On Monday, June 26, 2017 at 9:55:10 AM UTC-4, Mike wrote:
>
> As the days go by and we approach UFA time, I'm growing less inclined to
> believe this team is capable of progressing under its current
> leadership. They trade for Drouin and sign him in like 2 hours.
> Galchenyuk who has similar stats has trouble. I just don't get this
> negative approach to their home-grown talent while outsiders are greeted
> with instant credibility and a trunk full of cash.
So what I have to think is that they are just going based purely on "character/personality" traits when they make these weird double-standard-seeming decisions. It's not purely homegrown vs. outsider. It's not purely veteran vs. youth. Sometimes there are homegrown guys they love (Plekanec, Desharnais, Pacioretty), sometimes there are younger guys they love (ok, tougher but say Gallagher, De La Rose). Sometimes they hand out crazy cash to incumbents (again, Desharnais, Emelin, etc). And then of course they ride some of the others out of town (Galchenyuk, Subban, Beaulieu).
I think they just decide they don't like certain personalities, and put waaaay too much weight on those personal feelings. Whereas a newcomer, they don't know him yet, so he's a blank slate. Even if, like say Radulov and Drouin, they have big issues behind them in past organizations and it might seem like they'd be risky personalities to absorb into the borg collective as well.
For us as fans, we don't live with these players, we don't know them personally, travel with them, etc. So it's automatic for us to overlook off-ice stuff. But even then, it seems like maybe the Habs are going a bit overboard with their chemistry experiment here. I like to think I'd be a little more accommodating of individuality, and not let that colour my decisions so heavily, assuming all was good on the ice. On the ice is what really matters.
Not that I think there is anything truly wrong with the personality of any of the players they soured on - in fact if anything, I'd be willing to bet those are the personalities I'd actually prefer - but there are no big disasters here I don't think, it just seems like the Habs have a very narrow view of what they can tolerate, perhaps. And again, this is also all very weird in the sense that Bergevin himself was considered a joker when he played, so I'm not sure why they'd want all robo-clones or whatever. Maybe that disproves my hypothesis. Whatever the reasons, it truly is weird how the double standards are deployed.
l8r,
Gerry