Monica Pignotti is clearly being targeted in an unwarrented smear campaign
Transremaxculver
Pignotti, is clearly extensive.
I have identified 1002 posts which may be attributed to the following
posters/e-mail addresses. There are undoubtedly more addresses from
which postings take place, additional user names employed and further
postings by the user names identified in the following data which I
have not detected.
The postings are predominantly, single thread headers, with no
replies. My very rough calculations put this at above 90% of the posts
I have encountered. The majority of posts which are replied to, are
those made to the alt.religion.scientology group. Any person wishing
to subject the following information to statistical analysis is free
to do so.
Although there are a large number of groups to which postings are
made, and some variations between different posters, there is a clear
pattern of groups to which these posts are made. Those variations that
do exist, give the impression of the ‘elaborations of a bad liar’ to
quote Clarice Starling.
The close co-relation between the groups, different user names have
targeted, suggests strongly that there is a single agenda in the
postings made.
The significance of this is that either the postings are made by one
individual, or a relatively static group working within a single
policy agenda.
Monica can not be said to be being targeted as a result of a
widespread popular agenda. But ONLY, (I'd like to emphasise only more)
as a part of a single focused attack.
Candidates include a ‘nut Job’ and, given her critical opinion of
certain child treatment, and education styles favoured by the church
of scientology, that church sits very definitely in the frame as a
potential culprit.
Please note that in the following data each individual post will
frequently have been posted in multiple groups.
POSTER SANDAU CHIROPRACTIC SERVICES
e-mail smilax...@yahoo.com
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 3
Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
alt.religion.scientology
re.radio.shortwave
alt.revisionism
POSTER DIDACTICD...@YAHOO.COM
e-mail didacticd...@yahoo.com
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 46
Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
alt.religion.scientology
alt.slack
misc.health.diabetes
rec.puzzles
sci.lang
sci.med
sci.med.diseases.hepatitis
sci.skeptic
soc.culture.indian
soc.culture.singapore
soc.culture.singapore
soc.culture.usa
soc.culture.usa
soc.men
talk.politics.misc
POSTER NOAUTH
e-mail an...@remailer.gabrix.ath.cx
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 39
Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
alt.religion.scientology
soc.culture.usa
POSTER ANNE ONNIME
e-mail anon...@rip.ax.lt
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 271
Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
alt.adoption.issues
alt.conspiracy
alt.fraud
alt.politics
alt.politics.republicans
alt.religion.islam
alt.religion.scientology
alt.revisionism
alt.slack
comp.lang.java.security
misc.invest.futures
misc.invest.stocks
misc.legal
rec.crafts.marketplace
rec.food.cooking
rec.music.misc
rec.radio.shortwave
sci.astro
sci.electronics.components
sci.electronics.repair
sci.lang
sci.math
sci.psychology.misc
sci.skeptic
soc.culture.british
soc.culture.china
soc.culture.europe
soc.culture.french
soc.culture.german
soc.culture.greek
soc.culture.italian
soc.culture.japan
soc.culture.jewish
soc.culture.lebanon
soc.culture.nordic
soc.culture.pakistan
soc.culture.russian
soc.culture.taiwan
soc.culture.thai
sci.med
soc.culture.usa
POSTER GEORGE ORWELL
e-mail nob...@mixmaster.it
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 189
Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
alt.conspiracy
alt.education
alt.magick
alt.recovery
alt.religion.mormon
alt.religion.scientology
alt.slack
misc.invest.futures
misc.legal
rec.arts.sf.written
rec.crafts.marketplace
rec.food.cooking
sci.electronics.repair
sci.skeptic
soc.culture.german
soc.culture.japan
soc.culture.pakistan
POSTER ANONYMOUS
e-mail cri...@ecn.org
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 124
Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
alt.clearing.avatar
alt.religion.scientology
alt.slack
misc.invest.futures
misc.invest.options
misc.legal
rec.bicycles.misc
rec.crafts.marketplace
rec.food.cooking
sci.electronics.repair
sci.math
sci.skeptic
soc.culture.greek
soc.culture.pakistan
soc.culture.palestine
soc.culture.usa
POSTER NOMEN NESCIO
e-mail nob...@dizum.com
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 261
Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
Nomen Nescio
nob...@dizum.com
alt.baldspot
alt.clearing.avatar
alt.conspiracy
alt.fraud
alt.religion.islam
alt.religion.scientology
alt.revisionism
alt.slack
alt.support.depression.manic
alt.true-crime
ec.radio.shortwave
misc.invest.futures
misc.invest.stocks
rec.crafts.marketplace
rec.food.cooking
rec.music.misc
rec.radio.shortwave
sci.electronics.repair
sci.lang.japan
sci.math
sci.med
sci.skeptic
soc.culture.china
soc.culture.europe
soc.culture.french
soc.culture.german
soc.culture.greek
soc.culture.iranian
soc.culture.italian
soc.culture.japan
soc.culture.lebanon
soc.culture.pakistan
soc.culture.polish
soc.culture.turkish
