I have been on the CPAP for a month now. I have severe sleep apnea at the rate of 135 events per hour. I had gradually gotten worse and worse until I could not even stay awake to drink my morning coffee. I could barely function at work, and I was a danger on the roads to myself and others.
I loved CPAP! It gave me my life back! I knew that other people did not fall off to sleep anywhere and everywhere as I did, but until I got better using my CPAP machine, I had no idea exactly how bad off I was. I did not mind the machine for a second, and got used to it within days.
Now I can't sleep through the night because my chest gets sore when I use the CPAP. The pain is so intense that it wakes me up after about two hours. I then have to sit up for one to two hours before it subsides enough to let me lay down again. My setting was 15, and my sleep doctor had me get it lowered to 12. I was relieved and confident that would work, but it did not. It did not improve things one little bit. I constantly have the sneezes and a runny nose, but I could live with that. It would be a price I would be willing to pay in order to be able to function.
But now the chest pain is interrupting my sleep, and I can feel myself slipping backwards again. I am so upset. I cannot face going back to feeling the way I did before. Before I did not know how bad off I was. But after feeling well (and practically dancing with joy to feel that good after such a long time), I would know the difference. I am so depressed. It was all I could do to get through work today without breaking into tears.
Thankfully I see my sleep specialist on Tuesday. I hope he can give me some options. For the next two nights I am going off CPAP. My chest pain used to go away during the day, but now it is not and it hurts all the time. I hope two days is enough, and that on Monday night I'll be able to use it again so I'll be fit enough to make the two hour drive to see my sleep specialist.
My family physician says that my chest muscles can't handle breathing out against the pressure of the CPAP machine, and that there is nothing wrong with my heart or lungs. Has anyone else had this problem? A setting lower than 12 would not do me much good at all. Any suggestions?
Deeply depressed and desperate to find a way to keep using my CPAP.
Valerie Grieve wrote: > My family physician says that my chest muscles can't handle breathing > out against the pressure of the CPAP machine, and that there is > nothing wrong with my heart or lungs. Has anyone else had this > problem? A setting lower than 12 would not do me much good at all. > Any suggestions?
> Deeply depressed and desperate to find a way to keep using my CPAP.
Valerie,
My husband read your post - he's been on a CPAP machine at a setting of 15 for several months and is doing really great, sleeping comfortably all night. He also has heart trouble (has had bypass surgery) and goes to a cardiologist as well as a sleep specialist at a very good sleep disorder clinic. He says it takes BOTH doctors, because he has two problems, and it sounds like you might be the same way.
He suggests you get a cardiac specialist to check you out PDQ!
I will bet hard cash that if you press the issue, you can get your Doctor to put you on a BiLevel device at a lower pressure and still feel as good as you did on 15 of CPAP.
> I have been on the CPAP for a month now. I have severe sleep apnea at > the rate of 135 events per hour. I had gradually gotten worse and > worse until I could not even stay awake to drink my morning coffee. I > could barely function at work, and I was a danger on the roads to > myself and others.
> I loved CPAP! It gave me my life back! I knew that other people did > not fall off to sleep anywhere and everywhere as I did, but until I > got better using my CPAP machine, I had no idea exactly how bad off I > was. I did not mind the machine for a second, and got used to it > within days.
> Now I can't sleep through the night because my chest gets sore when I > use the CPAP. The pain is so intense that it wakes me up after about > two hours. I then have to sit up for one to two hours before it > subsides enough to let me lay down again. My setting was 15, and my > sleep doctor had me get it lowered to 12. I was relieved and > confident that would work, but it did not. It did not improve things > one little bit. I constantly have the sneezes and a runny nose, but I > could live with that. It would be a price I would be willing to pay > in order to be able to function.
> But now the chest pain is interrupting my sleep, and I can feel myself > slipping backwards again. I am so upset. I cannot face going back to > feeling the way I did before. Before I did not know how bad off I > was. But after feeling well (and practically dancing with joy to feel > that good after such a long time), I would know the difference. I am > so depressed. It was all I could do to get through work today without > breaking into tears.
> Thankfully I see my sleep specialist on Tuesday. I hope he can give > me some options. For the next two nights I am going off CPAP. My > chest pain used to go away during the day, but now it is not and it > hurts all the time. I hope two days is enough, and that on Monday > night I'll be able to use it again so I'll be fit enough to make the > two hour drive to see my sleep specialist.
