Nan
(Hartl...@aol.com)
Nan, the hyperpigmentation I got from Minocin were bad enough that my RD took
me off it. 2 years later, the blotches are still there and show no signs of
leaving.
Anne
I have heard from physicians that hyperpigmentation from minocycline can be
permanent. Also, the description I usually heard was of larger areas of dark
pigment, rather than freckle-sized. Of course, the best one to ask is the
doctor.
As others have mentioned, there are other causes of hyperpigmentation as well.
I have a history of severe psoriasis, and part of the healing process with
psoriasis can lead to hyperpigmentation. These areas eventually fade, but we
are talking over years and years here, and I still can see some shadow of where
they were. (strangers probably wouldn't notice :) )
Best regards,
LadyAndy2 in Los Angeles, CA (remove "nospam" to reply)
I have hyperpigmenattaion from hot water burns and am wondering how much
time would it take to go away
Thanks
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Share what you know. Learn what you don't.
I don't know if this is true of all hyperpigmentation, but my psoriatic
hyperpigmentation responded well to a LITTLE extra sun. Of course, sun also
has dangers, especially for those of us taking sun sensitizing drugs.
I never put anything on these areas except lotions (like Eucerin or Vaseline
Intensive Care) or coal tar preparations (like MG-217). Again, I have
psoriasis... I don't know if these things will do anything for you. Best one
to ask is a dermatologist.
Hi Lady,
I can not find any literature to back up this claim. What is funny is that I
too had " Heard" that hyperpigmentation was a rare side effect but the
updated literature is not even listing this as a side effective precaution or
adverse reaction ! Strange maybe the incidents were so rare that this is no
longer the case? I checked with the AF drug guide , RXlist.com and medicine
net.com They update this sites so fast but it is not there, weird ! Regards,
socjog
Marge: As i said, my RD was indeed aware and was very knowledgeable about the
protocols, etc. That is perhaps why I valued his opinion. I went to see him
with a packet of information and had just read the Henry Schemmal(sorry for the
spelling) book so I was ready to battle for it. He convinced me it was not the
way to go.
Nan
(Hartl...@aol.com)
>LadyAndy2
This is what mine is. Large permanent blotches. Fortunately, they are on my
legs and no where else.
Anne
My RD in NM took me off the minocine 2 years ago when the hyperpigmentation
started appearing. My RD here in TX has confirmed that this is what caused the
blotches. I didn't feel it was worth the risk and I also didn't feel that the
minocine helped to a substantial degree, and it was a joint decision between
myself and my RD to take me off the drug.
Anne
For some people. For others of us, it has not been effective at all. My RD in
NM also participated in the clinical trials for minocin, and my current RD is
the head of the department of Rheumatology for the University of North TX and
is well versed in the protocol as well.
>Hyperpigmentation can occur with our disease as a symptom,
>as it did in my case before minocin.
Which disease are you talking about in particular. I have erosive osteo and
had no hyperpigmentation prior to the minocin.
> You best tool is education. Read everything you can and take it to your
>Dr
>and discuss it fully with him/her.
You are assuming that I have not done this, which is presumptuous. Not every
drug helps all of us. For some of us, as several of us have stated in the
past, minocin is simply not the drug which is most effective for us. I am on
Sulphasalazine and prednisone. I just came off a trial of celebrex, on which I
suffered side effects that were common to one tenth of one percent of the
population. I have a problem with some drugs. Minocin is one of them.
Anne
Socjog-
Thanks for the info--I'm curious about the mycoplasm fixation test and maybe
someday will get my ins. to go for extensive thyroid and adrenal tests (which
I've always suspected are involved). Jan
Marge
Marge: What I posted is by no means hearsay and i fully indtend to continue to
respond when I feel the need to do so. You, soc and others frequently point
out the side effects of other meds. as you should and I will do the same with
AB therapy. i happen to value my docs opinion as he particiapted in the
trials. That makes him a very valid source of information. Both sides of an
issue are always the best way to give people the full slate of information.
