Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

dog mention in script

4 views
Skip to first unread message

Paul G. Barnes

unread,
Jan 14, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/14/98
to

Tung-chiang Yang wrote in message ...
>I read somewhere in rec.arts.movies.current-films that one Pomeranian(?)
>and one Pekingese were saved in the real Titanic sinking, though I did not
>attempt to verify it.

I don't know about the Pom, but the Peke was Sun Yat Sen which belonged to
Sir Cosmo Duff-Gordon's family. Sir Cosmo, his family, their servants
(including an Egyptian dragoman Sir Cosmo retained in Cairo on a whim) and
the dog were among the first to get on a lifeboat. IIRC, they were the only
passengers on that lifeboat. There was an unusual number of crewmen on
board...

cf. - A Night to Remember - Walter Lord

<Disclaimer>
I'm doing this from memory, so I may have gotten the breeds confused...
</Disclaimer>

--
Paul G. Barnes
pba...@imatrex.com is not my email address - it's spam-bait
paul dot barnes at mmcs dot org is my email address

Jeff A. Harrell

unread,
Jan 14, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/14/98
to Ja...@aol.org

Jack wrote:

> Actually I *think* I remeber an incredibly strange story I heard about
> the real Titanic sinking where a black labrador was found swimming in
> circles in the water. Has anyone else heard this story?

R. Norris Williams recounted a tale of seeing a dog swimming near him in
the water shortly after the sinking. He learned later that someone had
gone below decks to open all the kennels.

That dog was... wait for it... a black French bulldog.

Incidentally, we see the bulldog in question in the film, being walked
on the aft well deck. "First class dogs come down here to take a shite."

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jeff A. Harrell "Once we had printing presses,
RIVA Technologies, Inc. we were pretty much doomed."
je...@riva.com -- Scott Adams

geminiwalker

unread,
Jan 14, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/14/98
to

I wonder if that's why (older) Rose was holding a
Pomeranian in her lap when she first arrived on the
site. My daughter has a Pomeranian and she is the
sweetest thing (thought I am a cat person myself!)

I also thought it intriguing the aspect of Rose's
character in later life that she needed to surround
herself with all her pictures wherever she went...
and so much other clutter when first seen in her
home environment. I don't know if that is residual
of the trauma of having lost so much so suddenly
that you want to hold on to whatever you can,
or if it was just a part of her personality, because
she is also bringing a lot of her stuff (paintings,
vases, etc.) on board the Titanic when the voyage
first begins...what does anyone else think?

...kate
chu...@earthlink.net


Tung-chiang Yang wrote:
>
> I read somewhere in rec.arts.movies.current-films that one Pomeranian(?)
> and one Pekingese were saved in the real Titanic sinking, though I did not
> attempt to verify it.
>

> ==================================================
> Jeopardy! wrote on Titanic when she collided with the iceberg:
> : Actually I did read that there was more than one dog onboard the titanic and
> : I have found that 2 were actually "saved" on lifeboats.....at some point in
> : the night someone released the animals from the kennel-storage (not sure
> : what it was called) but I did read that there were 2 dogs that survived.....
>
> : As for "ugliest dogs in exsistence".....i'd look at it along the terms of
> : babies....99%of them are cute but now and then, you do see a
> : clinker.....(not to sound heartless but hey...I'm being honest!) Could be
> : that this was a *particularly* ugly dog.....
>
> --
> Tung-chiang Yang tcy...@netcom.com

Jason Long

unread,
Jan 18, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/18/98
to

The older Rose kept her pictures with her always because they were pictures
of her doing the things that Jack said that he and her would do.....they're
was one of her on the horse, with one leg on each side, and of a
rollercoaster in the background.....Jack helped her realize the precious
things in life and helped her see that life was so much more meaningful when
you live it...."make it count".....Jack opened her eyes to the world, and
she had been forever grateful for what he had done for her.....he always
remained in her heart.