> My family physician says that my chest muscles can't handle breathing > out against the pressure of the CPAP machine, and that there is > nothing wrong with my heart or lungs. Has anyone else had this > problem? A setting lower than 12 would not do me much good at all. > Any suggestions?
> Deeply depressed and desperate to find a way to keep using my CPAP.
> >He suggests you get a cardiac specialist to check you out PDQ!
> >Best, > >Mary (and Bill)
> I tried an interesting experiment. I went off CPAP for a couple of > nights. My family physician says my lungs are clear (listening > only--no x-ray as requested by my sleep specialist), and that the pain > is coming from chest muscles unaccustomed to breathing out against the > air pressure.
> I re-read my Tranquility Quest manual, and according to it, it is > supposed to reduce pressure when I am exhaling, but it does not say by > how much.
> Anyway, after being off the CPAP for two nights, I still have the same > problem. The idea was that perhaps being off of it would give my > chest muscles a chance to recover and heal a little, and hopefully > when I went back on at a reduced setting of 12, the problem would not > be there or would not be so bad.
> Now I am re-thinking this. If I have the same problem--waking up with > severe chest pain, mostly in the back but sometimes around the sides > and in front--maybe the problem is NOT my CPAP machine! During the > day the pain subsides quite a lot, but it does not go away completely > and sometimes I have mild chest pain in front.
> I know I have had sleep apnea for several years (probably most of my > life--I have always snored). I am also very overweight, and I have > had an ongoing problem with edema (swelling of feet and ankles) for > about three years. So now I am starting to wonder if I have damaged > my heart over the years. However, I am only 41 and my family > physician is holding fast to the idea that the pain is coming from my > chest muscles.
> I see my sleep specialist tomorrow. He is a neurologist, and I will > ask for his opinion and possibly for him to refer me to a > cardiologist. He might be easier to sway than my family physician. > (I have to be referred for our Canadian healthcare system to cover it; > I just can't refer myself.)
> Tell me, are these symptoms you think I should be concerned about? I > am wondering about congestive heart failure myself, but I do not know > a lot about that. Do you know what the symptoms of congestive heart > failure are?
> Thanks for your response.
If I were you, I would look into the possibility that the chest and back pain are the result sleep position. I have had this problem and my chest, back and ribs were very sore. CPAP may have preciptiated this condition due to your sleeping in one postion for longer periods of time and causing inflamation around the nerves in your back. I had this condition prior to CPAP since I could not sleep on my back. Now I can sleep on my back, with a pillow under my legs and a small pillow under my neck. If I sleep on my side for too long, the curve my spine causes inflamation of the nerves. I have broad shoulders which do not allow my mattress to properly support my waist and ribs. This causes the spine to be curved.
Mary Rawlinson <mar...@ibm.net> wrote: >He suggests you get a cardiac specialist to check you out PDQ! >Best, >Mary (and Bill)
I tried an interesting experiment. I went off CPAP for a couple of nights. My family physician says my lungs are clear (listening only--no x-ray as requested by my sleep specialist), and that the pain is coming from chest muscles unaccustomed to breathing out against the air pressure.
I re-read my Tranquility Quest manual, and according to it, it is supposed to reduce pressure when I am exhaling, but it does not say by how much.
Anyway, after being off the CPAP for two nights, I still have the same problem. The idea was that perhaps being off of it would give my chest muscles a chance to recover and heal a little, and hopefully when I went back on at a reduced setting of 12, the problem would not be there or would not be so bad.
Now I am re-thinking this. If I have the same problem--waking up with severe chest pain, mostly in the back but sometimes around the sides and in front--maybe the problem is NOT my CPAP machine! During the day the pain subsides quite a lot, but it does not go away completely and sometimes I have mild chest pain in front.
I know I have had sleep apnea for several years (probably most of my life--I have always snored). I am also very overweight, and I have had an ongoing problem with edema (swelling of feet and ankles) for about three years. So now I am starting to wonder if I have damaged my heart over the years. However, I am only 41 and my family physician is holding fast to the idea that the pain is coming from my chest muscles.