uk.misc
POSTER KULIN REMAILER
e-mail rema...@reece.net.au
Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 69
Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
alt.conspiracy
alt.religion.scientology
alt.revisionism
alt.slack
comp.lang.java.security
misc.invest.stocks
misc.kids
misc.legal
rec.food.cooking
rec.music.misc
rec.radio.shortwave
sci.astro
sci.electronics.components
sci.skeptic
soc.culture.british
soc.culture.french
soc.culture.german
soc.culture.greek
soc.culture.indonesia
soc.culture.israel
soc.culture.lebanon
soc.culture.malaysia
soc.culture.pakistan
soc.culture.usa
Monica Pignotti
culprit, though. They have no reason to be spending all this time and
energy going after me. My story is old news. I wrote it over 20 years
ago and what I had to say is nothing new. The smear campaign started
about 2 years ago, so it doesn't make sense that they would be just
starting then, when in all the time I did exit counselings (1989-2002)
they never did anything like that. Right now, with all the high level
whistleblowers, they have much bigger fish to fry than me. You'll
notice that many of the postings glorify Ronald Federici while
slamming me. They also are focused primarily on people who have
criticized Ronald Federici and others of his ilk. The very earliest
postings were from people who did not use anonymous remailers. These
were in March-April 2009. John Dorsay found that the IPs came from
Norther Virginia, Washington DC. Federici is located in Northern
Virginia. Many of the postings were centered around events involving
Federici such as the adoption cruise postings where people with no
connection to me were protesting him as a keynote speaker and he was
eventually canceled. I got blamed for this and it started a bunch of
smear postings calling me a terrorist and all kinds of other lies.
Given all this, I would say that the people responsible are people who
are in some way supporters of him. Also, have a look at this e-mail,
which was dated March 1, 2009, right before the smear campaign began:
It is also very interesting to observe, that for the duration of
Federici's lawsuit against me and 5 others (December to March 4, 2011)
the smear postings greatly decreased. There were only a few mild ones.
Right after the dismissal, the smear campaign escalated.
I don'[t think it is just one person doing all this. I think there are
a few people involved. I don't have direct proof that Federici himself
is involved in this, but given that so many of the postings revolve
around him and people who criticized him, whoever it is seems to care
a great deal about him and could be one of the "friends" mentioned in
the above e-mail. Also, have a look at what Federici has posted on his
own website in his own name and note the similarities:
http://www.drfederici.com/Response_to_Internet_Critics.pdf
On May 31, 8:39 pm, Transremaxculver <transremaxcul...@yahoo.co.uk>
wrote:
> e-mail smilax_san...@yahoo.com
>
> Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 3
>
> Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
>
> alt.religion.scientology
> re.radio.shortwave
> alt.revisionism
>
> POSTER DIDACTICDERIVAT...@YAHOO.COM
>
> e-mail didacticderivat...@yahoo.com
>
> Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 46
>
> Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
>
> alt.religion.scientology
> alt.slack
> misc.health.diabetes
> rec.puzzles
> sci.lang
> sci.med
> sci.med.diseases.hepatitis
> sci.skeptic
> soc.culture.indian
> soc.culture.singapore
> soc.culture.singapore
> soc.culture.usa
> soc.culture.usa
> soc.men
> talk.politics.misc
>
> POSTER NOAUTH
>
> e-mail a...@remailer.gabrix.ath.cx
>
> Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 39
>
> Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
>
> alt.religion.scientology
> soc.culture.usa
>
> POSTER ANNE ONNIME
>
> e-mail anonym...@rip.ax.lt
> e-mail remai...@reece.net.au
Transremaxculver
wrote:
> Thank you for recognizing this. Scientology is definitely not the
> culprit, though. They have no reason to be spending all this time and
> energy going after me. My story is old news. I wrote it over 20 years
> ago and what I had to say is nothing new. The smear campaign started
> about 2 years ago, so it doesn't make sense that they would be just
> starting then, when in all the time I did exit counselings (1989-2002)
> they never did anything like that. Right now, with all the high level
> whistleblowers, they have much bigger fish to fry than me. You'll
> notice that many of the postings glorify Ronald Federici while
> slamming me. They also are focused primarily on people who have
> criticized Ronald Federici and others of his ilk. The very earliest
> postings were from people who did not use anonymous remailers. These
> were in March-April 2009. John Dorsay found that the IPs came from
> Norther Virginia, Washington DC. Federici is located in Northern
> Virginia. Many of the postings were centered around events involving
> Federici such as the adoption cruise postings where people with no
> connection to me were protesting him as a keynote speaker and he was
> eventually canceled. I got blamed for this and it started a bunch of
> smear postings calling me a terrorist and all kinds of other lies.
