden name after marrying. My "official" name is Christiana Lynn Calvert Brogan. I use the name Christi Calvert Brogan on all official documents and on any correspondence relating to the reason for keeping it, that is, genealogy. I am a geneologist and therefore it was very important to me to keep my family name, which dies out with me. In fact our children will have the choice of which name they prefer when they are old enough to decide. But people call me Mrs. Brogan because it is easier than Mrs. Calvert Brogan, and because some just don't know that Calvert is my maiden name, not my middle name. So, while I am keeping my maiden name and use it often, I also respond to my husband's name.
Just my $.05 (inflation you know)
Christi Calvert Brogan
"Conjugal Creations" Wedding Designer San Antonio, Texas Ask me about NACEC!