Sorry it that bothers you but so be it. You do not own the thread nor do I so
anyone is entitled to post there. Anne asked a question of which I feel
comfortable sharing information about. That particular topic,
hyperpigmentation is something I have a familiarity with. If you notice, I
also mentioned that it may not be an issue for everyone.
Nan
Nan
(Hartl...@aol.com)
Keep researching.
Marge
Marge
It can occur as a symptom of many different auto immune diseases mine being
scleroderma , lupus and RA as some of them.
>
>You are assuming that I have not done this, which is presumptuous.
Oh no don't get defensive I didn't assume anything. It was a blanket statement
for those that read the board
.>Not every
>drug helps all of us.
Well, I have posted this quite often. Also many of us are not being told
correct protocol or instructions on taking this drug. The same "Some of us "
that you speak of well many that claimed the same no response from minocin when
I wrote to some it was discovered that there was a lack of knowledge because
of the tremendous misinformation.
Anne you sound like a person that does not have this problem. You sound very
educated so then why did you post this question if you knew the answer for your
own situation ?? I was just answering you with what knowledge I have learned
since on this treatment 21/2 yrs now and by going to the lead researcher in
this area of antibiotic therapy .
I am glad that the prednisone is working for you I am also sorry that you
have had many reactions. As I too have responded poorly to Methotrexate,
plaquenil and I am highly allergic to most drugs. For some reason minocin has
been the only drug to work for me I share this with you and the board for
information only. It is another journey in this auto immune world.
Regards,
socjog
> socjog
Socjog, I didn't post a question in the first place. I posted a comment to
the effect that minocin caused hyperpigmentation for me and got slammed in
several directions, including some email. Sorry if you thought I was being
defensive. Chalk it up to a bad day with Sir Arthur.
Anne
As always, thanks for your input!
Marge
Marge
I agree. Both are cosmetic. If any drug works for me I'd happily be bald with
polka dots!!!
Keep Smilin'
~Krissy
-------------------------
Akron, Ohio
Visit my web pages at:
http://arthritisnet.com
http://arthritisnet.com/kids
http://members.aol.com/KrissyJo/RA.html
http://fadedjeans.com
socjog-
So is there a satisfactory treatment for hypothyroidism? Or is it another
'just live with it' diagnosis? Jan
> Hi Lady,
> I can not find any literature to back up this claim. What is funny is that I
> too had " Heard" that hyperpigmentation was a rare side effect but the
> updated literature is not even listing this as a side effective precaution or
> adverse reaction ! Strange maybe the incidents were so rare that this is no
> longer the case? I checked with the AF drug guide , RXlist.com and medicine
> net.com They update this sites so fast but it is not there, weird ! Regards,
> socjog
DrSusan wrote:
A Medline search using the words hyperpigmentation and minocycline
revealed 39 articles between 1977 and 1999.
I think there is no question that minocycline may cause
hyperpigmentation of the skin. None of the articles (at least from the
abstracts) give the incidence with which this occurs but it is described
as rare (which to me means less than 10%). The word uncommon is often
used. So it happens but not most of the time. Minocycline can also cause
pigmentation of other areas besides the skin including fingernails,
sclerae (whites of the eyes), teeth and bone. There are a number of
articles in which biopsies of hyperpigmented skin were done and deposits
of minocycline were found in the skin. These deposits appear to be
minocycline attached to iron - a so called iron chelate of
minocycline These deposits are located within dermal
histiocytes, macrophages and eccrine myoepithelial cells.
These pigment changes may last for years even though the treatment has
been stopped.
There is some good news on the horizon that treatment with
lasers such as the Q-switched ND:YAG laser can achieve resolution of the
hyperpigmentation changes. (Reference B. Greve. Minocycline-induced
hyperpigmentation:treatment with the Q-switched Nd:YAG laser. Lasers in
Surgery and Medicine 22:2230227, 1998). So if any of you have develoiped
hyperpigmentation from minocycline, it is probably treatable.
Now, socjog has raised a reasonable point that hyperpigmentation
is only a cosmetic side effect. She is certainly right. This is
something that patients should consider when weighing the pros and cons
of this therapy and some people will consider it a trivial matter and not
a serious risk whereas for others, there may be some more concern. It is
of interest that other antibiotics do not appear to do this so if there is
ever any data on the use of other antibiotics such as Zithromax or
doxycycline in RA, perhaps they will prove to be safer agents than
minocycline.