> Given all this, I would say that the people responsible are people who
> are in some way supporters of him. Also, have a look at this e-mail,
> which was dated March 1, 2009, right before the smear campaign began:
>
>
> It is also very interesting to observe, that for the duration of
> Federici's lawsuit against me and 5 others (December to March 4, 2011)
> the smear postings greatly decreased. There were only a few mild ones.
> Right after the dismissal, the smear campaign escalated.
>
> I don'[t think it is just one person doing all this. I think there are
> a few people involved. I don't have direct proof that Federici himself
> is involved in this, but given that so many of the postings revolve
> around him and people who criticized him, whoever it is seems to care
> a great deal about him and could be one of the "friends" mentioned in
> the above e-mail. Also, have a look at what Federici has posted on his
> own website in his own name and note the similarities:
>
> http://www.drfederici.com/Response_to_Internet_Critics.pdf
>
merit in the case you make that the anonymous poster might well be.
(Sorry that sounds a little legalees but I did just read the
depositions and the summary Judgement.)
There are certainly stylistic similarities between the way he writes
and the tone of the anonymous poster. I would particularly note that
the dialogue between you is fairly unevenly weighted. There is a
combative and somewhat 'indignant' tone in what he writes, with a
certain sense of Spin in what he has to say. In your commentary I
sense a certain awareness that carefull thought in how criticism is
framed would be prudent.
Certainly there are clear links between the themes his writing raise,
and the themes carried forward in the anonymous postings. I won't
repeat what seem outrageous ideas that were written in his
commentaries.
His writing on the subject of critics is surprisingly similar to the
aproach apparently adopted by scientologists from my observations, and
at least one particular poster on ARS I can think of.
Criticise not the argument, but the person making the argument, which
I would regard as a supprising approach for someone 'authentic' in
their approach to discovering the most effective and applicable
strategy for work in a pschological/social sciences profession.
In essence he sounds like he's trying to win all the time rather than
how best children might be helped.
To be honest after careful consideration he sounds like a bully, and
such an internet campaign would fit the profile of a bully perfectly.
Put another way, he sounds like a loose cannon and a bully and you
sound measured and considered.
Rev. T.A. Krlll
Well done Tranny. I knew you were MI6 ;) Tell M and Q hello.
Andrew Robertson and John Dorsay will be here shortly to proclaim who it is.
But the one group that stands out is *rec.radio.shortwave*. That could
be our ham radio friend Keith Little, originally from Michigan involved
in the break in of an National Guard Armory there, and later a Army
101st "Screaming Eagles" Probably around 55...?
--
"... Where as many of us at one time idolized your fight against the
cult, these days we see how much of a sham you are." - Yaakov, a high
school teacher, to Rev. Dennis Erlich of the inFormer Ministry
[marijuana] Collective (May 15, 2011).
http://www.flickr.com/photos/62112837@N06/5777365284/in/photostream
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Informer-Ministry-Collective/104999406226397
Rev. T.A. Krlll
Sorry that's Keith Wyatt. I apologize Whippersnapper.
Subject: Who is Keith Wyatt? AKA Gunbunny? In 1979, at the age of 14,
Keith was involved with a villanous Maoist group Revolutionary Communist
Party, USA.
Date: Sat, 23 Jun 2001 21:39:57 +0200
From: ©Anti-Cult® - www.users.wineasy.se/noname/
<Anti...@galacticfederation.homeip.net>
Organization: ARSCC Sweden. Department for OSA surveillance.