This movie was the best movie that i ever saw, and I truly mean it.....I've
seen it twice, both times with my girlfriend (i'm 17), and I cried so hard
each time....I never cried like that because of a movie.....I guess it hit a
certain spot in me.....It makes you realize how special the people are in
your life and how you need to appreciate every second you spend with
them.....people influence each other's lives, and most of the time don't
even know it....Love is a strong emotion, and a lasting one as well....The
saddest thing about this movie though, is the fact that it actually
happened.....so many people, and especially the innocent children,
died....so many innocent souls were taken, and seeing the sweet unknowing
faces of the children in this movie was just to hard to take for me..Anyway,
cherish every day that you can see the sun come up, because life is short,
but it doesn't have to be empty....."Make it count"

Jay


Tayan

unread,
Jan 18, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/18/98
to

"Jason Long" <elt...@sprynet.com> wrote:

>certain spot in me.....It makes you realize how special the people are in
>your life and how you need to appreciate every second you spend with
>them.....people influence each other's lives, and most of the time don't
>even know it....Love is a strong emotion, and a lasting one as well....The
>saddest thing about this movie though, is the fact that it actually
>happened.....so many people, and especially the innocent children,
>died....so many innocent souls were taken, and seeing the sweet unknowing
>faces of the children in this movie was just to hard to take for me..Anyway,
>cherish every day that you can see the sun come up, because life is short,
>but it doesn't have to be empty....."Make it count"

Jay, well said! Jack showed Rose that love is more than about living
life missing and mourning the one you loved and lost, it's about
living life without fearing for the one you loved because if you truly
loved, you never lost him.

What a movie. :}

Be safe,
Tayan

--
I watched Titanic!
http://www.singnet.com.sg/~liviafyk/titanic.html

(To e-mail, remove "zap" from the address.)


Tayan

unread,
Jan 18, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/18/98
to

tcy...@netcom.com (Tung-chiang Yang) wrote:

>room with colorful paintings. After Jack drew her a sketch with pencil(?)

It was a "conte crayon". :)

Dennis Ferguson

unread,
Jan 18, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/18/98
to

Tung-chiang Yang wrote in message ...

>Have you found what the photo with Rose stepping onto an airplane means?
>The one with her one leg on each side is obvious, but the other photos
>are not so obvious for me.


It seems to tie in with her joy of experiencing 'flight.' Adds a little
more to the use of "Come Josephine in My Flying Machine" and it also seems
to fit Rose's character if she were to become one of the first female
aviators.

Dennis
----
df...@erols.com (Erol's Internet)
dfe...@gl.umbc.edu (UMBC)


Eskimo

unread,
Jan 18, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/18/98
to

Robert Williams wrote in message <01bd247a$49c68940$c4a12299@robertwi>...
>I agree... I think that that photo (the one of the airplane) has very much
>to do with her "flying" scene. By the way - I viewed it for my third time,
>with my wife (her fourth) and she noticed that one of the photos in the
>background is Rose graduating college. Pretty cool considering what her
>mother said huh?


Well, tell us, what did your wife's mother say?

Robert Williams

unread,
Jan 19, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/19/98
to

I agree... I think that that photo (the one of the airplane) has very much
to do with her "flying" scene. By the way - I viewed it for my third time,
with my wife (her fourth) and she noticed that one of the photos in the
background is Rose graduating college. Pretty cool considering what her
mother said huh?

R.

Dennis Ferguson <df...@erols.com> wrote in article
<69u0al$r92$1...@winter.news.erols.com>...

Robert Williams

unread,
Jan 19, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/19/98
to

I wasn't spaeking about my wife's mother.... I meant Rose's mother.... in
the scene before they get up before Molly Brown comes to the table... She
says something to the effect....
"the purpose of University is for a woman to find a suitable husband and
Rose has already done that..... "

R.

Eskimo <bluero...@hotmail.com> wrote in article
<69uct1$ejn$1...@m5.nassau.cv.net>...

Jill Cozzi

unread,
Jan 19, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/19/98
to

Robert Williams wrote:

> she noticed that one of the photos in the
> background is Rose graduating college. Pretty cool considering what
> her
> mother said huh?
>

Gee, I didn't notice that, even after 3 times. Guess this means I have
to go again, eh?