I see my sleep specialist tomorrow. He is a neurologist, and I will ask for his opinion and possibly for him to refer me to a cardiologist. He might be easier to sway than my family physician. (I have to be referred for our Canadian healthcare system to cover it; I just can't refer myself.)
Tell me, are these symptoms you think I should be concerned about? I am wondering about congestive heart failure myself, but I do not know a lot about that. Do you know what the symptoms of congestive heart failure are?
In article <53mh7k$...@gollum.kingston.net>, gri...@adan.kingston.net
(Valerie Grieve) writes: >Thankfully I see my sleep specialist on Tuesday. I hope he can give >me some options. For the next two nights I am going off CPAP. My >chest pain used to go away during the day, but now it is not and it >hurts all the time. I hope two days is enough, and that on Monday >night I'll be able to use it again so I'll be fit enough to make the >two hour drive to see my sleep specialist.
>My family physician says that my chest muscles can't handle breathing >out against the pressure of the CPAP machine, and that there is >nothing wrong with my heart or lungs. Has anyone else had this >problem? A setting lower than 12 would not do me much good at all. >Any suggestions?
It sound like you would be the perfect candidate for Bi-Pap or V-Pap!
Note that there can be a whole sequence of problems using CPAP, which has little to do with the CPAP itself (except indirectly).
They all boil down to "if you can't breath through your nose, CPAP won't work for/with you".
1) many people have problems with their nasal cavities drying out. This causes nasal congestion. In my case, I both need to humidify the air, and heat the humidifier, particularly in the winter. I just use a heating pad on lowest setting under the humidifier. This helped.
2) I've had cronic nasal congestion for years, without really being aware of it. Once aware of it, I talked to my pulmonary person, and she prescribed a nasal steroid spray (the over the counter sprays should not be used for more than a few days at a time, or they will cause more problems than they are worth. In my case, I started using beconase, and now use flonase. This helped the congestion during the day (always able to breath freely), but I noticed slowly that I tended to get congested at night.
3) Go get yourself tested for allergies, sooner rather than later. From your description of sneezes and a runny nose, you may have a serious allergy problem. In my case, when I finally went and got tested this last summer (16 months after starting CPAP), I tested off scale for dust mites, which, you guessed it, love to live in your bed (they live off of dead skin and other things that humans give off, and therefore love beds more than anywhere else). I've now just started getting injections for the allergy as well.
Note that congesion problems may have been cronic for you for as long or longer than Apnea, and you may therefore have become used to them as well.
I am new to all this but during my research on the subject, I did hear about a "bi-pap" capability......according to the sleep disorder technician, this is a cpap that has two levels of pressure one for inhale and a second lower level for exhale........you could ask about whether or not this could benefit you. again, i am a novice so be sure to get some expert advice. The technician at the sleep lab I attended was very knowledgeable and worked closelly with my physician and has made herself available to answer my questions. your technician should be able to help you too
gri...@adan.kingston.net (Valerie Grieve) writes: >I have been on the CPAP for a month now. I have severe sleep apnea at >the rate of 135 events per hour. I had gradually gotten worse and >worse until I could not even stay awake to drink my morning coffee. I >could barely function at work, and I was a danger on the roads to >myself and others. >I loved CPAP! It gave me my life back! I knew that other people did >not fall off to sleep anywhere and everywhere as I did, but until I >got better using my CPAP machine, I had no idea exactly how bad off I >was. I did not mind the machine for a second, and got used to it >within days. >Now I can't sleep through the night because my chest gets sore when I >use the CPAP. The pain is so intense that it wakes me up after about >two hours. I then have to sit up for one to two hours before it >subsides enough to let me lay down again. My setting was 15, and my >sleep doctor had me get it lowered to 12. I was relieved and >confident that would work, but it did not. It did not improve things >one little bit. I constantly have the sneezes and a runny nose, but I >could live with that. It would be a price I would be willing to pay >in order to be able to function.
Is this nose problem from allergies or only since you started CPAP? There are a number of things to try: change your CPAP filter often (2x week if necessary); nasal sprays to reduce sensitivity and reduce secretions (prescription items); a heated humidifier between the CPAP and the face mask. If allergies, treat the bedroom, use a room air filter.
Is it possible you are getting congestion in your lungs due to excessive nasal congestion?