Newsgroups: alt.religion.scientology
Hey Gunbunny, more than one person can play your game :-)
Keith Wyatt, AKA Gunbunny:
In 1979, at the age of 14, Keith was involved with a villanous Maoist
group Revolutionary Communist Party, USA. Headed by the aslyum seeker
Bob Avaikan. He was arrested by the Detroit Police Department on
numerous occasions. He was also the subject of heavy FBI & police
survillance. It was also believed that he was involved in the invasion
of the commanding generals office at Selfridge Air National Guard Base,
MI. On several occasions, Keith and his co-conspirators were observed
defacing government property. Survillance tapes showed that members of
the Revolutionary Communist Party were making plans to incite rioting in
the City of Detriot in the summer of 1980. Members of the RCP also
staged several demonstrations and interrupted the Mayor of Detroit,
Coleman Young, State of the City Speech. Keith Wyatt was in attendance.
The Revolutionary Communist Party, a group that supports the violent
overthrow of the United States Government, is noturious for supporting
such bombing campaigns as the IRA and the Shining Path. The Shining Path
is a Maoist group in Peru known for their ruthless murder of innocent
civilians. Members of the Revolutionary Communist Party sued the Detroit
Police and Michigan State Police for violating theirconstitutional
rights and all documents were released to the defendants.
After enlistment in the US Army he was denied any type of security
clearance and was allowed to remain in the service due to a loop hole in
the law. He was honorable discharged in March 1989. Keith Wyatt is known
to associate with radical groups such as the Irish Republican Army,
Workers World Party and the Socialist Party, USA. He is also a supporter
of Amnesty International. He has registered to vote for the Peace &
Freedom Party in the past. He has had no criminal record or arrest in
his adult years. However, those who come into contact with him should
use extreme caution. Currently unemployed, he has worked temporary jobs
as a custodian recently.
End of Report
USC 18 IV
KoX
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
---------------------------------------------------------------------
PR Series 12
PROPAGANDA BY REDEFINITION OF WORDS
[...]
"Psychiatry" and "psychiatrist" are easily redefined to mean "an
anti-social enemy of the people". This takes the kill crazy
psychiatrist off the preferred list of professions. This is a good use
of the technique as for a century the psychiatrist has been setting an
all time record for inhumanity to man. [...]
The way to redefine a word is to get the new *definition* repeated as
often as possible.
Thus it is necessary to redefine medicine, psychiatry, and psychology
downward and define Dianetics and Scientology upwards.
This, so for as words are concerned, is the public opinion battle for
belief in *your* definitions, and not those of the opposition.
A consistent, repeated effort is the key to any success with this
technique of propaganda.
One must know how to do it.
-- L. Ron Hubbard
HCOPL 5 Oct 1971
--
"... Where as many of us at one time idolized your fight against the
cult, these days we see how much of a sham you are." - Yaakov, a high
school teacher, to Rev. Dennis Erlich of the inFormer Ministry
[marijuana] Collective (May 15, 2011).
***
W7KEW
Keith E Wyatt
2855 Front St NE, Apt 9A
Salem, OR 97301
USA
http://www.flickr.com/photos/62112837@N06/5777365284/in/photostream
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Informer-Ministry-Collective/104999406226397
Rev. T.A. Krlll
W7KEW aka: KA8PVN
Keith E Wyatt
2855 Front St NE, Apt 9A
Salem, OR 97301
USA
Lookups: 255 Ham Member
Email: kilowa...@gmail.com
* Biography
* Detail
* Notes
* Logbook
Last modified: 2011-01-31 23:50:54, 0 bytes
QRZ Record 1733821
Lookups 255 (347) Mailing Label...
QRZ Admin W7KEW
Last Update 2011-02-23 17:33:05
Class Extra Codes: HVIE
Effective 2010-09-08
Expires 2020-09-08
Latitude 44.946541 (44° 56' 47'' N)
Longitude -123.039407 (123° 2' 21'' W)
Grid Square CN84lw
US State Oregon
US County Marion
Distance 1447.1 mi (2328.9 km)
Long Path 23409.7 mi (37674.3 km)
GMT Offset -8 hours
ULS Record 3226519 FCC page...
Web Page http://home.comcast.net/~kilowattradio/
QSL by Mail? Yes (e.g. Will this ham QSL by Postal Mail?)
QSL by eQSL? No (e.g. Will this ham QSL with eQSL?)