Penny

unread,
Jan 19, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/19/98
to

Here's what I think will get nominated (not what I think SHOULD be,
but what I think is likely):

BEST PICTURE - Titanic
- L.A. Confidential
- Good Will Hunting
- Amistad
- The Ice Storm

ACTOR - Matt Damon (GWH)
- Leonardo DeCaprio (Titanic)

- Kevin Spacey (LAC)
- Peter Fonda (Ulee's Gold)
- Jack Nicholson (As Good as it Gets)

ACTRESS - Kate Winslet (Titanic)
- Julie Christie (Afterglow)
- Helena Bonham Carter (Wings of the Dove)
- Julia Roberts (Best Friend's Wedding)
- Judi Dench (Mrs. Brown)

SUP. ACTRESS - Claire Danes (The Rainmaker)
- Julianne Moore (Boogie Nights)
- Kim Basinger (LAC)
- Gloria Stuart (Titanic)
- Joan Cusack (In & Out)

SUP. ACTOR - Danny DeVito (LAC)
- Jon Voight (Rainmaker)
- Rupert Everett (BFW)
- Robin Williams (GWH)
- Burt Reynolds (BN)

DIRECTOR - James Cameron (Titanic)
- Curtis Hanson (LAC)
- Steven Speilberg (Amistad)
- Ang Lee (Ice Storm)
- Paul Thomas Anderson (Boogie Nights)
(one director of a best-picture nominee gets shut out almost every year -
Speilberg for Color Purple, Andrew Davis for The Fugitive, Streisand for
Prince of Tides, Cameron Crowe for Jerry Maguire, etc. Call it a hunch,
but I think Van Sant will be brushed aside to make way for Anderson,
whose Boogie Nights is probably too risque for a best picture niomination)

ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY - Boogie Nights
- Good Will Hunting
- Chasing Amy
- As Good as it Gets
- The Full Monty

ADAPTED SCREENPLAY - LA Confidential
- Sweet Hereafter
- Donnie Brasco
- The Ice Storm
- Amistad

I won't predict five nominees for these categories, but these
are almost certain (I think) to be among the nominees:

CINEMATOGRAPHY - Kundun
- Titanic
- LA Confidential
- Sweet Hereafter

FOREIGN FILM - Shall We Dance?
- Ma Vie en Rose
- Deep Crimson
(Marborosi, from Japan, will be shut out because of Shall We Dance - only
one nomination per country)

VISUAL EFFECTS - Titanic (duh)
- Men in Black
- The Fifth Element
- Lost World
- Dante's Peak
(this category, if I'm not mistaken, can have up to 8 or 9 nominees,
or none at all if this branch of the Academy doesn't think there were
any effects up to standard this year! I remember only 2 being nominated
a couple of years back - Babe and Apollo 13)

That's what I think (and I'm not sure which screenplay category some films
would fall into, so sorry if I made any mistakes). What do you think?


--
DAMIAN PENNY ---------- g0...@unb.ca ---------- U.N.B. LAW '98
"Do you have the one with that guy that was in that movie that was out
last year?"
- from "Clerks"

Sarah Bartholomew

unread,
Jan 19, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/19/98
to

Sounds like a good list!

Don't forget costumes...how about:

Titanic
L.A. Confidential
Wings of the Dove
Boogie Nights (is 70s garb costuming?)
Hmmm...Oscar and Lucinda? I can't think of other costuming-type films,
except maybe The Fifth Element...Mrs. Brown...Amistad...???? Any other
ideas?

GLIMA

unread,
Jan 19, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/19/98
to

Penny -

It took a lot of guts to come up with such a complete list. Here are
the places I disagree on.


Penny wrote:
>
> Here's what I think will get nominated (not what I think SHOULD be,
> but what I think is likely):
>
> BEST PICTURE - Titanic
> - L.A. Confidential

Obviously, I agree on these two. The one you didn't pick is 'As Good As
it Gets,' I think, is a shoe in. Outside of these three, I dont' know.
'Ice Storm' is a real long shohe Sweet Hereafter' also have a shot.


>
> ACTOR - Matt Damon (GWH)
> - Leonardo DeCaprio (Titanic)
>
> - Kevin Spacey (LAC)
> - Peter Fonda (Ulee's Gold)
> - Jack Nicholson (As Good as it Gets)

Instead of Spacey, I think Dustin Hoffman will probably get a
nomination.


> ACTRESS - Kate Winslet (Titanic)
> - Julie Christie (Afterglow)
> - Helena Bonham Carter (Wings of the Dove)
> - Julia Roberts (Best Friend's Wedding)
> - Judi Dench (Mrs. Brown)

Helen Hunt, I think, will definately get nominated. Of your picks, I
think Julia Roberts is the least likely.

