Re: 1st Season Stargate Universe - Justice - 5 star poll -SPOILERS AHOY !

[Tim Bruening]

"Sir F. A. Rien" wrote:

> "David V. Loewe, Jr" <dave...@charter.net> found these unused words:
>
> >On Mon, 07 Dec 2009 08:32:18 -0800, A Watcher <stoc...@earthlink.net>
> >wrote:
> >
> >>Tim Bruening wrote:
> >>> Gisele wrote:
> >>>> Gisele <ilov...@nospamlycos.com> wrote:
> >>>>> "George Avalos" <george...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> >>>>>
> >>>>>> "Justice"
> >>>>>> 12-4-09 SGU
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 5 stars (American)
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 0-1 stars (honor killings)
> >
> >>>>> 2.0 The only good character that has a personality gets left on a
> >>>>> dead planet.....great. Although I'll bet he gets that abandoned
> >>>>> spaceship working. Now that will be interesting if he gets back to
> >>>>> the Destiny and tells everyone what Young did....<g> At least,
> >>>>> *that* would be interesting and if it happens in the next episode
> >>>>> next year, then that might warrant a good score.
> >
> >>>> Wanted to add that leaving the only scientist, that can help them get
> >>>> back to Earth or survive, on a dead planet seems like a very, very
> >>>> stupid move. Granted, Rush deserved some kind of punishment but
> >>>> banishment is way too harsh and foolhardy. I think Rush is right,
> >>>> Young does not know how to command.
> >
> >>> During the investigation of the "Murder of Spencer", Young insists on
> >>> following procedure. Yet when Young learns that Rush framed him for the
> >>> death of Spencer, Young does not follow the proper procedure, which
> >>> would be to arrest Rush and throw him into the brig. Instead, Young
> >>> abandons Rush on a desert planet without dur process.
> >>
> >>He learned from the incident with the IOA team trying to use the gate to
> >>dial Earth that Rush can't be allowed to touch anything on the ship.
> >
> >Young was also not in favor of that particular maneuver and learned from
> >Eli that the attempt would have failed = perhaps catastrophically as
> >Rush claimed.
> >
> >Moreover, Rush had *help* setting that up.
> >
> >>Rush is just too smart and is totally dedicated to going on with the
> >>mission instead of returning to Earth. He made what you might call a
> >>battlefield decision to take an extreme measure.
>
> Is there an echo in here?

I remember Rush ordering Greer to shoot an idiot in Air 3.