Uses LOTW? No (e.g. Does this ham use ARRL's LOTW ?)
Admin For (1) W7KEW
Other
Callsigns
Alias Comment
AC7XC Previous callsign
DA2EJ Germany 1987 <------------------- Army Post?
KA8PVN 1st call as Novice 1982
--
"... Where as many of us at one time idolized your fight against the
cult, these days we see how much of a sham you are." - Yaakov, a high
school teacher, to Rev. Dennis Erlich of the inFormer Ministry
[marijuana] Collective (May 15, 2011).
http://www.flickr.com/photos/62112837@N06/5777365284/in/photostream
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Informer-Ministry-Collective/104999406226397
Transremaxculver
>
> >>> Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 3
>
> >>> Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
>
> >>> alt.religion.scientology
> >>> re.radio.shortwave
> >>> alt.revisionism
>
>
> >>> e-mail didacticderivat...@yahoo.com
>
> >>> Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 46
>
> >>> Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
>
> >>> alt.religion.scientology
> >>> alt.slack
> >>> misc.health.diabetes
> >>> rec.puzzles
> >>> sci.lang
> >>> sci.med
> >>> sci.med.diseases.hepatitis
> >>> sci.skeptic
> >>> soc.culture.indian
> >>> soc.culture.singapore
> >>> soc.culture.singapore
> >>> soc.culture.usa
> >>> soc.culture.usa
> >>> soc.men
> >>> talk.politics.misc
>
> >>> POSTER NOAUTH
>
>
> >>> Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 39
>
> >>> Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
>
> >>> alt.religion.scientology
> >>> soc.culture.usa
>
> >>> POSTER ANNE ONNIME
>
anonymous postings and what you post below.
Some insight into your reasoning would be helpful.
> > Subject: Who is Keith Wyatt? AKA Gunbunny? In 1979, at the age of 14,
> > Keith was involved with a villanous Maoist group Revolutionary Communist
> > Party, USA.
> > Date: Sat, 23 Jun 2001 21:39:57 +0200
> > From: Anti-Cult -www.users.wineasy.se/noname/
> > <Anti-C...@galacticfederation.homeip.net>
> Email: kilowattra...@gmail.com
Hartley Patterson
> > http://www.drfederici.com/Response_to_Internet_Critics.pdf
> >
> I have to say that whilst I hold a healthy scepticism, that I see
> merit in the case you make that the anonymous poster might well be.
> (Sorry that sounds a little legalees but I did just read the
> depositions and the summary Judgement.)
I'm inclined to think that Monica has correctly identified her stalker(s),
and that the cult isn't directly involved.
The purpose (aside from sheer nuttiness of course) is not to convince
anyone who reads Usenet but to flood Search Engines. This is presently
ineffective, but as OSA's fifteen year campaign against ARS demonstrates,
failure does not deter loonies!
--
ARS FAQ
Please read before posting
http://www.newsfrombree.co.uk/faq.htm
Kat
wrote:
> failure does not deter loonies!
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Truth.
Ted Mayett
Transremaxculver
<ars.to.tedmay...@XXmmXXspamgourmet.com> wrote:
> Nicely done!
>
Thankyou.
> >e-mail smilax_san...@yahoo.com
>
> >Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 3
>
> >Known Groups posted in re Monica Pignotti
>
> >alt.religion.scientology
> >re.radio.shortwave
> >alt.revisionism
>
> >POSTER DIDACTICDERIVAT...@YAHOO.COM
>
> >e-mail didacticderivat...@yahoo.com
>
> >Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 46
>
> >Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
>
> >alt.religion.scientology
> >alt.slack
> >misc.health.diabetes
> >rec.puzzles
> >sci.lang
> >sci.med
> >sci.med.diseases.hepatitis
> >sci.skeptic
> >soc.culture.indian
> >soc.culture.singapore
> >soc.culture.singapore
> >soc.culture.usa
> >soc.culture.usa
> >soc.men
> >talk.politics.misc
>
> >POSTER NOAUTH
>
> >e-mail a...@remailer.gabrix.ath.cx
>
> >Known Posts re Monica Pignotti 39
>
> >Known Groups posted in Monica Pignotti
>
> >alt.religion.scientology
> >soc.culture.usa
>
> >POSTER ANNE ONNIME
>
> >e-mail anonym...@rip.ax.lt
> >e-mail remai...@reece.net.au