> SUP. ACTRESS - Claire Danes (The Rainmaker)
> - Julianne Moore (Boogie Nights)
> - Kim Basinger (LAC)
> - Gloria Stuart (Titanic)
> - Joan Cusack (In & Out)
>
> SUP. ACTOR - Danny DeVito (LAC)
> - Jon Voight (Rainmaker)
> - Rupert Everett (BFW)
> - Robin Williams (GWH)
> - Burt Reynolds (BN)

I alos like Reynolds, Williams and Everet. Greg Kenier(sp) could get
a nomination. Robert Forrester may be a surprise nominee.


> DIRECTOR - James Cameron (Titanic)
> - Curtis Hanson (LAC)
> - Steven Speilberg (Amistad)
> - Ang Lee (Ice Storm)
> - Paul Thomas Anderson (Boogie Nights)

I think that James Brooks will get a nomination. both Lee and Speilberg
are question marks in my mind.

>
> ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY - Boogie Nights
> - Good Will Hunting
> - Chasing Amy
> - As Good as it Gets
> - The Full Monty

As weak as it is proclaimed to be, 'Titanic' will get the nomination
here. Either 'Monty,' or 'Amy' will not.



> ADAPTED SCREENPLAY - LA Confidential
> - Sweet Hereafter
> - Donnie Brasco
> - The Ice Storm
> - Amistad
>

Don't be surprised to see 'Jackie Brown,' get one in this catagory.

> That's what I think (and I'm not sure which screenplay category some films
> would fall into, so sorry if I made any mistakes). What do you think?


Good of you to make so many predictions. Any other opinions?

Gary
GL...@Prodigy.net


Lestat

unread,
Jan 21, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/21/98
to

I have to agree with tung....
I think Rose, young and old, likes to have the decoration. However, i dont
believe that she went from color paintings to b&w photos in memory of jack.
I think that they both symbolize her wanting to get away from the stuffy,
restricted life she was leading. The modernistic and somewhat rebelious
painting by picasso and monet symbolize her need to live a colorfull life.
Later, after her colorfull life has been accomplished, she replaces the
paintings with real memories. thats what i think.
Lesat.

Yes, that is my email, but not my regular account.. to contact me
personally, post a message with "Lestat" as the subject.......

Lestat

unread,
Jan 23, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/23/98
to

They may also only use pics of rose's early life because they used Kate
winslet in those pictures. Somewhere in her life, rose stopped looking like
Kate and started looking like the old rose. They probably didnt have enough
money in the budget to cover the costs of altering the photos to make kate
look more like the old rose... =)

as strange as that may sound with a 200 mllion dollar budget, it is a very
possible possibility: they didnt want to make the transition between the two
actresses cause they didnt want the hassle....

Lestat


Phlip

unread,
Jan 23, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/23/98
to

Lestat wrote:

>They may also only use pics of rose's early life because they used Kate
>winslet in those pictures. Somewhere in her life, rose stopped looking like
>Kate and started looking like the old rose. They probably didnt have enough
>money in the budget to cover the costs of altering the photos to make kate
>look more like the old rose... =)


You can age and morph pictures with free software on a PC.

Let's say Rose had a "youth" period where she made a point of living, then
settled down to become a housewife when older. After the photo-ops.

-- Phlip
======= http://users.deltanet.com/~tegan/home.html =======
If this is the direction the rats were runnin', it's good enough for me.

Mr. Majestyk

unread,
Jan 23, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/23/98
to

In article <tcyangEn...@netcom.com>, tcy...@netcom.com (Tung-chiang
Yang) wrote:

>All they need is *ONE* color photo of the old Rose to show that old Rose
>did not indulge herself in the past memory :)
>
>==========================
>Lestat wrote on Titanic when she collided with the iceberg:
>: They may also only use pics of rose's early life because they used Kate


>: winslet in those pictures. Somewhere in her life, rose stopped looking like
>: Kate and started looking like the old rose. They probably didnt have enough
>: money in the budget to cover the costs of altering the photos to make kate
>: look more like the old rose... =)
>

>: as strange as that may sound with a 200 mllion dollar budget, it is a very


>: possible possibility: they didnt want to make the transition between the two
>: actresses cause they didnt want the hassle....

