Re: dr abu ameenah bilal philips lacks the essential QUR’ANIC knowledge and credibility per se

[Al Nakba]

On May 17, 5:51 pm, kenadian <kenad...@my-deja.com> wrote:
> alt.christian.religion, alt.religion.islam, alt.religion.islam.shia,
> soc.culture.israel, soc.culture.pakistan.religion
>
> kenadian <kenad...@my-deja.com>
>
> dr abu ameenah bilal philips ,
>
> salaamun alaykum my brother in islam.
>
> i am ali vasanji aka ali kenadian.
>
> like you, i am also a canadian muslim, from calgary, ab.
>
>  i have read some of your writings, seen you on tv and youtube, etc.
>
> however, i think your gross attack on the shia faith is unfounded and
> unjustified.
>
> And it is based on lack of  the essential  QUR’ANIC knowledge and
> credibility  per se.
>
> no disrespect or pun intended.
>
> allow me to explain if i may.
>
> 1: 5.
>
>  iyyaka naaabudu
>
> wa-iyyaka nastaaaeen
>
> thee we WORSHIP;
>
> thee we ask for HELP. –
>
> ok so far??
>
> question
>
> 1.     did allah leave this verse unexplained?
>
> NO HE DID NOT.
>
> allah explained it in detail.
>
> do you know where to look for those details
>
> in the holy QUR’AN alone?
>
> thee we WORSHIP;
>
> thee we ask for HELP
>  –
>
> 2.     what did allah mean thereby?
>
> 3.     and also how did he help the suppliant/s
>
> when invoked in their daily salah??
>
> 045:006
>
> These are the Ayat (revelations, etc.) of Allah,
>
> which We recite to you (O Muhammad SAW) with truth.
>
> Then in which HADITH
>
> AFTER
>
>  Allah and HIS AYAT
>
> will they believe?
>
> Note
>
>  Then in which HADITH ???
>
> ALLAH HAD PROVIDED ALL ANSWERS IN THE HOLY QUR'AN.
>
> allah says further:
>
> Chapter 1: AL-FATIHA (THE OPENING).
>
> ahdināş
>
> - şirāţal
>
> mustaqīm
>
> 001.006
>
> guide us -
>
> şirāţal mustaqīm - the straight path,
>
> şirāţal-ladhīna
>
> 001.007
>
> the path of those ....
>
> Note carefully:
>
> 1: 6. ahdinas --guide us --
> siratal-mustaqim--the straight path,
>
> 1: 7. the path of those -
>  siratal-ladhina ;
> ==^^^^^^^^^^^^
>
> stop  here and ask yourself a couple of simple questions.
>
> 'the path of those -
> siratal-ladhina':
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
>
> question
>
> whose path is 'siratal-mustaqim--the straight path' -
>
> vis-à-vis
>
>  'the path of those -
> siratal-ladhina' ?
>
>  ^^^^^^^^^^^
>
> was/is it Allah’s path,  according to the very 1st surah AL-FATIHA?
>
> NO IT WAS NOT!!
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^
>
> Was /is it the Holy Prophet and Messenger’s [sas] path,
>
> according to the very 1st surah AL-FATIHA??
>
> NO IT WAS NOT!!
> ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
>
> Please prove it, if you STILL believe otherwise and only from the
> very
> 1st surah AL-FATIHA and no other.
>
> Then, why did allah guide to THEIR PATH  and not to his own path,
> according to the surah AL-FATIHA?
>
> which you profess as being so important to the islamic worship
>
> and the islamic monotheism!!
>
> Simply based on the facts cited above, where is
> the islamic monotheism in surah AL-FATIHA pe se?
>
> and above all, why did ALLAH EXALT THEM ?
>
> and also JOIN THEM UNTO himself?
>
> and unto His Worship in surah AL-FATIHA?
>
> WHO WERE THEY??
>
> SEVERAL TIMES A DAY IN YOUR DAILY SALAAT
>
> EVEN YOU, LIKE THE REST OF THE MUSLIM UMMAH
>
> ARE ALSO SEEKING GUIDANCE TO THEIR PATH,
>
> vis-à-vis -,
>
>  'the path of those -
> siratal-ladhina' ?
>  ^^^^^^^^^^^
>
> WHO WERE  /  ARE  THEY,  dr abu ameenah bilal philips ??
>
> Your kind reply will be appreciated very much
>
> Ali kenadian
>
> brief introduction to dr. abu ameenah philips
>
> dr abu ameenah bilal philips is a jamaican canadian islamic scholar
> who converted to islam in the early seventies after journeying
> politically and intellectually from christianity to communism.
>
> http://www.bilalphilips.com/index.php/about-mainmenu-53/bilals-profile#
>
> knowledge international university
>
> administrator
>
> address:
>
> p. o. box: 341585
>
> riyadh – 11333
>
> kingdom of saudi arabia
>
> e-mail:         ei...@kiu.org
>
> fax:    +966 -1-4807880
>
>    p...@prestonchennai.ac.in

kuss emeq ya kalb!