Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Reverb pedals

2 views
Skip to first unread message

Jon

unread,
Dec 26, 2009, 9:56:34 PM12/26/09
to
Does the Boss FRV-1 Fender '63 Spring Reverb Pedal come close to
emulating the true spring reverb sound?
Are there actually any that are worth buying?

Squier

unread,
Dec 26, 2009, 11:07:17 PM12/26/09
to
> Jon <texasr...@suddenlink.net> wrote:


personally nothing emulates an actual tube driven spring reverb
except a tube driven spring reverb.

however, that doesn't mean that there are not nice reverb abd delay
pedals out there that can't effect a good reverb type sound.

the best option would be to get an external tank reverb unit
(fender used to make them and some other makers out there
still make actual external spring tank reverb units).

or try out popular pedals like the Holy Grail etc...
if your ears are used to hearing actual fender long tank reverb
then no pedal is going to quite sound the same as that.
But if get used to the pedal ways of reverb and/or delay then
the effects the pedals produce can certainly cut it for live gigging.

Tony Done

unread,
Dec 27, 2009, 12:38:38 AM12/27/09
to

"Jon" <texasr...@suddenlink.net> wrote in message
news:4b36ccc5$0$5350$bbae...@news.suddenlink.net...

> Does the Boss FRV-1 Fender '63 Spring Reverb Pedal come close to emulating
> the true spring reverb sound?
> Are there actually any that are worth buying?

Having tried a few Boss digital pedals, I advise against getting one without
trying. I haven't liked any of the ones I tried.

I tried a Holy Grail, and thought it was very good, but I was looking for
more than a one-trick pony, as both my amps have a good spring reverb. In
multiFX pedals I tend to prefer plate or room effects.

Tony D

RichL

unread,
Dec 27, 2009, 12:51:50 AM12/27/09
to

I have the holy grail pedal, it does a pretty decent job of mimicking
the real thing, but it's not the real thing.


underwood

unread,
Dec 27, 2009, 4:46:27 AM12/27/09
to
On Dec 27, 6:51 am, "RichL" <rpleav...@yahoo.com> wrote:

Hi!

Take a look at the line 6 verbzilla!

greets
Jürgen

underwoodblog.blogspot.com

Fred

unread,
Dec 27, 2009, 11:18:05 AM12/27/09
to
Jon wrote:
> Does the Boss FRV-1 Fender '63 Spring Reverb Pedal

I like delay over reverb when it comes to rock/blues ...
Nuthing beats a real Fender 'verb though.

Rufus

unread,
Dec 27, 2009, 3:13:55 PM12/27/09
to

Second. There's only one way to get that jaw dropping Fender-verb, and
that's with the real thing.

I use delay over reverb now, even with my 112 which has a tank in it.
It's just less muddy sounding.

--
- Rufus

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 8:42:59 AM12/28/09
to
"Tony Done" <tony...@bigpond.com> wrote in news:ypCZm.64962$ze1.11102
@news-server.bigpond.net.au:

It's also hard to get reverb to sound good in front of an
amp..especially with any distortion..

So... the whole game changes if one has a loop, and the ability to put a
pedal in the loop..

MANY years ago - I had this rack unit from DOD that was a Spring
Reverb... An actual Spring reverb in a 1U rack... I LOVED that thing!
One day I'll find it again! :)

But, I've had the Digitech XP400 - Great reverb with some nice reverse
ones...

From Boss - I had an old RV-2?? had delays and reverbs... And of course,
one of the ones from Electro Harmonix (the first one)

I'm going to state again.. going through the front-end of an amp will
never be optimal - there's too much gain-staging... if you don't have an
amp with a loop...Maybe it's time to get an amp with a loop - or
reverb...

--
Christopher Bell
http://www.myspace.com/bellboudreaux

______________________________
| |
| Any Amp! |
| ________________________ |
| |!!o Q Q Q� Q Q Q :: | |
|==============================|
Linux user #497844

Dr. Zontar

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 10:27:50 AM12/28/09
to

I'm surprised no one has mentioned this month's Guitar Player mag.
They do a shoot-out between the Boss FRV-1 and a Lee Jackson "Mr.
Springy" pedal. The FRV-1 wins. Overall, they say it captures the vibe
of a tube-driven spring reverb, but can sound a little harsh if the
tone knob is cranked. (Who cranks the tone on a reverb anyway?)

IMHO, reverb is one of the FX that digital technology does really
well. I have spring reverbs in 3 different amps, but wind up using
digital 'verb most of the time. Not only does it sound good, but it
doesn't rattle when my bass player turns up.

- Rich

keenerdog

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 12:23:45 PM12/28/09
to
Have you tried out the Hardwire RV-7? It is essentially Lexicon reverbs
in a pedal format.