It's worth noting, if it hasn't already been mentioned, that the
photographs we see are the ones Rose *chose* to bring with her to the
Titanic site. I think she would have deliberately selected pictures that
were closer in chronology to her youth, being that this was when she made
all the breakthroughs in her life that she and Jack had spoken of -- like
riding horses like a man, or going to the rollercoaster, flying a plane.
I'm sure that these moments had more meaning to her, because they were the
early ones, than the events of later in her life.

By the time Rose would be old enough to be in color photos, she would have
been well settled into her new life. What I see in the old photographs is
Rose very consciously doing these things like horseback riding as a
tribute to Jack, to honor his sacrifice. So it would be very appropriate
for her to bring *these* pictures with her in particular. Remember that
the row of photographs isn't meant to be a comprehensive survey of her
life. Each one has a very specific meaning, tied to moments in the film.

________________________________
Mr. Majestyk

BigJohn

unread,
Jan 24, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/24/98
to

You'll notice that most of the pictures of Rose are of her in her prime.
There would be no reason for her to look like Old Rose at that time in her
life. Remember, she was only 17 when she was on the Titanic, so she still
had plenty of time before she would have started to look like Old Rose.
Some of the pictures did make her look older though, especially the one that
looked like a studio glamour portrait.

John

--
"Promise me that you will never give up, no matter how hopeless..."
-Jack Dawson
---------------------------------------------------------------------


Lestat wrote in message <6aba3b$c8...@ns4.quik.com>...


>They may also only use pics of rose's early life because they used Kate
>winslet in those pictures. Somewhere in her life, rose stopped looking like
>Kate and started looking like the old rose. They probably didnt have enough
>money in the budget to cover the costs of altering the photos to make kate
>look more like the old rose... =)
>
>as strange as that may sound with a 200 mllion dollar budget, it is a very
>possible possibility: they didnt want to make the transition between the
two
>actresses cause they didnt want the hassle....
>

>Lestat
>
>
>

smlpw

unread,
Jan 26, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/26/98
to

I don't know what you think, but you remember that Rose said she wants to
"just head out for the horizon"? I think she just wants to prove her point.

Anyway, my cousin has a different theory : she says that Rose is too afraid
to go places by sea because of her unfortunate incident and starts
travelling by air. That makes sense : remember how she was transported to
the fortune hunter's ship? By air! :)

Tung-chiang Yang <tcy...@netcom.com> wrote in article
<tcyangEn...@netcom.com>...


> Have you found what the photo with Rose stepping onto an airplane means?
> The one with her one leg on each side is obvious, but the other photos
> are not so obvious for me.
>

> =================================
> Jason Long wrote on Titanic when she collided with the iceberg:
>
> : The older Rose kept her pictures with her always because they were


pictures
> : of her doing the things that Jack said that he and her would
do.....they're
> : was one of her on the horse, with one leg on each side, and of a
> : rollercoaster in the background.....Jack helped her realize the
precious
> : things in life and helped her see that life was so much more meaningful
when
> : you live it...."make it count".....Jack opened her eyes to the world,
and
> : she had been forever grateful for what he had done for her.....he
always
> : remained in her heart.
>

> : (deleted)
>
> --
> Tung-chiang Yang tcy...@netcom.com
>

Rob Findlay

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

Hi,

I'm not disagreeing with the theory that Rose is afraid to go places by sea,
but I think there is a simpler explanation as to why Rose travelled to the
Keldysh by helicopter.

Remember Brock Lovett and his team were going well overtime and over budget.
If (old) Rose had travelled by boat, ship, whatever, it would have taken a
while to get there, thus making his expedition go even more over budget. I'm
sure it was Brock's idea that she travel by air.

Rob

Paul Gordon

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

"Rob Findlay" <hell...@netspace.net.au> wrote:
>
>I'm not disagreeing with the theory that Rose is afraid to go places by sea,
>but I think there is a simpler explanation as to why Rose travelled to the
>Keldysh by helicopter.
>
>Remember Brock Lovett and his team were going well overtime and over budget.
>If (old) Rose had travelled by boat, ship, whatever, it would have taken a
>while to get there, thus making his expedition go even more over budget. I'm
>sure it was Brock's idea that she travel by air.
>
You make perfect sense about why she traveled by helicopter, but I WILL
disagree with the idea that Rose is afraid to go places by sea. She is
a fighter. If she had developed a fear of the sea, I bet she would make
herself go just to face that fear and get over it.