The literature is not terribly helpful as to who might be at more
risk for this. However, there is an old paper from 1980 from JAMA
entitled Minocycline-induced pigmentation at sites of cutaneous
inflammation in which 4 patients were reported who developed blue-grey
pigmentation at sites of inflammation and one patient developed
generalized brown pigmentation insun exposed areas. Therefore it seems to
me that patients with cutaneous inflammation such as patients with
psoriasis might be at higher risk than RA patients. Unfortunately there
are no studies of minocycline in psoriatic arthritis published so we can't
know if this is more common in these patients. Certainly anyone taking
this drug would be prudent to use sunscreens liberally on sun exposed
areas.
Since I started this whole minocycline thread initially with my
report on the O'Dell followup paper, I have been saddened to see how it
has degenerated into flaming and silliness. It is my hope we can keep
this on an informational, nondogmatic level.
DrSusan
HO...@auhs.edu
> So is there a satisfactory treatment for hypothyroidism? Or is it another
> 'just live with it' diagnosis? Jan
Fortunately, we can replace thyroid hormone and no one need die
from hypothyroidism as was the case in the past.
There are two thyroid hormones T4 and T3. The body converts T4 to
T3.
The argument is over how to replace the thyroid hormones,
whether both T4 and T3 need to be replaced or just T4 and what source
to use.
There are a number of choices of thyroid replacement.
1. The first and oldest is dessicated animal thyroid gland - from cows.
Basically a meat processor (Armour) takes the thyroid glands, grinds them
up, dries them out and you take extract of cow thyroid which contains
both thyroid hormones, T3 and T4) as well as other cow proteins. This is
what Elf Marge was talking about some doc claimed was natural. My opinion
is that it is certainly a natural form of thyroid replacement if your
practice includes hypothyroid cows, but for people, thyroid extract is
a source
of foreign cow derived potentially antigenic proteins. If you are going
to limit beef consumption in a patient with rheumatoid arthritis, as may
be helpful, why would you want to give them dried cow thyroid to eat?
2. Thyroxine (T4) has been chemically synthesized as both T4 and T3. T4
comes under the names Levothyroid, Levoxine and Synthroid. T3 comes as
Cytomel. Generally most docs only replace T4 assuming the patient can
convert the exogenous T4 to T3 on their own. However, a study in the New
England Journal of Medicine (I don;'t have the reference here but can get
it if anyone is interested) suggests that patients may feel better if you
replace with a mixture of T3 and T4. However, an editorial in the same
issue felt it was premature to add T3 to all patients on the basis of that
one paper although it was thought provoking.
Finally I should again reinforce that patients with 1 autoimmune
disease such as lupus or RA or myasthenia gravis or multiple sclerosis or
Sjogren's or scleroderma etc are at higher risk for autoimmuine thyroid
disease and hypothyroidism than normal individuals and should have TSH
(thyroid stimulating hormone) levels
checked yearly regardless of age and gender. The recommendation for
"normal" individuals is that women over 50 have yearly thyroid screens but
not healthy women under 30 or men (This is based on disease incidence).
So hypothyroidism is a treatable disease.
And, as far as I know, minocycline has no role in the treatment of
hypothyroidism <g>.
DrSusan
ho...@auhs.edu
Susan Hoch
HO...@auhs.edu
My ankles are all blotchy red and folks sometimes ask if I've been burned.
I've tried Dermal K, saline injections and some kind of laser treartment but
nothing helped very much. (I've had psoriatic arthritis in the past but not
for the past 2 yrs or so). Anyone else with this condition? Jan in KC
It is good of you to give us that information. I can only share from my own
personal experience.
I guess with th amount of years I have been sick and the protocols I have used,
hyperpigmentation( if it happens) does not bother me as I am glad to be rid of
all the pain and fatigue.
Thanks for the laser info. I will keep that on hand to share with others, if
thats ok!