>But now the chest pain is interrupting my sleep, and I can feel myself >slipping backwards again. I am so upset. I cannot face going back to >feeling the way I did before. Before I did not know how bad off I >was. But after feeling well (and practically dancing with joy to feel >that good after such a long time), I would know the difference. I am >so depressed. It was all I could do to get through work today without >breaking into tears. >Thankfully I see my sleep specialist on Tuesday. I hope he can give >me some options. For the next two nights I am going off CPAP. My >chest pain used to go away during the day, but now it is not and it >hurts all the time. I hope two days is enough, and that on Monday >night I'll be able to use it again so I'll be fit enough to make the >two hour drive to see my sleep specialist. >My family physician says that my chest muscles can't handle breathing >out against the pressure of the CPAP machine, and that there is >nothing wrong with my heart or lungs. Has anyone else had this >problem? A setting lower than 12 would not do me much good at all. >Any suggestions?
There are bi-level machines that work like the CPAP but switch to a lower pressure while you are exhaling. There are also some new 'smart' CPAP devices that adapt the pressure to your needs throughout your sleep, possibly reducing the total load on your lungs. Brief descriptions are in the Sleep Apnea FAQ now located on the Phantom Sleep Page at www.newtechpub.com/phantom/
>Deeply depressed and desperate to find a way to keep using my CPAP.
Let us know what the doctors come up with! And don't despair. -- Jerry Halberstadt. *President, New Technology Publishing, Inc: Health & Business Resources *Principal, FORESIGHT: Visionary business plans. * PHANTOM SLEEP PAGE <http://www.newtechpub.com/> *<halbe...@world.std.com> * 6 W.Blvd. POB 1737, Onset MA 02558 USA.
gri...@adan.kingston.net (Valerie Grieve) wrote: >Now I can't sleep through the night because my chest gets sore when I >use the CPAP. The pain is so intense that it wakes me up after about >two hours. I then have to sit up for one to two hours before it >subsides enough to let me lay down again. My setting was 15, and my >sleep doctor had me get it lowered to 12. I was relieved and >confident that would work, but it did not. It did not improve things <snip> >Deeply depressed and desperate to find a way to keep using my CPAP.
Dear Valerie, I also had some chest pain (which felt more like the aftermath of a hard punch centered in the back) from the CPAP. I was placed on a BiPap, which automatically reduces the pressure when you exhale. It needed another sleep study titration, but they came up with 2 settings (inhale/exhale) which work and are more comfortable. The only time it bothers me now is when I sleep more than 8 hours- usually when I've been sick. You might talk to your doctor about CPAP alternatives. Frank
In article <53ugfs$...@gollum.kingston.net>, gri...@adan.kingston.net
(Valerie Grieve) writes: >I know I have had sleep apnea for several years (probably most of my >life--I have always snored). I am also very overweight, and I have >had an ongoing problem with edema (swelling of feet and ankles) for >about three years. So now I am starting to wonder if I have damaged >my heart over the years.
I'm not a doctor, so by all means take this with a hefty grain of salt. I'm a medical writer who has read and written quite a bit about sleep apnea, including researching and editing a recent series of articles on cardiovascular complications of sleep apnea.
As you suggest, medical literature reports that years of sleep apnea can have cardiovascular effects. However, from what I have read specifically regarding heart failure (which you mention), CPAP has been shown to be effective at reversing heart failure symptoms in several groups of patients. Here are some references: Takasaki et al, Am Rev Respir Dis 130:1578-1584, 1989. Malone et al, Lancet 338:480-484, 1991. Bradley at al. Am Rev Respir Dis 145:377-382, 1992.
It would be cool if you could see a cardiologist who believes in the cardiovascular effects of sleep apnea. I get the idea that not all of them are converts, yet.
Someone wrote earlier suggesting BiPAP instead of CPAP, and my semi-educated bet would be, that's going to be your answer.
You sound like a smart medical consumer, so I'm sure you'll work your way to a solution that works for you.