--
Paul Gordon (gor...@neosoft.com)
"When faced with a problem you do not understand, do any
part of it you do understand, then look at it again."
(Robert A. Heinlein - "The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress")

Madame Bijoux

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

In article <01bd247a$49c68940$c4a12299@robertwi>, arizo...@earthlink.net
says...

>
>I agree... I think that that photo (the one of the airplane) has very much
>to do with her "flying" scene.

I thought it had to do with "Come Josephine", myself - "Come Josephine
in my flying machine going up she goes...up she goes...", for the simple fact
that Jack sang it to her, and she also sang it while floating on the
driftwood.

If you can find the RA clip of it, it's an _adorable_ song.

Madame


Harpreet S. Kohli

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

Madame Bijoux (thre...@NOSPAM.scsn.net.THISMEANSYOU) wrote:
: I thought it had to do with "Come Josephine", myself - "Come Josephine
: in my flying machine going up she goes...up she goes...", for the simple fact
: that Jack sang it to her, and she also sang it while floating on the
: driftwood.

I think you're right. There is a scene (it was right after they danced at
the party) that was edited out and this song was supposed to be playing at
that time. Or something like that. I have yet to look at the script and
find out, but I heard someone mention it before.

--
HK

Sarah Graybeal

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

Madame Bijoux wrote:
>
> In article <01bd247a$49c68940$c4a12299@robertwi>, arizo...@earthlink.net
> says...
> >
> >I agree... I think that that photo (the one of the airplane) has very much
> >to do with her "flying" scene.
>
> I thought it had to do with "Come Josephine", myself - "Come Josephine
> in my flying machine going up she goes...up she goes...", for the simple fact
> that Jack sang it to her, and she also sang it while floating on the
> driftwood.
>
> If you can find the RA clip of it, it's an _adorable_ song.
>
> Madame

Any idea about where we could find that clip?
--
Sarah Graybeal
Aerospace Engineering, Georgia Tech
gt9...@prism.gatech.edu
http://www.prism.gatech.edu/~vaps6sg

Lonnie

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

Yes, that time where they 1st sang "Come Josephine" was edited out after
the 3rd class party. Also edited out right was:

[Rose points suddenly]
Rose: A shooting star!
Jack: My uncle always said it meant a soul was going to heaven.
Rose: Thats sweet. Aren't we supposed to wish for something?
Jack: What would you wish for?
Rose: Something I can't have.
[Rose turns away and goes to 1st class]
Jack: Rose! (It is too late)

Make it count,
Size does matter,
Amanda
(People who only have unimportant info ARE important.)

Dante Hicks

unread,
Jan 27, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/27/98
to

Harpreet S. Kohli wrote:
>
> Madame Bijoux (thre...@NOSPAM.scsn.net.THISMEANSYOU) wrote:
> : I thought it had to do with "Come Josephine", myself - "Come Josephine

> : in my flying machine going up she goes...up she goes...", for the simple fact
> : that Jack sang it to her, and she also sang it while floating on the
> : driftwood.
>
> I think you're right. There is a scene (it was right after they danced at
> the party) that was edited out and this song was supposed to be playing at
> that time. Or something like that. I have yet to look at the script and
> find out, but I heard someone mention it before.
>
> --
> HK

...You're close. Right after the third class party, Rose and Jack are
walking along the boat deck near the lifeboats singing the song
together. The scene helps to explain Jack's impulse to talk to Rose the
next day during the church service.

Dante :)

Joe Marinelli

unread,
Jan 28, 1998, 3:00:00 AM1/28/98
to

>Yes, that time where they 1st sang "Come Josephine" was edited out after
>the 3rd class party. Also edited out right was:
>
>[Rose points suddenly]
>Rose: A shooting star!
>Jack: My uncle always said it meant a soul was going to heaven.
>Rose: Thats sweet. Aren't we supposed to wish for something?
>Jack: What would you wish for?
>Rose: Something I can't have.


Later on, in the script when Jack dies, Rose looks up and sings "Come
Josephine" and a shooting star (Jack's soul) streaks across the
sky........so sad.

Joe

0 new messages