Here is a youtube link of one being put through its paces:

http://bit.ly/85j2fw

My wife gave me one for my birthday and I'm using it in a
stereo rig. I'm really liking the plate reverb setting...

If you're into the surf thing, a real tube driven spring reverb is the
only thing that sounds right. IMHO...

-KK

Zootal

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 1:32:53 PM12/28/09
to
>
> I'm going to state again.. going through the front-end of an amp will
> never be optimal - there's too much gain-staging... if you don't have an
> amp with a loop...Maybe it's time to get an amp with a loop - or
> reverb...
>

Can you go into a bit more detail? My amp has an effect loop, but I've never
bothered to use it. What do you mean "too much gain-staging"?


TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 1:38:09 PM12/28/09
to
"Dr. Zontar" <drzo...@yahoo.com> wrote in news:575ac4b6-d506-483c-b5e7-
45caf6...@k19g2000yqc.googlegroups.com:

> IMHO, reverb is one of the FX that digital technology does really
> well. I have spring reverbs in 3 different amps, but wind up using
> digital 'verb most of the time. Not only does it sound good, but it
> doesn't rattle when my bass player turns up.

I TOTALLY agree with you... and add my love for Digital Delay as well..
When I sold my Boss DM-2 for $35 a few years ago, I thought I was
ripping the guy off :)

But yeah... I still use the F out of my Quadraverb...

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 1:45:46 PM12/28/09
to
"Zootal" <use...@spam.zootal.nospam.com> wrote in
news:MNWdnXsxEJWvZ6XW...@giganews.com:


> Can you go into a bit more detail? My amp has an effect loop, but I've
never
> bothered to use it. What do you mean "too much gain-staging"?
>
>
>

The power a guitar pickup puts out is miniscule.. It's really just a
magnet. The amount of amplification it takes to get it to be (for
example) 50 watts, is staggering.. As a result, everything gets
amplified. If you have a cracking cable... It gets amplified..noisy
pedal.. amplified... etc.

So.. with reverb, it never sounds good when it's in front of all the
gain needed to get loud (IMO) - it brings out the imperfections..

If you have a loop... change your world and start putting things like
chorus/phase/delay/Flanger - and reverb in that loop... It will change
your perspective on EVERYTHING...

Pedals that sounded like crap - will probably KILL. And I'd only do it
with 'time-based' pedals - no distortions or compressors or wahs. I'm
not saying it can't be done, but, loops put pedals in a certain place in
the gain-stage chain that benefit those ones I mentioned above..

Rufus

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 2:20:39 PM12/28/09
to
TheChris wrote:
> "Zootal" <use...@spam.zootal.nospam.com> wrote in
> news:MNWdnXsxEJWvZ6XW...@giganews.com:
>
>
>> Can you go into a bit more detail? My amp has an effect loop, but I've
> never
>> bothered to use it. What do you mean "too much gain-staging"?
>>
>>
>>
>
> The power a guitar pickup puts out is miniscule.. It's really just a
> magnet. The amount of amplification it takes to get it to be (for
> example) 50 watts, is staggering.. As a result, everything gets
> amplified. If you have a cracking cable... It gets amplified..noisy
> pedal.. amplified... etc.
>
> So.. with reverb, it never sounds good when it's in front of all the
> gain needed to get loud (IMO) - it brings out the imperfections..
>
> If you have a loop... change your world and start putting things like
> chorus/phase/delay/Flanger - and reverb in that loop... It will change
> your perspective on EVERYTHING...
>
> Pedals that sounded like crap - will probably KILL. And I'd only do it
> with 'time-based' pedals - no distortions or compressors or wahs. I'm
> not saying it can't be done, but, loops put pedals in a certain place in
> the gain-stage chain that benefit those ones I mentioned above..
>

...yeah...what Chris said...

--
- Rufus

Dr. Zontar

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 2:35:51 PM12/28/09
to
On Dec 28, 2:20 pm, Rufus <n...@home.com> wrote:

> ...yeah...what Chris said...

Except maybe for phasers. I still think they sound better before the
amp. They can sound kinda brittle in the loop.

- Rich

Rufus

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 2:41:41 PM12/28/09
to

...I'll give you that - not brittle really, but subdued...might depend
somewhat on the amp being used, though. I'm running my Moog phaser
through the front end of my stereo rig, but I did it so I'd get the
effect out of both sides instead of just one.

And I'll add that I'm beginning to think the same about my Mini Deja
Vibe - I think it could sound a bit more pronounced if I run it through
the front. Again, I put it in the loop on one side because I only
wanted the effect out of that side.