Whenever I travel and sleep on a new matress I have problems similar to what you describe, but not so sever. Before you jump to the worst case, (heart probelms) do explore all the other possible areas, such as a different matress, lower pressure, higher pressure, Bipap, Dipap etc. There is an answer. Hang in there.
jso...@aol.com (JSoest) writes: >Valerie, >In article <53ugfs$...@gollum.kingston.net>, gri...@adan.kingston.net >(Valerie Grieve) writes: >>I know I have had sleep apnea for several years (probably most of my >>life--I have always snored). I am also very overweight, and I have >>had an ongoing problem with edema (swelling of feet and ankles) for >>about three years. So now I am starting to wonder if I have damaged >>my heart over the years.
Make sure your CPAP pressure is not excessive.
For some information on the relationship between apnea and heart disease, see the articles on the Phantom Sleep Page at www.newtechpub.com/phantom
>I'm not a doctor, so by all means take this with a hefty grain of salt. >I'm a medical writer who has read and written quite a bit about sleep >apnea, including researching and editing a recent series of articles on >cardiovascular complications of sleep apnea. >As you suggest, medical literature reports that years of sleep apnea can >have cardiovascular effects. However, from what I have read specifically >regarding heart failure (which you mention), CPAP has been shown to be >effective at reversing heart failure symptoms in several groups of >patients. Here are some references: >Takasaki et al, Am Rev Respir Dis 130:1578-1584, 1989. >Malone et al, Lancet 338:480-484, 1991. >Bradley at al. Am Rev Respir Dis 145:377-382, 1992. >It would be cool if you could see a cardiologist who believes in the >cardiovascular effects of sleep apnea. I get the idea that not all of >them are converts, yet. >Someone wrote earlier suggesting BiPAP instead of CPAP, and my >semi-educated bet would be, that's going to be your answer. >You sound like a smart medical consumer, so I'm sure you'll work your way >to a solution that works for you. >Best wishes, >Sally in Seattle >JSo...@aol.com
-- Jerry Halberstadt. *President, New Technology Publishing, Inc: Health & Business Resources *Principal, FORESIGHT: Visionary business plans. * PHANTOM SLEEP PAGE <http://www.newtechpub.com/> *<halbe...@world.std.com> * 6 W.Blvd. POB 1737, Onset MA 02558 USA.
: > My family physician says that my chest muscles can't handle breathing : > out against the pressure of the CPAP machine, and that there is : > nothing wrong with my heart or lungs. Has anyone else had this : > problem? A setting lower than 12 would not do me much good at all. : > Any suggestions? : > : > Deeply depressed and desperate to find a way to keep using my CPAP.
Hi Valerie. I also tried the CPAP (and BPAP) and was unable to breath against the pressure. I have now used a DPAP for over a year and it works great for me. It is a "demand" PAP which has a base level set at about 5 and then only responds when you have an apnea, ramps up, then gradually ramps down if you are breathing again. It does this all night long and causes alot less stress on the lungs and heart. If you want more info, send me email and I'll put you in contact with the manufacturer who can send you a brochure. Chris --
Sally, I did not see the original post re CV problems as a result of OSA but you are correct that it can have a serious affect in terms of causing secondary pulmonary hypertension and possibly an enlarged heart. The symptoms are often swollen ankles and edema and especially shortness of breath . The danger of course is congestive heart failure. Certainly, someone with these symptoms should immediately see a pulmonary specialist. Usually, diagnosis is achieved after a flueroscopy and/or an echocardiogram and sometimes a heart catherization. and a sleep study to see.if OSA is the culprit...........again , to valerie .....get thee to a physician.
In article <55bg93$1...@usenetw1.news.prodigy.com>, WEJH...@prodigy.com
(Janet Carroll) writes:
Jan,
> CV problems as a result of OSA >but you are correct that it can have a serious affect in terms of >causing secondary pulmonary hypertension and possibly an enlarged heart. > The symptoms are often swollen ankles and edema and especially >shortness of breath . The danger of course is congestive heart failure. > Certainly, someone with these symptoms should immediately see a >pulmonary specialist. Usually, diagnosis is achieved after a >flueroscopy and/or an echocardiogram and sometimes a heart catherization. >and a sleep study to see.if OSA is the culprit...........again , to >valerie .....get thee to a physician.
Amen!
However, I would certainly opt for a sleep test FIRST, before undergoing heart catheterization or any other invasive procedure. It would be easy enough to screen patients at that point by asking them (and their partne, for accuracy) about snoring, stopping breathing during sleep, and daytime sleepiness. If the answers are yes, get thee to a sleep specialist.