WHOSE PATH is Şirāţaal-M​ustaqīm? Please prove it only from Sūrat Al-Fātiĥah --- & --- ‘His Highness’ Prince Aga Khan, His practice and community, etc.

[kenadian]

ya ali madad,

please share



Anonymous said...


Dear brother Shakeel

Assalamo Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahe Wa Barakatahu



I know it’s been 4 years since you raised some issues about ‘His
Highness’ Prince Aga Khan, His practice and community, etc.

http://worldmuslimcongress.blogspot.com/2008/04/aga-khan-50-years-of-imamat.html




I am ali kenadian, an Ismaili Muslim follower of ‘His Highness’ Prince
Aga Khan.


Brother Shakeel, you have raised some interesting issues, but have
been a little too harsh and judgmental – might I add, without
PRODUCING much QUR’ANIC evidence to back up your denunciation of my
Imam and faith.

That is your right and prerogative.



often it is said that ‘ignorance is bliss’ - but it is no excuse to
deride another person. Remember that if you point a finger at someone,
only you will point the remaining 4 at yourself. That is the law of
nature.




WHOSE PATH is Şirāţaal-Mustaqīm?

Sūrat Al-Fātiĥah (THE OPENING)


1: 5. Thee we worship; Thee we ask for help.


1: 6. Show us the straight path ---- Şirāţaal-Mustaqīm,


1: 7. The path of those …. Şirāţal-Ladhīna…
Pickthal's Quran Translation



You probably recite the QUR’ANIC text of this Surah several times in
your daily salah, do you?



Question


1. Now first of, WHOSE PATH is Şirāţaal-Mustaqīm?
^^^^^

2. was it the path of Allah?

Please prove it only from Sūrat Al-Fātiĥah.
^^^^^

3. was it the path of the Holy Prophet [sas]?

Please prove it only from Sūrat Al-Fātiĥah.
^^^^


4. According to Sūrat Al-Fātiĥah only Şirāţaal-Mustaqīm
was / is NEITHER the path of Allah
nor that of the Holy Prophet [sas].
^^^^


5. WHO WERE THEY,
who were EXALTED by Allah
unto HIMSELF and WORSHIP
in the Holy Qur’an & ISLAM?
^^^^


6. which you like,
1 1/2 billion OTHER MUSLIMS acknowledge IT
daily in your salah,

DO YOU NOT??
^^^^


The path of those …. Şirāţal-Ladhīna…

WHO WERE THEY??
^^^^



40:50
They say: Came not your messengers

unto you with

MANIFEST PROOFS-- Rusulukum Bil-Bayyināti?



They say: Yea, verily.

They say: Then do ye pray,

although the prayer—Du’aa
of disbelievers is in vain.
^^^^^^




'Amara Allāhu Bihi 'An Yūşala
^^

ordered Allah Bihi—UNTO HIM be joined
^^


2:27
Al-Ladhīna Yanquđūna `Ahda Allāhi Min Ba`di Mīthāqihi
^^

Wa Yaqţa`ūna

''Mā''
^^


'Amara Allāhu Bihi 'An Yūşala
^^

Wa Yufsidūna Fī Al-'Arđi 'Ūlā'ika Hum Al-Khāsirūna (2:27).


Those who break the covenant of Allah after ratifying it,
^^

and sever
^^

''THAT--HE WHO'' ' - WHICH
^^



ORDERED ALLAH BIHI—
UNTO HIM BE JOINED ,
^^


and make mischief in the earth: Those are they who are the losers.




So, my dear brother despite all your piety and faithfulness to ISLAM
& ALLAH ALONE,
ACCORDING TO YOUR INTERPRETATION THEREOF;
^^

or whatever, you cannot ever hope to get onto Şirāţaal-Mustaqīm on
your own,
in your complete life time, period!


Saying your mechanized-salah in a parrot-like fashion is one thing ;
^^

and understanding your prayer and what you are saying, is quite
another.
^^



Do you still believe that our Holy Imam [sa] and his faith and
community are on the wrong path?



Then please use your intelligence and answer my simple questions which
even a grade
12 student can understand and reflect upon.

ali kenadian
canada

march 02, 2012
Thursday, March 01, 2012 10:10:35 PM

http://worldmuslimcongress.blogspot.com/2008/04/aga-khan-50-years-of-imamat.html