--
- Rufus

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 3:00:27 PM12/28/09
to
"Dr. Zontar" <drzo...@yahoo.com> wrote in news:398b42a7-1eda-4b74-b7b3-
c3daf6...@a21g2000yqc.googlegroups.com:

Could be... I'm still looking for a great phaser.. My Small Stone is
starting to not be so great :)

Rufus

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 3:15:58 PM12/28/09
to
TheChris wrote:
> "Dr. Zontar" <drzo...@yahoo.com> wrote in news:398b42a7-1eda-4b74-b7b3-
> c3daf6...@a21g2000yqc.googlegroups.com:
>
>> On Dec 28, 2:20 pm, Rufus <n...@home.com> wrote:
>>
>>> ...yeah...what Chris said...
>> Except maybe for phasers. I still think they sound better before the
>> amp. They can sound kinda brittle in the loop.
>>
>> - Rich
>>
>
> Could be... I'm still looking for a great phaser.. My Small Stone is
> starting to not be so great :)
>

Depending on what you're looking for (and your budget), check out the
Moog one sometime...after I heard one I had to get one. What I like
about it is that you can still hear your guitar through it - even if you
dial it on heavy. Keep on Foogin'!

I also like the Red Witch one -

http://www.redwitchanalogpedals.com/VideoViewer.aspx?VideoLoc=/Video/Moonphaser

...I like their chorus too.

--
- Rufus

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 3:25:33 PM12/28/09
to
Rufus <n...@home.com> wrote in
news:yfqdnST7oqpjjKTW...@mchsi.com:


>
> Depending on what you're looking for (and your budget), check out the
> Moog one sometime...after I heard one I had to get one. What I like
> about it is that you can still hear your guitar through it - even if
you
> dial it on heavy. Keep on Foogin'!
>
> I also like the Red Witch one -
>
> http://www.redwitchanalogpedals.com/VideoViewer.aspx?
VideoLoc=/Video/Moonphaser
>
> ...I like their chorus too.
>

My thing with Phase shifters is all psychological :) I grew up with
'Lou Reed - Rock and Roll Animal' and 'Judas Priest - Hell Bent for
Leather'... Those two albums had the BEST phase shifter sounds to me..

I assumed they were Small Stones... Years later, interviews confirmed
that both guitarists (Steve Hunter and Glen Tipton) had MXR Phase 100's
- which I had, but thought was crap...

So.... I like the Small Stone, but, it's such a tone-sucker, I'm
starting to not like it..

There's a guy at work with a Mutron Phaser II that he's trying to sell -
but that thing is like a small suitcase :)

Thanks for the tips..

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 3:27:32 PM12/28/09
to

> TheChris wrote:

That does sound good... But I'd go NUTS with those reverse knobs...Who
designed that thing??

Rufus

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 3:42:08 PM12/28/09
to

Yeah...ain't those fine? Red Witch pedals are out of New Zealand, I
think. You can find them on Amazon if your local doesn't carry 'em.

Definitely on my GAS list for 2010.

--
- Rufus

Rufus

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 3:49:39 PM12/28/09
to
TheChris wrote:
> Rufus <n...@home.com> wrote in
> news:yfqdnST7oqpjjKTW...@mchsi.com:
>
>
>> Depending on what you're looking for (and your budget), check out the
>> Moog one sometime...after I heard one I had to get one. What I like
>> about it is that you can still hear your guitar through it - even if
> you
>> dial it on heavy. Keep on Foogin'!
>>
>> I also like the Red Witch one -
>>
>> http://www.redwitchanalogpedals.com/VideoViewer.aspx?
> VideoLoc=/Video/Moonphaser
>> ...I like their chorus too.
>>
>
> My thing with Phase shifters is all psychological :) I grew up with
> 'Lou Reed - Rock and Roll Animal' and 'Judas Priest - Hell Bent for
> Leather'... Those two albums had the BEST phase shifter sounds to me..
>
> I assumed they were Small Stones... Years later, interviews confirmed
> that both guitarists (Steve Hunter and Glen Tipton) had MXR Phase 100's
> - which I had, but thought was crap...
>
> So.... I like the Small Stone, but, it's such a tone-sucker, I'm
> starting to not like it..
>
> There's a guy at work with a Mutron Phaser II that he's trying to sell -
> but that thing is like a small suitcase :)
>
> Thanks for the tips..
>

...reminds me - my ex-roommate has a Mutron III envelope filter I'd like
to talk him out of...