Marge
Marge
Hi, Jan... when I have active skin psoriasis plaques, they often resemble
burns. To be sure, I would have a dermatologist look at what you have and give
you a diagnosis. It could be one of the 5 forms of skin psoriasis. You can
see some <icky> photos of the different kinds at the National Psoriasis
Foundation's website: http://www.psoriasis.org/
Janet
How absurd, Anne ( of the slammers, not you!) I coorespond with a lot of
people on minocycline treatment, and while it does not always cause
hyperpigmentation, it certainly can. I have a picture of what it looks like.
If anyone wants to see it, write me and I will e-mail it to you. May take a
day or so to get back to you if you do, flaring in the middle of celebrating
two birthdays in the family this week over here.
All the therapies for arthritis have benefits, and downsides as well. It
is a matter of choosing what works the best for our particular case and
whether the side-effects are worth the benefits.
I hope that were able to consider the source(s), and not let it ruin your
day! Liz G
Hi Jan,
No this one is easy to treat with hormonal replacement of the thyroid hormone
with a synthetic drug called synthroid or you can use a natural animal hormone
called Amour(sp) with cytomel for T4 replacement I am on synthroid with no
problem. You have to get your levels checked often in the beginning then once a
yr. or as needed. After a while you really know when they are off at least I do
:) So this one is fairly easy to tackle . I wish the other disease were this
easy . Regards,
socjog
BTW there is a thyroid newsgroup and many thyroid sites online. If you want the
links e-mail me :)
I've contacted the endocrinologist my Mom goes to (who I think is the very best
of all her docs) for T-3/T-4 and any other tests. Thanks. Jan
Also, to test for hasimotos, is it the Thyroid antibody we need tested as
that should be my next step.
What I found fascinating is that from age 18 to 30 I was on Cytomael. When they
switched me to synthyroid, I did not do as well and they took me off.
shorthly thereafter, at age 32 I found myself in the RD's office..
Is that coincidence?
Thanks
Marge
Marge
> Also, to test for hasimotos, is it the Thyroid antibody we need tested as
> that should be my next step.
Dr Susan wrote:
Hi Marge. Yes, you are right. In Hashimoto's thyroiditis, a form of
autoimmune thyroiditis, patients commonly make antibodies to thyroid
microsomes as well as to thyroglobulin. It is thought that the antibodies
bind to the thyroid and initiate inflammation. The other kind of
autoimmune thyroid disease, Graves' disease is characterized by a
different kind of autoantibody. This one to the TSH receptor (thyroid
stimulating hormone) on the thyroid cells. The Graves antibody binds to
the receptor and stimulates the thyroid cells just as an excessive amount
of TSH would. Therefore Graves is an autoimmune thyroid problem which
usually results in hyperthyroidism (too much thyroid hormone). In
contrast, most patients with
Hasimoto's thyroiditis usually present with hypothyroidism (too little
thyroid hormone) because of interference with hormone production by
inflammation
and glandular destruction.
The fact that these are antibody related autoimmune diseases makes
it somewhat logical that they track with other autoimmune diseases such as
lupus, RA etc. In all these diseases, the defect is somewhere in the
immune's system's inability to differentiate self from foreign.
> What I found fascinating is that from age 18 to 30 I was on Cytomael.
Cytomel is T3.
>When they
> switched me to synthyroid
Synthroid is T4
>, I did not do as well and they took me off.
Off completely. How could that be? You were still presumably
hypothyroid.
> shorthly thereafter, at age 32 I found myself in the RD's office..
> Is that coincidence?
I tend to think it is both coincidence as well as you reaching a prime age
for RA -
Dr Susan
ho...@auhs.edu
> And, as far as I know, minocycline has no role in the treatment of
>hypothyroidism <g>.
LOL! Dr Susan, this discussion of pigmentation and minocycline and
thyroid made me think of something I heard, that in patients on minocycline,
sometimes dark splotches were found on the thyroid. I cannot remember where
I heard this, but was wondering if you knew anything about it, what might
cause it and if it would be related to minocycline use, autoimmune disease,
or other thyroid problems. Liz G
socjog-
Appt. for 12/20. Probably find out I'm normal. Jan
Normal?? What a horrible thing to be!!! I would hate to be normal! <beg>