--
- Rufus

Dr. Zontar

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 5:00:30 PM12/28/09
to
On Dec 28, 3:25 pm, TheChris <cab...@nospam.hotmail.com> wrote:

> My thing with Phase shifters is all psychological :)  I grew up with
> 'Lou Reed - Rock and Roll Animal' and 'Judas Priest - Hell Bent for
> Leather'... Those two albums had the BEST phase shifter sounds to me..
>
> I assumed they were Small Stones... Years later, interviews confirmed
> that both guitarists (Steve Hunter and Glen Tipton) had MXR Phase 100's
> - which I had, but thought was crap...

The Phase 100 always sounded too much like Jerry Garcia to me. Hard to
believe Tipton used one.

> So.... I like the Small Stone, but, it's such a tone-sucker, I'm
> starting to not like it..

I think the Nano version that's out now has true bypass.

I also like my MXR Commande Serie Phaser. It's sounds an awful lot
like a vintage Phase 90, but with adjustable depth. The only thing is,
I've had 2 of these pedals, and the first one made a loud thump when
switched. The one I have now doesn't.

- Rich

Kevin Collins

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 5:10:42 PM12/28/09
to
On 2009-12-27, Jon <texasr...@suddenlink.net> wrote:

I used to have the Little Lanilei pedal, which is an actual short spring reverb
in a pedal. It was nice as long as you don't want surf-verb!

Kevin

Geetar Dave

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 5:29:18 PM12/28/09
to
On Dec 26, 9:56 pm, Jon <texasrock...@suddenlink.net> wrote:

I'm late to this discussion. I admit it. TheChris stated something
that I had been kicking-around inside my tiny pea brain for a while.

I lost interest in reverb units once I got a vintage Fender Twin
Reverb back in the mid-90's. The rest just never sounded "right." As
such, I pretty much abandoned using reverb for live stuff. It occurred
to me over the last day or two that the reason I never liked pre-amp
reverbs is because my favorite reverb happens AFTER the preamp stage.

Consarn it, now I think I'm gonna have to play around with my one amp
that has an effects-loop. It has a decent reverb in it already.

Also, let me add a +1 nod to the Quadraverb reverb for a guitar rig.
Yeah, it's a rack unit. Yeah, it's old. Yeah, I sold mine. Yeah, I'm
looking to buy one again.
;^)

-dave-----:::
www.myspace.com/geetardave

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 9:06:37 PM12/28/09
to
"Dr. Zontar" <drzo...@yahoo.com> wrote in news:be3890c2-104e-4940-9d88-
9fc308...@d21g2000yqn.googlegroups.com:

Those Commande Series pedals were built SO cheaply.. Thank your lucky
stars that it still works :)

Thankfully, I've barely heard Garcia :) but, I know he had one because I
bought one for a friend who was recreating period pedalboards from
Garcia... For some reason, he took my Boss Heavy Metal pedal as well :)

TheChris

unread,
Dec 28, 2009, 9:08:27 PM12/28/09
to
"Dr. Zontar" <drzo...@yahoo.com> wrote in news:398b42a7-1eda-4b74-b7b3-
c3daf6...@a21g2000yqc.googlegroups.com:

It didn't hurt Eddie Van Halens perfect sound :) But, I just never got
into the PHase 90...

TheChris

unread,
Dec 29, 2009, 9:02:49 AM12/29/09
to
Rufus <n...@home.com> wrote in
news:95idndnIkv95hKTW...@mchsi.com:

Now, THAT sounds like Jerry Garcia! :)

Jon

unread,
Dec 29, 2009, 8:26:11 PM12/29/09
to
Rufus wrote:

> ...reminds me - my ex-roommate has a Mutron III envelope filter I'd like
> to talk him out of...
>

I have an original Mutron and a Maestro Stage Phaser. One of the dials
Says "Balls"

Rufus

unread,
Dec 29, 2009, 8:32:28 PM12/29/09
to

...should augment dat wit wunna deeze -

http://www.umop.com/tm7.htm

--
- Rufus

Jon

unread,
Dec 30, 2009, 10:54:58 PM12/30/09
to

Damn, off the wall spurt of lunacy that could rival Zappa.
This is what mine is:
http://www.wingspreadrecords.com/maestro_stage_phaser.jpg

Rufus

unread,
Dec 30, 2009, 11:40:29 PM12/30/09
to

That neat - retro, and to the point...I like it...

...then there's this:

http://www.metasonix.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=36

--
- Rufus

Lu R

unread,
Jan 1, 2010, 9:17:27 PM1/1/10
to

"Geetar Dave" <e...@one.net> wrote in message
news:0c779386-d1e6-4165...@q2g2000yqd.googlegroups.com...

-dave-----:::
www.myspace.com/geetardave

My bro had a quadraverb I used to borrow a lot..it had a deep tone about it
that sounded like it was analogue..still..fender spring reverbs are the
best.. amen.


0 new messages